Pastosa Ravioli

Gemelli the Restaurant which is down the block is slated to become a Whisky Down location in Fall…read more2026. Could Gemelli the store be packing their bags too? The store has no life inside, it's depressing. The shelves have minimal products which are overpriced. The grab and go dinners only had 2 choices available, so sad. Store made frozen pasta is available. Fresh meat is available, looked good but expensive. Salted cod was $21 a pound, why? There's a full array of salads in the front showcase which showed some promise but too expensive. No other customers in the store and it was lunch time. The quiche we bought had plenty of cheese and tasted good heated up despite the bottom crust being underbaked. I think that Uncle Giuseppe's sucked away business from Gemelli which used to be the only high end Italian market around.

We have always liked the meats from Gemelli but I was disappointed that after I was told the price…read moreof my purchase I gave a credit card. Upon looking at the receipt I noticed they charged a fee for using the card. When I questioned the higher amount on my receipt the manager, I believe, said the credit card company puts it on there. WRONG! It's up to the merchant to tell the credit card company and in NYS it is illegal to charge more for using a credit card unless info is posted with the credit card amount and the cash amount or there is a discount for cash. Check this out on the NYS Consumer Affairs web site and point it out to merchants who are illegally charging you this fee. Yes, the store is paying a fee for accepting credit cards but that is part of their overhead and the burden should not be placed on their customers. Just wondering if they write off that expense after collecting it from unwary customers. There is a $500 fine for each complaint.

Front case January 2026

Pork chop

See all

Mulberry Street Babylon

3.5(290 reviews)

1.7 mi

by far the best pizzeria in Babylon amzing service , can't…read morego a week without it Will definitely be back

Best pizza in Babylon hands down. Have to stop by whenever I'm in town. Top notch service and…read moreatmosphere!!

Dessert display

Too Good to Go Box

See all

Il Villaggio Pizza & Pasta

3.3(26 reviews)

Quaint little restaurant with more than enough staff. I've been there a few times before and…read moreenjoyed the food. This time I ordered lasagna. It appeared in a bowl with way too much mozzarella cheese. I had a hard time finding the noodles and meat. Very little sauce as well. I guess I should have sent it back and ordered something else but I didn't! Not sure if I'll be returning or recommending this restaurant!

Calamari fra diavlo. I did love it and everything else was amazing however Please Chef. We who…read moreorder it love spicy, but whatever you're doing is beyond ridiculous. cut it down by 50%. Please....... I was warned by the waitress.

Vegetable Napolian

See all

Pasta Chicken & Spinach

Cafe il Villagio

3.5(56 reviews)

Cute place with friendly staff. Bread basket delivered nice and warm. I ordered the penne Romano…read moreand although it was a large portion size, there was barely any chicken in there and I was a little disappointed in the lack of flavor in the sauce. Considering 1 pasta bowl was $32, I expected a little more from my dish.

Went here with my daughters and they both got the baked ziti which they liked. I ordered the…read morelasagna. It actually looked like a big blob of mozzarella cheese when I got it. So I started eating it and literally had to search for the meat and noodles which were unidentifiable. I'm not sure why I didn't send it back! It was awful. I've eaten here several times before and no complaints the other times. Did the cook change? Ugh

I forgot the name of the seafood dish but it was so good!

See all

Shrimp Scampi

Babylon Cheese Cellar

4.7(44 reviews)

•$$$

This place is just so awesome! Anytime I need a good cheese it's my goto. The staff and owner are…read morefabulous - this last time I took my daughter (who recently discover cheese) to find out which one she liked most. They let us sample a range of awesome blue's, and then we grabbed her a wedge of her own "nibbling cheese" that I'm not allowed to touch. Make sure to try their sandwiches, mac and cheese, or charcuterie boards (or supplies for them). They are all fantastic!

Cute little shop! The staff is always very kind and knows what they're talking about but not…read moreoverbearing which I appreciate! Tons of different cheese to try and other things here and there. They're also always more than happy to let you sample the cheese. The parking could be better, but it's not usually super crowded. I'm definitely going to try some of their food next time I go!

Cheeses

See all

Talina

4.5(72 reviews)

1.3 mi

The second time visiting the AMAZING Brittany at Talina for the Freshest, most authentic italian…read morecusinie! Ive been waiting all month to come back here for my moms early birthday dinner and it was a magical experience! She took the best care for us! The atmosphere was identical to how I remember on my trip to Italy! So welcoming, warm, and true to the culture! We started with the apps: eggplant & tomato gratin.. the tomato was so fresh, sweet and the best eggplant ive ever had.. topped with a simple breadcrumbs The Piadinas were probably my FAVORITE that ive be so excited to try! Especially the Nud: prosciutto cotto fontina cheese and mushroom spread .. this was my favorite on the apps menu that id have for myself as a meal! After sharing the delicious apps my mom and I shared our favorite pasta. Strozzapreti Gratinati that Brittany hand rolls herself with sausage rags, arugala and light breadcrumbs topping! Ended the meal with dessert to celebrate my moms bday, the apricot crostata and pear desserts were our favorite! Sweet plum pear and fresh apricot tart! Thank you so much for making the celebration so special! Brittany and pietro, thank you so much for offering your talent and giving the community the truest italian experience From service, ambiance, kind waitstaff, to every part of the meal was Perfection!!! and im so happy to have the honor of sharing the meal & service by you! AGAIN, you guys set the bar high....I will forever recommend your establishment and highly rate Talina as the best italian restaurant on Long Island!

