Stopped in for a quick slice of pizza. The presentation of the slices had alot to be desired as some of the pizza looked like it had been there overnight. I ordered slice of cheese and it was ok. Overall the whole place looked kind of dirty and rundown. Probably would try again but not at this location. read more

See all

If I could rate for friendliness it would be an easy 5.. Just a heads up!!! The online menu vs actual menu are different. This location does not offer anything fried because they don't have a fryer? I assume lol The wait for a cheese calzone, and cheesy bread was wild lol so do not be in a rush lol Had to update now that we tried the food The cheesy bread they made was not good at all. Photo included .. The pizza was basic, not terrible Sub was ok read more

Pavone's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

The food was bad and servicer was rude- not in a safe area. Try a different side of town.

Pizza is actually great, It's the atmosphere that's off putting , the homeless outside and inside are always in this area and constantly asking for money . This area always seems sketchy and unsafe . Unfortunately for this business I will no longer be patronizing this establishment. read more

Killer good pizza and the price is right. I ate so fast and forgot to take a pic. Will definitely be back when downtown Syracuse.

I went into pavones today to get a salad. Today's date in May 13th 2026. There was a man behind the counter who looked so high on drugs. Kept Dozing off but what made it worse. While he was making my salad. He was eating things then putting his hands in my salad. So I walked out and got my money back. Never again will I go there. read more

A favorite pizza joint for me and many folk. Some go for lunch, some grab slices after work or order a whole pie to take home with them. Slices at lunchtime are always fresh, and they usually have about five or six different options, besides standard cheese or pepperoni. One of my favorites is their garlic pizza. It's salty and tasty and garlicky without chunks of garlic or a heavy garlic sauce. Another favorite is their garlic knots. I could eat a dozen of those for lunch - but then I'd need a nap. They are just the right amount of buttery, and garlicky and crunchy and soft. Soda in bottles or from the fountain. Decent indoor seating if you're staying. read more

Slice quality has fallen off a cliff over the past 2 months. Slices are often soggy and floppy, and I've found that taste has also been inconsistent. Hard to go back for lunch when I'm constantly having to throw my slices in the trash read more

Very kind service and quality slices! A tiny bit pricey but the quality and employees made it worth it.

Great inexpensive place to eat, food is good quality and well prepared This business is ran efficiently even if you see a long line you'll get through it pretty quick, Dining area is clean and comfortable as are the bathrooms Only downside is one they don't take credit cards (At least not at the downtown location they do at the Manlius location) and 2. The first time I tried the call ahead ordering, it wasn't even started when I got there, hopefully an oversight I'll give it a try again read more

Pavone's Pizza - Bigger menu online - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Trash compared to the other one in the nice neighborhood, dirty, dingy, slices look like from yesterday pizza never come back to this location read more

Good New York pizza Atmosphere is degraded due to homelessness. Friendly staff Good price. read more

Greeted beautifully upon entering by who we call THE POLITE MAN...man serving us...very engaging, kind, super polite. (We stopped off the highway after reading some reviews.) Diner-like place in the city. Pizza was very good--(hidden very hot under the tomatoes and cheese!! Be careful.) I had a meatball/sausage combo and it was out of this world. Awesome sauce, delicious well made meatballs and sausage on an excellent roll. Hmmmm I want to go back right now!! read more

Pretty good pizza, nice ambiance, and good service! They did give us ranch instead of blue cheese (or maybe their blue cheese tastes like ranch? It's unclear.) Otherwise I'm satisfied! read more

I'm originally from Long Island, where the pizza is out of this world. Pavone's is the closest to LI pizza I've found in Syracuse. I love it! Thank you read more

This place is going down hill customer service is horrible The new staff is not pleasant I ordered and pizza and was the only one there and it took 30mins if employees would of stopped small talk it would of been done quicker read more

Great NY style pizza. We were in town for medical and stayed in our room most of the time. They delivered to our hotel in about 45 min. Very suave, thick crust, fresh toppings. Very big pizza!! We would have ordered a smaller size if we could have. A lot was wasted. Cheese bread with sauce was worth it as well. read more

Been on a pizza kick lately and Pavone's was on the bucket list. Sampled the cheese slice and was not disappointed. Nice sauce and solid quality cheese, the crust is chewy- a little thin to support the toppings. Not too greasy. there was a long line in the shop... clearly locals are aware of the quality grub at this joint. Would definitely recommend this place for a quick slice! read more

Food was good, especially for the price. Will go back if I am back in town. The help is doing their best as they were new based on our discussion, I would not have guessed they were new except one was training the other. read more

