Should be 5/5. A group of us stopped at Pequod's on our way to Wisconsin... fourth year in a row. Never disappointed, Pequod's is the best pan pizza... bar none...we eat a lot of pizzas, many, many, pizzas all over the U.S. This is by far the best pan pizza. We call in our order at the Indiana/Illinois border while heading north. Our pizza is waiting for us when we arrive. Hole in the wall, planted in the middle of a neighborhood, Chicago friendly, awesome service - absolutely love this place. read more

Deep dish pizza was fantastic! Me and family of 4 got the large and left with a couple extra slices! Super filling and flavorful! Aside from the yummy pizza the place is pretty small and cramped (not a big deal at all). I'd definitely make sure to make reservations if you're going at peak dinner time (especially on weekends)! The bathrooms doors are hard to open and close, something they may want to fix! All in all I recommend this place for people visiting the area! It was definitely a yummy experience! read more

Pequod's Pizza - Large Pan Pizza w/ pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

It's alright. Not a fan of the under crust of the pizza but the edges were nice. I also liked the sauce -- very flavorful! Overall, the pizza was okay. Probably wouldn't return. The mozzarella sticks were mid. Some nice seasoning on the outer layer but very stiff. Food: 3/5 Price: 3/5 Experience: 3.5/5 read more

Pequod's Pizza - Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

See all

Getting there wasn't the best start. Parking was a challenge, and since there were no available spaces nearby, I had to park about a block away. It was a little frustrating, but I figured the walk would be good exercise before a big meal. The restaurant itself is small and has an older, cozy feel. The dining area is quite compact, so I wouldn't recommend it for large groups or parties. Unfortunately, the service left a lot to be desired. We only saw our server three times: to take our order, deliver our food, and bring the check. In between, he was nowhere to be found. The lack of attentiveness and hospitality was disappointing. Thankfully, the deep dish pizza completely turned things around. The crust was crispy with a nice char, giving it excellent flavor and texture. The gooey cheese was evenly distributed throughout the pizza, and I appreciated that the sausage came in generous chunks instead of small crumbles. The tomato sauce was well balanced, neither too sweet nor too acidic which tied everything together beautifully. Despite the disappointing service, the pizza alone is worth coming back for. Next time, though, I'll probably order takeout. With service like this, leaving a tip didn't feel well deserved. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

See all

Pequod's Pizza is in my home town of Morton Grove, and I hadn't been there in over 50 years! I remembered the pizza as being exceptional, and had been talking about going back forever. It was a long standing joke between my husband and myself...could this pizza possibly live up to my expectations? And the answer is.... Yup! It is as good as I remembered it to be. The carmelized pan crust looks burnt (they even warn you on the menu that it's supposed to be black), but it's the best part of the pizza. The pizza/tomato sauce was extremely flavorful (not just plain tomatoes like Lou Malnatis or Rosatis). The sausage was delicious, and the onions were sweet. There was a ton of sausage, and lots of onions on the pizza--very generous portions. The mozzarella cheese appetizer was served very hot, and was pretty good. Basically...your typical frozen moz sticks. Nothing to write home about, but nothing to complain about either. Service was very good. The only negative I can point out is there was an overwhelming mildewy smell when you approach and enter the restaurant. It was very off putting. Overall, this is the best pan pizza I've ever eaten, and as such, I highly recommend Pequod's. read more

See all

How can something that's already delicious get better? Well that answer is to come to the original location and enjoy the delicious pizza where it all started! This is the best Chicago style pizza I've ever had hands down the flavors are there and I must say they don't just stop there as the crust is perfect super crispy flavorful and just too darn good! Combine that with the toppings cheese and sauce it's a pizza that you will start to crave again and again! We went with sausage, meatballs, and onions all of which were super yummy toppings that just hit the spot for this pie to make an incredibly delicious pizza like how can you go wrong! Or server was awesome she was super friendly and talked with us for a bit as we came in the morning she was telling us about Pequod's and her story of working there which was super cool as it made us feel like we were locals with that friendly vibe she put out, she also totally said you need some ranch for this pizza and then she went to get us some and I must say she was right it took something that was already over the top to a next level so shout out to her for saying that! Overall I'll be counting the days tell I get to come back here again for another delicious pizza and I definitely have to say that I really enjoyed this location more than the other one as this one was straight up lowkey in a neighborhood and the vibes just hit a lot harder! read more

