Stopped for dinner...the atmosphere, staff, beer and wine were great.... really disappointed in the calzones... really weird... I was expecting all the ingredients inside the crust as usual... the calzones came out flat with the melted cheese on top and they were sliced... I've was really surprised to see such a sight... very minimal sauce... wouldn't recommend the calzones... read more

Such a great family run spot. We love that they do the pizza of the month to mix things up while maintaining some great standard menu selections. read more

The pizza was awesome! I'm an old dude and have eaten a lot of pizza in my lifetime and Papa's Pizza is the BEST PIZZA I've ever tasted. If you're in Cloverdale and want to have a Pizza you gotta go here! We really liked the atmosphere too. read more

Haha there's definitely not honey in the dough, don't know where "Curtis K." came up with that. Awesome pizza. Awesome atmosphere. And they serve beer & wine. read more

I use to live in town and this was a frequent visitor. Great pizza, great dough- solid on toppings. Salads are nice size and good assortment of veggies- vs lame iceberg salad. When in town I still stop by and grab a meal. 10 years later same great recipe. Keep it up! Small pizza and large salad plenty for two big eaters read more

We have been ordering their pizza for 14 years and we love them. Friendly staff, decent pricing, and such a great slice

Food was ok, customer service is trash. The cashier working there was so rude over the phone and specially in person, rather go somewhere else where they have even a little more common respect. Word of advice for the girls working there: don't talk about customers when they're literally sitting right by it's very disrespectful and unprofessional and especially all because you couldn't understand what was being requested read more

Love the new location, great pizza, great atmosphere. I buy these as pizza day treats at work, they handle the order of 12-15 X LG pizzas with as much care as an order for 1. Nice salads to go. reasonable prices too. read more

Great atmosphere, really nice decor, very friendly helpful staff, bar has a good selection of beers. Food was excellent, efficient service. We had Mediterranean Salad, garlic bread (delicious and generous) and a Mediterranean Pizza... if we were here tomorrow I would go back. Great choice! read more

we had the best waitress ever rylee reasoner she was so cute and nice, she was the best ever we love her

Based on the glowing reviews I've decided I'm never trusting Yelp again. First of all it took 35 mins to get the pizza, yes I do understand pizza has to be baked but it was a looooong time. We got the pesto chicken and I was pretty surprised to see the guy pull out a bag of Tyson frozen chicken. Yuck. The pesto was definitely from a jar and the crusts were kind of burnt. The frozen chicken tasted really odd and made the whole thing so salty I couldn't even eat it. Too much garlic, too much salt, not enough pesto and cheap frozen chicken. No no no. I really don't get it. Even if they did everything else right you can't use bags of chicken and expect a pizza to taste good. I wouldn't go back. read more

Seriously, in my opinion, this is the best pizza you can find anywhere. Everything just tastes fresh and delicious and top-notch. I don't know what else to say. I don't know their secret is and I'm sorry I can't say more. All I know is that eating a Pizza from Papa's(yes, I used capital 'P' when referring to a Pizza from Papa's), I get the sense that I'm eating a pizza from made in a small, renaissance village celebrating holiday or the end of a long war with Spain. Wonderful. read more

I can't say enough great things about Papas. Mike and his team always provide great service and the pizzas are the best in town. The salads are great (wonderful dressings) and there's a good selection of beer on tap. Great wine list, too! Papas is a great place for bday parties as they have ample seating for large groups. We are lucky to have such a well run, exceptional pizza place in Cloverdale. read more

Amazing pizza and appetizers only complaint I have is that they dont deliver before 5pm

Best pizza in the area. Hint of apple sauce in the crust. Well worth visiting. Better than round table. Better than La Vera's in Santa Rosa... I like it more than Old Chicago Pizza in Petaluma read more

Is Papa's Pizza the best Pizza in the world? No there must be someone that makes a better pizza. So Papa's is the second best pizza. I've been eating here for 20 years, always great. Thank you Papa's. read more

I had my wedding in Hopland, and I needed to find some local pizza to order for the rehearsal dinner. Papa's seemed to have the best reviews of any other local pizza shop, so I went with them, and prayed it would be good! I knew I'd probably made a good choice when, after placing my phone order, they called me back, thanked me warmly for such a large order, and said they were giving me one of my extra large pizzas for free. Awesome! I'm pretty picky about my pizza, but this pizza was amazing, all of our guests at the rehearsal dinner loved it. Generous toppings, delicious crust, and they made some custom gluten free pizzas too which were devoured. Delicious pizza and great service! Can't recommend them enough! read more

Totally delicious. I ordered a pizza not too thin on the crust, and I wanted it a little crispy, and it came out perfect. Nice staff.

