Whenever I'm craving a gyro I tend to order from Pegasus the prices are reasonable and they are one of those spots that had almost anything you can think of on the menu so anyone can find what they are looking for! The platter comes with choice of salad or soup and then an additional potato side and they have lots to choose from! Always a hit. read more

See all

Stopped in on a Thursday and it was quite busy! Service was super hospitable and lovely. Classic diner vibe. Thursdays they have a buffalo chicken wrap so I tried that and it came with chicken noodle soup and fries. Generous portion! read more

We got served immediately on a Sunday at noon. The waitress was knowledgeable about the kitchen. The ambiance was cookie cutter traditional Greek-American diner like Omega. There was several slot machines right behind us and the tables next to us were about a foot too close. There was a couple odd customers. The Creamy chicken soup was pretty good, comfort soup. The Texas BBQ Chicken Sandwich I liked but the bottom Texas bread got soggy from the heat and everything somewhat fell apart. The amount of chicken and onions were great, although it was somewhat uneven BBQ slobbered on. Good but not fond dining. The fries were very, very crispy. $14 The Greek skillet was fine. $11 Chicken fajitas had red peppers and typical. read more

See all

More than eight years ago, I wrote a review that definitely needs an update. Pegasus is my favorite restaurant to go to for lunch or breakfast. Their kitchen rocks. The food is outstanding and always consistent. Portions are hearty and the quality of the product is the best. Specials every day on the menu and on their chalk board. Sandwiches are thick and burgers are juicy, always coming the way it is ordered. Their entree salads are the best in MKE, IMHO. Breakfasts or lunch, one can order a side of fruit instead of fries/potatoes, etc. The fruit is always cut up cantaloupe and honeydew in a cup. Coffee is excellent! The servers here are professional and friendly. If you sit at the counter, you'll see what I mean. They look at and make sure they are getting what their customer's asked for before serving. They prepare the dishes for service with care and efficiency. Pegasus always has fresh bakery items; cakes, cheese cakes, baklavah, etc., all of which are the highest quality. The restaurant is full of comfortable leather booths and large tables that are very comfortable. The restaurant has plenty of on site parking, but street parking is also abundant. I highly recommend Pegasus! read more

See all

Service has always been prompt ++& pleasent . And over the last 15 years the quality of food remains at 5¹¹s. When we cant figure out which restaurant we could enjoy, we solve the problem...we go to Pegasus. We like feeling well satisfied. Always A1. No complaints. Diane K. read more

I have been here to dine in, had food delivered, & stopped in for take out. The staff has always been friendly and wrap my to go soups with care. Chicken dumpling soup is my favorite along with their gyros. I have eaten here with friends and family and highly recommend for good tasting foods! read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Inside - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Friendly staff, good food, reasonable prices, family friendly. We always feel.at home when enjoying breakfast here.

This is quickly becoming my favorite go-to when I order Grub-Hub. They have such a huge menu, everything you could want. Breakfast is served all day. They have soups, salads, sandwiches, burgers. For dinners, they have Seafood, Italian, Mexican, Greek Specialties, Chicken dinners. Friday Fish Fry, It was a tough choice between the Pasta and the Meatloaf today. I went with the pasta, it had chicken and shrimp, spinach and mushrooms tossed in alfredo sauce with garlic bread on the side read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Pasta ala Roma with chicken and shrimp - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

We still like this place, but come on, guys, time to go back to 24 hours. We have nowhere to go after Brewers games or just after a late night of work. It's sad that all the "mom n pop" type restaurants changed their business models because of COVID-19. I don't blame you, but I really believe you could make a killing as one of the only 24 hour sit down places outside of George Webb's. read more

I had an issue with the word choice used on the menu because it was misleading, so I got less food than I expected. The waitress agreed with me. Then the manager came over with a rude and snobby attitude. She started the conversation by saying "What's your problem huh?". I explained what my issue was, and she responded spitefully. She had no intention of caring for the customer, her only intention was to fight with me about my complaint. The food looked good, and the waitress was kind. But I won't recommend this place to anybody, because the manager clearly doesn't care for the customers. read more

While visiting family in West Allis, we stopped by and had a wonderful breakfast. Been there several times for breakfast and lunch and they are always consistent and friendly. Had the All American and The Meat Lovers Skillet with coffee and OJ. All cooked to perfection. Server was very nice and attentive. The menu looks like they practically have everything, so anyone should be able to go here and enjoy a good down to earth meal. read more

The other day I ordered a four piece fried chicken dinner with mashed potatoes and gravy. It was a takeout order, so I didn't know what I was getting till I arrived at home . The soup was pretty good, the chicken was pretty good, the potatoes were pretty good, but I cannot figure out why with a chicken dinner they would put beef gravy on the potatoes. Wouldn't it make more sense to put chicken gravy on potatoes with a chicken dinner? This is why I gave a four star rating. read more

The buser basically stood over us the entire time we ate, took away my food before I was finished and stared at us the entire time we were there. It was extremely slow when we were there but find something else to do . It's extremely rude and I was so uncomfortable the entire time read more

