We stopped here before a sunset cruise. It wasn't busy. The server was nice. The negative is it took about an hour to get our food (fish sandwiches). We had to get them to go and snarf them down right before the cruise. I wanted to like this place. The sandwiches were huge and we could have split it. It was a good sandwich; not great. I would not try the place again. read more

Peter Trout's is a divey bar & grill on the shore of a working commercial harbor. Like every other restaurant in the area, they make their real money from summer people. We came during shoulder season; we could easily see this place keeping the lights on with delicious meals for hardworking boatbuilders in the dark of winter. The ambiance is "run-down basement." The service is slow. The room is cold. I was leaning toward rating this place two stars until our fish sandwiches arrived. They were perfect. I've worked with deep fryers, and I'm here to tell you: Peter Trout's uses clean grease at the right temperature. Our fish was crispy without being greasy, plus it it had the clean look and zero aftertaste of clean grease in a clean fryer. Bam: right back up to three stars we go. Peter Trout's is the clear choice for those who value authenticity, have plenty of time, and appreciate simple food made well. read more

Outstanding halibut, beers....cool laid-back vibe. Loved it!!! Sat at the bar and had a great chill lunch! read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Halibut sandwich! - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

Delicious bar food right by the water! The roasted potatoes were a personal favorite starter, but the real star of the show was the fish sandwich. The batter was light, so it didn't feel too heavy. The servers also did a great job despite being understaffed. read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Half fish sandwich - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

Fantastic food. We came here twice for lunch while visiting Acadia. First visit we had the whole fried chicken, biscuits, picked and house ranch, sides were broccolini, fiddleheads and cauliflower and a Cesar salad which was plenty of food for 4 people. Our second visit it was Nashville hot chicken sandwiches, a fish sandwich which was a whole filet of haddock huge, a Cesar salad and wedge. Again delicious and a lot of food. Service is great and so fun to talk to. read more

See all

Horrible service, waiter was rude, food was FREEZING, it was so cold that I had to go out and get my winter jacket, no substitutions, only one soda and it was Coca Cola in a can. I could go on and on but for 94 bucks, it isn't worth it. Also threatening to fight someone because they left a bad review is insane.... read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

Very eclectic little bar and restaurant. No frills place and not a huge selection of food, but what they had was good. Very laid back atmosphere. Kind of pricey, but to be expected based on the area. Our server was fine...not super friendly, but his personality fit perfectly in this place. I would definitely eat here again if I was in the area. read more

See all

Arrived about 1pm they were still serving brunch. We decided to try the Chicken sandwich. This was the best chicken sandwich my husband or I've ever had. The 2 chicken breast were juicy and well seasoned, bun was fresh and homemade pickles were crunchy. The smashed fried potatoes were amazing, just wish there had been more. Service was great. Will definitely return and try their other options. read more

What a cool spot right by the water. We came on a Friday evening at 7:30 and realized the restaurant closes at 8:00. We were able to grab a picnic table outside. We enjoyed the cool air and the views while we waited for our food. We ordered a few of the sides (3/$18) The market fish sandwich and mushroom toast. We waited quite a long time for our food. But once it came out, we dug in! The mushroom toast was phenomenal and came topped with an egg. The fish sandwich was HUGE! Would have loved to have a little more side with the sandwich - it came with three small little smashed potatoes and the fish was overly battered. We had to wait a very long time for the bill, when we realized we were probably forgotten because we were the only ones sitting outside by then. I went inside to ask for our bill and the server was unapologetic and even seemed annoyed that I was bothering him. We would definitely come back! And next time ask what the market price was ahead of ordering. (The fish sandwich ended up being $38! A little steep) read more

See all

This was are first restaurant me and my 3 traveling companions went to in Maine . We got in late and it was open. We were greeted and seated fast. The waiter was friendly. First thing he said was they were out of hamburger. The menu was limited. Chicken or chicken or $36 fish sandwich. You are nuts if you think I would give you $36 for a fish sandwich. We were hungry so i ordered the chicken sandwich. It was served with oil and mayonnaise the fried chicken was okay. But the dressing ,didn't like it even a little but I was hungry so I choked down. The others ordered the wedge salad with chicken. It was covered with so much dressing it was floating the lettuce. They didn't care for it but they were hungry and choked it down. It was uncomfortably cold, had to stick it out because I was hungry and to tired to go elsewhere. Take from this what you my ,it's not my favorite place read more

Sooooo - we came into this place hoping for fish and chips- which looked amazing. Miffed because dinner menu was not til 2:30. Ethan greeted us with a smile, kind of, not really... But then warmed up and we had a blast. Probably the greatest chicken sandwich my wife and I have ever had. No exaggeration. This place is five stars no doubt. PS. We love you Ethan. Best table enforcer ever Everything is scratch made. Don't miss it. We will be back for sure. Forgot to mention the bathroom art.... read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

