We drive from Endicott to buy pizza here. Having been born in NYC, this is just like a New York City pizza. Ingredients are fresh. Staff is friendly and courteous. Parking may be a bit on a challenge in this neighborhood and you may need to walk a half block. They are next to Cavanaugh's market store and across the street from The Beef. We've had a few different styles of pizza but you can't beat their plain cheese. For me...it's like being back where my roots are. There are limited seat is you choose to eat in. read more

I have to be honest, I have NEVER been a fan of their pizza (red sauce) ,so I decided to try it again ( my wife loves their pizza).I ordered the roasted red pepper pizza ,added pepperoni. IT WAS AMAZING , you get a bite of sweet peppers along with the heat from the hot peppers, along with the pepperoni it truly was awesome, now I want to try the buffalo chicken pizza ... Highly recommend this place. read more

The servers are so kind and helpful. The pizzas are great and so flavorful. Highly recommend the vodka pizza.

Crisp yet also chewy thin crust, heavenly meatballs, perfect sauce. Friendly/helpful staff. Just a few tables, and a high top window bar for seating- this is very much a stop and eat quick or stop and run on home with your pizza treasure kind of place. Epic pizza, I very much enjoyed it- thank you, Paul and Sons! read more

Paul was amazing and his pizza is even better! Stopped in while on a roadtrip. Service was friendly and quick. Pizza was incredible - like Dave Portnoy 9+ good! Paul personally handled our food allergies with grace and professionalism. My daughter said the only thing bad about this place is "it's too far from home"! read more

Best pizza in all of NY (including NYC) Seriously there's no comparison. You can't really order in. Limited hours. But so worth it. Old school vibes. Chef Paul is incredible. Try the arrabiata and ricotta and you'll see what I mean. It's a little spicy, but the ricotta delivers an amazing finish. 10/10 recommend! read more

Paul & Sons Pizza - arrabiata and ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Binghamton, New York

Holy Shit! I'm from Queens and this pizza is LEGIT! Real NY pizza, nothing around compares! We got a pepperoni and sausage pie & a white garlic and ricotta pie with prosciutto and red onion. Amazing! Great portions, delicious pizza this place is my favorite place now! Authentic good quality pizza that's it!!! read more

See all

What a wonderful experience. From the moment I found their listing I knew I found the perfect place for our pizza order. Being from out of state and surrounded by pizza places you just never know. From the moment they answered the phone to the moment we had the pizza they were kind, friendly, and welcoming. We felt like we were dining with family. They treat you like you matter to them. It is genuine. The pizza was amazing. I wished I had ordered more to take home for our drive. My heart sank when I realized they are closed today :). I would have ordered more! (We. Ordered 10!) Such fresh ingredients. Such passion for food. Every single player loved it. Thank you again so much Paul and Sons and sweet Maggie. You made our night. Dana & New Hampshire Jr. Mountain Kings hockey team read more

See all

I live in Brooklyn and have been in Manhattan and Brooklyn for decades. My daughter goes to Binghamton and lives off campus across the street from Paul& Sons. Make no mistake, this is the best pizza I've had in years. I pretty much given up on most pizza in NYC but Paul & Sons revived my passion. This is as a good a pizza you will ever eat. Plus they know customer service. Casual, friendly, and so very kind. Don' go anywhere else. read more

This pizza is like dropping into a friend's house and discovering that their Italian nonna is visiting and has taken over the kitchen. I'm a sucker for the thin crust with a slight char on the bottom, fresh mozzarella, big basil leaves and halved Tom Thumb tomatoes of the TOMATO. This pizza has a fabulous homemade vibe of a home you want to return to. And I LOVE the refreshing fennel salad with pumpkin seeds and chick peas and a light dressing - add the feta! Yum! read more

See all

We needed a quick lunch and had never been. Usually tend to stay in Endicott for pizza. But honestly / this no frills place (with awesome customer service) is in our top places now. You can walk in and choose a slice from the pre-made options - and there were several. The spinach and ricotta was my favorite. Pepperoni had just enough spice. But the crust was the best part. A good crunch and flavor. We will be back. read more

Never a bad bite at Paul's! This sweet West side place has gourmet pizza with toppings you've never thought to use together.......a tasty adventurous experience! Eat in on a few casual tables or take out. Make time in your life for Paul's! read more

Love the hole in a wall restaurants! You can see the prep area and all of the fresh ingredients while you are ordering. Service are very kind and knowledgeable about their products. And the taste was amazing and mouthwatering. The pizza crust was also a perfect thin and crispy how I like it. I will definitely be going back here. read more

Great pizza Pricey $$, they enforce their time, open and closed, I really don't blame them, just maybe one hour earlier, if possible I passed it up several times because it wasn't, "(12:00pm)‼ actually" read more

After trying different pizza shops with in upstate we finally found the spot. Awesome NY City pizza by the slice. And a really nice owner. read more

Paul & Sons Pizza - 4 slices & 2 soda's $14!! - Pizza Near Me - Binghamton, New York