See all

Stop! Stop reading! Go get this pizza right now! This is some of the best pizza I've ever had. As a pizza connoisseur, take my word for it. The caramelized crust is out of this world! That crispy, slightly burnt caramelized cheese ring crust adds a smoky flavor you won't get elsewhere. Our server was an absolute gem and was so nice to talk to. I have been to both locations and this one is my favorite. This is the original location and it has such a cozy vibe. I love that this location is in a converted house, it's so cool! Anytime I'm in Chicago, this is a perfect spot. Pequods is just a good time all around. No matter what you get you will be happy! I can't wait to come back, this place is outstanding! read more

See all

Stopped in on another Monday night and was not disappointed. We made reservations online, which are a must. This time we ordered a thin and pan pizza. The thin pizza was good, but I prefer the pan, the edges of the crust were burnt and crunchy. Service was very good! read more

This certainly was an interesting experience. A friend of mine had told me that this place felt like going to a restaurant in a house, which really confused me. When we got there I saw that he was exactly right. This is right in the middle of a residential area and these people who can just open their front door and walk a few steps to some Pizza are living the dream. The building is pretty small for the amount of people that they squeeze in there. But they were extremely accommodating with us and squeezing in some extra people at our table, which was much appreciated. We had a reservation, which was 100% the right move for how busy this place gets. I had done some research on what their pizza was like so I wasn't surprised when I saw the crust, which some people might think is burnt but it is not. Instead it is caramelized. It was definitely interesting and unlike other versions of Chicago Deep Dish I have tried. The sauce was also quite good. If I'm being 100% honest, this wasn't my favorite Deep Dish I had while in Chicago but it was definitely in the top contenders. read more

Pequod's Pizza - deep dish with caramelized crust - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

Came here to try Pequod's Pizza and I'd definitely recommend making a reservation ahead of time. We didn't have one and ended up waiting about 30 minutes. The place itself is pretty small and has an older vibe (I think it's one of their original locations). The pizza was good, don't get me wrong, but I personally didn't get the crazy hype around it. It's solid deep dish, just not something I'd go out of my way for. That said, we still had a fun time overall. Service was friendly and attentive, which made the experience better. Parking is street parking, so keep that in mind if you're going during busy hours. read more

See all

Was at the location by DePaul last time so we came here this time! Much more of a cozier feel. Tighter spaces between tables and not as well lit. Kind of a lodge/cabin vibe. To start, we ordered the Caesar salad and app sampler which came with mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms and jalapeños. We got two large pizzas: one that was all veg and another that was all meat. For 6 of us, it was a lot of food. Should've gotten a medium or one pizza to share with different toppings on each half. Beautiful burnt crust. And it's more bready than cheesy which I prefer. (Lou Malnati's does the opposite.) The sauce also has much richer seasoning and the toppings are fresher. Expensive of course. But it's a treat on rare occasions. Absolutely worth it too. Staff was nice. Really attentive and we had no issues. Everything came out correctly. Parking is parallel around here. It's kind of in a neighborhood. Not difficult to find. read more

See all

You know I love pizza. Pequod's has been on my bucket list for a long time and I finally got to go while I was in the Chicago Burbs on a Friday for a late lunch. We ordered pepperoni with well done crust. The pizza is delicious. Nice crisp lacy caramelized bits along the outer edge. Very generous with the pepperoni. The service absolutely sucked. I went half my meal with no drink refill after asking twice with the dining room only 2/3 filled. I burnt my mouth on the pizza and couldn't get a drink refill to cool it off. I eat a lot of pizza all over the country. This was delicious and I enjoyed it but I think it's a one and done for me. read more

