Went with nine friends from NewYork. We all had a wonderful experience. Richie, our bartender/waiter, was amazing. He took the time to answer all our 'menu' questions and , when my meal didn't come out with the others, he brought me a free drink . Have to say , when my meal arrived, it was absolutely 'worth-the -wait' ! We will definitely be back. Highly recommend. read more

Food was good. Had the burrata and cheesy garlic bread for appetizers, and shrimp scampi and penne vodka with whipped ricotta and added chicken. All had good flavor. Prices were reasonable for what felt like a more upscale restaurant. Didn't seem to have a dress code. We made a reservation although it might not have been needed. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Shrimp scampi - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Less than average. We ordered the Lasagna WHICH WAS NOT LASAGNA. What we got was penne pasta but they called it DECONSTRUCTED LASAGNA......which didn't even look or taste like any Lasagna anybody has ever had. NO WARNING JUST HERE IT IS. When brought to their attention, NOTHING !!!!! This is what you get. Management doesn't even care. read more

While vacationing in St. Thomas we decided to go off our resort and try an Italian restaurant. We had a reservation but went early to take advantage of their great Happy Hour! We first sat at the bar and enjoyed a couple of glasses of wine. We decided to try the Truffle Polenta Frites. They were very delicious. I would definitely recommend them!! Our bartender was SUPER friendly and very attentive. Then we went to our table for dinner. Once again the service was outstanding. We enjoyed more wine, we also enjoyed some bread. I ordered the Chicken Marsala. It's was so delicious that I cleaned my entire plate!! The vibe of the restaurant I would say was upscale, classy and intimate. But definitely good for larger groups and families. If you are ever visiting St. Thomas I highly recommend checking this place out. read more

See all

In the mood for Italian? We chose this restaurant based on the previous Yelp reviews and thoroughly enjoyed it. The restaurant looks unassuming from the outside but once you enter, you are greeted with a well laid out and thoughtfully decorated dining room and bar. The lighting is very dim so bring your readers. I wanted a hearty Italian meal so I ordered the paperdelle bolognese, rosemary focaccia and truffle polenta frites and, of course, a glass of wine. All were delicious and very satisfying. Our bartender and waitress were extremely cordial but very "proper" in their delivery of service. This definitely makes my list for restaurants to visit in the USVI. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Rosemary focaccia - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

This place is great! In redhook and thus a great reprive from the resort meals. The meals were all served hot and delicious. Had the chicken Parm, scampi, lasagnas as meals. My favorite was actually the mussels in red sauce with the cheesy bread to sop up the flavors. The Caesar was adequate. Wine list reasonable variety. Pricing very reasonable compared to the resort restaurants which are all mostly OK (even the highly rated ones). We have been to St Thomas 5 times and feel this is actually the best tasting Italian place. 2 bottles of wine and dessert made the meal complete. Staff was EXCELLENT!!! read more

Our server Richi was helpful and attentive. Doesn't look like much from the outside but inside the atmosphere was nice and inviting. We were seated at a high table. Colors were nice and made for a good background for our photos (no crazy bright lights to mess up our photos). n The Gallant Fox cocktail was their take on an Old Fashioned. We had Prince Edward Island Mussles in a aribiatta sauce - delish! Didn't want to waste all that yummy sauce so we added Rosemary Focaccia - great call. Then we devoured our Penne Lasagna and Snapper Picatta. Food was excellent - too bad we didn't have room left for dessert. We plan to return again in the future! read more

See all

One of my favorite Italian restaurants, ever! Me and my girlfriend were in St. Thomas recently and we were looking for a place to eat one night that was romantic and this was the restaurant we chose. I absolutely loved the whole atmosphere of this place. Red Hook in general is a great little spot to be in if you're looking to have some good food and drinks. The staff were super friendly and the service was excellent. We started off with some drinks and ordered some antipasta and finished with pesce. We ordered: - Zucchini Fritti 10/10 - Pesce Meatballs 9/10 - Snapper Piccata 11/10 - Margarita 8/10 - Local IPA 9/10 If you're looking for great Italian food in St. Thomas this is the place you want to go. Enjoy :) read more

