Really overpriced for what it is; decent but not great. Service was lacking - from the hostess who persuaded us to dine at the bar after telling us it would be 30+ mins for a table despite the place never being even half full to the bartender who while friendly, was not the most attentive dude in the world. Menu looked great however food was underwhelming. Fresh fish not so fresh tasting. Wine overpriced. Cocktails weak. Service lackluster. Meh. read more

Great service. Great food. Right proportions. Nice quiet atmosphere. On expensive side but the food and quality is worth it.

Pleasantly surprised at the level of service, quality of food here. I've been to many Italian restaurants in Chicago and New York and this was on par. The ambiance was perfect too! Not an island vibe but more of a dark romantic vibe. read more

Jessica H in the events department is AMAZING!!!! My Dad and Stepmom went to dinner and she made it such a special evening!!!!!! She helped me Make it extra special even though I'm in California and it wasn't a huge event but she made me feel like we were throwing a banquet. The special touch and attention to detail was incredible!!!! The place is beautiful and they go above and beyond. Thank you Jessica H and Pesce team!!! read more

Absolutely delicious food! Had the best penne alla Vodka here. The bruschetta was also amazing. The focaccia bread is complementary and is served with olive oil and balsamic vinegar. Had the whisky with aperol too, pretty potent. Great ambiance as well! read more

See all

Great Italian spot right in the middle of red hook. Lots of vegetarian options & the wait staff was very helpful in modifying other options on the regular menu to fit dietary needs. It's a great spot for a date night but try to reserve ahead of time if you don't want a long wait or be seated at the bar read more

See all

A fantastic Italian treat while on the island. Delicious fresh pasta, but fantastic service and yummy wines. I regularly eat Italian and this was a really enjoyable meal! I recommend starting with the bruschetta. read more

The food, staff and cleanliness is below average. Not difficult to make chicken Parm over pasta.... Frozen breaded chicken, mozzarella, sauce... Mediocre. Tell me what Italian restaurant doesn't serve bread with the meal?.... Homemade pasta that was way over cooked.... Maybe an off night, but not good.... read more

Phenomenal meal. Incredible appetizers, specialty cocktails and entrees. I had the red snapper piccata - which was one of the best dishes I've had in a long time. And all of their pasta is freshly made. This restaurant is elegant, has a wonderful glow and the service is top notch. We'll be back! read more

So we did not make a reservation but maybe you should. It was fancy. We got fruit punches to drink. Started with the maricodi and mussels. The mussels were fabulous so tender and the sauce was good I am allergic to alcohol and they accommodated me great! So I wanted the lobster but they did not have it very disappointed with that. So I chose the chefs pesto pasta with shrimp and the chicken parm. The pasta was great and the chicken parm was crispy and really good. Oh and had a side of cheesy bread that was awesome. Finished with lava cake and ice cream it was amazing!! And the service was one of the best parts I'm not going to lie I forgot her name but a younger women with blonde hair. read more

See all

Worth the trip from our hotel! Prices were reasonable and the food was very good! Pasta Monday's was a plus! The service was very good and great ambiance! read more

Everything we ate was sooooo good. Great size wine list, delicious focaccia, 4 different pastas all of which were great, and would dare to say the top 3 tiramisu that I've ever tried. Server was very nice and attentive and quick to give suggestions if you needed it. Mood was set for a great date night but also very family friendly. Just make sure you make a reservation cause they stay busy. read more

We were in the mood for Italian and so glad we found Pesce! There was a bit of a wait but it was no big deal as we had no reservations and they were only allowing a certain amount of guests dine in at a time (COVID-19). Ended up sitting at the bar which was ok with me. Our waiter/bartender was so awesome. I can't remember his name! Very friendly and helpful and really funny too! He was able to ask the kitchen to make an accommodation for me (I had an odd request...hey, i needed my veggies for the day even on vacation lol). They had no problem accommodating me. Even if they couldn't, I would have been ok with that. I got the Pesce Meatballs and the Italian egg rolls. Soooo dang good! I couldn't even finish. Barely got a chance to touch my side of veggies. Will definitely go back the next time I'm on the island. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Pesce Meatballs - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Wow, everything here was delicious. The zucchini appetizer was crispy yet refreshing. I took a risk ordering the truffle mushroom papperdelle pasta (I don't like mushrooms texture, I know I know!) But it was soo good! Pasta was cooked to perfection and all the flavors jived together. And then there's the bread. It was by far the softest bread I've ever had at a restaurant.. I'd sleep on a pillow made up of that bread. All in all it was a great experience and I would return on my next visit. read more

