Hadn't been here in a long, long time - at least a couple of boyfriends ago and I've been married for a while. So it was great relax with my guy in a burger joint that hadn't been manufactured in a board room. Great burgers - BIG! and the price was right and the service was stellar - no bs, no nonsense, no flashy up-selling. Just "you wanna a drink with your burger?" and yeah coleslaw so I get my veggies. Loved our waiter - she showed me how to change the colors on my new phone and gave me tips for cooking steak. We needed that burger after a really long day. Paul's was the perfect place to get away from all the overcrowded, really noisy, new fancy eateries. This place is real NY, real East Village, real neighborhood. We will be back. read more

True and true, a solid very big burger is exactly what you'll get at Paul's, along with the best steak fries with just a hint of salt. It's been here as long as I can remember. No frills, no big talk from the staff. They take your order, deliver it and let you enjoy. The place is truly authentic in decor, you would think it was a theme restaurant but it's legit and original design. Take a fun photo outside with the bigger than life burgers. read more

See all

The ambiance is great, it feels like you are in an older diner and time slowed down a bit. They had baseball running on some older model tvs which added to the vibe. The burgers are highly customizable but I found the fries and onion rings underwhelming on the seasoning and the same for the burger itself. With a half pound of beef its a substantial part of each bite and it not having any seasoning on it really made the burger bland. read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Combo fries - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The average price for a respectable New York city burger and fries thus far has been a painful $27.58, so it was refreshing to see a $17.50 price point at Paul's Da Burger for the great american combo. I've hit mostly the most popular spots so far, but a passionate minority have been in my DMs RIDING for Paul's in the East Village. I arrived and set foot into an ambiance that felt like a time capsule to the mid 90s: Checkered table cloths, a thick vizio TV playing NY Giants highlights on loop, vintage posters littering the walls, and signs that read "You don't get it your way. You take it my way, or you don't get a damn thing." It's a remembrance of the east village before androgynous transplants with fine line tattoos and black loafers took over. The nostalgic ambiance had me ready to pick up the Nintendo 64 sticks and play Ocarina of Time. I sat down, put my order in for an American Cheeseburger with fries that ran $17.50, and pulled out my trusty scale from a past life to weigh this thing. It came in at a whopping 14oz, which makes it the heaviest burger we've had yet. You also get a healthy portion of 8.3 oz of fries. As much as I would have loved this thing to go crazy, it's not competing with the high level burgers. The beef is fresh ground sirloin and was juicy, but was hardly seasoned. The bun was uninspired and disintegrated after a few bites, and it was just sloppy to eat overall. 6.3/10 for me. However I will say, sometimes I do want a cheap burger in a no frills environment when I'm battling a hangover. It helps me reset and get back to myself. IG @johnny.novo Tiktok @jnov__ Substack @johnnynovo read more

See all

Love this place. Their burger has been the best burger in NYC since the beginning. Beefy, juicy, and hefty! We've been coming here off and on for over ten years, and the burgers never changed. read more

I went to this quirky little burger place a couple of months ago. The staff were friendly, and it seemed like a bunch of the other people eating there were regulars, similar to the similarly old-school but very different B+H Dairy a couple of doors down. While the burgers are pretty big, the price point is a bit high for a burger, especially when it comes to adding accompaniments (I've honestly never heard of any place charging more for lettuce, for instance.) I didn't bother with a drink and ordered a medium rare Deluxe Mushroom Burger, with the deluxe option adding lettuce and tomato on the side, along with fries. I also asked for pickles. In general, the deluxe option is $7 more. The burger is listed as "smothered with mushrooms," and was $20.25 for the deluxe option. The burger itself was the size of those you can find at many diners, but compared to those diners, it was much juicier, though maybe it could have used a little more salt. The bun eventually fell apart from the juiciness of the burger, and there is a kaiser roll option for a dollar more, but I wouldn't bother. The mushrooms were a bit different from the usual ones on burgers, which I was happy about. They were meaty, and there was indeed a whole lot of them, so the add-on was worth it. The fries were pretty standard, with a good amount of crispiness, and were salty enough. For the price, I wouldn't bother getting the deluxe version next time. The burger was juicy enough that the tomato and lettuce weren't necessary, while the fries weren't good enough on their own that I would pay $7 more just for them and the other toppings. For a bit over $14 before tax and tip, I would definitely get it again. However, if I wanted to pay over $20 for a burger, I'd rather stop at other places that also offer cheese or much better fries, such as my favorite burger at Wollensky's Grill, or somewhere else. I might also try their smash burger next time, which I think was $8.50 or a dollar more. I can see why they've been in business for a while, though similar to other spots serving junkier food, I probably won't be back for a while. read more