See all

Love this spot! Gritty, busy, and delicious... A run down building in a residential neighborhood. The room is cramped. The waitstaff expert at working the floor. A bar with draft beer and 2 big screen TVs running sports make this an eatery with Chicago personality. Wait staff move fast, taking care of business with a great attitude. No extra time, but always making sure you're happy. They deliver just what you want. On this visit I started out with a tall Pilsner glass of Krombacher, cold and crisp. Then onto a house salad with homemade Italian dressing. In conclusion, the raison d'etre, a beautiful deep dish pizza with the famous charred crust. This caramelized, cheese-crusted edge is worth traveling for. I had anchovies, onions, and black olives. 5 stars! I'll be back. read more

See all

I don't get out this way often, but I had an appointment nearby so I brought my wife and son along, and we stopped for lunch. We got there right at opening, and I'm glad we did. 30 minutes later, there was a line waiting. The place is tiny and funky, but clean. Service was quick and nice. We got poppers and a deep dish pizza. The poppers are made there, and they were much better than what you usually get. The pizza is next level. The crust was some of the best I've ever had. I don't do a ton of deep dish, but this is now at the top of my list. Next time, I'd order a little differently though. We went overboard on toppings but that's my fault. I can't wait to go back. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

See all

In the great deep dish competition, I'd probably put Pequod's in the middle of the pack, but it was still a great deep dish and the salad was awesome. They are super generous in the toppings (about $5 per protein topping and $3 for veggie toppings), but light on sauce and cheese. The caramelized edge is interesting but I don't think it makes the deep dish that different from other spots. Still recommend giving it a try as I know it is beloved by many. Service was quick and friendly. read more

See all

I definitely recommend Pequods for deep dish! I tried them at their other location as well. The wings at this one wasn't the same but still good! The inside was small but home style. The service was a bit slow since there were only 2 servers unfortunately. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Small Pan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

See all

Wow--cannot say how much I underestimated pizza. Pizza is pizza is pizza, right? Wrong! I had probably zero expectations for this, and it blew my tastebuds away at the first bite. I forgot how delicious pizza can be when all the ingredients are 10/10. Firstly, the service? Stellar. 11/10. My husband accidentally placed an order for the wrong day. He drove out and nobody could find the order until they checked the next day's orders. They were able to just make our two pizzas right then for him. It obviously took extra time, but they could have sent him away and made him come back the next day. Angels. Pizza saints. May they find favor and fortune for all the days of their lives! What we got: Thin crust pepperoni - This was for our girls and they devoured their slices. Loved it so much. The pepperoni was so generous and thinly sliced. The crust was like crackery. No complaints, all praise. Pan crust sausage and spinach with extra sauce - The crust!! Crunchy and buttery on the bottom, but also fluffy on the inside. I feel like I haven't had such a good crust in so long that I forgot what it could be like. It's sort of Detroit style but 1000x tastier. The sauce is on the chunkier side, which I absolutely love! There's nothing worse than a dry pizza imo. The sauce is punchy and flavorful, and it soaks into the middle layer of the crust without making it super soggy. Perfection! The sausages are meatball-sized and the spinach is dispersed throughout. The cheese is ooey and gooey in the best way! No hard, dry plastic cheese here. It pulls for miles! Just thinking about it makes me want another slice. It's dangerous how delicious it is. Like, yes, I could stop at one slice, but my tastebuds tell me just a half a slice more... Wish there were even more locations, but this was worth it! read more

See all

As an out-of-towner with family in the area, a few of us ate a Pequod's last year and were blown away. When we had new folks with us this year, we insisted they try this spot! Make sure you get reservations - it will make your experience much smoother. We ordered two cheesy garlic breads, one large pizza, and one medium pizza for our group of six at the suggestion of our server. It was WAY too much food. The sauce on the pizza and the dough is unmatched, providing great flavor. However, we felt the medium pizza (pepperoni) tasted better than the large pizza (pepperoni & mushroom) - maybe just because of the sauce ratio differences. Just a quick walk from the Morton Grove train, I would return to Pequod's again and recommend it to anyone in the area. read more

See all

Cozy neighborhood spot with some of the best deep dish pizza you'll find anywhere. Service was great. Parking was easy and there were no leftovers to take home. The pizza is that good. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