If you have that cheap home phone service that keeps advertising on TV, then make sure you don't miss any payments. This pizza place is named to remind you when to send your money to the phone company: "Payvonage Pizza." The guy told me the pizza didn't need warming, and it totally did. It was lukewarm. The Garlic Knot I bought was only 55 cents which is an amazing price. It tasted pretty good but it was already cold, too. If they didn't really make pizza at all, and were located in Philly, it would be PAphoney's Pizza. After Paladino's it's my fave pizza in SYR, but that's not saying much because I haven't tried that many. As I said with Nick's, bear in mind that I give a 5 star to anything that really does it for me. A 4 star is more "average" because I don't rate family businesses less than 3. So a 3-star family business is more like a "1 star" to you. And my 4 is more like your 3, maybe. With that in mind, the 4 star here means that Nick's is not my favourite. If it were Pacino's Pizza then Robert DeNiro would come here to eat just to remind himself what his biggest rival is up to. I liked it slightly better than nearby Nick's, and the selection was pretty good. The crust was a nice hard NY style base, and had a real crunch to it which I liked. Make sure you always insist that your slice is properly warmed, though. This pizza is verging on a 5, and it's great that the location is downtown, but I'm going to stick with a 4 just because overall I think it was a little bit too dry. And if it was Paterno's Pizza then lots of underage boys would end up scarred for life by eating it, so I just want to say, I'm glad it's not. read more

See all

Pavones is without a doubt the best place to grab a slice downtown on your lunch break. The slices always taste fresh and are not greasy like some pizza can get. If your ordering a full pie it's a little pricey but is very convenient if you don't feel like making dinner. Would recommend read more

The highlight of a trip downtown is Pavone's Pizza sandwich. I've enjoyed them for years. I don't know what happened since I was there last, but they changed the way they make it and it wasn't good. No flavor, dry and meatballs? Now where near as good as they used to be. Their pizza wasn't anywhere near as good either. I have no idea what happened, but someone made changes and they weren't good. I won't be going back anytime soon. I so bummed. read more

It was one of those, "if-I-don't-eat-pizza-right-now-everyone-will-rue-the-day," kind of evenings, so we speed walked over to Pavone's. While we waited for our slices, a lively conversation between the staff and a patron who ate his slice with the paper plate and pizza folded in half ensued. We quickly learned the fellow patron was originally from the Bronx. Then a friendly debate about which borough of NYC has the best pizza began. An answer to whether Pluto's status as a planet would be easier to come to than the great pizza debate of ever, and despite the entertainment value, we were fortunate our slices were ready before the discussion really got underway. The cheese slice was pretty much what you would expect. It had a thin crust and while I didn't think there was anything particularly outstanding about it, I would get it again because it felt like it had a sense of consistency backing it up. Now the mushroom slice was sooo good. So much so that I felt slight ordering remorse about the plain cheese. Would I get it again? UM, YES!!! In short, I'm overjoyed that I live a quick walk away from this establishment, and it's definitely going to me my go-to. read more

See all

Great pizza ! Wish I had a picture to upload but the truth i ate it before I had a chance- delish! My go too is the pepperoni bu t the garlic and veggie options looked amazing too - also .. they have a Hawaii! So I'll be back to try them all read more

Wow this place brings back tons of memories of my early to mid 20's. Back in that day there was hardly any food to eat on Warren street. The glorious Sutherland days when hot food was essential to survive the harsh call center days. I still remember deciding with coworkers between Subway, The Bagel Shop(now closer), and here. So I can that I have had a lot of different foods here, but never once I have I loved anything I've gotten. It's not terrible or bad in anyway, but there are just a lot more other places I would go to for a good slice of pizza...or even a whole pie. Besides their pizza, I would also get their pasta dish with meatballs. That was pretty good, but again not outstanding. The service here was always meh at best, sometimes you would get a cool person, but most of the time they kinda seemed like they weren't feeling the place. When I came back here to try it out again, everything was exactly how I remembered. A decent place if your on Warren and don't have a lot of time, but not a recommendation from me. read more

Should be a 0 rating but Yelp won't let me. First no gloves were worn by anyone on 4/14/22 at 11:45am. While I'm waiting to cash out with 5 other people behind me now. They are arguing with each other who is going to make the salads, get the spaghetti or run the register. After 5min of no one still cashing me out I left the pizza on the counter and said I'm out. I work downtown and it's close to my office. But I'm done going there. Skeeves me out that not one of them had gloves on. read more

Butternut location - Our order was supposed to be delivered at 11:45-11:55am. Called at 12:05 pm they said the delivery driver just left, he would be here soon - their ovens turned off so they were a bit behind. No problem! 12:20 we call back. We were met with a very rude female stating delivery driver had other stops, he would be there soon. A male employee called us back shortly after saying the delivery driver is here but didn't have our number (they forgot to write it on his form). The delivery driver apologized and was very very nice. Their customer service sucks, the pizza was burnt and tough to bite. The wings were good and crispy. They forgot one of our pizzas too. Overall, our office will not be ordering from them again. read more

Pizza is great compared to the other spots I been too. Everyone has their preferences I'm from Chicago so I'm about the sauces and crust. I got the special and it was delicious although I get extra sauce. But I'm a sauce person. read more

The perfect slice. We should ask for their dough recipe says my 10 year old son. 2 cheese slices and a drink for $5.35. A couple nicer downtown restaurants to capacity. The 2 of us took advantage of the special. My son remarked "it's GOOD!" Talking with his mouth full. Yup! And we just saved 50 bucks! read more