See all

Recently, a friend was hosting a gathering for their birthday at the Otto's Shrunken Head bar as he was a big fan of the place and he wished to convene with close friends. When he pointed out that he was planning on some dinner at Paul's da Burger Joint before the bar I asked if I could join in on that since I had not been here in a number of years. In addition to that I was even more surprised that I had not managed to offer up a Yelp about any of the past experiences so here we are. For the unaware, Paul's is a burger joint off of Saint Mark's Place on 2nd Avenue and while it might seem like a hole in the wall, its a place that you surely want to drop into should you be craving a burger or happen to be visiting our neck of the woods and are on the carnivorous side. There is sufficient seating to relax in and while I am not 100% certain I think that you can also sit at the counter if there is a need for that. There is some Rock and Roll themed decor and the whole place smells like the grill which might annoy some but I honestly enjoy it. I kept my order simple with a Bacon Cheeseburger and a side of Fries. These burgers are sizable and this would sustain me for the time that was to be spent in Otto's. I don't drink so I wasn't worried about needing something substantial in my stomach before that part of the fun. My friend and I chatted comics and films while we ate and enjoyed the Punk Rock and Metal that was playing over the speakers. Though my buddy and I were each covering our own orders, the policy of Paul's is one check per table so I'd have to Venmo him my amount afterwards since I was strapped for hand cash at the time. Lately I've been using Google Pay for everything. I always recommend this place to my fellow carnivores and especially since there is a fun hamburger photo op out in the front of the restaurant. Thanks Paul's, I will not be taking years to get back there again. read more

See all

Forget a smashburger, if you want a real burger for "the price it is worth," as described by internal signage, come to Paul's. Make sure to be attentive to behind the counter, as the sizzling burgers being pressed on the grill continue to make my mouth water. Simple menu offerings remind you of how long Paul's has been around, and how they haven't changed their decorations or process one-bit from the good ol' days. Expect the type of service that would help with anything, but in a slightly rude and old time way. It was a great experience and a generic burger with cheese hit the spot to cure a drinking induced hangover. read more

Burger was bland and had no flavor also was not a fan of the pickles coming from someone who loves them. Tasted like gym socks. Also $7.00 for a beer is definitely an overkill. The only good part of the meal was the curly fries. read more

Good servers, good decor, good food. I got the cheeseburger Deluxe and my friend got the El Paso Burger Deluxe. Both were good in a very classic, greasy, juicy American diner burger way. And I really want to emphasize, GREASY and JUICY. The bottom bun was completely soaked through with the juice and grease of the Patty. The patty itself tasted high quality but could have used a bit more salt. Additionally, I wish that the burgers came with a bit more fries. Even though the burger was quite large, I found myself eating through the fries fairly quickly. Despite the large portions, it was pretty expensive. Paying $17.50 for a burger with fries is a bit hard to swallow especially with tax and tip surely bringing the charge to over 20 dollars. read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Cheese Cheeseburger Deluxe - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

This is Da Burger joint that you must visit. It's a classic NYC establishment off St Marks in the East Village with retro interior and a cow at the counter that says THIS IS NOT BURGER KING. I was a little overwhelmed by the menu. They list a whole page of burgers with every topping possible. And two rows of prices - regular and deluxe. It's annoying that they charge for basics like lettuce tomato onion. Apparently pickles are free though lol. It's one of those menus that you can end up with a $20 burger accidentally. I paid $15 for a Pepper Jack cheeseburger medium done with lettuce tomato and pickles. Only after did I see a smash burger for 8.99 on the board menu. I was looking for a quick in and out situation but the burger I ordered would've been a better for dining in. Noted! I got the burger to go and paid cash because they charge a fee for credit cards.. let's get with the times. When I was down the block I couldn't wait and took a giant bite out of the burger. It was super juicy and the patty was thick. The meat to bread ratio was impressive. The patty isn't seasoned but there's salt and pepper in the bag which I didn't bother with. Great fcking burger!! I kept eating it and it wasn't getting smaller.. Excited to try the smash burger next time. read more