Well this was eventful. So the food was great. However, we had great in house entertainment starring a fat cockroach. As we were enjoying our meal I see a cockroach crawling up the wall and hid behind a crevice. We were stunned, couple of moments later, the cockroach made its way over above our table. My dad was stunned and tried to quickly get up which ended in him tripping and falling flat on his back. Now the craziest thing is, we laugh only because we felt bad for my dad. However, management took it as we were ok with the ordeal and no apology was given. When the manager came to check if my Dad was ok, he said "Well, at least it's not a flying roach". We were only good sports for my Dad, but I would expect better care no matter how the customer reacts in the moment. I hope they learn better customer service at our expense. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - This is a artist rendered drawing of our entertainment. - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

First thing you need to know is that you should make reservations. We got in as soon as it opened and there already people inside eating. We met Jimmy our waiter and he was a hoot. Loved how he interacted with us and made us feel like we were at home. We had Bruschetta and Fried Zucchini for appetizers. The pasta is home made and the chicken parmesan is cooked to perfection. We didn't get any pictures of the meals because by the time we thought of it it was almost all gone. Dessert selection was great and very tasty. Make sure to come here if you want Italian food while in St. Thomas. read more

See all

Had Veal Marsala and Salmon. Both were delicious. Great ambience. Friendly staff. Definitely recommend this restaurant. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Guava icecream - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Friendly service, INCREDIBLE food, and a relaxed atmosphere. I will definitely be back. Best calamari and shrimp scampi I have ever had! read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

I was extremely disappointed in Pesce. The food didn't taste similar to any other Italian cuisine I've had in my life. The flatbread pizza was bland, with absolutely no sauce and very little tomatoes to make up for it. The fettuccine was extremely salty, to the point that I found myself reaching for a drink after every other bite. The only redeeming factor was that they had gluten free options and the chicken was delicious, but we had to pay extra for that. The service was decent but no one was there to greet us at the door and we had to walk over to the bartender to get a table. The food is also expensive and is not at a fair price point for the quality of the food. The restaurant itself is beautiful, but it tricks you into thinking you're going to a nice italian restaurant when in reality the food is not good at all. read more

3rd trip to the island, 1st time here, What a pleasant surprise, service was good, food was fresh. Loved our visit and will recommend read more

See all

This place was awesome....the severs were very friendly and attentive . The food was very good and amazing....and let's not forget one of the best tiramisu I have ever had.....yummmm....great place employees, and of course great food.... read more

The food here was excellent here! Nice restaurant with a huge wine list. Our Server Erin was really nice and always constantly came to check on us! Ask for him if you ever get a chance to visit this place! 10/10 I'll be coming back on my next trip to St Thomas! read more

See all

Overall we liked this restaurant, food was good, recommend the chicken Parmesan Over the fettuccine.

We found this place on our last night here. It was absolutely delicious!! If we found it sooner we would've been back. 10/10 recommend!! Our service was great and the food was delicious. Best meatballs ever! read more

Wonderful place, really cozy and welcoming. The food is delicious and the service is amazing. Do not hesitate!

One of our favorite meals in Red Hook. However, when we made the reservation at 6PM for Pesce, we ended up with a reservation at the Mexican place next door? Luckily they were able to get us in at 7:15. They have an amazing wine list, we got the Martinelli pinot noir. The scallops might have been the highlight of the evening. Our entrees, the spaghetti and meatballs and the chicken fricassee were both amazing. We ended with the lava cake and espresso martinis which were perfect. Make sure your reservation is for Pesce when trying to book!!!! read more

See all

Fantastic spot for high end Italian and seafood. Beautiful atmosphere and the service was great. The food and wine was delicious, and the house made black cherry ice cream was off the charts. read more

