My kid uses his first-edition "PB&J With Tay" t-shirt like a bat signal. He wears it on days he wants a sammy. This has been our routine more or less every other Saturday for the past five years. So I have somewhere around 130 sandwiches under my belt, and my gifted little Bat-Potato has maybe double that (he loops his momma into the rotation on her weeks). --- Be forewarned that it's peak midlife lunch. By that I mean Tay's doesn't have niceties like an all-you-can-drink Bloody Mary bar. Frankly, I'm not even sure Tay has a liquor license. On the surface, Tay's seems to prioritize the whims of my nine-year-old. But it feels wholesome as fuck. Wholesome like...you'll get an enthusiastic "HI FRIENDS!" on the way in, guaranteed. It's not unlike arriving at a preschool; I love it. Tay's is an order-at-the-counter place. I don't need to order (they've memorized mine), but you probably will, at least the first few times you go. They seem to be pretty good at remembering after that. You would think that 130 sandwiches would have afforded me the luxury of having tasted the entire menu. Nope. I've tried the Make My Tay with whichever jalapeno-infused jelly sounds good, 130 different times now. So I just order a jelly, and they figure the rest out. And, for the record, the Make My Tay is pretty much PB&J perfection. I know cream cheese sounds a little weird, but it's gonna change your world, guaranteed. My Bat-Potato enjoys the Kids Classic with strawberry jam. Untoasted. Actually, please make sure his sandwich has not been placed within 12" of a toaster and try not to glance at the toaster while you make it. So I guess that's a solid option if you are a child or have the palate of one. Our drink of choice is a glass of milk, because again I arrived at a preschool and ordered an upscale elementary school lunch; why not further relive my childhood with some cow juice? The sandwiches are paired with ruffles, or some chips of that sort. You get a generous helping, and the sammys are also substantial. The meals are not inexpensive, but I don't think the owner is making out like a bandit either; for my son and me, the total is around $25 including drinks. The dining area is quaint with four or five small tables and one larger one. The decor is...old west ghost town, maybe? It feels vaguely Old Spaghetti Factory-esque. A wall-sized window overlooks the shopping plaza and McCullough. Wholesome like...you'll get an enthusiastic "HAVE A BLESSED DAY!" on the way out. I don't even much care for blessed days, but for y'all I shall have one. And then we leave. As I meander down the stairs, somewhere around step five, the forcefield ends, and I am no longer in my Elementary School's cafeteria. And my Bat-Potato says, "Race you!" read more

Positive / negative / pro tip / recommendation for owner Positive: Quality and simplicity over confusion. They made something simple taste so good and it reminds you of your childhood numerous options and very reasonably priced. I had the razz and it was delicious. It's so cost-effective my drink almost cost as much as the sandwich. Would absolutely come back. They are located on the second floor and a ton of parking options Negative: It's not really a negative aspect but there's limited seating because it's so popular Pro tip: It's great to grab and go because there's local parks nearby Recommendation for the owner: I was only in town for a few hours and I saw this on numerous reels. When I went to the website, I wish I would've seen a picture of the sandwiches. read more

Highlights: {Sweet tea} very nice and smooth, perfectly sweet {Menu} lots of options {Employee} seemed very passionate {seating} lots of options to sit and very nice seating Downsides: (Price) very high for chips and a sandwich (dessert) advertised as a traditional banana pudding but didn't have any banana flavor (Upsale) lady working wouldn't exactly take no for an answer really liked to upsale Update: I went awhile back but forgot to review. Removed a star for snarky comeback from business owner. Never have to lie for a review and being implied I'm lying in a reply from a business owner is just distasteful. Lady who was working definitely did also try and upsale a lot as she went on and on in detail about how they won a competition for their banana pudding. She asked us a total of 3 times if we wanted the banana pudding which we finally said yes because she would quit. So yes very frustrating. I have no intent to bring down a business and majority of my reviews are positive. Being accused of lying from a business owner is just wrong. Now a 1 star review. I don't recommend anyone else to get harassed. read more

