This is definitely my go to place for pizza, meatball subs, chicken parm platters or sub sandwiches. They have a wide selection of pizzas with different toppings. I have never gotten anything that I didn't enjoy. read more

Met some people here for a quick dinner. It's in a strip mall with lots of parking, which is a big plus. Lots of room inside & plenty of tables if you want to eat in, which was also excellent. The bathrooms were a little grubby I'm told, and there was very little lighting in the parking lot, but overall it was a nice enough neighborhood place. We ordered a couple of pies, which true to its name, were NY style. The pizza was good and the staff was friendly. Food came out fast. They had a local hot sauce (parlor city pepper co sweet heat) on the condiment table and it was phenomenal with the cheese slice. Super close to downtown too without being right in the heart of things. We were going to LUMA festival after, and this was the perfect place to grab a bite beforehand. read more

Best pizza in Binghamton Love the Buffalo chicken and Chicken Parm pizza. Prices are very reasonable. read more

Food 8/10 Service 9/10 Ambiance 7/10 Came in for a quick slice and was not disappointed. Although the parking lot can use some work my RV had plenty of room. read more

Stopped in to pick up an order for my office for a small celebration. Inside is really spacious for seating and customers. Staff were pleasant and communicative. We ordered three pies and an antipasto salad . The crust was well done for New York style pizza. Pepperoni style was not greasy and just the right amount of crispness. Reasonable size portion for the cost as well. A good style New York pizza for sure. read more

The mango habanero was fire! The taco one is good. Very New York, the chicken wings are saucyyy

OMG, don't let the neighborhood or lack of ambience scare you away. Trust me when I say, Ricotta Pizza will change your life! Thank you to the two officers who recommended it. read more

New York pizzeria has good but the service is is getting bad they did not show the first I ordered and they did not show the second time I ordered sk I had to call / ordered online e to get dinner read more

We're born and raised New Yorkers that moved to FL 13 years ago. We're up to visit friends and tried out New York Pizzeria. I was literally brought back to my childhood. I love the classic pizzeria look, the hot oven feeling and especially the yelling your order over the high pizza display! The pizza was delicious and the staff was super nice, even got excited when I told them this was my 7 month olds first time in NY and having NY pizza! (Don't worry she only chewed on the crust) Can't wait to come back in the future! read more

Pizza and service are way better if you go there to the Pizzeria. I would not recommend delivery.

Pizza took and hour and 20 minutes and was ice cold. Driver obviously had it in his car for at least 30 mins. Tried calling to complain and they kept hanging up on me. I order from you guys all the time. No more. At least Nirchi's shows up in a reasonable amount of time. read more

Great local pizza place. This place has been here for awhile so they know what they're doing

By far the best pizza in Binghamton. Best garlic knots. Best round pie. Get the prima sausage and pepperoni. Any pizza will do, it's all good. read more

Gotta love this place it's been there for well over 35 years and still going strong with great pizza.

Good! I'm from NYC living in Philly, so take my review with a grain of salt. Not great, just good, especially for the price. Half sausage, half mushrooms is 15 and change which isn't bad. The amount of sausage on the pie is ridiculous.. Seriously, you won't be wishing for more! Canned mushrooms, but that's no surprise. Thin crust which is good. The amount and flavor of the sauce was lacking for me and I wanted more cheese. Very nice people working the counter when I picked up and pleasant to place the order over the phone. read more

New York Pizzeria - Sausage and mushroom pie - Pizza Near Me - Binghamton, New York

Food was great service was much better then excepted loved it. The atmosphere was pizzeria very polite but casual

Great food, service and people! One of my favorite places in town! Their Stuffed spinach pizza pie is amazing! Love the people and how quick to get in and out too! Definitely a must for genuine Italian food! Five stars! read more

Had some family over and needed a quick dinner. Great food, friendly staff. Will be back

Was our super-fave pizza place until 1/2 hour ago. Called into order pizza, garlic bread, salads, and drinks, (we get carry out from there at least 2x A week)! NEVER AGAIN!!! Our call was answered by a exceedingly rude & disrespectful young woman. Was left with the impression our order ($25+) was an huge imposition to her. Guess this store has enough business that common courtesy and customer appreciation no longer matter. Oh well, we will be looking for a new pizza place. Even the best pizza in Binghamton is NOT worth such treatment. read more