Pavone's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

We have traveled back to New York for business here in Syracuse and let me tell you this Pizza place is Phenomenal!! I travel for a living so I'm well versed in Restaurants ect... The dough,sauce and cheese is Excellent AAAA++++++ Highly recommend read more

What Pavoni is lacks in luster, excels at making pizza that is pretentious in its simplicity. They're not trying to make a killing at slices of pepperoni at 2 1/2 bucks each. There's a lot to love and get change back in your pocket. Make a memory and keep this local effort going strong. read more

The pizza is amazing - arguably better than Mario and Sakvo's. They used to work at Pavone's back in the day, I hear. I can't compare the pizza to that at the other Pavones in town, but I don't see how any of them could be better. Definitely consider ordering the extra large. It's a great value, and just freeze what you can't finish. It's almost as good as it tastes at the parlor. read more

Solid NY Style pizza. Not too greasy, nice crust (if you buy by-the-slice) and a very good taste. If you are from the BiG city you'll find it above average, but probably not as good as your favorite pizza joint. However, quality for price is fantastic. Drop in and grab a slice. read more

Wasn't as good as I remember it. Pizza was ready in ten minutes. That was a good thing. Good pizza Just wasn't fantastic this time. Thicker and a bit chewier than last time with cheese only in middle of pie. Still good. Just not amazing. read more

This place has been around for years, you can tell by the outdated seating area. Also the place could use a paint job and some updated kitchen supplies. They don't even have a POS system, still writing it down and using an old cash register. The food is still good, I gave it 3 star rating because my crust was blackened on the bottom from either not using a screen when warming or over cooking it, not sure which was to blame. Went there during lunch and was surprised to see that there was an abundance of slices available, and I think they should pre-cook some chicken wings so you don't have to wait 10 minutes for them to cook. The salads are big but a lot of it is iceberg lettuce, they could use more romaine or Greenleaf to spruce it up. Overall not a bad place, but they could do some improvements. read more

Words Do Not describe the food! I am New to Syracuse! I grew up in In NYC! Last 24 years outside of Philly. First the positives. The bread the sandwiches were on we're good. By the time we got home ( 6 miles away) the grease from an attempted cheese steak were leaking everywhere?!? Negatives. I have never tasted "gravy" with such a bitter after taste in my life! We trid an eggplant Parm sandwich, Fried Musheroom app, cheese steak without the peppers because Jalpenos do not belong on a Philly cheesesteak! And a plain pizza! Dinner for three $37.04 3/4 of it is in the trash today! This restaurant came with high reviews! Still tasting it in a bad way. read more

Having grown up in Long Island I have high standards for pizza. Luckily, this place meets my standards! I usually get a plain slice to go. Just like the typical pizza you would commonly find in Long Island or New York City, this pizza has nice thin crust, tasty tomato sauce, but not too much sauce, and delicious mozzarella cheese. They always have a variety of slices available from different meats to some vegetarian options. Their garlic knots are pretty good too. The calzones are a popular item. The guys behind the counter always serve with a smile. One even complimented me on my manicure! It is a casual place with the same type of pizza place decor I am accustomed to. Some may call the decor dated, but I call it traditional. The one located in Downtown is my usual spot. One night when this location closed early we got delivery from one of their other locations. They also have a catering menu. It's no surprise that it is owned and operated by descendants of Sicily trained in NYC! read more

If this is the best pizza anyone has ever had, they don't get around much. I do like it here, but it is a block from my office so convenience trumps taste. The staff is friendly but the customers can be a bit sketchy. Still a three star though, i am a regular here. read more

Walked into the pizza shop and put my shirt covering over my face, I had walked 4 blocks from where I had parked before I had gotten there. As soon as I walked in I apologized and the man upfront said no problem. A man who I assumed was the manager came out and started yelling at me about not having a mask on yet she didn't even have a mask on himself. I had advised of the situation and he started to get really aggressive. At the same time one of the workers told me that they don't want my business and why am I even buying pizza at this point. This gentleman as well had a mask on but it wasn't even covering his nose or mouth yet he said these horrible things to me. The worst customer service that I have ever experienced I definitely will never go back to this place ever again. Very disgusted with the way they treated me. I do not advise going to this place if you don't want good customer service and wants to deal with very mean arrogance insulting people. I tried the food and it was rock solid, I took the food back in with my mask on and one of the guys that was being disrespectful still didn't even have his mask on properly. read more

Pavone's Pizza - One of the employees who told me they didn't want my business and still not wearing his mask properly after they insulted me. - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

This is my all time favorite pizza! I ate a slice every day from this particular shop for lunch while I was pregnant for my daughter, Ironically it is her favorite pizza now too. I was not working near a Pavones when I was pregnant for my son, so I had to settle for Pizza Hut for lunches. Guess what pizza he likes the best? I have seen a lot of great places come and go.. this is one I hope is around for many years to come. read more