This spot is a gem! Make sure to come early.. we arrived around 7.30pm and there was a long wait.. around 45min, but the bar is first come, first serve. Unfortunately, by the time we sat down and wanted to order, their famous fish sandwich had already sold out :'(. We were told they were understaffed, so the orders were taking a while to come out. By the time ours came, it was already past 9pm. We were one the last people at the restaurant. They close at 8pm, but as long as you get seated by then, you're fine. We shared the half fried chicken and wedge salad. They were both fantastic! The (honey/maple?) butter that came with the biscuits was delicious and unexpected. It's a pretty big space with some tables outside. I'd definitely try coming back for the fish sandwich next time I'm in town! read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Cute decor - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

See all

Ordered the Cesar salad with a fried chicken add on, with some biscuits on the side. Enjoyed everything especially the biscuits. I learned that their specialty was tinned fish. I like that they have seating outside with a water view. read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Outside Peter Trout. - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

Best meal of our vacation, and we didn't even have seafood!!! Fried chicken was super crispy and juicy. Comes with 3 sides, we had battered squash, squashed potatoes, and brussels sprouts. Squash was crispy and good seasoning. Potatoes were AMAZING and Brussel sprouts were crispy as well and well seasoned. Probably a very salty meal so I'll have to cut salt out for a few weeks to make up for it. Well done Peter Trouts! Oh yea, and a good local brew, Finch and Thistle, read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - 3 sides, battered squash, Brussels in the back and squash potatoes. - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

See all

There were only two guys working that night that didn't seem to have any service experience and were not on top of their game. When we first came in, one of them said we could have the window table after they wiped it down, but then proceeded to seat the customers that came in behind us there instead. So we had to sit at the communal table next to another family under the loud music speaker. The four of us had the "special" of the day, Halibut fish and chips. We wish we asked what the price would be as it was not on a board or communicated to us. It was expensive for what was served to us. After the food took forever to come out, the serving size was laughable. It looked like they made enough for 2 plates then realized it was for 4 people and spread it amongst 4 plates. There were maybe 3 or 4 smashed small potatoes on each plate. Every other fish and chip dish we've ever had has always had an abundance of fries. It's a shame because it looked like everyone who ordered from the regular menu had huge servings. To be fair, the fish and the chips were good and hot. The service was seriously lacking. read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Exterior - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

Good food. However, if you want to actually have your food within an hour of ordering, this is not your place. Ridiculously SLOW service.

The food was amazing!! Biscuits were delicious, loved the maple butter. Fried chicken sandwich was moist with the perfect amount of seasoning. Bartender was so nice and attentive. Over great experience, my only complaint would be that the lightning is way too bright. read more

Great spot with attentive servers, very cold beer, and yummy food. The Nashville Chicken Sandwich and smashed potatoes were so incredible we went back and had it again a couple of days later. Being from Tennessee, I have tried lots of attempts at Nashville hot. This one is one of the best. Enjoy! Tip: order an extra serving of the smashed potatoes. The normal side size served with your meal is weirdly small (like 3 bites) and these are so good, you will want more. read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Nashville hot chicken sandwich. Out of this world! - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

See all

Food was good, fish sandwich had no seasoning Price was crazy high Service absolutely sucked read more

Where to even begin! On a trip to Mount Desert Island, we actually had the good fortune of STAYING at Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn. I'll be brief on the Inn portion as there are not many rooms, but it was a terrific experience. There are a handful of apartments above the restaurant, and the owners live in one as well as some of the staff, but the rest are rented. A beautiful view, and easy parking across the street at the town docks where local fish come in each day. The owners and their daughter were very nice and took care of anything we needed. I would absolutely stay again! Now on to the restaurant and bar. We actually wound up eating at the restaurant three times while we were there. Of course the convenience was nice, but after trying it once we knew we wanted to try other menu items! A very nice relaxed setting, they have a sign in sheet when you walk in, and then you can hang out outside or walk across to the dock. We had great service each meal, and each was just as good as the last. The fish sandwich you honestly have to see to believe, even the pictures do not do it justice, the chicken sandwich just as impressive and probably the best I have ever had, and even the wedge salad..... you may say, "it's just a salad". But it was perfect, perfectly cooked chicken nuggets, great dressing, and CHUNKS of pork belly. I have thought about it many times since having it. No matter what you get, get a side of the smashed potatoes, they are crispy, well seasoned, and very tasty. If you are in the area, this is a great stop for food, and even better place to stay! I enjoy seeing what is going on with Peter Trout's online and hope to visit again before too long! read more