Me and my mom came here about a month ago for lunch. I've only been here once after bowling with some friends and we wanted to grab a bite to eat afterwards. I enjoyed my breakfast so it wanted to try something new on their menu. When you arrive there the staff were in masks and had customers spaced out for health and safety purposes due to Covid. Both me and my mom ordered the lasagna which was half the dinner size portion but it also came with soup and dessert. They also have affordable drink prices so we both decided to have one to go with our meal. The chicken soup that came with it was seasoned well and came with slices of homemade bread which we enjoyed. When we received our food, we both thought this is half the dinner portion? I can't imagine what you get for dinner! The lasagna was piping hot, came with a side garlic bread and was covered in gooey mozzarella. We both ended up eating half of it and brought the rest home. We both took our dessert home as well because for me there was no room for cheesecake lol. I know some of the reviews I saw it was hit or miss with their dining experience, but so far I have received to 2 good meals and don't mind going back again. read more

Very clean very nice. Food was exactly what I asked for. My server was excellent. Would definitely recommend eating here.

Stopped here after attending the Wisconsin state fair. Although the food is delicious at the fair, the prices aren't. We decided to have a quality/nutritious meal, and skip the deep fried fare! The server was very courteous and attentive, the prices were extremely reasonable, and the speed and accuracy of the orders was phenomenal! Delicious food! The appearance and cleanliness of the restaurant was "second to none." Bathrooms were tidy, and parking plentiful. read more

I only order certain things. When I like, I stick with it: Chef Salad has beef, turkey,ham,two cheeses, cucumber, tomato and onions. Huge salad is great! Price increase AGAIN +$2 Clam Chowder, let largest you can on fridays. Brownie: thick and gooey but the best i ever had at the expensive price of $4.00 Location is wheelchair accessible. read more

pegasus as excellent food at reason for her pricing. I support are restaurants! They've been there for us while the whole Covid season and have worked hard to make our day a little easier! Many choices of foods in friendly personnel. read more

Three and a half stars please. I've been home all day not feeling well and wanted something comforting for dinner. I ordered delivery through a service and it arrived relatively quickly. I got meatloaf, mashed potatoes, gravy and green beans. Fair to say it's more diner or cafeteria food than actual items made by a chef. Even so, it was delicious and hit the spot. If a hospital cafeteria had really good food it would taste like this. read more

See all

I am in another state, and have been ordering on line, and the Pegasus could not be doing a better job, getting food to a sick family member. I am worried miles away, They are kind and with each order work with me to assure me that I have done what I needed to on the computer (ok I have computer issues) Daily , and my family sounds better on the phone, and I know the food is getting to them. If I was closer, I would be cooking and dropping off daily! Thanks for the good food, patience with my ordering. read more

PEGASUS A great spot if you want to grab ur friend or group of friends. Sit down and have amazing food with amazing service. Old school family Diner but a comfort feeling. Cons: Small parking lot read more

Used to be a great place but I won't go back due to help wears way to much perfume and it ruins your food. Also I don't like my food Luke warm or a waitress only wearing her mask half up her face...I value my life and the boss needs to make sure his employees follow the steps when serving . read more

The service was great! But the food was very pricey for what you got. I had a bacon egg & cheese croissant with a small side of hash browns for 13.00 way to much for what a got. Another dinner had a side salad which was excellent. Soup was just ok. I had a small orange juice which cost as much as a Gallon in the store read more

got steak and eggs.had to cook steak three times to get medium rare , by then eggs were cold, recooked eggs rushed, runny. servers tried to correct grateful. Ny steak tough. when paying a 21$ bill cashier agreed that the cooks don't know what their doing. that its too bad but offered no recourse or discount. mentioning I probably won't be back, cashier invited me to pay 50$ for a steak somewhere else.a very polite F U. leadership asleep at switch. which them luck and blessings. there's obviously internal turmoil. I hope everyone involved in this business finds some peace. Sincerely, Vija Grosgalvis of Milwaukee read more

Disappointing. Haystack onions were soggy and over salted, not crisp. Chicken wings had plenty of meat and were very tender. The BBQ sauce lacked flavor and was poured onto the wings too thickly. Blue cheese dressing for the wings contained little blue cheese and had little blue cheese flavor. The Greek salad was excellent. Portion sizes for all items were generous. read more

I was at Pegasus around 3-4 in the AM. The waitress and the other staff are Super Friendly! I took a couple of photos of fish in the Aquarium. I got this yummy salad! The waitress was so nice! read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Cheap good diners are a dying breed. Pegasus hits all the spots. Large menu, decent prices, large portions, good satisfying food, friendly servers, pies to buy as you walk out, and if you're super interested, they have alcoholic drinks. read more

Great food! I had spaghetti and meatballs. Marinara sauce was homemade and meatballs were as well. Really large serving but the price even included a dessert. I had blueberry pie. We are staying in a nearby hotel for a few days and definitely will be back. My husband really enjoyed his omelette. The service was great and has a family run vibe. read more

I love this place! We tried this one weekend because our normal breakfast place was closed. We instantly fell in love with this place. Such greeting people when you walk in. We have been regulars for almost a year ish. We go every other weekend now :) Maria and Eleni are amazing! Love them so much! Friendly, staff is great, food is delish! read more

My friend absolutely loves this place. I thought it was alright, but nothing special. If you enjoy Greek-style dining, you might like this restaurant read more

This is one of my favorite resturants in Milwaukee. The staff are very friendly. Food deliciousand very generous.If you are hungry this is a place to go.Prices are very resonable. Great place for families and friends.Ribs are the best I have ever had they melt in you mouth that is how tender they are. read more

I love this place, I eat here for breakfast and dinner every Monday and Tuesday on my days off from work.

