Delicious! Large portions and absolutely wonderful! Server Annie was terrific and gave recommendations! The owner even came out and asked how our food tasted which was a lovely addition! read more

Petos - This was a HUGE portion of Pastitios!! We brought half home and had amazing leftovers the next day! - Greek Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Authentic Greek restaurant- don't sleep on how delicious this food tastes! We ordered a hefty take out order bc I like to have the options for the reviews I write. Walking in, the whole store has been revamped from the dark interior of Italian to the bright white and blue of the Greek flags! Speaking with Patricia and the family, this is the best and authentic Greek food I've tasted in Carmel. My salad was ridiculously large with sizable options for the ingredients! A whole block of seasoned feta w the richest piece of chicken added! The spanikopita is in casserole style (authentic) - if you're eating the triangles, that's incorrect. Had the falafel and the lentil soup!!! The best lentil soup ever!!! Hope I get a punch card for how often I plan to eat here! read more

See all

I ordered takeout and came home with no Tzatziki Sauce on either the Lamb Gryo or Flalfel. It was okay, not great. Better options on the same street for less $. I really wanted to LOVE this place, but forgot Tzatziki sauce on Gryos!? I don't know. Staff very friendly, Cool ambiance! Food was okay. May give it another try, but very disappointed. read more

We were in town visiting relatives and plan to make dinner at this gem a holiday tradition from now on. We descended on Petos on a winter night shortly before they closed, yet the staff could not have been more gracious. Along with kind service and an ambiance boosted by classic Christmas carols, the food was excellent--the best Greek cuisine we've had outside of Greece itself (with generous portions to boot). Our family shared the maroulousalata, taramosalata, hummus, saganaki (Opa!), pastitsio, lamb gyros, and Santorini pasta, all of which we recommend--especially the pastitsio, which struck a perfect balance of seasonings. We found the wine selection well curated as well. Don't sleep on Petos. read more

TERRIBLE service. Do not recommend!!!! Wait staff would rather sit around talking than waiting on tables.

The octopus was amazing, all the food was incredible. The staff were friendly and accommodating. I love the Greco-Egyptian decor, it's unique and beachy. Love this place! read more

First time at Petos very quaint restaurant. Love the decor felt like your transport to Greece. The food was delicious. Service made a memorable experience for my family and I. It was a great Friday night dinner location and will need to go again soon. read more

I usually don't post reviews, but I will this time. The food was delicious even if it took longer," according to the waiter." honestly, I was enjoying my feta cheese and the wine I did not notice was delayed. The food was incredible. I ate mousaka. Wow, the portion was significant enough, and I ate it all. The flavors were terrific. I was asked multiple times about the service, making me feel comfortable. Even though it was busy, I did not feel crowded. It's well worth the money. read more

Great place to dine. Make a reservation. We stopped in the week before and they were not taking walk-in guests. So we made a reservation for the next week, and was not sorry. Very attentive wait staff. The Tirokafteri...very good! Creamy, salty, a little spicy...great with warm pita bread. My husband had Lamb Gyro. That came with rice, and flavorful Greek Vegetables. Lamb was tender, and well seasoned. I had Pork Souvlaki. Two skewers of tender pork, with rice and Greek Vegetables. We had plenty to eat, and boxed up our entrees, so we could have dessert. I have Bougatsa, a Phyllo dough with a custard filling, reminded me of a Greek inspired Sugar Cream Pie. My husband had the Baklava Cheesecake. Great experience...we will be back! read more

See all

We had been hoping to try this place for lunch for a while now but they seemed to be a dinner only service. However recently we found out that they were open for short lunch service as well. A friend and I went for lunch and the decor inside is very nice - greek music playing, white walls and airy kinda decor. Our server was polite and quick on her feet. I ordered the lavash gyro wrap with fries and let me say that I was very happy to see lavash being offered. Pita feels too heavy at times. Food came out at a reasonable time and it was a pretty good wrap - good meat to veggies to sauce ratio. The fries were oh so good! Well salted and crispy. My only comment would be the gyro meat was bit under-salted. I am aware that salt is a personal preference, however if one was to argue that the meat was perfectly salted, then the fries were over salted. But to my taste, fries were well seasoned and perfect and meat could have used a bit more salt. My friend enjoyed his falafel meal as well. We hope to be back to try other menu items. The pricing however was a bit on the higher side. read more

Had lunch today with my friend-- everything was delicious. Started out with some yummy white wine-- chilled expertly-- along with some hummus-- so tasty-- velvety smooth. Friend had the Greek salad and I had the falafel pita sandwich. We were both very pleased with our selections. The food is incredibly fresh and authentic Greek cuisine. Our server Michael was fabulous! Owner very kindly gifted us with a delicious serving of baklava-- which I ate when I arrived home-- heavenly!! read more

Great service. I had the Filet Mignon kabobs-it was large enough to share and deliciously tender. I also recommend the Petos platter for an appetizer. This is the best restaurant for authentic Greek food. Baklava for dessert is a must! read more

Petos - Filet Mignon Kebab - Greek Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

This place is incredible . We have always talked about stopping in and finally gave it a try tonight. For us it was a 5 star experience. The menu is very large so we decided to share a few items to get a good variety. We started with a large Greek salad and it was the best I've ever had, even from someone that grew up in Detroit with plenty of Greek coney islands nearby. I could have drank the dressing with a straw. We then ordered pita bread which is perfectly seasoned and made to order. We finish our dinner with calamari and Greek fries (do not skip these fries!!). Each dish somehow was even better than the last. And I want to especially call out the service. The owner check on us twice and our waiter was incredibly helpful and seemed so happy to work there. We will definitely add this to our rotation and bring guests when they visit. read more

Loved the service and atmosphere here. The chef/owner visited with us to check on food and service. Food was excellent!