See all

Great tasting food.. but our waiter (Richie) was a better addition to our experience. Very kind and knowledgeable with excellence. The garlic bread was delicious read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Garlic cheesy bread and rosemary focaccia bread - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Had a reservation here and my group got seated right on time. The interior is very cozy and Italian feeling. We went on Pasta Monday so we all ended up ordering a pasta dish. I had the penne alla vodka which was flavorful and had just enough sauce! We also ordered a Caesar salad and focaccia bread which were both great. The tiramisu for dessert did not taste like a traditional tiramisu but it was still yummy. Overall a pretty solid Italian meal in St. Thomas! Parking can be tricky but we found a spot on the road. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Penne Alla Vodka - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

This place was my favorite food spot in St. Thomas. We came here our first night for dinner after stopping at the Easterly. We were starving so we ordered some bruschetta to start. It came out relatively quickly and we were impressed by how fresh it was. I ordered a moscow mule, which was a little gingery but overall super refreshing too! We ordered the chicken pasta to split and I ended up having leftovers and eating them later on. The ambiance was very low lit and romantic, which was exactly what we were looking for. The service was great and the price was super reasonable. Thanks for such a great experience! read more

We sat at the bar for dinner. Nice choice of wine by the glass for Happy Hour 5-7. Our chicken and veal Parmesan were excellent. The sauce is delicious...not too sweet- just right. They use a high grade semolina thick noodle that made their pasta stand out. We preceded dinner with some rosemary focaccia that was generous and went well with the wine. Service was good but they like most restaurants in Red Hook run understaffed. I would consider this place more fine dining. Prices were comparable to the local market. read more

Monday Pasta Night was great. This was some of the best Italian food we have had anywhere. Service was fine. Desserts were just right. Parking was an issue but that was to be expected. It was worth the hassle. read more

We've visited Pesce twice in a short stay. Service and staff are amazing. The bartender is incredibly conscientious and recognized us the second time we came. Shamara was our server last night and she's probably the nicest person l've encountered on the island. Such amazing energy and attention to detail. DO get the rosemary focaccia for an appetizer. In fact, maybe double your order. YUM. (Pro tip: their happy hour is 3-6 and you'll get $3 off the bread if you sit at the bar vs other tables). The spaghetti with marinara is great. All pasta is made in house. The shrimp scampi was just okay. I like a buttery, savory scampi. This tasted like it had too much lemon- it was overall more sour tasting than anything else. Very heavy garlic- which l'd normally like, but it just wasn't great. The PEl muscles with the spicy sauce were fantastic. The burrata wasn't good. Seems like the menu has a lot of hit or miss items but the hits are so good, l'd come back just to keep trying other things. There are no water views here, and the windows are covered so it's somewhat dark in the dining area. The facilities are clean and we got seated quickly both times. Reasonable wait on food. read more

See all

Risotto and the lobster were very delicious. The customer service was second to none. Food was service timely. Very spacious and comfortable and the bathroom were very clean and beautiful. read more

For our final night in St. Thomas, my husband and I were looking for a more casual dinner and decided Pesce's menu looked good. It's this cute little Italian restaurant on the Red Hook strip, and we were very pleased with our dinner. Our waitress Kiki was just a delightful, kind, most helpful woman. We ordered the burrata and garlic cheesy bread for apps--both hit the spot. Then we asked Kiki what she recommended for dinner. She said "Snapper Piccata, Chicken Parm, and Penne alla Vodka" so we ordered all 3 and again! Kiki delivered. All 3 were delicious and great portions. We couldn't finish all 3 so we had leftovers the next day, and they were just as good. Also! The cocktails were outstanding! We recommend the Genovese gin cocktail--light, not too sweet, and incredibly flavorful. Will definitely revisit! read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Near to far: Snapper Piccata, Penne alla Vodka (center), Chicken Parmesan - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

We go to St Thomas every year and our annual dinner at Pesce is always fun! This year we were lucky to have Shamara help us enjoy ourselves. Best service and great personality. The food is always good and we can't wait to go back next year! read more

The food was delicious, but the service was really exceptional! Highly recommend for an Italian dinner as a change from other local options.