See all

Service was on slow side even having a reservation took them 30min to sit us down even though i saw two tables and empty seats. the place is extremely small and no parking lot all street parking. I ordered a pequod pepperoni salad which was delicious I originally asked for no pepperochini and the salad came with everything on menu plus olives. since I dont like olives they had to bring me new a new salad.the Italian dressing and ranch were great. the pizza was delicious especially the dough and the sauce was a little on the tart side. overall it was a good experience but quite a bit noisy in there made it hard to talk with my friends I felt like I had to talk louder. once more people left it was better. while the pizza wasnt a wow factor it still was decent. read more

See all

I had heard from a client that the pizza here was the best in Chicago, so I had to try it. Giordano's has long been my husband's favorite. Well I was impressed!! This is now my favorite deep dish pizza ever! I did really like the caramelized crust...I thought better taste and less bread than Giordano's. My husband likes it just as well as his long time favorite. I highly recommend coming here to try it! Beer selection is very good too. This is a casual place, not one you come for the ambiance, but come for the outstanding pizza! It's read more

First time here. It was tempting to go to their Chicago location, but we opted for here. Luckily, we were here around 2pm (weekday). Their lounge is tiny, and it quickly got crowded. My guess is with the pizza wait (30-35 minutes) and people eating and drinking (another 45 minutes), you'll be waiting for a table. The pizza was good. We ordered the medium and with only 2 of us, we brought 3 slices home. The staff was friendly. Overall, good experience. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

Excellent deep-dish pizza. We stopped by (original location) on our drive home from Milwaukee to NJ and had a great time. Thanks to booking on OpenTable through Google, our corner table was already set and waiting for us. They have a nice draft and tap beer list with several local options. My kids each ordered the Half Spaghetti, but "half" is misleading cuz the portions were huge! Both had plenty left over, and the meatballs in it were the size of stress balls- delicious ones! For the grown-ups, we split a medium Pan Pizza (their name for Chicago-style deep dish) with pepperoni. Medium is a lie. This thing could feed a small village! The caramelized, blackened edges on the crust were phenomenal, and even split three ways we still had major leftovers because it's filling af. Service was excellent! Pequod's also offers thin crust pizza, salads, and sandwiches, but honestly, the deep dish alone is worth the visit. A fantastic stop, and we'd absolutely go back. NOTES/TIPS: **Street parking was easy in this residential neighborhood. **Clean bathrooms. **Classic pizzeria vibes- wood paneling. Loved it! read more

See all

Pequod's is always consistent and has some of the best pizza tomato sauce I've ever tasted in the U.S. Fresh ingredients, delicious hot pizza and friendly service keep us coming back. The only reason I dropped a star, is because they could a little better on the cleanliness of the Morton Grove location. read more

See all

Waited over an hour and a half. The thin crust pizza was not cooked well. Could not tell the difference between what I ate and frozen Jacks pizza read more

If you're going to invest the calories and probable wait-time in an Authentic Chicago-style deep dish, this is your spot! They were fast, efficient, and to our surprise... able to seat us immediately, without a reservation (Note: it was Saturday at around 1pm)! You need to like-- or at least want-to-try-- Chicago Deep Dish to like Pequods, but it was tasty! The prices are reasonable and the local-feel/business vibe was awesome. Loved coming out to check-it-out, and support! read more

See all

Dear Pequod's, There is no world in which there is an acceptable excuse for the toilets locations in the dining area. The food doesn't matter when every moment and interior wind gust breathes... toilet. Let me break this down: Delicious salad. Toilet. Yummy appetizers. Toilet The pizza is 5-Stars-Great! - Toilet. The staff is cool. They served us next to the toilets. I am sure the thought is that I am the only one who cares about this weird layout - but trust me, I am the one who matters. Change it. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

Probably the best pizza I have had in Chicago! I really like Pequod's pan pizza, the flavor was great and the crust was cooked perfectly. We got the medium size for 2 people and we still had leftovers. Will definitely be back next time I am in town! Make sure you make a reservation ahead of time! read more