See all

Really expensive bad burger with no atmosphere. I'm a big fan of hole-in-the-wall joints but if you have no ambiance, you have to have good food or good prices. You can't charge $17 for an unseasoned, bland, lumpy burger and 10 steak fries. Also, bun was cold. read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Cheeseburger Deluxe - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

We have been going to Pauls for years and can always depend on a really great burger. Service is excellent, everyone seems happy to work there. The four of us went last Sunday and all ordered (surprise!) burgers. Their selection of toppings is endless and you can really get creative. However, there are times when the classic American Cheese burger is what you crave. We all take it rare, but in Paul's case, order the med rare. The rare barely sees the griddle. Their milkshakes are wonderful. The atmosphere is kind of kitschy, or they really haven't done much with it over the years, but it's a comforting, welcoming little place that has long escaped one's burger radar. Go. Another note, we were a party of 4 and normally tip 20-25%. We were surprised that they included their tip. Which was less than we were going to leave. That was a bit annoying, but we went with what they felt they were worth. Go anyway. And remember cash is cheaper than credit. As a P.S.: if you are going into our City and complain about a burger costing $17, that's what it is. Deal, or don't, but don't bitch about it. Every savvy person who is aware of skyrocketing rent, product costs these days do not begrudge a restaurant for doing their best. Paul's product is fantastic, and the cost really isn't hard to swallow. Reviews from silly people complaining about pricing need to stay home, or move to a square state. read more

Had the pleasure of visiting Paul's Da Burger joint. We had a great server who took our order quickly and the food came pretty fast. The burgers were so big. The food was delicious. Love the quirky signs and the old school style of the restaurant. read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

If you're looking for an authentic big juicy cheeseburger with fries and an ice cold beer this is the place !! The best burgers I've had soooo juicy Their cheesesteak was delicious too definitely recommend this place Super cute retro diner decor inside read more

See all

Super slow when I was there and service was good (I got there at like 5pm). The burgers need more seasoning otherwise, good food.

Glad I came up from Hells Kitchen. Worth the cab ride for their signature burger. My local homie was right.

A traditional no-frills burger spot with a good selection of beers. Burger and fries are up to standard at a pretty good price read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

The burgers here were just alright. I wouldn't say it's a bad burger, but it's not my favorite in NYC for sure. The burger itself is pretty thick and I personally like a thin cut of beef, but if you like big meaty burgers then you may like it! However, the bottom bun got soggy extremely quick and fell apart the moment I picked up the burger. This was due to the heavy greasy liquid in such a massive patty size. The burger was also frozen and could have used some more seasoning. As for the fries, they are your standard fries, so you can't really go wrong here! The gravy on the fries added a nice savory flavor and the fries itself were crispy and airy. I asked for a side of chipotle mayo to add flavor to my burger, but I found the mayo to be too runny, as if some water was added to it. I will say the service is amazing. The servers and chefs are so friendly and accommodating and that made the experience nice! The interior also makes you feel like you're inside of an 80s diner and I enjoyed that ambiance. I would say if you're looking for a quick burger fix that will satisfy a craving, give Paul's a try, but in general, I don't think I'd be back for a burger. The fries are great though! Also, if you do come here, get an ice cream soda. The coke float was the perfect sweet beverage to go with a greasy burger. read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Eastsider Burger Deluxe Gravy Fries - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

I lived in NYC for years and Paul's was always a favorite from the moment they opened back in the day. I was in the city with my son recently showing him my old stomping grounds which included a mandatory stop at Paul's. Same vibes, same friendly staff and welcoming vibes. I was thrilled that it hasn't changed a bit and that I was able to turn the next generation onto the awesomeness of Paul's. Please never change! read more

The place is a great local place to come eat and relax...I recommend any one in the neighborhood to stop by read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Get the Burger ....any one - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I saw Paul's written up among the greatest hole in the wall burger places in each state so we were in the neighborhood and came over. It is as advertised a great little hole in the wall with a great burger. We had the St. Marks burger w/ cheese mushrooms and onions. It is a large patty and actually was served perfectly medium rare. I was working so the fries would have been too much but next time I'm in. read more

By far one of the best burgers that i have ever had. Its juicy and flavorful. The fries are really good.