I'm from Chicago, and I haven't tasted Greek food -like my friends Yaya cooked or the corner family restaurant - until I walked into Petos. This was their first location in Castleton and - even without the fantastic new location - I was in food heaven. Mom, dad and the kids were working that night - such great people! I ordered enough for four because I couldn't decide. Should have ordered more. So good - all of it! Just go, you won't be sorry. read more

Door dash tonight a new place for us. Tried hummus, chocolate baklava, moussaka, shrimp pita. All were delicious! Will try in person next time. read more

So glad we finally tried Petos, amazing! We've lived in Carmel for 15 yrs & have tried every supposed Greek restaurant throughout Indy & all have been only "fine" until now. We had given up trying a few years but kept hearing great things about Petos so finally decided to give it a try for lunch today, so happy we did. We have a new favorite restaurant. Started with Meltizanosalata & WOW! So fresh & the pita alone is worthy of its own 5 stars. The pita around town has always had a store-bought quality & was disappointing. This was so tender & chewy, not dry or greasy. Though we could have eaten the eggplant alone with a spoon, this pita was the perfect compliment. We both ordered the lamb gyros with fries - the serving size is generous! More of that delicious pita overflowing with fresh, tender lamb slices & complimented with lettuce, tomato & just enough flavorful tzatziki plus an extra ramekin of tzatziki on the side which was also wonderful with the fresh, crispy & perfectly seasoned fries. Can't wait to go back & try more menu items. What a local gem read more

We had a very disappointing experience for lunch today. Waited an hour for food, they ran out of Coke, food was not hot except Spanakopita was delicious. Meat was luke warm. Ordered gyros on Pita and they made it as a wrap and tried to get us to accept it. Did not. Gyro drowning in sauce. The most shocking thing is we ordered some pastries (12) from the bakery and when I went to pay, it was $67!!! I should have declined but I am still in shock. Too many really good Greek Restaurants that have real ambiance. Save your money, your time, and your pallet! read more

Petos - Greek Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Restaurant has a friendly staff and nice venue. It is not a loud place so we had the ability to talk and eat the entire evening. We got the saganaki, moussaka, and souvlaki. All food was 5/5. Flaming Cheese (Saganaki) was great. My wife got the chicken Souvlaki which are kebabs essentially. I got the Moussaka which is a Greek lasagna with beef and eggplant. We loved everything and the price was on par with a standard evening out in Carmel ($20-30/person) We will return. read more

This is THE GREEK RESTAURANT in Carmel. The Pasticcio is outrageously delicious and the lamb souvlaki was fantastic. A real, family owned restaurant with Mom and Dad in the kitchen. Opa! read more

Excellent Greek food. Saganaki as an appetizer was great - fresh pitas with some seasoning on it to eat the Saganaki with. Avgolemono soup was very hearty. Pastitsio also excellent - large serving. read more

Delicious food. The Greek salad is authentic, the chicken (kotopoulo) is very good - well seasoned and extremely tasty. I am a first generation Greek, and going to this restaurant almost made me emotional. Reminded me so much of Greece, from the authentic music to the blue and white everywhere to the Mythos beer and real Saganaki flaming cheese. It might be in Carmel, but it could be in Athens too. You can tell all of the food is homemade and mindfully prepared. The tzatziki was delicious - obviously freshly made. The lemon potatoes that came with the kotopoulo are a Greek classic and rivaled my aunt's potatoes (hope she never reads this! Sorry Theia!) So delicious. I was just shocked at the flavors. It's rare you find a place that REALLY knows it's Greek food. A yiayia (grandmother) is cooking back there and she knows what she's doing. This place deserves a 5 star overall rating. Must try it. read more

Ordered the filet, cooked to perfection, the sides and appetizers just as great (and they do matter as much, if not more than the meat itself). The service from hostess and server was excellent. I will say it did take longer than normal to receive the food but, the bottle of wine kept us busy so it was fine. Adorable set up, love that it's intimate. Would return, would recommend. read more

Loved our food; service was outstanding; we'll be back! Menu was interesting--there were several things we wanted to try!