I like this place because the menu is huge. There is something for everyone, whether you want breakfast, Greek or Mexican. The dinner specials are a nice value and come with dessert. Everything seems very fresh and the customer service is quite good. Everyone is very nice and attentive. They are open 24 hours and offer delivery through services like DoorDash, so that gives you another way to enjoy this place! read more

This was your typical Greek place with a verity of menu items. Father's Day was packed for breakfast but I got a booth with duct tape to fix the cushion. I had the gyro and eggs with toast/hash browns. See the picture. Toast was wheat, white or rye. A Greek place and they don't have Greek toast. The gyro meat was standard. The sunny side up eggs were perfect. Hash browns could have been crisper. The place was packed and the food came so quick which surprised me. Over all it's a solid breakfast place. Would I go back, yes. It is my fav breakfast place, no. Will it work for breakfast, yes. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Gyro and eggs - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Came in here after searching for 24 hour dining and avoiding Johnny V's like the plague. Staff was friendly and attentive, even at 3:00am on a Friday night. We were seated in a booth by the fish tank and our server came right over. I wanted a chocolate malt, and she made it sooo great. My whole table "helped" to devour it. The menu is extensive, offering all sorts of cuisines. I opted for a skillet, one person got the corned beef hash, one got biscuits and gravy and one got a gyro sandwich (or wrap... i don't remember for obvious reasons). One member of our party promptly fell asleep upon food delivery, so I'll never know how the biscuits and gravy were, but they looked nasty, and lacked the eggs that were supposed to come with it. My skillet was seriously awesome - and I ate every bite. The gyro wrapwich and CBH were also devoured. Our server was very friendly and quick, and the experience was actually decent! I would absolutely recommend this place for drunkchies. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

No matter what time of day I have come here I have always enjoyed my food for what it is.....diner food from a very large menu. Actually I thought the Greek omelette was one of the better ones I've had in the city. What stands out to me is the very different dining experience that can be had, depending on the day and day of the week. The Friday/Saturday 3am "After bar crowd" can be pretty loud and disruptive. Sunday morning/lunch it's very busy with families, groups of people possibly after church and there will likely be a wait. The servers, no matter the time of day, always go above and beyond to provide a good experience. read more

Went out to eat here for my sons 10th birthday last week during Covid. Food was excellent as always ( I've visited here about 10 times now. They were consistent with the Covid guidelines and was happy overall. read more

I had a Greek skillet brought home and was enjoying it until I came across a long gray hair,I called the restaurant and was told by Souls the hostess that we don't have anyone with gray hair which I replied doesn't Jo Ann who happened to be the waitress and to which she replied oh you sat in her section,I said my sister did,so she said bring the box back,she brought the waitress to the front to show her she had her hair in a ponytail which has loose ends,my sister gets her money back,and the owner tells her if you don't like our service don't bother coming back,what such great customer service,not. Disgusting!! read more

We decided to stop here at about 1:30 AM on a Friday - well technicality Saturday morning. My husband ordered the Gyro. His meal came with a choice of potato so he ordered fries. He also got a cup of soup so he had ordered clam chowder. I ordered the shrimp basket. My meal came with a choice of potatoes and a cup of soup. I ordered fries and the chicken with pasta soup. My meal came with a dessert and I ordered it after I ate my food. The manager (who I assume was the manager) packaged the cake I ordered while I paid. The soup came first. My soup was disgusting. It was way too salty and the noodles turned to mush. My husbands soup was okay. I told the waitress and she brought me a cup of the clam chowder at no extra cost. When the meals came out they looked pretty decent. My husband said his was okay except for a couple areas on the lamb that were really tough. My shrimp was really good. Perfectly crunchy on the outside. I would probably order it again. Both of our fries were horrible. They were cold and unseasoned. The waitress clearly did not want to be there and she seated a group of drunk people (8) right next to us even though there was no one else in the restaurant and plenty of open tables. I mentioned they were really loud and distracting and she did nothing about it. She never asked them to be quiet. I also noticed when they were seated she immediately brought all of them a glass of water. She didn't give or even offer us water. As I paid and was signing the receipt the manager (who I mentioned earlier) was hovering over me and I could smell his breath and his body odor. It made my stomach turn. When I got home I decided it was time to eat the piece of cake I got. I opened the container and the smell of the cake was not good. I took 1 bite and couldn't even swallow it. I immediately spit it out and rinsed my mouth out with water. read more

See all

The service and food was super good. I like an old fashioned family Greek restaurant with lots of other choices. Excellent goulash.