Great concept! I love being able to build my own PBJ and having different flavors of jelly to pick from and several toppings. I do wish they have more bread options such as whole wheat or multi-grain. They also have standard salted crinkle chips that they serve on the side which is a good balance of the sweetness from the jelly. I built my own PBJ, with almond butter and strawberry jalapeño jelly. This combo was so tasty. The gentleman who made the sandwich stated that the jelly was made in-house. He made my order as I placed the order, I didn't have to wait at all! They have plenty of seating options indoors and as well as outdoor. I LOVE a good PBJ sandwich, so I will definitely return! read more

See all

Such a cute, quaint place. It is upstairs and decorated so cute and cozy. I am not a peanut butter fan but my boyfriend loves it, so it was his request to eat here. The sandwiches were freshly made by the owner while we had conversation with him. They looked good and tasted good but, with me not loving PB, I could only eat half. If you love peanut butter, you definitely need to try this place! read more

See all

Such a sweet and simple concept that makes you feel like home. Wonderful ambience and service. Tried the Elvis and loved it. read more

PB&J with Tay - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

This place brought me right back to childhood in the best way. We tried the Kitchen Sink PB&J and wow... it was truly out of this world. Easily the best PB&J I've ever had. Every bite was nostalgic but somehow even better than I remembered as a kid. Jeremiah, the owner and PB&J mastermind, was so kind and welcoming. You can immediately tell he has a real passion for what he does, and that love definitely shows in the sandwiches. If you're even thinking about going, do it. I can't wait to go back and try more. Highly recommend! read more

See all

We aren't reinventing the pb&j... just now we're making it with Tay. ;) Honestly such a good spot and so many options. The sandwhiches are insanely big and filling and nothing beats eating it in a cozy place that feels like someone's home. The service / owner is always such a delight to talk to and passionate about what he does. It's no surprise at all they've won so many awards . ALSO a little hidden gem is their amazing banana pudding (also award winning). read more

Really quaint decor, friendly staff, and great food. I'd seen tons of great reviews, and they were well deserved. Can't wait to go back and try another sandwich. I had the "Make My Tay", and my wife had the one with egg on it. Both were fantastic. read more

This place was so unique and absolutely caught me by surprise! When I tell yall this is the best pbnj I have ever had I mean it! The service is also amazing, the owner likes to get to know you and make sure service is up to par and beyond! They truly make this place worth going too! read more

PB&J with Tay - The Razz - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Unlike my girl, I really enjoyed the concept of this place. It had great customer service, (even with the pressure of trying the pudding) I understand you can be excited about a product you have and that is okay to express. $40 for a couple fancy pb&js and a pudding was a bit of a sticker shock to me, but MAN they were good. I might have to sneak out of the house to come back to this one. read more

Had been wanting to try this place for a long time, wish I had stopped by earlier. It was busy, but the owner was extremely nice and we didn't wait long to place our order. In fact, I was amazed that he was taking the orders, making the sandwiches, and ringing up customers so quickly and efficiently that my order was ready right when I finished paying. I tried the Pooh Bear sandwich with peanut butter, honey, bananas, and walnuts served on TX toast. It was served with chips, but the sandwich was so filling, I only ate a few chips. My friends ordered the Pooh Bear, the Razz, and the Egg-collect. Everyone loved their selection. We enjoyed dining in as the restaurant was clean and had a comfortable vibe. I felt like I was eating my meal at a friend's house. I will return to try more sandwiches! read more

PB&J with Tay - The "Pooh Bear" sandwich with chips - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

It was my first time eating here, but it won't be my last. There are a lot of delicious choices on the menu but I opted for the Daily Special aka The Hearty! When took that first bite into the sandwich, the peanut butter, jelly and everything else immediately covered the corners of my mouth. Luckily I was able to lick it off and not have the goodness drop on the table. The service is great! They were kind of busy and only the two people working the counter, but we still received our order in a reasonable amount of time. The space is quaint and looks like a time capsule in some aspects. It's cozy and airy. It's also in an upstairs location so be prepared to WALK up the stairs. I want to try and different sandwich next time, but I'll probably stick with The Hearty PB&J! read more