This spot reminded me of a place I'd find at home (Brooklyn) and was hands down the best food I've eaten in a national park town We happened upon this place since we were staying down the road. As someone who eats vegetarian 95% of the time, I was attracted to all the thoughtfully crafted veggie sides. It was pretty packed on a Friday night but we were able to get seated outside right away. Staff was pleasant, laid back but still attentive I ended up getting the mushroom egg toast and shared a bunch of sides with my husband. -mushroom toast was excellent sourdough grilled, buttered and topped with delicious mushroom. The egg was a bit hard but it did have some runniness to it -market fish sandwich was enormous! Looked ridiculous in one little brioche bun. This could definitely be split between two people. It came with crispy potatoes which were so good, you'll only wish there were more of them -biscuits with whipped honey butter- save room for these. They're off the hook tasty -asparagus - small portion, but cooked perfectly -heirloom tomatoes- so sweet and refreshing. I'm not a fan of raw onions but they're easy to avoid -corn - was sweet and fresh, but could have done with less mayo and more seasoning If you're looking for elegant food in a dreamy laid back coastal atmosphere- who isn't- check this out! read more

See all

The cranberry island oysters were the best oysters I've had in my entire life. This is more of a local spot which is refreshing to find. We also had the fried chicken and multiple sides that were all delicious. Not to mention there were beautiful views! read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Oysters - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

See all

Wow, so glad we tried this place! It's on a list of essential Maine restaurants and now I know why. It's in Southwest Harbor, tucked away near a real working boat launch. We went for late lunch on a Friday and got our choice of seats. Ordered the crab cake and the fried chicken sandwich, and they were both super large and fantastic! The chicken included 3 thighs (tender inside, nice amount of coating), with homemade pickle slices and a little aioli, and more aioli served on the side. Delicious! And even better we're the fried smashed fingerling potatoes! I could have eaten tons! Nicely crispy and salted. And the crab cake. Oh, the crab cake. Wide and tall, and full of large chunks of fresh crab, and what I'm guessing are chunks of the same buttery brioche that the sandwich was served on. Iced tea was excellent classic tea, and only $2 including a refill :-) Go find this place - you'll be glad you did. read more

See all

Glad we ventured off Main Street for this find! Love the ambience, the crabcake and the fish sandwich. read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - When they say the fish sandwich is big, this is what they mean! - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

I never thought that the best eating in Bar Harbor was in fact just outside of Bar Harbor. Peter Trout's Tavern sound and even at first glance looks like your run of the mill eat and drink spot near the water, but looks are deceiving. The food was terrific. I decided to step back from seafood, eyed the 'Nashville hot fried chicken sammy'. If people were fighting over the Popeye's chicken sandwiches, I think a full on brawl would break out if there was a shortage on these. This sandwich was so good, it's almost surreal. The cutlet exceeded the size of the sandwich, which is always welcome. Bread/bun should never overshadow the meat. The bun itself was excellent. Whatever sauce is on it is delicious. It's listed on the menu as "spicy stuff". What it is, it's damn good. Not done yet. The Biscuits are awesome. Nice, flaky, hot and came with a honey butter. I did not know it existed and I'm glad to now know it exists. Even re-heating ones not finished a couple days later, and they were still great. We got a shareable arugula plate. Again on the mark. Fresh with a nice peppery flavor and lightly sauced. I normally don't call out staff by name but Suzette was wonderful. Had good beer recommendations and did swell all around. Again if you're in or near Bar Harbor. Get outta there, and come to Peter Trouts. It was the best place I ate at on the island and it's not even close. read more

See all

We arrived on a Tuesday at about 7:00. We were seated at the bar. The person tending the bar spent probably 10 minutes working other orders before even acknowledging that we were there. We eventually were given menus and waited another 10+ minutes to order drinks. We waited another 10-15 minutes before she came over to take our food order. We asked for 2 orders of chicken nuggets and a burger. After about an hour and 15 minutes, with other tables having been seated and received their food we finally got ours (we had asked about an hour in and were told our order was in). The nuggets were cold (clearly they had been fried up and just sat there). The food was ok. The bartender then proceeded to sit down at a table and talked with people she must have known. Someone else eventually closed out our tab. This was a random Tuesday. I can't imagine how bad they are on a busy night or a weekend. read more

Peter Trout's has an excellent selection of craft beers and wines and a fun tavern vibe. The food is a massive step up from how I think of tavern food. My husband and I visited for dinner and had the ribeye for two, grilled oysters and sides. The steak is locally farmed and one of the best I've had, perfectly seasoned with garlic and rosemary. The portion was very generous, so we got a whole other meal out of the leftovers. The grilled oysters and heirloom tomato salad were also excellent. The biscuits are out of this world- I would visit again just for those. It was a rainy evening so we unfortunately didn't get any food pics, but the servers were incredibly gracious and packed everything up to go. Everything on the menu looks delicious and I hope we'll get to try more during our next visit to MDI. If you're lucky enough to be there definitely check it out! read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Outdoor seating ambiance - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

