The Good: Chicken noodle soup was okay. Dinner roll -- buttered -- was good. Restaurant was clean. Service was not unacceptable (but not particularly friendly). Needs Improvement: $6.52 for 8 oz soup and a small roll? Terrible value. 3 pieces of chicken in this serving. Counter attendant asked if I wanted the roll buttered. I assumed that meant a pat of butter would be provided. Nope, they butter it for you. Cost savings for them, I imagine. Thanks I can butter my own roll and have you handle my food less. Bottom Line: Geraldines has great baked goods but is overpriced on about everything. Visit on special occasions, I guess. read more

Geraldine's Bake Shoppe & Deli - 3 pieces of chicken -- fits in one spoonful -- in this serving. - Bakeries Near Me - Chubbuck, Idaho

See all

so good, breakfast sandwich and cookies 10/10. The bread was great and the sandwich was simple.

Solid 4 star experience yesterday...stopped by on the way out of town and was pretty impressed by the quality of food, service and cleanliness of this bakery and sandwich spot. I had the spicy Italian which included all the great Italian meats with a little bit of kick as well. I had mine on the white French roll. The sandwich was packed full off meat and the fresh produce was a great accent to a well executed sandwich. The service was really good and the very friendly gentleman that took our order was exceptional. My only disappointment and my co-workers was we all got soup and it all tasted like it was either out of a can or frozen. Had higher hopes for a bakery not having homemade soup but the service and sandwich made up for it. read more

Geraldine's Bake Shoppe & Deli - a sub sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Chubbuck, Idaho

I called to order a lemon meringue pie for my mother's 95th birthday. She is in assisted living and has been in "lockdown" since mid-October. She reports that the flavor of the pie was good, but there was no crust. She most definitely wanted to give the baker a tip or two for a good crust! She was also disappointed in the smooth meringue-her old school ways insist on peaks in the meringue-but said it also had a good flavor. Kudos to the ladies who answered the phone when I called to inquire and again when I called to place my order. Friendly, informative, professional. Having read the online reviews I will be stopping by for cinnamon rolls in the future! read more

Visiting the area and found Geraldine's, so glad I did. Wonderful sandwich on amazing bread and incredible cinnamon rolls. Employees are cheerful and friendly. read more

I've been craving one of their cherry pies for what feels like forever and checking on the page to see if it's the daily pie. I finally decided to send a message on Facebook asking when one would be available. Not only did they get back to me quickly After business hours (I wasn't expecting a reply for a toasty second, but was thrilled to receive one so promptly), but they offered to make me one the next day. ON TOP OF THAT, when I sent another message asking if I could give a card number over the phone to limit trans-personal item contact during this Covid thing, I got a reply within minutes of sending the message, instructing me to call when I got there. Fantastic food, great prices, and equally superb customer service. read more

I've been searching for the best cinnamon roll for quite a while now. I live in Twin Falls, ID but on a visit to my in-laws they recommended Geraldine's cinnamon rolls. They. Did. Not. Disappoint. UHMAZING. The dough is delicious. The ratio of cinnamon filling to roll to icing is perfecto. The texture is divine. This is my new go to place for cinnamon rolls. Totally worth the 1.5 hour drive. Probably a good thing it's far away. I could add some serious poundage if I lived closer. read more

Great food and great service. Best cinnamon rolls around. Bread and rolls are excellent. Always courteous and helpful.

The. Best. Bread. You. Will. Ever. Have. So good! Their sandwiches are amazing, and bread is made in shop. Nothing beats the freshness. They're super quick and friendly. You can't go wrong stopping in for cinnamon rolls or for a quick lunch break. read more

Absolutely delicious food, fresh meat and cheeses! Lots of goodies to choose from. Friendly staff and very quick!

Well, the rolls were awesome, but I ordered chicken NOODLE soup, not chicken broth with 2 carrot chunks.... the sugar cookie was mediocre..... generally meh.... read more

Excellent sandwiches and pastries! The staff was very friendly. Nice atmosphere in the dining area.

Bread was excellent. Service was fast and pleasant. We all loved our sandwiches and the cinnamon rolls we took home.

I had an unpleasant experience a month ago. Since then, the owner contacted me and we resolved the issue. She was very caring, and took care of my problem. I want to say the food is excellent and I will go back. Thank you! read more

I am writing this review because what we were served today actually made me mad!This place used to have delicious sandwiches and baked goods. Imagine my disappointment when my hoagie came on just an oversized hotdog' type bun. Gone is the meaty homemade tasting buns! To top it off the german chocolate cake was a dead ringer for a store bought Betty Crocker mix with canned frosting! You can't expect to keep customers coming back to a 'bakery' that doesn't serve homemade products! read more

Baked good that are absolutely to die for. That's about all that you should need to know about Geraldine's. They are most famous for their dinner rolls, cinnamon rolls, and orange rolls, but the cookies, cupcakes and other desserts are just as fine. They also serve a decent lunch, with soups, sandwiches, and salads served until late afternoon. They have a small, clean dining area where you can eat in, but there is no table service. I'd recommend the turkey-ham salad sandwich and the dessert of your choice; I've never picked a bad item out of their dessert case. read more