See all

What's not to say about this restaurant that hasn't already been said? PB&J with Tay made for a cute date and a unique dining experience. The sandwiches were pretty creative and the dining area was very aesthetically pleasing. I would write more about this place but with so many positive reviews, I think it's better if you try it for yourself. The only important detail unrelated to the food is that I don't believe there is a handicap accessible entrance; this place is located on the 2nd story of a building. Would still recommend for a fun outing. read more

See all

Absolutely fantastic service! I saw this place on instagram and what immediately drew me in was the food. I asked the owner what I should order for a first time visitor and he suggested the Elvis which has bacon, banana, and of course, peanut butter and jelly. The jelly I chose was strawberry jalapeño and let me tell you it was a great choice. He also told me about this amazing banana pudding that won first place at the San Antonio rodeo and I see why. It is the perfect combination of creamy and smooth, better than any other I've had before. I chose to dine in, there's a quiet rustic comfort feel about this dining room. 10/10, I will for sure be coming back. read more

See all

As soon as you walk in the smell is amazing Excellent service. The owner takes his time to tell you about the sandwiches. The Eggcellent is simply delicious. I would not have thought of eggs and peanut butter, but my God it is heavenly. Will definitely be back. read more

PB&J with Tay - The Eggcellent - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Love me a good OG PB&J but came across these cute place. They took PB&J and took it to the next level! I got the Texans which was a peanut butter with the blackberry Jalapeño jam and bacon on Texas toasted bread. It was so good. We got to even meet the owner of the restaurant and we gave us a little history story of his business. We would be coming back for sure! read more

PB&J with Tay - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Super good and cozy spot! Tried the bacon PBJ&Tay and it was so good! The Nutella PB sandwich was amazing too. Cool, cozy atmosphere, definitely a fun place to grab something different and delicious. Has a nostalgic vibe that I personally loved! read more

Located upstairs, this place was absolutely amazing. I got my order to go but as soon as I got back to my hotel and tried it, I hated I didn't get another one! they are addicting. I got the PB& tay with Raspberry jelly and it was to die for! read more

The only place that serves PB and jelly sandwiches in town. Every sandwich is made with love and you can customize it however you want, chunky or regular peanut butter, spicy jelly, bananas, marshmallow cream, bacon, add whatever your heart desires. Service is friendly too and you feel like you're eating at somebody's house. Oh and I forgot to mention, their banana pudding is the best. If you're handicapped, unfortunately, you're S O.L. because PB&J with Tay is only accessible by stairs so taking an able-bodied friend or family member that can get your food for you is highly recommended. read more

What a little surprise!! This little gem here was really cool! They got a good variety of PB&Js that are all customizable and a few options of jelly, including spicy ones, too! All sandwiches are served with chips, and surprisingly, very filling! The shop itself is small, cute, and very vintage and homey! A must-try for a lunch or pick-me-up snack! read more

PB&J with Tay - The Pooh Bear (w/Peanut Butter, Banana, Honey, and Walnuts) - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

The service was great. A great little establishment the kids will definitely love. The indoor decor feels like your back at grandmas house, cute and cozy. We tried different types of PB&Js from cream cheese and bacon to banana and Nutella. No complaints of the tase and the portion sizes are good. Drinks sold separate. Located upstairs. Plenty of parking. read more

PB&J with Tay - Nutella and banana - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

I actually found PB&J with Tay off TikTok, and I'm so glad I did because this place is a total hidden gem! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt incredibly warm and welcoming. The owner was so attentive, joyful, and full of positive energy, it really made us feel comfortable as first timers. He was also so patient and supportive of our options! I ordered the peach Nutella with granola build-your-own, and it was incredible! The atmosphere and environment was so unique and comforting. The Texas toast used for the sandwiches absolutely stole the show. The coffee was nice and strong, and I loved the variety of cute mugs they offer once you walk in! Little touches like that make the experience feel personal and fun. Overall, the quality of service and the quality of the food were both amazing. If you're looking for a place with great vibes, delicious bites, and genuinely joyful service, PB&J with Tay is a must-visit! read more