Great pizza quick in and out if you like new york style pizza this is the place to go Large variety in toppings great price and good staff read more

Got order completely wrong. Clueless. And didn't even taste good. Avoid. Only giving it 2 starts because the clueless staff were at least pleasant as they screwed up the order. Really don't go here. read more

My new friend is on a Keto diet and getting her to eat pizza is like "parting the seas". A Saturday night I convinced her to order a pizza. I ordered a large mushroom and black olive and paid for it. To my surprise I got home and a plain pie was in the box. At that point it was too late to order something else. I strongly suggest you look in the box if you pick it up or even have it delivered to see what you have. Paying for something and getting less is not good service. read more

Food here is delicious with generous portions and reasonable prices. Great pizza. Garlic knots are legendary!!

i LOVE this place! The absolute best pizza-by-the-slice selection I have EVER seen. Usually over TWENTY different slices to choose from! Cheap prices! Their plain pizza (the best indication of a pizza joint's quality) is good. Not very good, not great, but good. This is about the only pizza place where the plain (cheese, red sauce) pizza gives me slight heartburn. Their specialty pizza is very good (not great, but cheap, and very good!). The Philly Cheesesteak (steak, peppers, onions), and there Taco pizza are very generously topped. Unfortunately, I usually avoid the Chicken Spiedie pizza because, I assume, spiedies are fully cooked before they go on pizza, then pizza is cooked. By the time the slice is reheated, chicken is pretty dry. read more

The best authentic NY style pizza in the area. You can't beat the subs, either! We always get takeout here and it's our favorite spot. read more

New York Pizzeria - Turkey sub - Pizza Near Me - Binghamton, New York

Prices, selection, freshness better than most Pizzarias in NY, and better than at least 90 per cent in all of Broome. Variety is really astounding. For the price of a tip in other places, you can have a full delicious lunch. 2018 / 2019 update No less than a dozen types of pie were available, even on a Monday. The slice specials are magnificently very satisfying and wholesome. Talk about fresh with quality you'll be impressed with. The really dedicated staff work with top efficiency together. The staff are solidly responsive and take tremendous pride and care to succeed from start to finish. There's a fine Sub / Hoagie menu right in front. Plenty of seating. Me and my other decided to eat al fresco in front; she had the 2 veg slice special, me just 2 plain. For the holidays, catering from here might well be a terrific crowd pleaser. Has and always will beat the competition. Overjoyed even more with each visit, Cordiali Saluti, L.- read more

We have ordered from New York Pizzeria three times and they have been great every time! They're delivery times are usually within 30-45 minutes even on a busy weekend and the food is never cold. My first tip is to try their garlic knots. They are so delicious -- may be some of the best I've ever had. As far as their pizza goes, I have only ordered their pepperoni and buffalo wing pizzas, both I highly recommend. The crust always has a nice crisp to it unlike some other reviews have suggested. I have ordered one of their cheesesteaks and it was pretty good, definitely one of the better ones that I have had since moving to Binghamton. After living in Philadelphia I have high expectations. I will order from them again, possibly tonight because writing this review is making me hungry. read more

I called earlier today for a large plain pie. They gave me an obviously old pizza, most like from last night. Disgusting. Embarrassed I purchased this to share with people. Have had NY pizzeria pizza that was good in the past. So this was a huge letdown. read more

Almost always on point! Whether delivered or eat in. Tonight's pizza was but at all typical. It was really thick and not as "greasy" as usual! I had half pepperoni & half crumbly sausages. Oh, it hurt didn't taste like their typical, with spices either. So disappointed. The salads are always just do so but ordered the large tonight. It consisted of iceberg lettuce, 2 tiny grain tomatoes& 2 slices of unpeeled cucumber. Boring! However, this being said-One time in the many times I have been! The staff works there asses off! Prices are great. Sometimes they can't keep up with the lunch mess and crowd. So you might have to clear a table. But you can't beat their lunch specials. It's one of the 2 restaurants in that area. And the best!! When my brother comes in from Savannah and my son comes in from Austin, Texas, they always want to eat here. Definitely the best New York style pizza in the area. And the delivery guy got here very fast and in a nasty rain storm. Thank you!! read more