Just OK. Hard to rate Italian high when you are Italian and you live in the northeast US. They try here, but it's kind of like Florida Italian. Not horrible, but leaves you wanting more.... Staff and servers were very nice. read more

We enjoyed every bite and sip!! Everyone was so friendly and helpful. A great selection of food and drinks. Great, friendly, knowledgeable staff. read more

Service and food were amazing. By far the best Italian food I have had. You have to get the gnocchi appetizer, toasty on the outside and soft on the inside. The sauce was great. Cute little restaurant. read more

See all

One of our favorite restaurants on St. Thomas! A close walk from the Red Hook ferry, this is a low-light and a date night Italian restaurant. They make everything from scratch and you can especially tell with their pasta. We had focaccia bread, Caesar salads, veal piccata, a vegetarian pasta, and a spaghetti Aglio e Olio with Snapper. I highly recommend for date night! read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Spaghetti Aglio e Olio with Snapper - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Always a favorite spot! Pastas are house made, large selection of wines to choose from, the ac is cold and inviting , and the service is always on point. Thanks! Ask for Josh, he's the absolute best! :) read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Gluten free bruschetta - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Richi our server took great care of us and was an absolute pleasure. We got the Shrimp Scampi and the Bolognese. Both were great, as was the bruschetta. Highly recommended. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Let me start off by saying that the food was AMAZING!!! My recommendation for food would be to get the shrimp scampi, it is awesome! The waitress, Shamara, was the best one I've ever had! She was so nice! The environment was very cozy and great for any amount of people, really! I would definitely recommend this place, along with the other restaurants in their food chain, the names that I know are: The Patio, CFM (Caribbean Fish Market), Sunset Grille, and Agave. I haven't checked out Agave yet, but I hope I do sometime soon while visiting the amazing, STT. read more

Nice cozy restaurant dim lighting. They do have mini table lamps to view the menu. The Host and Waiters were very informative and patient with new customers. The food was hot and cooked to perfection. The orders was placed and the food was put on the time with in minutes. read more

See all

My husband & I's 2nd trip to St.Thomas & we are so sad we missed this place the first time around. We visited twice during our trip & both times exceeded our expectations. Shamara & Cortina went above & beyond with service. My husband thoroughly enjoyed the shrimp Alfredo & my ribeye with rustic potatoes & broccolini were top notch. The crab cakes, spinach artichoke dip, & garlic bread were all amazing! This is a great restaurant for a romantic dinner...perfect mood lighting! Have all positives for both times we ate there for dinner this week. Can't wait to return in June next year! read more

As an Italian from the northeast, this food was pretty good. They could've given some bread with your meal, but that might be asking a lot for the islands. read more

We celebrated my father in laws birthday here while on vacation and the staff made him feel so special! It was a wonderful night filled with delicious food! Everything we ordered was delicious! read more

Stopped in on a Sunday night with a party of eight no reservations. Luckily, we seated right away as the rush of diners soon followed. Started with some wine and libations along with octopus gnocchi, burrata, brischetta, and meatballs. Our waiter was very attentive and kept us hydrated. We dined on flatbreads, salad, chicken frances, marsala, salmon, and ribeye. Everything was delicious and plentiful. There was no room for dessert. Enjoy! read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Bar or table seating - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

