Very tasty. We now live in California and dream of new York pizza! This place will not disappoint! Great eggplant Parma pizza. Yum... read more

Pelham Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

We eat here occasionally. The pizza is good but there is one or 2 within a few miles that are a bit better. They have the best chicken cutlet parm wedge (aka sub, sandwich) and have some really good pasta dishes. We get both take out and we sit in. The guys in there are great. Always friendly an pleasant as is the one female waitress who has been there for years!! It gets very crowded and busy in a Friday night so be prepared to wait a little while to sit if that's what your planning to do! Definitely would recommend Pelham pizza if your in the area! read more

Best in Pelham, hands down. Great pizza, excellent service, the people are friendly and kind. The prices are well set and the the food, especially dinner selections are more than spectacular. read more

Family owned Bronx style pizzeria. Perfect crust, perfect slices - great Sicilian pizza! It is the quintessential NY pizza experience. Walk up to the counter order your slice to go or stay and eat at one of the booths. Yes it is cash only. Yes they have a menu of other great red-sauce offerings from soup, salad, eggplant parmigiana etc. Yes when it is crowded you have to sometimes push your way to the counter past the folks waiting for booths and take-out. But all in all the experience, taste, quality and welcome of a well run, classic NY pizzeria. If you are in the neighborhood - stop bye - you will be glad you did read more

Simply the best pizza there is. The pasta e fagole soup is also delicious do yourself a favor and eat here you won't be sorry.

Great food with great service -- very consistent. Try their eggplant rolls -- excellent! read more

I've been there twice. First time would have gotten 5 stars. Their regular pie is fantastic, I loved it. However the second time I went I got a calzone and soup. The soup was a tomato broth with a bunch of beans in it. Thats it, nothing else; I was more than disappointed. The calzone was horrible. They pre-make them earlier in the day so when they added the filling that I wanted all they did was warm it up. It tasted old and stale. For all the amazing reviews, I am some what disappointed. Just get pizza from here and leave it at that. read more

Best pizza and value. Fun guys working there. Never a disappointment.

Really good pizza... My absolute favorite is the spinach slice, with a side sauce for dipping. It's really delicious. My kids love the Penne Vodka and the Chicken Parm dinner. read more

1st time there & lived up to the hype!!! Garlic bread is really good and got half plain half pepperoni pizza which was very tasty! No complaints nothing fancy inside but great food & entire meal was really inexpensive compared to Scarsdale. They have seating and service was fine we will be back!!! read more

Fresh, Hot, Delicious. Everyone is so friendly. I usually will swing by on my way home from the train & the place is usually packed. I moved here about a month ago, being a pizza snob I had to try all the pizza places. this is one of the best. read more

They have the best linguini white clam sauce around !!! My fave and their eggplant rollatini is also Delish !

Perfect Pizza. The sausage is out of control.

I found this place on grub hub and the prices looks right so I decided to give them a try. I got Fettuccini Alfrado, Garlic knots and a slice of cheese cake. The pasta was a good price, a great serving, and tasty. I needed to add a little bit of salt and garlic but I rather have too little seasoning than too much so they get an A for the pasta. The garlic knots were ok, they seasoned it with dry oregano flakes and I needed to pick it off but still very minor mishap so I give the garlic knots a B+. The cheese cake was really good no critiques at all A+ :) Overall: I will be a frequent buyer from this place and next time Im going to try the penne ala vodka ^.^ read more

Simply put: the best pizza anywhere. Crispy with perfectly seasoned toppings, from delicious sausage to healthy veggie combos. Lasagna pizza a real winner if you love lasagna and pizza! I dream of that slice! Happy playful staff in joyful neighborhood setting if you're dining in. Great at home if you just want to pop by for take out. If you have a pizza stone, beautiful reheat next day. There's a reason this place has been around so long! Mangia! read more

Love their pizza, esp. The regular pizza and spinach pizza. Always busy there. Reasonable price, too.

Absolutely fantastic!! Probably some of the best pizza that I've had around the city. The sausage and lasagna pizza is fantastic!

The best pizza I have had in a while. The salads and other menu items are awesome. The owners are super friendly and they make all feel welcome. read more

All I can say..... The BEST PIZZA AROUND... try the Arugula Pizza. All their food is EXCELLENT I'm just a pizza junky. Great staff and very friendly. Keep up the great work!!! read more

Inexpensive. Great portions. Low key. Great local place. Hidden surprise: try the burgers. They have a great char-grilled taste.

This pizza is just okay. I live in the area and I refuse to buy this pizza except as a last resort. It is definately the best in Pelham but that doesn't make it one of the best period. There are a big fish in an extremely small and shallow pond. For better pizza try A&V Pizzeria in Yonkers, or Mina's on Lake Ave in Yonkers. read more

Went there one night when visiting a friend who lived a few blocks away. BEST. PIZZA. EVER. (had a white garlic pizza) I live 700 miles away & often wish for this pizza again. read more

Best pizza I've ever had from a regular pizza joint. Top notch. And great arugula salad!

By far The Best Pizzeria in New York hands down. It's always cooked just right, never under cooked. The prices are very good as well.