New York Pizzeria - Basic large salad & pepperoni/sausage pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Binghamton, New York

Excellent pizza. Nice staff. Located in a completely abandoned strip mall that looks pretty sketchy at night. The pizza is worth it, but you might want to go with a buddy and watch your back coming and going from your car... read more

Ordered the eggplant parm pizza--totally hit my craving spot! Crust was just right, sauce nice and light, lovely texture on the eggplant--crispy on the outside and creamy on the inside! Now, my only problem is not with this fine establishment, but with Yelp itself. The boneheads who run this app have been getting opening hours wrong for quite a few businesses, including this one. I always filter for the hours a business is open before going because I don't want to be that jerk who walks in five minutes to closing and keeps everyone from going home on time. Even more awkward is walking in thinking you've got another hour, and only after being seated find out that you are indeed that jerk because the restaurant closes an hour earlier than reported on Yelp. Long story short: the pizza here is amazeballs but the hours are different than Yelp thinks they are. The hours (as of tonight, 6/26/17) are M-F until TEN, Saturday until 11, and closed Sunday. read more

This is another of my favorites! Guys in there are all friendly and don't keep you waiting. They have a buffalo chicken pizza that is PHENOMONAL!!! Has HUGE chunks of real chicken! Sauce is good and crust is very good. Nice area to sit inside and check out games, or sit outside. Pasta is really very good too. Excellent variety of almost everything! Restaurant is clean and comfortable and restroom is clean as well. Buy 2 slices and get a free fountain drink!! I easily give 5 stars....only way it could be any better is if you could get a Heineken.....;) read more

I grew up in Binghamton, believing that this was pretty mediocre pizza. No real reason to go unless you had to choose between it and Domino's. But then I moved to New York City, and realized - nope, it wasn't even mediocre. It was crummy. The decor is fairly run-of-the-mill, and the store is clean enough. Staff is pretty much hit-or-miss, and the prices are good. The actual pizza, however... I've learned that you can just have a thin crust and call it "New York" - see, the pizza has to actually be -good-. This floppy crust, bland sauce, and salty cheese don't qualify. At their peak, they're passable, but most times, I wonder again why I came in. (Because my best friend loves the place, that's why.) Oh well. If you find yourself standing in front of the place with nothing but a few dollars and an empty stomach, go ahead, it won't hurt you. But it won't leave you with a taste of New York, either. read more

Bacon pizza! Need I say more? :) It's one of the least greasy pizzas I've ever had. They have a buy two slices get a free drink policy for about $5. The crust was crunchy on the bottom and doughy in the middle. Delish! read more

New York Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Binghamton, New York

See all

Always pleased! Delish za awesome quick service.. Love the two slice soda lunch deal. A long time favorite of ours. read more

THE BEST pizza in Binghamton & their wings are beyond amazing. Busy or slow the staff is always the sweetest. Love this place and the owner works with his staff, notnjist behind the scenes. read more

The veal parm sub was mushy and disgusting tasting! Tasted like ground veal instead of cutlet..it was horrible

Their pizza is trash, they gave me dry chicken wing chicken on my "buffalo chicken pizza." See pics. Ridics. read more

New York Pizzeria - What the heck is this! - Pizza Near Me - Binghamton, New York

One of my favorite pizza places in the area! Lots of bang for your buck, and the specialty pizza flavors are all yummy in my experience

While I can't vouch for the other pizza shops in Binghamton NY, I'm assuming the other reviews are accurate in stating that this is the best pizza in the area. I know that's not really saying much. The two slices + a drink for $4 is a pretty good deal and the slices are a good size. It appears that they had a lot of different pizza options including a taco pizza and a buffalo chicken which my friends seemed to like. Taste wise, the pizza really wasn't bad. I went with the pepperoni. It was a bit greasy, but not over the top. The strip mall itself where it is located leaves much to be desired, but oh well. Decent pizza. Good prices. Ok bathroom. read more