We were looking for dinner on a Monday evening and a good chunk of restaurants on the island are closed on Mondays so I randomly stumbled across this place and saw they had a Monday night pasta special and a happy hour! Parking can be a little tricky but we luckily found a spot on the road. Service was truly exceptional here! I didn't think an Italian restaurant would be my favorite place on the island but everything was hot and fresh and delicious! They make all of their pasta in house and their happy hour specials included bruschetta and focaccia and both were amazing. Pasta alla vodka was seriously to die for! It had whipped ricotta in the center and it was sooo good. Pasta Monday specials included a list of pastas for $22 so I thought that was a great deal for the amount of food we got! Our server was so attentive and it was so appreciated after our numerous bad experiences at other local restaurants. If you ever visit the island, you have to go here! read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Focaccia - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

This had to have been the most disappointing meal I've had all year. The waitress was kind, but couldn't offer much recommendation on anything because she was new. I loved the ambiance of the restaurant and the friendliness of everyone there even those that didn't wait on us. This was my birthday dinner and the risotto was very undercooked and the lobster was bland with what tasted like lemon on it. It looked amazing but tasted horrible. It was expensive and just was lacking all around in flavor. I love Italian food and have eaten all over, but this just wasn't good to us. I'm unsure what other Italian options are available on this island but I definitely wouldn't go back. It was a nice experience outside of the food. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Lobster with risotto - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Nice Italian restaurant in Red Hook. Service was friendly and fairly quick. They had a large drink menu and some tasty cocktails. My pasta was rather salty, but I enjoyed the fresh noodles. Chicken was cooked well. Nice area and reasonable prices. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Carbonara with Chicken - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

This restaurant caught me a little off guard. We picked it sort of casually from the list for a nice dinner date, and it turned out to be one of our favorite meals of the trip. The atmosphere is refined and warm once inside the building. The staff were friendly and proudly offered descriptions of the food options as well as recommendations. As everything came out to our table we were totally impressed with the quality and flavors of our entrees and drinks from the bar. The prices were what we expected for an upscale date night dinner and we left very satisfied. read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Chicken Francese (no polenta, sub linguine) - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

First time eating at this restaurant, it was my daughter's graduation dinner. They had a congratulatory card signed by the crew. The food was amazing and service was impeccable too. Would give them a 10 if I could!!!! read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Penne alla vodka - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

In St.Thomas for my Princess' birthday, she wanted Italian, and what my Princess wants my Princess gets - Yuo I'm one of those dads who's daughter has him wrapped around his finger! Either way, this spot was highly recommended and we definitely wanted to give it a try. The staff was super friendly, they have a great menu, and the food is delicious. I had the snapper Scampi, the wife the shrimp scampi, my baby the chicken Alfredo, and my boy the spaghetti & meatballs. Everyone was extremely pleased with their meal, all made happy plates. We also enjoyed great cocktails, although they have a large wine selection, and we topped off the night with great desert. A must if you're looking for great Italian on the island this is the place you want to come. read more

See all

We were seating at Pesce on a Friday night without a reservation and our waitress and the whole staff was amazing. Definitely wouldn't recommend this place for traditional Italian food. However, the fish dishes were great. On person in our party was also gluten free and had the flatbread and said it was better than most gf options! We ended the night with the limoncello crème brûlée which was pretty good! read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Chicken Parmesan - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

We dined at Pesce Restaurant in St Thomas, VI last night. What a rare treat!! Food and service were top notch.Are waitress was Keke and she was incredible!! We are from Chicago,so we know our food. I would highly recomnend read more

Food was good. Reservations were also good. Good place for a date. Would suggest better lighting. read more

A great dinner in Red Hook but even on a Thursday night - reservations are a must. The complimentary basket of warm rosemary focaccia bites with olive oil and Parmesan was delicious. I had the daily flatbread special - rosa sauce, chicken, sun-dried tomatoes, and shaved onions - and it was so flavorful, well seasoned, and the right amount of crispy. I paired it was a small Caesar salad. My husband got the truffle mushroom pappardelle; the sauce was super rich (a tad too much for my taste but he liked it!) and homemade pasta was well cooked. Lots of wine and cocktail choices. The dessert menu had several options that sounded great but sadly we were too full! read more

Pesce iTALiAN - Truffle mushroom pappardelle - Diners Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all