The menus were photo copies, the food was underwhelming, I had the mixed grill which consisted of chicken, pork and shrimp, the pork and chicken were over cooked and dry. The wife had the gyro sandwich and was not impressed. There are a lot better Greek places in the neighborhood. A one and done. read more

Loyal customers treated to a novice server engineering a disaster of a meal. Its just so much its hard to figure out where to start. Ruined our meal even ordered greek salad which never was delivered, and the kid added it to the bill. Just one misstep after another. . .life is too short to stress out over a meal, yet you stress because its so outrageous its unavoidable. Won't prolly ever return. read more

Petos - Mediterranean Sea Bass and roasted potatoes - Greek Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Family of 4 randomly walked in on a Friday night at 6:00. No expectations. simply wanting to try something new. We loved it! We were seated quickly, wine was great, food was good, server was super accommodating to my requests/queries around gluten free options. We got saganaki, dolmades, lemon rice soup, roast chicken, and a couple other things. We'll definitely be back to try more. read more

This place is the absolute best Mediterranean that we have ever had! We suggest the chicken kabobs (will try lamb next time) and grape leaves! Staff was really great, offered us water and a table while we waited for take-out. read more

The food was delicious. We definitely will be coming back. We probably will wait until they get the kinks. Worked out regarding organization. You can tell they had just opened up due to timing of meals and a tad bit of confusion with orders. We got our appetizers and immediately our dinner came out when we had just started eating our appetizers. Also we ordered a specific side and they brought out the wrong side twice then still left the wrong side dish. Service was great though overall. read more

Petos - Trio dip platter - Greek Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

This is my new go to Greek restaurant in Carmel. The food was just absolutely fantastic. Gyro plate is old to for two to share. The staff is pretty young and it shows but the rest of the experience more than makes up for that. read more

Cute family owned place. On a slow Saturday lunch we were greeted promptly and warmly. The young waiter who took care of us had a great sense of humor and did a good job, checking on us as needed but not too obtrusively. Chicken gyro was very good as was the falafel and flaming cheese (literally presented tableside while on fire). Kid had the Shawarma and fries and enjoyed it. We didn't have room for dessert, but their homemade pastries & sweets looked great. Will definitely be back. read more

Hostess sat me down and waited 15 minutes before anyone even acknowledged I was there, while the restaurant was not very busy. Awful service, limited menu, overpriced. Please go somewhere else. read more

We really wanted to like the restaurant. The restaurant lost our "ticket" in the kitchen. After an hour of waiting with two small children (who were starving) we asked where our food was and was told it would be right out. Five minutes later the waiter came back and said they lost our ticket. They didn't even try to repair the mistake. We ended up leaving because it was almost my kids' bedtime and asked for the check. They charged us the full amount for the drinks and appetizer. We will not be back. read more

A delightful lunch experience provided by a charming staff! The Shrimp Saganaki was the best shrimp dish I've ever had. The hours and the phone number listed on a couple of sites seem to be incorrect. read more

See all

I enjoyed the lemon soup and the baklava dessert was delicious!! I was able to be seated right away. The service is always great!

Great food and wonderful service!! Authentic Greek restaurant won't disappoint! We will be returning soon!

First time at this restaurant. The weight staff was friendly, quick to meet our requests. Our food arrived but not all at the same time and we waited for a number of minutes for our friends to get their food before we could all start eating together. For a Wednesday evening the restaurant was not crowded, but the noise level was very high and we had trouble hearing each other talk. There were 6 of us so sitting at a long table instead of a round table so that was part of the problem. Also, the menu item prices seemed higher than other Greek/Middle East restaurants in the area. However, we will go back now that we know what to expect. read more

Went to dinner with my family, including 2 toddlers. We had the saganaki (delicious!), chicken souvlaki with roasted vegetables, a pasta dish, and the greek burger. The greek burger definitely stood out and was so delicious! The rest of the food was fine but didn't stand out. I was disappointed in the roasted vegetables l, as they were primarily green beans, seemingly from a can with some seasonings. The service was fantastic and everyone was very friendly and helpful! It was not a very easy dining experience with two toddlers, as they do not have a kids menu or even to go cups for kids drinks. read more

We decided to serve Greek food for a family birthday celebration as we have eaten both lunch and dinner at this location before. We chose Peto's as we love the food and thought our family would too, also the restaurant is close to where we live. The owner went above and beyond to work with us in selecting and preparing the foods. A few days later we got the order and laid the selections out on our kitchen/dining area counter tops: appetizers, main course platters and desert. It looked marvelous and our family helped themselves. They loved the new tastes, textures and choices of this delicious assortment of Greek foods. Many thanks to you Peto's for creating such a unique and enjoyable meal for our family celebration. read more

The food here is absolutely incredible!! I have been to many different greek and Mediterranean restaurants all across the country and never have I ever tasted better Greek cuisine. At most Greek restaurants I am not a fan of tzatziki nor gyros but at Petos I fell absolutely in love with both! The saganaki, in my opinion is one of the best items on the menu. The servers ignite the cheese with fire and gets the whole place excited with every saganaki that has been ordered (But pretty much everything I've tried is incredible). The customer service is incredible, the servers work so hard to ensure an amazing experience as does the family that owns the restaurant. The ambiance is very welcoming and friendly and every time I go, I always want to come back!! P.s. the cheesecake baklava and the dark chocolate baklava is absolutely amazing!! read more