Great little place in The Yard. It's a warm and inviting inside. It'll remind you of your grandma's house. Plus the guys running the counter were super friendly. We were recommended a couple different sandwiches and they were all delicious. I got the Texan with strawberry jalapeño jelly, my wife got the KJB which he recommended she add a couple things to (wish I could remember what they were) but it was also wonderful. Lastly she took the Pooh bear to go so we could try it later. The crunchy walnuts were the star there. Also worth noting, all sandwiches are paired with the objectively correct ruffled potato chips. We definitely overdosed on PB&J today but it was worth it! read more

We came here around lunch time on a Sunday and they weren't too busy. Plenty of open tables and I'd be surprised if you encountered too long of a wait. The staff were super friendly and gave great suggestions on what to order! I can't believe this idea isn't a thing in more places. If you're a peanut butter lover or even just have a sweet tooth this place is an absolute must go if you're in reasonable proximity of San Antonio. I had the double decker with strawberry and blackberry jalapeño jam and see why it's so highly recommended. I appreciate that the menu is a small step below state fare food in terms of craziness and the vibe is way more cozy family hangout. I am sure I'll be back here and can only hope it will be sooner rather than later read more

PB&J with Tay - Double Decker Delight - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Eating here was delightful. I went by myself. The chalkboard menu was extensive, so I let the guy behind the counter give me advice. He suggested adding walnuts to my peanut butter and jelly sandwich with chocolate hazelnut spread, to cut the sweetness. He was so enthusiastic about the food, and I love to see it. Every meal is served on a vintage Corelle plate (if you know, you know). They toast the bread. They use top-notch ingredients. It's super cute inside. Go here. read more

PB&J with Tay - Gourmet peanut butter and jelly - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Service was great, fast and very friendly. The atmosphere is very much a home vibe. Just a heads up to anyone: As mentioned in a past review which is important to mention as I observed this issue, but the restaurant does not provide ADA access as the only way to enter the restaurant is taking stairs to the second floor, so anyone in a wheelchair, aged, or with a disability would find it very difficult to access due to the stairs. The food is very average. As a peanut butter lover, I was initially excited to experience this restaurant. The combination of flavors in the sandwiches was not very memorable and Elvis sandwich (peanut butter, jelly , banana, bacon) that I make at home, tasted pretty much the same offered there. Ingredients used at the restaurant were very simple which equals a simple forgettable taste. Only one type of bread is offered, Texas toast, which loses flavor in possibly using or offering different bread types. Due to average taste, the other drawback was the price. Felt expensive for what you're getting. For the total of three PB sandwiches with chips and drink, it came to be about $50. Prices with phots on yelp appear to be outdated as they seem to be higher now. From a business model, seems to be great from the owner standpoint but the customer is paying a high price point. It looked promising as I saw hype about this place from instagram, their past news tv appearances, and yelp ratings, but overall a Cool concept to visit but to not go again. The service and ambiance really carried this visit. *update per owner's response* Just to give those an idea of what you're spending despite the $30 estimate total for order $48.55 w/ tip ( so I rounded up to $50) Elvis w/chips and water Make my tay w/ chips and coffee Classic w/ chips and two juice boxes read more

We found this place by accident! We were looking for some place to have brunch and this popped up. We were intrigued and decided to check it out. I am so glad we did! First, let me say, this place is really "cute". The decor is lots of tasteful antiques and a comfortable atmosphere. Now, let's get to the food. The restaurant has just been voted into the top 100 sandwich shops in the country! Not bad for an establishment, which only serves peanut butter sandwiches. But what sandwiches they are! I opted for the "Razz". Peanut butter, raspberry jam, Nutella, and granola. Since I am not a great fan of Nutella, I just asked them not hold it. No problem. The last ingredient was granola The sandwiches are all made on Texas Toast. They are lightly grilled as well. It was delicious! With a serving of potato chips, it really was a lot of food. I left a single bite of sandwich and a couple of chips. I was full. My wife had "The Texan". Texas Toast, lightly grilled with peanut butter, strawberry- jalapeño jam, bacon and we asked for cream cheese. The additions and deletions were simple. Tell them what you want and you'll get it. The food is copious and delicious. And, the couple who owns and runs it are charming and innovative. What more can you ask for? Good food in filling quantities, served by nice people, in comfortable surroundings. The formula is complete. Highly recommended! read more