There's no secret as to why this place is packed every day. The best Pizza, and absolutely the best minestrone soup you ever tasted. Loaded with vegetables and thick like your spoon could almost stand up in it. I couldn't wait to dip the small Italian loaf that came with the soup at the end. Mamma Mia "What a soup! And sautéed broccoli. No stems like other places give you. These hard working guys deserve their own TV show. Pelham is on the map for good. read more

Pelham Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

See all

initially I was weary - walking in ,seemed outdated and the food prep people were also touching the money. But let me tell you what a slice of pizza. I go here at least twice a week. New York style pizza with such a flavor. Staff is always courteous and 2.50 is a steal for this delicious slice. My teenage son eats about 3 slices per visit. If you are in the area stop by you will not be disappointed. read more

If your not a local not sure if they will serve you. After waiting 20 min and watching people before us get their meal we left.

Well, I just had to check this out, to see how Pelham Pizza was doing. Ya' see, I used to live in Pelham. Had Pelham Pizza all week long for lunch and again on the weekend, because Mom wanted a night off from cooking. I was SO SICK of Pelham Pizza! My siblings and I would groan "Oh, NO, not pie AGAIN!!!!" Then we moved to Connecticut. My sister and I would hop in my car and drive back to Pelham, for PIZZA. Then I moved to Florida. Now, all I have to say is; "Pelham Pizza, I MISS YOU!!!!!" This pie is so good. It always has been, ever since the place first opened, in the 70's. Back then a little guy from Italy, named Marcello, tossed a pie that cost 25 cents a slice. Whatever it costs now, it's worth it! The Italian Ice is a great little summertime treat, too! Sorry, I took this place for granted, when I lived a mere block away! read more

I have lived in Pelham all my life! Take it from me; Pelham Pizza is the best choice you could make if you are craving real NY Pizza! I have tried many other pizzeria's around the area and I find myself wondering if the pizza doesn't taste like it does in Pelham pizza you really shouldn't even bother opening up around here. These guys are like a second family to me! They are the nicest group of guys you will ever meet serving you food. If your ever in the area, I definitely recommend this place. DO NOT pass it by if your looking for real pizza! I promise you will not be disappointed! I put that on my life. They crush the competition! If it's not Pelham pizza, ill give up pizza for good! I'm serious! Try it and thank me later. Enjoy :) read more

Very good pizza and friendly service! I bit crowded sometimes, but nice atmosphere anyway. Recommended! read more

By far the BEST pizzeria in New York...Try the lasagna slice and you will never order anything else. I can go down the menu and rave about everything on it. You can't go wrong eating here. read more

This is absolutely the best place for pizza and any Italian food. I'm 70 years old and have only been taught to eat the best and cook the best and this place serves the best. Cash only but it's worth every penny to go out of your way to eat here. My favorites are the shrimp scampi and the garlicy frothy fresh white pizza. Nobody can beat them for fabulous taste and portion. read more

I feel very comfortable in this pizzeria. The food is good and the service is friendly. An unpretentious place to enjoy a nice slice and a pasta fagioli. I hope they never update the decor because its perfect 1980's Bronx. I recommend it. read more

Pelham Pizza has been our one and only stop for pizza since I can remember. Half the time I can't remember some of my phone numbers but I never have a problem remembering theirs. As much as my family and I have been die hard Pelham Pizza lovers for over 30 years,lately it just doesn't seem to be what it once was. The staff are great, service is excellent and prices are resonable but the pizza just isn't as consistantly good as it used to be. I don't think it's a quality issue it's just that they have out grown the small store. Even though if they moved to larger quarters it just wouldn't be the same place. They need to expand to get back to the consistantly excellent pizza they once made. read more

I walked into restaurant half-hour after ordering my pizza (exactly how long they said it would take before it was ready), there was a line almost out the door of BOTH people with pick-up orders and people ordering there. Ten minutes later I'm at the front of the line and am informed that my pizza was sold to someone else. Apparently, "it was up there a long time." In other words, the time I spent waiting in line for it. That incident aside, the food is incredibly overrated. It's mostly a result of somehow establishing itself as a local staple here in Pelham, a status that almost always transcends the actual quality of food and service. read more

Some of the dishes are bit expensive for me, but the food is soooooo amazing! I just have to eat the Meatball Parmigiana Roll at least once in a while, the best meal ever.! read more

Great local New York Style pizza the guys Behind the counter are always busy but eager to help

Best pizza in town. Don't bother going anywhere else. They've been here forever for a reason. And they aren't going anywhere either. Always stop in when I'm back "home". read more

The Pizza is great, that attitude and service not so much.... i know the guys are busy, i know its a small pizzeria, i get it but i have gotten nothing but nasty attitudes every time i go into this place.... my order is always right once they find it, but they never seem to get my name right over the phone so once i get in there to pick up my pizza there like well we don't have and order under that name.... its molly... M O L L Y ~ not that difficult... oh well the pizza is good so we still order from here.... read more

Ordered a large pie, and it was even better fresh than the late-night slice I got when really hungry. The house salad was fresh and well-made as well. Nothing fancy, but great quality. read more