Beautiful and cozy restaurant, it's very small so definitely make a reservation! Nice bar area and…read morea few high tops by the front window. Small menu but very nice and interesting recipes. I really appreciate the attention to detail in regards to ingredients and flavor pairings. The pasta is very good and is homemade, made in house. The service was impeccable. Great wine list and drink menu. The salad was huge and more than enough for two people, though it was slightly overdressed.

Coffee bar vibes

Zucchini- served cold which was interesting but still very good

See all

Strozzappreti Gratinati

La Famiglia

3.9(193 reviews)

1.7 mi

Second time here and glad I gave it another shot. Food was way better than the first time and our…read moreservers for the private party were sweet. Second private event I've been to here in the upstairs space. The space is beautiful and large. Perfect for both events (baby shower & communion).

This place is wonderful!! Service is outstanding went last weekend for the third time this year…read morealways a great experience. We had the hot antipasto with our group so delicious more than enough food. Our group ordered many delicious entrees. The wait staff didn't rush the courses. Our experience was a 10!!

The baked clam is small neck so it was very petite but the sauce was very delicious.

See all

Veal Marsala

The Pizzeria of Babylon

4.2(67 reviews)

Jake was great behind the bar and made sure our drinks were full and fresh! Truly a nice and…read moreattentive bartender even though it was busy. Food came out hot and timely. Not a first time, but will be back again! -Peter and Mike

The decor and ambiance inside is much more elevated than I imagine when I hear "pizzeria". Gold…read moreaccents, mirrors, and nice marble ~ no red checkered plastic table cloths here! The menu had lots of great options without being overwhelming. I couldn't even decide on a pizza, they all sounded so good! We got a Caesar Salad Chicken Cutlet which was satisfying as a salad and as a protein. I liked that it was served with fresh lemon. We also got the beggars purse pasta with a sausage cream sauce. I felt that the pasta had a bit too much sauce but all meals were served with pizza bread so I used that to soak it up. The pricing was fair for the quality and vibe of the restaurant. This restaurant has its own spacious parking lot as well.

The Pizzeria side

Buffalo Garlic Knots .. it's addictive

See all

Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.5(224 reviews)

2.9 mi

Recommend you go to Alitalia. They got the best food there and that pizza is great. Their food is…read morethe best.

Had the pleasure to be able to stop and have an early dinner yesterday at Alitalia, we used to live…read morein West Babylon over 30 years ago and haven't been there since. We had a party of 4 and arrived at about 3pm, we didn't realize that the dining room didn't open till 4pm but they let us sit down in the dining room and we had to order from the counter which was no big deal. They did have a young lady in the dining room but she said she was not a waitress, this is just my opinion but they should let her wait on tables when something like this comes up so she can get the experience to become a waitress. Food was delicious, we all had different chicken dishes and all of us loved what we had. Prices were very fair. Definitely will be going back soon. They also do a pasta night and a chicken night the was very reasonable.

See all

The Brixton

4.3(440 reviews)

1.5 mi

Brixton - Babylon, NY…read more My friend and I visited Brixton on Christmas Eve and had a wonderful experience. The small plates were thoughtfully prepared, the cocktails were creative and well balanced, and the staff was attentive and clearly hardworking. The atmosphere felt warm and inviting, making it a great spot to relax and enjoy good food and drinks. All in all, a very pleasant experience. Highly recommend

These are one of the tougher reviews to make. It is easy to be enveloped by the plethora of great…read morerestaurants in the competitive nature that is NYC, but when you venture all the way out here to Babylon, NY, you have to change that mindset a bit. The Brixton is a beautiful restaurant with very relaxed and casual vibes. The word around town is that their drinks are awesome. What about their food, though? They originally would not seat us in the middle of the afternoon because most of the empty tables were reserved. We had to request to sit outside, which was empty, before they decided to serve us. Odd that they did not even offer that to us. The General Tso' Cauliflower was the only great thing served to us. It is incredibly crispy and flavorful. You almost forgot that you were eating a piece of vegetable at times. The Short Rib Brisket Sesame burger was shocking. $18 for two White Castles-sized sliders. It was easily consumed, and I was left much to be desired. This is most definitely an appetizer item, not an entree. The Chicken Waffle was good. Nicely deep-fried and packs a lot of flavor. The waffle looked dubious. If I had to guess, it might not be mad fresh to order. Essentially, it's 3 drumsticks/wings over a possibly frozen Eggo waffle. I would recommend a second dish if you are looking to get full. The Steak frites and Eggs Benedict were the final dishes served. It is hard to mess these dishes up, but the ribeye was nicely seasoned and cut up. The dishes were nicely displayed. Overall, this is just an OK experience. When the deep-fried cauliflower appetizer is the most memorable dish here, it is quite alarming. Portion sizes are on the small end, and none of the flavors for the entrees really stuck out. Perhaps I will come here strictly for the drinks next time.