Not only is the pizza here some of the best in the county, but the service here is amazing as well. I also want to give them a shoutout for being one of the only places in cloverdale serving food immediately after the Kincade Fire. Most families didn't have a place to go or place to cook and they were open and running. Serving up pizzas nonstop. These places really are the kind of thing that support a community. Also, try their monthly pizza. Amazing takes on some classic dishes but in pizza form. Can't recommend them enough. read more

Fantastico!!! Excellent pizza! Great service and delivery too!

I have never eaten at the actual place so I can not comment on the service but I do pick up my pizza and I have had pizza from here quite a few times. This pizza is awesome! Some of the best real italian pizza I have had. Ingredients are always fresh and of high quality! I definitely recommend this place! read more

I ordered a small mushroom and pepperoni done crisp to go. I received olives and pepperoni and it was soggy and rather salty. oh well its hit or miss read more

Always the best pizza. I stop every time we are in Cloverdale. Mike has been running the place for 30 years and seems like it just keeps getting better every year. Great selection of beer and wine, great atmosphere and a friendly staff. What more could you ask for? read more

The mozarella cheese was the kind that's perfectly golden and somehow crispy at the same time. We got the Brazilian style pizza and added bacon - so good. read more

Local restaurant with a lot of local kids working here...and the kids are actually working! I like the pizza. To top it off, this is an independent AND locally owned/operated restaurant. Can't beat that triple combo! read more

I have always enjoyed their pizzas and their Mediterranean salad is incredible. The staff is top notch and delivers excellent customer service each and every tjme. read more

Yum yum yum, they are so liberal with the mozzarella. Love the crust, too. Can't forget the pesto cheesy bread. Always a satisfied customer.

Awesome pizza! New to the area from Illinois! Had just flown back here from Chicago and didn't feel like cooking so we decided to check the place out. Will definitely order again. read more

I came with about 20 people we were looking for a good pizza place. After travelling for hours we found this little gem. The environment is super cool the bar is great. When u walk in the first thing u notice is the aroma,the smell of a perfect pizza joint. The staff was super nice and fast. Being able to cater to that many people and doing it with class,a smile and quickness is a good feeling. We ordered 4XL pizzas and they all great cheese,pepperoni, Mediterranean and i think it was called luau my favorite was Mediterranean and luau great pizza. The pizza cooked and was given to us in a good amount of time Over all the whole group ate every last slice and loved it ,everyone was happy the quality of the pizza matches the price. If I'm ever in town again all definitely go back. 10 stars thank u PAPA'S for great pizza and a nice place to rest before out dive home. read more

It had been a while since my family had enjoyed a great pizza, but we found one at Papa's Pizza Cafe in Cloverdale! Absolutely loved the Pine Mountain and an extra large was only about $26 :) Still great and the new location is fantastic! read more

We came in with a large group of 17 people & the service was awesome & so was the food, we'll definitely be stopping by here again, thank you! read more

The staff had very good customer service, Mike right there helping them out. Pizza delicious, beers on tap very impressive. Look forward to my next visit. read more

Wonderful pizza!! The cheese was amazing, my pizza critics aka kids said it was soooo delicious and I have to agree even my parents ( who don't care too much for pizza) dug in and had 2 pieces. Stop by and enjoy a pie :) read more

We stopped here on our way to San Jose, returning from camping. The pizza is excellent. The dough/crust is one of the best I've tasted in a long time. And they have a nice patio in the back. Ideal for kids. read more

This place has the absolute best pizza I have ever had! I'm from LA and visit my parents in Cloverdale often, and I was absolutely blown away by the many amazing restaurants in this area. Papa's pizza has become a staple in my visits home, my favorite items on the menu are the mediterranean salad and the Russian River pizza.... the crust and the ranch dressing here are to die for! I always tell myself I'm just going to have a salad ;)... but the pizza is honestly irresistible. The service is always great, and I am really loving their new location with the bar. Great pizza, lots of alcohol, and quality service... what more could you ask for! read more

The food, staff, atmosphere, prices and location are all fantastic! Mike and Denair have filled the void in Northern Sonoma County with their "Pizza joint". The staff are friendly. This is as good as a pizza place gets! read more

The best pizza place in town. Delivers!!!! Pizza is perfect every time. Way better than Mary's. They are always early or on time. Salads are great, not wilted. Wings are awesome. Service is great, delivery persons are courteous. read more

I lived here in cloverdale for 16 years came here as a child always Loved their pizza it was always better than Round Table and Mary's Pizza. I love the new location always packed when i go their especially friday nights read more

Papa's is my go to pizza place. The pizza is great and reasonably priced. I usually order ahead and take it home but occasionally take the family there. It can get pretty loud in the restaurant but the kids enjoy it. They have a few video game consoles and are usually showing a sporting event on the flat screen. read more

We had a great experience here! Order the spicy chicken wings as an appetizer, Sonoma salad which was large enough to share. We had the Western Pizza which we really enjoyed. Loved the addition of crumbled bacon on top. the new location is really homey and comfortable, and the service was excellent. We will be back soon! read more