See all

I pulled up to this place after reading reviews and was underwhelmed by how the restaurant looks from the outside. Oh dear it needs a makeover, BUT the staff was super friendly. I was hoping to get pizza by the slice but they were so busy that they were unable to keep up with orders and keep slices available to order. So...we got a pie instead. To keep the kids happy we went with a basic pie and I asked for extra sauce just in case because nothing is worse than a glorified dry ass bread stick posing as a pizza. The pizza was great, sauce to cheese ratio was great and it was little spicy. I guess it was the pepperoni?? Idk. The kids did not complain and neither did I. I was quite happy to have extra left over slices to eat the next day. The only disappointment was that they did not have a Margherita pie as an option on their menu, and the pizza purist in me shuddered. read more

Paul & Sons Pizza - Pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Binghamton, New York

There probably is not much I can say about Paul & Sons Pizza that hasn't already been said but I will at least attempt to describe how much I love this place. I moved to Binghamton from Long Island a few years ago and was pretty disappointed at the quality of Binghamton's pizza until I went to Paul's. The exterior is nondescript which I feel is a good sign that the food inside will be great since amazing chefs usually let the food speak for itself. Paul is an award winning chef who is well known in Manhattan. He spent his career working at some of the finest eateries in NYC including a Michelin starred restaurant. His Pizza DOES NOT DISAPPOINT! All of the pies are insanely good, from the classics like cheese, pepperoni to his specialty pies like Gorgonzola, walnut, balsamic or his weekly specials which includes a mouth watering ramps covered white pizza or gyro styled pizza and many more. I can't recommend Paul's enough. Paul & Sons prioritizes quality over quantity which is rarely seen anymore. They are open 4 days a week Wed-Sat. It's pretty common to see a line forming outside before they open at noon so try and get there after 12:15 if coming for lunch. Stop in and try their pizza for your self if you haven't already. I promise you won't be disappointed. read more

Paul & Sons Pizza - White slice with assorted peppers!! - Pizza Near Me - Binghamton, New York

Absolutely best pizza in Binghamton no question, no competition, no debate, no controversy, no hot take, no DISRESPECT. Best pizza. Enough said. Ambiance--- old school new yawk. read more

See all

Our last dinner while in the area and we actually had eaten earlier but it was so early we were hungry again around 8 pm lol. We looked up pizza and this seemed to be the best. Plus omg feta cheese on pizza? Anyway we ordered and pizza was delicious. I can't say for all of Binghamton but from the places I went upstate this was my favorite pizza place. read more

I was passing through and a friend told me I had to grab pizza from here. I got two slices with different toppings and they were absolutely delicious. Nothing super fancy, but really fresh ingredients and amazing crust. Try it! read more

Best pizza in town!! I'm from Long Island and this is the only place I can go in Binghamton for my pizza! They messed up my order and were incredibly nice and accommodating. Will be coming back very often! read more

It is absolutely the best-tasting pizza in town. Good bread, delicious sauce. Obviously, they use high-quality ingredients

Very good. Good food. Excellent pizza. The best pizza in Binghamton hands down. Good service!

Excellent! Freshly made with delicious and different toppings. They also have soups and sandwiches which are fresh and tasty. Best pizza in town. read more

Hands down, the best pizza in Binghamton. Both times we've had their pizza, we've wanted to order on a day that they're closed but decide to wait till Wednesday and haven't regretted it. My family and I are Southern California transplants and have STRUGGLED finding good pizza. From the moment I saw the photos and reviews I knew this was our place and came closest to our favorites back home. The Sausage, Pepper and Garlic pizza is amazing, my favorite once I get it home. I bet though that the Tomato, Basil and Mozzarella would be equally amazing right out of the oven...well, a few minutes later since that stuff is hot lol High quality ingredients, taste and supporting a small business really can't taste any better. Keep making amazing pizza, Paul and Sons and we'll keep ordering and spreading the word. read more

Tried them recently for the 1st time and was quite impressed with the taste and overall quality of the pizza. A bit pricy...but not too pricy for the level of freshness...taste...and what I was expecting. And...checking other Mom & Pop pizza shops of late...they're all getting pricy. I guess Joey B's "Build Back Better" economic platform was blowing smoke up our arses!!! read more

The best NY style pizza I have ever had. If there was a global pizza olympics, Paul & Sons would represent the New York category. It is exemplary. Paul and his sons are true artisans. They elevate the NY slice without seeming pretentious. They have clearly put in thousands of hours into their craft. read more

Best pizza in town!! They have great specialty pizzas, and great customer service! Love coming here every week!

The pizza was excellent, closest thing to down state pizza in Binghamton. The amount of toppings is perfect. The service was also great & the employees were very friendly. read more

Not a bad pizza place, in fact the pizza here is above average for the area. A decent selection, but not much, and the pizza is not fresh, but most places wouldn't make slices fresh. Price is great, and the workers are nice, but there really aren't many so sometimes the wait is a bit long. Not the cleanest place either, but not to the point where it is an issue. In all, it's basically a small pizza place with good basic pizza. read more

2 slice special with a drink was great. Crust was just the way it should be, thin and a little crispy, AND if folded the way it should. Sauce was good, seasoned but not sweetened. Definitly would go back for more! read more

Paul and Son's has my favorite slices of all pizzerias combined within the Binghamton, Ithaca, and Oneonta areas. The house salad and the soups are very tasty as well. I'm surprised they don't have more reviews. Friendly owner as well. Also, the map on the wall to the left is terrific ! read more

We have gone to 4-5 pizza places since moving to the area and we have found Paul & Sons Pizza to be fantastic. Their pizza is always consistent and the staff is very polite and pleasant. Will continue to frequent especially on Friday nights ! read more