It's been a while since my last visit to Peter's Pizza, several years, in fact. Ordered a cheese slice the other day. Slice had a slight floury taste to it, still doughy also, like I recalled from years ago. Stiff crust. Being a pizza aficionado, I'd say Peter's Pizza is a slight grade above gas station pizza. It will get you by in a pinch, fill you up, but it's not good pizza. I have to disagree with most of the other reviewers, they need to take ride down to New Haven and sample some decent pizza. C'mon, you live in Connecticut, you should know what quality pizza tastes like ! read more

Peter's Pizza - Cheese slice, at Peter's Pizza in Waterbury, CT. - Pizza Near Me - Waterbury, Connecticut

Classic CT pizza! Look it up CT had some of the first American pizza and this place does that justice. We had simple cheese and pepperoni pies for my sons birthday and they went above and beyond for us. Great guys great pizza and great service. We had a kids birthday at the nearby paintball place and they suggested Pete's. Pouring rain mid session and I called to see if they would seat us. They normally do just take out and delivery but offered to seat the whole party impromptu! What?!?! So awesome, particularly with December rain! Those boys were ready for that hot pizza. Did I mention their pizza is awesome?? Crispy almost 'fried like' crust slightly thicker than thin crust with generous toppings. Highly recommended read more

I asked them if they could make a heart shaped pizza for my boyfriend on Valentine's day. Gentleman who took the order said "no problem!" Great service! The pizza looked awesome and came with generous amount of toppings! It tasted amazing along with the cheesy garlic bread, chicken tenders, and cheesecake! Couldn't have asked for a better place to order with. Delivery man was great in helping with my surprise. You guys are the best, thank you from Bermuda! read more

Peter's Pizza - Heart shaped large meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waterbury, Connecticut

Delicious pizza they also serve lunch and dinner meals! My sons favorite pizza joint ! They do serve the HUGE delicious dinners and have good prices staff is friendly and they had a great waiter/delivery guy he was super kind and very attentive !! Don't have a lot more to say besides... I recommend eating at Peter's Pizza!! And the place is clean as well as the Chef, which for me is very important!! read more

Peter's Pizza - 13.00 medium Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waterbury, Connecticut

See all

Ordered a pizza, delivered, today. Service was good. Pizza was average. Crust: Crispy but bland Cheese: Average to Below Average Toppings: Good Sauce: Poor Did not like the sauce at all. Very over-seasoned. Sorry, but I would not buy again. read more

Just ordered 2 pizzas from here, both cheese (always the safe way to go when ordering pizza from a place you've never been), one thick, one classic. The taste is really good, BUT, we ordered extra cheese on both, and we barely got any cheese at all. Granted, we ordered through Uber Eats for the first time, so maybe Peter's didn't see it, but extra cheese for each large pizza is $3.49, so we're out $7.00 (not to mention all of the deliveries fees etc.). The pizza arrived hot and fast, though, and they really do taste great. Might be back after the pandemic when we can order directly, pick up ourselves, and complain right then and there if they skimp on the cheese! read more

New pizza place located right next to Carmen Anthony's. The facility is clean and has a nice seating area with tables. Pizza was really good. Good quality cheese, tasty sauce, and a nice crust. Owner is super friendly and cool! Give it a try :-) read more

I really like the pizza here. This is my place to order every time. They follow instructions well and food is always fresh and hot. The wings are amazing! read more

I order pizza here virtually once a week it's always great! There are many pizza places in Waterbury and Peter's pizza is by far our favorite. By the way try the sausage bread you definitely won't be disappointed! read more

Just had a burger and fries and these guys are up there with the best burgers in Waterbury. Everything was cooked perfectly!

Delicious. I came across this pizzeria on yelp and decided to try them. I ordered half Philly cheesesteak & a half margarita pie. I'm a visitor from New York but, i wish i lived closer just so i can order from peter's. read more

Good pizza Good atmosphere very pleased with the all around Cleanliness and Nice people What else can you ask for when you don't want to cook Anyone to find a nice place to go here it is go read more

i ordered baked ziti and it was penne with mozzarella. no much ricotta and NO sauce. had a side of garlic bread which was very inexpensive. however, the garlic flavor was kinda gross as well as the "marinara" that came with it. not trying to be a karen i just don't want you guys to be disappointed like me :( read more

Peter's Pizza - Baked Ziti - Pizza Near Me - Waterbury, Connecticut

I personally didn't like the pie at all. I couldn't eat it. Which upsets me cause he's close by, it's nice n clean and their very friendly. But again way way too much cheese and not enough sauce. read more

Got the pizza delivered and it was just average. Nothing special sauce was bland and cheese. Crust not crispy and all needs to be cooked more. Overall really basic. Will go back to my regular pizza place way better. read more