PB&J with Tay - Dining Room - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

The food was amazing and the vibes there were immaculate! The owners are very welcoming and engaged with the customers, and the food is brought fresh to you in the most cozy dine in area 10/10! read more

PB&J with Tay - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

My girlfriend and I came for the first time right before they were about to close and the owner Jeremiah was nevertheless very welcoming and super helpful with suggestions! I got the Double Decker Delight (on the right) and my lady got the The Egg-cellent (on the left) and they were both delicious. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a cute spot with some elevated pb&js! read more

PB&J with Tay - The Egg-cellent (on the left) & The Double Decker Delight (on the right) - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Great food, great service, great ambiance. The sandwiches here are a work of art and taste delicious. Take it from me you will love it.

Lived up to the hype. We thoroughly enjoyed our sandwiches and the warm, welcoming service. My son went sweet (Double Decker Delight) and I chose a more savory option (Make My Tay with pepper jelly). The banana pudding is also outstanding. read more

PB&J with Tay - Double Decker Delight - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Just a quick review of our first ever visit to a gourmet (but casual!) Peanut Butter and Jelly sandwich shop! It is located upstairs at the end of a nice area, with shops in old rail cars to two story music buildings. It doesn't look it from the outside, but when you get inside, it kind of feels like an old house. It's a nice vibe. Even nicer was the owner and team, as they chatted with us (even finding some military music commonalities!) and helped us pick. I had an outstanding "Elvis." Peanut butter, banana, bacon and a choice of jelly (I got jalapeño strawberry, lol!). Wife got a "Rocky Road" and our son got a custom job with... coconut shavings! Ah... that's my boy! Bottom line... we loved it! We'll be coming back when we need that comfort food, taken to the next level! read more

PB&J with Tay - PB&J with Tay upstairs! - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

I never thought I'd visit a restaurant where their primary dish was peanut butter & jelly, but we did and man was it delicious! As soon as you walk in, they're so very welcoming and quick to serve. The vibe inside is so very unique, cozy and home-like as well. We'd definitely go back again to try a different type the next time. read more

See all

If you enjoy supporting a local business with super friendly folks and great food this is the place for you! Owner could not have been friendlier and the place is just fun. There are a dozen different sandwiches to choose from and endless ways to customize on top of that. Don't snooze on the banana pudding either! read more

See all

Amazing. Fun little restaurant with amazing food and service. Will definitely be back!!

My girlfriend Debbie and I were getting a custom birthday cake from a nearby merchant when we decided to get lunch. We found PB&J with Tay and we were overjoyed! The man behind the counter was friendly and full of smiles. He made great recommendations. I decided on the 'PB&J with Tay" sandwich which is peanut butter, jelly, cream cheese and BACON! I know it sounds weird but it was awesome! The combination of flavors was so satisfying that I had to write this review. My sandwich was served with 2% milk which made it perfect. Indoor seating is limited and cozy with a great view of outside. I am looking forward to returning. read more

Made the trip for peanut butter. lol I'll considered, it was worth the trip. We got the double-decker delight and another sandwich, I forget what it was called. Both were exceptional. I recommend bacon and peanut butter with cream cheese wholeheartedly. The place is a little rustic, a little homey, but well worth the visit. read more

Tried PB&J with Tay for the first time! Just have to give credit where it's due. Wife took me here for my birthday and it was the best experience. Owners were super friendly and welcoming, letting us take our time reading over the menu and was willing to help answer any questions. The atmosphere was so incredibly nostalgic. Reminded us of being back home at our grandparents house as kids having a PB&J snack after playing in the yard. I had the Make my Tay and my wife had the Pooh Bear and added strawberry jelly. Both sandwiches were a 10/10!! We will definitely be coming back for a nice little getaway and travel back in time to when things were simple with a comforting PB&J. read more

See all

The best pb&j sandwich you will ever have. Service was amazing and owner is super friendly. Love the down home feel. Highly recommend. read more

PB&J with Tay - Zoe enjoying her peanut butter and jelly with Nutella sandwich. - Sandwiches Near Me - San Antonio, Texas