After years from hearing from others to try Pequods, I finally made the trek here. I heard it gets packed, so came in between the lunch and dinner rush. I highly recommend doing that. As others say, parking is tight. We parked across the street and dang people speed down the street. Also, I recommend your party to have 1 to 4 people. The restaurant is very cramped. Service- One person was taking all of the orders and getting all of the drinks. She had some help with running food. Plan on at least 40 minutes for your pan pizza. Pricing - fair They were out of their pequod's ipa but they do have a large selection of craft beer. Now to the pizza. It was only ok to me, didn't live up to the hype. The carmalized crust felt burnt. I did like the spice of the pepperoni. Glad I tried this Chicago burb pizza legend, but it was only ok. read more

shoutout to keith the uber driver for recommending this place to a couple of californians who were in desperate need of real pizza 11/10, eat here today, eat here yesterday, eat here tomorrow. asap. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Small Pan Pizza with Pepperoni, Fresh Garlic, and Extra Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

See all

Delicious pizza, needed a little more cheese to truly be a deep dish in my mind. Around the edges the cheese was nonexistent. Fried mushrooms were cold, but that's on DoorDash. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Medium Pan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

Pequod's had been on my list for a long time! Got to knock it off the list and try one of their pan pizzas last week. First of all, the OG spot is cool. Its like a little wooden house, very small, probably seats 30? They have a private room in the back or something, too (someone was having a birthday party while I was there). I went with a small sausage pizza. How was it? Sausage Pizza- When this thing came out, it looked great. It had HUGE pieces of sausage on it! You could see the burnt cheese crust around the pan, and the sauce looked vibrant. They serve you your first piece. I bit in, and got the sausage first. It was good! I noticed right away though that the cheese was like lukewarm. I could physically see steam coming off the pizza, I know it was cooked fresh, I know it was "hot", but it wasn't as hot (temperature wise) as I had liked. The cheese crust was nice and crispy. Dough had a good flavor. I ate 2 pieces and took 2 with me to go. Cool spot, would definitely return and maybe get my pizza "well done" next time. read more

See all

The referral came highly recommended and now I see why. This deep dish sausage and pepperoni pizza, hands down, was the best pizza I've ever eaten! The crust is by far the best I've had cooked to perfection with the best crunch. The facility is cozy and very clean. There is some sort of info all around the place and our server Lynn was so kind and told us a lot about the history of the place and that the man in the photo on the wall next to us was the owner. She had such great things to say about him. We asked what she recommended and proceeded to place our order. We ordered fried zucchini which was tasty, but I feel there should have been a few more pieces for the price. Then we enjoyed the deep dish sausage and pepperoni and a thin cheese pizza to go. Lynn stopped by while I was about finished with my piece and asked if I liked ranch dressing, I do, and she suggested I dip the crust into the ranch and try it. She said it's a homemade ranch and it's delicious. That it is! And that combo was perfect! I would have loved to see a brushetta on the menu and with a crunch like the pizza crust and that would have complimented the pizza even more. Only one complaint.. the seats aren't the most comfortable. We will surely be returning! I almost forgot.. they sell merchandise as well! read more

See all

My favorite pizza ever! It's has a super crunchy bottom and great breading. The servers are so nice too ! The beer menu is basic, and the parking is street parking. But again this is my favorite pizza ever and I think everyone should try it! It's more "tavern" style I suppose rather than Chicago deep dish style, but it's still thick and cheesey!! read more