Village standard for many years. Great burgers with endless selection of toppings, crispy fries and other standard grilled food. A friendly joint indeed. read more

@jefeeatsss For Video Review. To start off I ordered my burger medium well and the burger meat was tender. It tasted like a classic bacon cheeseburger. I added ketchup and mayo to it. The fries were unsalted but still were fresh and crispy. It was very good and I would definitely eat here again. It has a nostalgic aesthetic when you walk in. There's a lot of New York memorabilia inside. The service was great when ordering to finishing up my order. They showed me hospitality. read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Bacon Cheeseburger and Fries - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Sadly this joint isn't as wonderful as snoop's help might bring in order to actually choke down this bland burger, and fries that don't even deserve to find themselves on a plate for service. Speaking of service my buddy didn't even order anything because as he had the menu in his hands one of the employees literally kept harassing us every 2 minutes are you ready.. That's definitely not inviting regardless how limited a menu is. I honestly think the aesthetic is why most people like it because they have random stuff thrown up all over the place like an ADD nightmare in making. This is like a sleazier version of Mel's for anyone who's heard of that diner which is hard to get sleazier I might note. Especially since I'm talking the Sunset Strip location not even Hollywood. Now onto the look of the bland burger that tasted like it was boiled for hours loosing all nutrients/flavor possible. Sure it's a thick burger, but what's that good for without any flavor? It's like a Mondo Burger.. Looks like it will fill you, but ultimately leaves you wondering how on earth you ended up here. Was Thanos right!? read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - My buddy's experience through my eyes! - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

I've been going to Paul's from the beginning. Paul's used to be a delivery boy for an upper east side burger place. He graduated to being a cook at the same burger place, saved his money and opened Paul's Da Burger. I always have a Turkey cheese with mushrooms. It is by far the best Turkey burger I've ever had. I'm addicted and make trips to Paul's from my home in Jersey. Yes, they are that good. read more

Cheeseburger. SUBPAR. No flavor. If this Burger had a personality it would be labeled BORING & BLAND. Impressed by the size of the Burger which I wasn't expecting but it wasn't seasoned. PAUL'S DA BURGER JOINT advertises itself as NYC'S Best Burger but sadly that is not the case. WALK DON'T RUN. read more

See all

Paul's burgers and fries are top notch. I am a burger snob and Paul's is one of the best in NYC. The prices are very fair for the amount of food you receive. The food is always consistent and the service is always prompt. Long live Paul's! read more

Best burger in NYC by far! Huge backyard bbq style patty and never over seasoned like those flat patty smashes everywhere else. I love love love this joint! read more

Back when I lived in Virginia, there were several burger joints that I would frequent that provided a delicious and enjoyable experience that is hard to duplicate. Joints like Holy Cow, Damn Good Burger, Basic Burger, and Good Stuff Eatery would take the cake any day over Shake Shack. Sure, it could be a pricey meal, but the size of the burger, along with an incredible milkshake and an order of hand cut fries could make any lunch, or dinner, a real treat. Could Paul's Da Burger Joint keep up with the Jones's and join this fraternity of burger shops? The burger here is massive. A half pound hunk of meat, served on a toasted potato roll. I got mine with bacon, egg, and American cheese (they have a selection of burgers or you can make your own). To me, I love an egg on a burger. It adds depth and flavor to balance the meat. I also believe the burger patty should be the star of any burger, and here, they put it up front and center. It could use a bit more flavor, and it is scorching hot when it comes off the flat top, but it definitely is the center of attention. The egg is not messy, but does not really add much. The cheese is good, as is the bacon. However, I should have gotten a mayo or something to add a bit more to it, but it tastes quite alright without it. As for the milkshake I ordered, I got a black and white per my servers suggestion. At first I liked this, since it is more like a drink than a milkshake, but that is the problem. It is supposed to be drank like a milkshake, not glorified chocolate milk. I also believe they "cheat", using a vanilla ice cream base and pumping in syrup rather than authentic flavors. Also, add an Oreo milkshake. It would bring in more customers. Another suggestion is a chocolate marshmallow milkshake. Believe me, it is as good as it sounds if you ever tried one. The fact they do not hand cut their fries is a disappointment. Those are the best. Instead, here they are pre-frozen and then cooked. Oh well. I will not get these. Since this ended up being $20, that is not bad for a burger. However, I expect more than what I got, which is why I deduct a star from this review. It has the basic components down, but needs a few more tweaks to make it a damn good burger. Then I will be able to say holy cow! This is some good stuff. read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