Service perfect, foccacia bread with cheesy olive oil starter-amazing then the best shrimp scampi I have ever had!!!! read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

We ate here on 4/30/22. We had eaten there in 2015 and this was our first visit to the island since the hurricane. It was nice to see that this business survived. The food was good, large wine selection, and the dessert was excellent. read more

Very yummy food here! Our waiter was super kind and very attentive. I love pasta & especially this restaurant's! Will most likely be coming back to indulge once again read more

The atmosphere is really quite relaxing and feels like an old Italian villa. It is quiet and the tables are candlelit. The service is outstanding and out server Torey did a great job of telling us a little about himself which made it a nice personal experience. The wine list is very nice and will pleasantly surprise you as you have a good selection of various regions to choose from. I had the chicken piccata with au gratin cauliflower. Trust me it is amazing! My wife had the vodka pasta and chose the smaller portion which turned out to be a good decision. They have 1/2 portions of their homemade pasta dishes which is really nice. We didn't save room for dessert but we would have chosen the double chocolate Kahlua cake. Next time we will order the calamari and cake. We gave it a 4 star because zero view, pretty pricey and you have to pass a bar with the smoking section outside to get to the restaurant. As far as authentic Italian on St Thomas goes, this is right up there with Virgilios Parking is a little easier here. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Inside the restaurant - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

The food and ambience was generally very good - also a very kid friendly restaurant. The appetizers were spot on. The stuffed pepper appetizer was lemony and refreshing - highly recommend. The eggplant Parmesan was not cooked well (we got a refund for the same) but the pasta and sauce tasted very fresh and was filling. The dessert was thanksgiving themed. I enjoyed the pumpkin ice cream (which tasted a lot like pie). The pecan pie flavors were a little off due to how it was spiced - which was more of a flavor being mismatched from my expectations - but the texture was spot on. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Thanksgiving special dessert - pecan pie, pumpkin ice cream and marshmallow - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

We ordered the bruschetta, and the tomatoes were nicely diced that it fit perfectly on the thin slices of baguettes. For the main course, we ordered the Chicken Parmigiana and substituted the spaghetti with Penna. My husband ordered the spaghetti carbonara with blackened chicken. The restaurant made the noodles in house (it tasted so good), and the chicken was exquisite. To top Off the amazing dinner, we ordered the lava cake with ice cream for dessert. So good! read more

My husband and I recently went back to Pesce when we were in Red Hook, and it was pretty good. We enjoyed the house made herbed focaccia, and all the pastas are homemade. They also have an entire vegetarian section! We were pleasantly surprised that they had non alcoholic beer and mocktails. I thoroughly enjoyed the carbonara without pancetta (though I wish I had asked to add peas and I didn't really taste truffle). My husband though the panzanella salad (minus bacon) with tomato, gorgonzola, and arugala (though slightly overdressed) and bolognese was very good. The tiramisu wasn't quite as mind blowing as we remembered. Our server Crystal was very friendly! read more

Pesce is back and ba-bang! They're awesome. Are there on Christmas Eve and it was fabulous! Each of us had a house-made pasta dish and nothing but raves for the chef and staff. read more

I would rate this restaurant one of the top 5 best Italian restaurants (outside Italy) that I've ever eaten in. I didn't expect to get good Italian food in the Virgin Islands. But I was wrong! The food was very good and the drinks were also very good. read more

Starters meatballs and bruschetta both were fantastic. Main meals fettuccine Alfredo, chicken Parmesan, shrimp scampi and spaghetti & meatballs. All the food was good it's a must stop read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Chicken Parmesan with fettuccine Alfredo - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

We did a carry out of shrimp scampi linguine, Caesar salad and zucchini appetizer. All of it was very good. The pasta is handmade and really nicely done. The ambiance in the restaurant itself is beautiful, we were too beached out to eat there that evening, but will try it another evening. read more

Yeah, it's Italian but the pasta tastes fantastic and the dishes have seafood options you'd expect and all was great. Not sure about Italian in Virgin Islands? I was too but it's not your typical Italian place. Definitely recommend read more

Had dinner Christmas Eve on our vacation. Food was excellent and large portions. Our server was new and very attentive. Only reason for four stars was a couple of screaming children at a couple of tables. read more