Went there today and the lady working in front, I assume was the manager cuz she was older and the rest were kids didn't even bother to look up from her papers when I walked in and I continued to stand there for an awkward amount of time till she looked up and gave me the coldest greeting I've ever received. She really seemed like she could have cared less about the customer she just had walk in. I ordered a sandwich and soup, the soup had the consistency of water when it was suppose to be a thick broth. It was disgusting, the sandwich was alright but for ten bucks you'd expect more than two thin slices of turkey. I've never felt more unimportant to an establishment and I won't be returning. read more

What a wonderful and delicious place to eat some lunch! Everything I've tried has never disappointed! prices are fair and they seem to keep things stocked well. They also support many small home businesses that make and sell items such as kitchen towels as they are displayed all over the store. If this bakery ever closes up shop, I will cry. read more

I have mixed feelings about this place. Their sugar cookies are the best I've ever had, but their sandwiches are just ok and they are amazingly slow. Make you want to pull your hair out slow. And today was really the last straw. I ordered a sandwich in a meal with chips and a cookie and the girl waits until I pay to let me know that she's not going to make it until she rings up the rest of the people in line...wtf? I'm not trying to be rude but what about first come first served? My time is valuable and I don't see why I should have to wait for the next 3 people in line to get rung up... I kinda wanted to make her refund it because I was in a hurry but I just sat there and waited for her to ring everybody else up... I did question it because I thought it was weird by saying "Wait, you're going to make my sandwich later?" But then I bit my tongue... read more

Bread is friggin great. Homemade recipes to this day. Don't be fooled by the sugary stuff and the soup though. All corporate bought. Except the cinnamon rolls read more

A very delicious local bakery. Excellent rolls and treats. Everything here is good. I always order the pulled pork for lunch. The only disadvantage is that they close early (at like 6 or something). It's a great spot to meet up with friends for lunch. I highly recommend! read more

Rolls, rolls, rolls, rolls, rolls, rolls. Please, do yourself a favor and get some of the most tasty Idaho rolls ever. Really GOOD! The only think that prevented 5 stars here would be the Deli side. It's good, but not 5 stars good. Did I mention you should buy some rolls? read more

Amazing. I have never had a bad experience. Their baked goods are always delicious and so are the sandwiches. They are a little pricey, but completely worth it! read more

I love their lemon bars. I usually get their roast beef sandwich because they use the best meat. My husband recently tried their chicken cordon blu. Soo good! It's also a great place to stop and get some rolls for dinner! read more

I keep trying to like Geraldine's. I want it to be the go-to local yummy bakery on the corner. It gets good reviews from locals. But in the handful of times I've eaten here I just get mediocre food that leaves me unimpressed. The soup tastes like its from a can or frozen. The baked goods are usually dry, including the cinnamon rolls they are "famous" for. They need to introduce more fresh ingredients and add more flavor combinations to give their food some depth if they want to compete with the recently opened Panera. It reminds me of cafeteria food complete with heavy set women in dirty aprons serving food on paper plates. read more

The food is alright, a little overpriced for what you get. Some of their employees need to work on their attitude(teenagers) and customer service. read more

Tasty sandwiches with fresh ingredients! I got a large sandwich and a cinnamon roll for $7.50. The bread was really good!

Soup is frozen then heated up to serve. Rather poor for an in-house bakery and cafe. You can make a mighty tasty chicken soup in an one hours time that is to die for using all fresh ingredients. If you need a recipe let me know. read more

I love fresh baked bread and I'm picky about bread that I buy. This bakery consistently has the best tasting bread and rolls. I don't eat a lot of sweets, but I love to splurge on their pumpkin rolls or peanut butter bars. Mostly I just hope I'm in line when they put out their samples! It's the real deal - and worth the drive to Chubbuck. read more

Geraldine's Bake Shoppe & Deli - My family loves their crescent rolls! So soft and yummy! - Bakeries Near Me - Chubbuck, Idaho

See all

There is no doubt that Geraldine's has several delicious choices on their menu, but as most people in Pocatello will tell you, they have gone seriously downhill. The current owner purchased the bakery and their recipes from the original owner and ever since they have gotten progressively worse. I will say the rolls and homemade bread as well as the cinnamon rolls and peanut butter squares are as delicious as they have always been, but stay away from everything else!!! The soups and cookies aren't homemade (despite popular belief), and they have had multiple problems with the health department about the temperature of their refrigerated items for sandwiches being too warm! You can definitely tell the only reason they are still in business is because of their rolls. Lots of better choices for a bakery in Pocatello, and they probably won't try to serve you a sandwich that might make you sick and an overpriced cookie they took out of a box in the back. read more

Geraldines Shop makes delicious baked goods & wonderful made to order dishes. However, my appetite was recently destroyed when I placed my order in person, a dozen cookies. The cashier was pleasant as she removed the cookies two or three @ time from beneath the display glass and placed them neatly in a box. She then proceeded to take my money. The transaction was done with Bare Hands! That's right, no gloves! I couldn't believe my eyes, if not gloves then some other barrier when handling food such as Wax Paper squares! read more

Went to grocery store bought milk, eggnog,beef ribs $7.05 went to Geraldine's got 2sugar cookies and 2 sticky buns $9.20! O M G! Won't do that again! I bought maple frosted cinnamon rolls at Albertsons a week ago, 4 for .99, they were every bit as good as anything from Geraldine's.So, save your $ unless you have $ to burn, everything they have is WAY overpriced. read more