I stopped by once before, back when they first opened and picked up a cheese pizza on my way home one day for my kids (who were still living home at the time, but since moved out!). I didn't get to try it that time, but they seemed to enjoy it. Yesterday it was my god daughters birthday and I wanted to take my family out for dinner. I said let's go to "XXXX" place, and my cousin, who has been to Peter's and ordered delivery from here before suggested Peter's instead. I was open to where ever they suggested. So, at 2 pm, the 8 of us stepped into Peter's and were immediately greeted by the staff. They have tables and a big area for parties, however, this isn't your typical table side service type of place. The process is, you go up to the counter, order and grab a bottled drink from the cooler and they will bring your food out to you. Well, I intended on having pizza, but the menu is so vast that we all decided on other items besides pizza from the menu. I had the turkey club grinder with fries and the rest of my party ordered whatever they wanted. For 9 people to come to a place, enjoy a good meal and have plenty of leftovers to take home for $98 is unheard of! Is only about $10 per person. My aunt is allergic to tomatoes, and the staff made her a special eggplant grinder (without sauce) but with peppers, onions and cheese that she can't stop talking about. My little cousin ordered a meatball and sausage calzone and it was HUGE and stuffed!!! He could only eat half of it! There is great value here at Peter's. You get a lot of quality food for your money. The staff is friendly and very competent and the place is clean as well. We order delivery often from another place in the area, but that is about to change since the other place is just "okay' and a little more pricey, but we have been loyal to the convenience of the delivery service. I will definitely be back! read more

Very underrated place. This place has EXCELLENT pizza and it's a go to for me compared to other pizza places around town. You'll thank me later. read more

Your average hole-in-the-wall pizza place. You'll go in hungry and leave satisfied. If you're in the mood to share a pizza with someone (at home or in the restaurant), Peter's will not disappoint. read more

Outstanding pizza! Florentine was worth all 5 stars. Delivery was prompt and courteous.

It a great local pizzeria with a good dinner menu. The owner is friendly and the pizza is better then their competitors. Also it's the only place where they sell anything close to a zeppole. read more

Stopped in for a quick slice, pizza was good store was clean and the service was excellent. I will be back

I saw this place one day and decided to give it a try. Bought a slice and it tasted great! Crust was delicious,sauce was great and service is fast. The owner and staff are very friendly and great to chat with while waiting for your order. I am a regular now and always enjoy thier pizza. They have a special now for $1 for a slice of cheese! Try it out and enjoy! read more

Best Pizza place in town!! Peter is a complete gentleman and aims high to satisfied all he's customers!!!always ready to make what ever you want and how you want it. Just ask! Food is absolutely delicious. read more

If you're looking for a good time with some low priced high quality pizza/food, definitely come here! Where do I even start? Came down with a few friends last week, it was late at night and we had no expectations, just wanted some pizza. And as soon as we walked in, I felt at home. We sat down and was greeted with a smile. The food was fast and delicious. The service was probably the best i've seen, everybody was so patient and kind. We were outstandingly pleased. As we finished, we didn't feel rushed to pay and leave. We sat around for a little while longer. But as conversations came to an end, we paid and left a generous tip. As we were walking out I turned and said "Thank you." and got a "Come again soon!". You bet, this is my new favorite hang out spot. 100% check it out if you happen to drive by with a hungry stomach. read more

Peter makes awesome pizza. I order there all the time and they are consistent with the quality of the food as well as the friendly way they treat their customers. read more

One of the best pizza spots in Waterbury! Was playing paintball at Extreme Paintball up the street and as always when I'm done I have to call in a pizza for me and my crew. read more

This is a Good place to go for a wonderful pizza! They also have other terrific foods that I have yet to try. The people there are very nice and helpful to all of your needs. read more

Cheese pizza and meatball grinders were okay. Have had better from the area. The people, probably oqnera, are always welcoming and friendly.

Horrible restaurant with even more horrible service. The pizza has always been mediocre but at least it used to get the delivered. They took my payment and never delivered the pizza. When called to respectfully complain, they treated me in very disrespectful matter . Will never go back there read more

Pizza was really good, the sauce wasn't too sweet which I always see as a downside to a pizza. We got a bacon and roasted red pepper and the toppings were plentiful, no skimping at all. Unlike the other review, I prefer the bacon in large pieces, I like to see how much I am getting. The really big find in this place for us was the WINGS!!! My husband and I were searching for the longest time for a place that serves the hot wings the way we like them. No breading and done saucy, we do not like the hot wings that are made hot using spices, we much prefer wings that have the "Red Hot" type sauce smothered on and these fit the bill nicely! The wings were also very meaty and the blue cheese dressing was not a packet of Ken's salad dressing, it actually was GREAT blue cheese served on the side in a to-go container. We will definitely be back because of the wings and as a result we will continue to get the pizza there too! read more

I recently moved to waterbury and wasn't sure where to get pizza. I was going thru this app (yelp) and was strolling thru the pics and saw the one on Peter's Pizza site. It looked wonderful!! So, I ordered it and it is now in my top five best pizzas I've had. read more