Pequod's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

I've heard of this staple of "Chicago Pizza" for years, being in the outskirts of Chicagoland doesn't always give me the opportunity to come check out these iconic places. I had no idea this was basically like an old home converted into a restaurant or at least that's what it looks like at first glance. Looks like it's been that way for decades by the looks of it, literally at the south end of a neighborhood in Morton Grove. Walking into it just reminds me of an old school bar and fairly small, the actual bar has literally like 4 stools. The service was great and very attentive courtesy of Stefanija. I came to order the staple right, the pan pizza! I ordered a half cheese and half pepperoni and jalapeño pizza. Being that I'm Mexican you can guess which was my side. It was very very tasty with lots of pepperoni and pickled jalapeños. It was like a medium deep dish is how I would describe it as far as the thickness of the crust. The only thing I would say is that the pepperoni on top could've been crispier but flavor wise it was great. We also ordered some chicken tenders and some fries, the tenders were very mid like the frozen tenders you throw in the air frier...not top tier tenders at all. The fries were perfectly crispy which I enjoyed more than usual. You can tell the place probably gets packed on a Friday and Saturday night just because of how small it is. I'd say there's probably like 10 tables maybe plus the couple seats at the bar. I would come back and I would love to try a tavern style(thin crust) pizza and see how well they do that. I give this place 4/5 stars it's not a 5 just because of the missing crispy pepperoni and just because it's not very comfortable at a two seat table not very much room. I will return and if I lived in Morton Grove this would probably be the place where I would always order pizza from. I'm sure the thin crust is great as well. read more

See all

A whale with panties on its head? How can it be bad, right? Holy crap this was some good pizza. They're supposedly known for their crusts and the "burnt" caramelized cheese that doesn't taste burnt. The personal size was perfect as you get MORE of that black edge than a larger slice. Plus, trying to get multiple people to agree on pizza toppings is the worst! This was recommended by some locals and it did not disappoint. I also had the Pequod Salad (small) which had lots of goodies inside. Their house Italian dressing was great. They had some good beer choices as well. This place was a bit small, but it appeared like they had more seating in the back. Make reservations unless you're going during non-peak hours. Staff was friendly, it had a "neighborhood" vibe with houses right across the street (can you imagine living near this place?). I think they have multiple locations and also saw signs they ship via Goldbelly! read more

See all

Pizza is decent just that it's too small and not a fan of the thin crispy burnt edges... the inside pieces were good and well made. However there isn't anything special that I would rave about. But the biggest issue is that a medium pizza with 5 toppings is 44!!! That's just insane honestly . If you did deep dish it would be even more ... I don't think any single medium pizza should ever be over 40 dollars. That's wild - I'm surprised it was packed too , ppl really got a pizza spending fund or something. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Medium Thin Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois

I don't understand the hype. I hate writing this because besides one staff members, everyone else was soooo nice and sweet. So you need a reservation or else, there is 4 bar seats or patio dining. I liked the bar, it was cozy. The mozz sticks were good. I couldn't get a pic of the whole thing because he dropped it & quickly slapped our slices on our plate, causing sauce to fling in spots. Alridy then! The pizza was not good. I don' even know how I swallowed the first bite. The sauce has zero flavor, the pepperoni was barely cooked, sausage was good, the 3 pieces I had. Barely on my slice. Other than that, it was just dough. Not a fan. Definitely a over hyped up tourist spot. I love pizza! Any pizza actually. It's my number one food. So this was a huge disappointment. read more

See all

We heard about Pequod's pizza from some friends. We decided to try it out while in the Chicago area. Ordered hotel delivery the first night and found the pizza to be very good. The following day we drove to actual location there in Morton's Grove. Not being from the area we weren't sure how to order the frozen pizza's to take back home. We were there about 15 min before they opened (didn't even realize this), but instead of just ignoring us they were very accommodating and still made the sale. We appreciated this since we needed to get on the road to head back home. Very nice staff. read more

Once I found myself in the outer reaches of the Second City, rueing the travel planners who had me far from the hustle and bustle (and culinary arts) of downtown. But a quick search of the internets found the "other" Pequod's location in Morton Grove, a quick drive away. Get the keys! The standard order, a large deep dish pepperoni to go. A satisfying end to a long day in the 'burbs, sitting in a hotel room, watching mindless television and chewing on Pequod's. It can be a lot worse. The only downside is that carry-out doesn't have the same feel as in-house dining - the pizza was a little cooler, so no cheese-pull. Also, a little doughy - was that because of the cooling time, or is the recipe different in Morton Grove? Regardless, it hit the spot. Pequod's, you're still the one for me. And if you're stuck in the outer 'burbs, this one will do. read more

Pequod's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Morton Grove, Illinois