The place is a greasy filthy mess and unappetizing to eat in. The burgers are unremarkable. Not sure why this places gets such recognition.

It's tasty but it's also freakin' messy. We didn't even mind eating outside on the busy sidewalk because this burger would've never made it home (grease prolly would've ate through the bag about midway). My biggest complaint is the lack of salt. You gotta salt your meat man. You just gotta do it... read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

No fills classic burger joint that has been a neighborhood classic for years love the small old school diner vibe that reminds me of old simpler times in NYC and I hope it stays for years to come. Classic burger joint with every and all burger combinations that you could possibly think about . I had the classic bacon cheeseburger with a nice thicc slab of ground beef. Such a great mix of fat beef the bun is so fluffy yet firm. I also reccomend that you get the fired pickles love it soo much. read more

See all

Great homey place with juicy, perfectly cooked burgers. My so had the Sou l burger- a monster of a burger with bacon and grilled onions. A juicy medium rare as requested. The steak fries were delicious and demolished. I had a cheddar cheeseburger with shoestring fries. Huge and juicy. The fries were seasoned well and not too salty. My husband's burger was the Eastside burger with Bacon, cheese, mushrooms and onions. Cooked to order - medium. It was a great spot on a rainy night. Satisfying and the burgers hit the spot. read more

See all

The best turkey burger in NYC. You can customize any burger any l, way you want. The beef burgers are fire as well. They have mad templates on the menu you can easily run with. Friendly fast service. The only reason this doesn't get 5 stars is because of the grimey decor, which I ironically like, it harks back to the New York City I grew up in and was molded by. I come here all the time for lunch and I'm not ever disappointed. read more

Recently named to a top 25 list of restaurants in NYC in The NY Times, this food is shockingly not even average. I love a good dive place that puts out great food with zero ambiance, like I loved La Caridad for almost 30 years at 78th and Broadway, but the food was noticeably and unbearably not even average. Last night a hefty burger that seemed like it was cooked maybe half in a microwave and half in a steamer, not sure how else there was no flavor and no grill marks and no sear or crust, sat on top of a bun. Flavorless and flat, Lovely's Old Fashioned on 8th Ave has nothing to worry about, boring and a waste of time. The onion rings and French fries were also lifeless and unmemorable. I love great burgers. All types. But this is maybe the worst burger I've had in so many years that I can't remember one that challenges it for being more bad. It certainly doesn't help that my kid and I were hyped for awesome burgers when we walked in, but even when we started eating them and realized they were not going to compete at that level, well they met only the worst expectations of a burger. Too bad. Here is the link to the article that drew us to this place: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/11/dining/our-reader-favorite-nyc-restaurants.html read more

WORST BURGER. Absolutely ghastly. The decor of this place is cute but the food is just beyond awful and EXPENSIVE. $30 for a burger, horrible fries and a beer read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Bar area - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Oh yeah.... Burgers as big as your head! $20 for a pizza burger with fries. So good. Nothing has changed in there in many years, other than the prices. Fluorescent lighting. Dirty walls. Strong chemical smells of cleaning solution. But burger was awesome! Pizza Burger Deluxe! Mmm. read more

Paul's Da Burger Joint - Pizza Burger Deluxe - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Massive burgers, and friendly staff. Burger are decent but I wouldn't say they are the best burgers we've ever had, granted we live in New York and the bar is pretty high. I think the meat could use a little more seasoning and I wasn't too crazy about the steak fries that came with the burgers. Overall a good experience and I'd recommend this place at least once and go back if I'm in the neighborhood. read more

See all