We dropped in here for lunch at a local friend's recommendation. They are definitely operating on a scaled back basis right now - only outdoor dining and to-go available. We sat outside on a Monday around 1 PM. Several other customers came to take advantage of the beer and wine to go while we ate. But other than that - activity was light. So - please check this place out for a bit if you are in the area. :-) We tried the meatloaf sandwich, fried chicken sandwich, the potato salad, sweet corn and biscuits! I would get any of these items again. It was all so good. And there were many other items I want to try! The meatloaf sandwich was served on toasted sourdough with a tomato jam. The meatloaf was so tender and light. Not something you can item say about meatloaf. The fried chicken sandwich was moist and almost flaky - comments were made that it was almost as flaky as fried fish. My only caution was that it took a while for food to come out - but we weren't in a hurry! And it was more than worth the wait! I do hope to come here again next year on my annual trek to the Island! read more

See all

Crab cakes were awesome along with the slaw. Don't usually care for restaurant slaw as it's just covered in mayo. Not this slaw, it was delicious. Get some smashed potatoes, these are fingerling potatoes crisp yet soft and tender. The fish and chips were no joke. Thought I was going to get a couple pieces of small fish with fries. Nope 3 large hanging over the plate crispy fish on top of a bed of smashed potatoes. Highly recommend this place. Great service, great food, and the music was good ole rock and roll. read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Fish and chips. Crab cakes - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

Lucky find today, better go hungry biggest portions ever. Food was fantastic and based on what we received value was unbelievable. Glad we found it!! read more

Visiting family for the holiday!! Checked Yelp reviews and thought we should check this place out. Wow!! The reviews are spot on!!! Hamburger, Sammy fried chicken, and the crab cake. All were amazing! Loved the side fingerling potatoes. Also ordered sides of biscuits. we will be back!!! PS outdoor seating with fabulous views read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

Gigantic fish sandwich, fried chicken, and crabcake. Come hungry. Sign up at the wait list by the door. Worth the wait. Opposite harbor master and a local pier with parking. read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Dining area from table near the entrance - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

Great service, terrific food and hidden gem! We had 7 for brunch and everyone cleaned their plates! The waiter was very nice! Loved the smash crispy potatoes and sourdough bread. I would give two thumbs up! read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Classic breakfast with sausage, we also had with bacon! Over easy eggs and had scrambled eggs! - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

See all

This was our first meal on MDI. Since we were staying in Southwest Harbor this was perfect it has a great location by the water, friendly service and good food. Hubs had the friend haddock sandwich which he said was delicious (and HUGE!) and as a vegetarian I did a mix of sides. All were tasty but since they brought all the food out at the same time, some were getting cold and had clearly been sitting awhile waiting on the fish. Service was great, we enjoyed our meal here. read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Fried haddock sandwich - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

See all

Wow go and get the fried chicken sandwich either plain or Nashville hot. It was huge, 3 big pieces of meat so easily splittable. We did a wedge salad and the sandwich and split and couldn't finish. Get the biscuits omg they were great. Quaint setting across from a lobster pier where boats were coming in. My family loved it. read more

See all

We enjoyed our meal at Peter Trout's - the picnic tables outside provide a great view of the water. We came during brunch hours and I wish we could've ordered from the full menu as the brunch menu was a bit limited. The breakfast burger ($17) with egg and pork belly was absolutely delicious, but doesn't come with anything - I added some smashed potatoes which were pretty good. My husband had the crab cake Benedict - also delicious and came with a few smashed potatoes on the side. The server was nice, but I think was attending to almost every table and so our meal was a bit on the slower side (with a view like theirs, not necessarily a bad thing, but we had a little one with us who gets restless). We would probably return, but would prioritize the regular lunch or dinner menu. read more

Wonderful! First day to the area and everything is closed except Peter Trout's. Terrific restaurant in a great spot with great food and selection of local beers. read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Crab cake and local brew - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

Best food on MDI - all of it was simply exquisite. Appetizer of sautéed mushrooms on grilled bread with a lightly fried egg, fried haddock sandwich with fresh pickles and spicy coleslaw on grilled brioche, and sides to die for - pickled radish, garlic scapes, asparagus and cucumber, braised greens, and grilled asparagus plus craft brews - OMG!!! And a view of Manset Harbor and mountains with fog drifting in and out of sailboats to boot! read more

Peter Trout's Tavern and Inn - Gastropubs Near Me - Manset, Maine

I won't knock the food, but the value is pretty atrocious here post-pandemic. I saw an old menu where the fish sandwich was $15 a few years back and now is $38. You're better off finding value elsewhere. read more

Stopped on a slow afternoon at the end of the season. Server was attentive since it was slow. I was blown away by their burger....bun perfectly toasted and the egg fried exactly the way it should be. It was awesome. read more