So not order from these idiots they can't even make sure they the right salad out of a fridge. When did a caesar salad come with boiled eggs and balsamic dressing. I thought I would give them one more chance and boy how wrong was that decision. read more

A very tasty Italian beef sandwich but very small for $10 for just the sandwich. The 12//9/2022 afternoon manager needs to crack down on a pair of employees for being very loud and obscene while arguing with each other in front of several customers. read more

Food is good here we have tried the sandwiches as well as the soups. Only complaint I have is sandwiches are light on veggies with a higher price compared to other places next time I will order extra otherwise I love this place read more

Pizza was terrible in presentation; called to inform them and the manager was very professional and handled the situation in an excellent manner. The 2nd Pizza arrived and it was worst than the first so...I'll just stick to sandwhiches from now on. Great Customer Service...5-star....Sandwich was perfect....you be the judge read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - PizzaGate - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

See all

While on a work trip, I was looking for something to be delivered to my hotel for dinner and Pickleman's fit the bill. The online ordering website is easy to use and allows you to fully customize your sandwich. I ordered around 4:40pm and the sandwich was delivered less than 30 minutes into the 45 minute delivery window. The sandwich was still warm and tasty! I would order from Pickleman's again when I need dinner delivered in Columbia. read more

After reading a few reviews I decided to try it. I ordered online--it was a breeze. When we picked up the staff was friendly. Our sandwiches were on the small side but incredible flavor. The bread was soft, warm and crispy all at the same time! This place was so good we are getting an order to go to have a great lunch on the road. read more

Amazing. Every time I have ordered or been to this place my food has been immaculate.

Pretty good. A little pricey but good flavors overall. Chicken Baja soup was pretty good. They give you a piece of bread with certain menu items too. read more

I wish I had a nicer review to write, since the sandwiches are pretty darn tasty. But unfortunately, I had a terrible customer service experience at this Pickleman's location. I ordered food online for pickup around 1:30 pm. I didn't have the sandwiches in hand until nearly 2:45. The only reason I'm giving two stars instead of one is because if the woman I believe is the manager. I think her name was Stephanie. When she realized the situation she apologized and refunded my money, and I hadn't asked her to. I've worked in the food service industry so believe me, I know shit happens. When I walked in to the store, they were dealing with a big rush of customers. I waited a while to complain because again, I've been there. There's nothing worse than people who scream in your face because of a minor mistake. First, the man at the cashier suggested I had the wrong location and hadn't placed my order. At this point, i had already paid and had been waiting for more than 15 minutes. I finally had to show him my receipt to prove it. That's when Stephanie intervened and refunded my money. But after that, there was no sense of urgency. It took another 15-20 minutes to fill my order. I can tell they were slow because the manager went in the back for a while, came back out and looked surprised to still see me there. She then scolded the others and moved things along. I appreciate her actions, but the whole situation was frustrating. I ordered a turkey bacon with no tomatoes and my friend ordered an Italian sub. The Italian sub was fine, but my sandwich had tomatoes and no bacon. That said, both sandwiches were yummy, with high quality ingredients and especially delicious bread. Both cost $6.29, which seemed fairly affordable for what you're getting. But I'll never visit the Broadway location again. read more

I love the southwest salad. The ingredients are always fresh. The Chipotle Ranch dressing with the combination of veggies will awaken your taste buds. Most important to me is great customer service. Everyone at the Creve Coeur location are extremely nice. I've never received bad service. During this time (Covid-19) there customer service Rocks! Thank you all! Stay safe and keep up the great work. read more

Pickleman's has great wraps, pizza, and salads. I especially love that I can get a lettuce wrap since I enjoy Keto. The chicken asiago pizza is incredible and the soups are delicious as well. Its a great place to eat and the whole family will find something they like on the menu. I wold caution that they actually charge you an extra 99 cents for the lettuce bun which I don't understand since it costs nothing. That part I do not like at all. Other than that its good eats in Columbia. read more

Love this place I always try to stop at least once to get a sandwich there when in Columbia the Italian beef sandwich is delicious they have prompt delivery people food is pricey but definitely worth it and their soup is awesome too read more

I USED to love this place... especially considering Columbia's lack of delivery options. but after several botched orders we finally had enough with this delivery experience from hell: we ordered our usual, the asiago chicken salad and a plain sandwich (no lettuce, etc. just bread, cheese, meat and honey mustard). after an hour (yes, we waited a full hour before calling to check on the order's status), we called to see where our order was. we were assured that our driver was on his way. twenty minutes or so later, he shows up, minus the salad. he takes the money for the entire order and says he'll be back with the salad. he says he can't return if he doesn't have the money. it seemed a little fishy to me, but i was hungry. then another 25 minutes pass, no delivery guy. my partner checked his sandwich to discover that it was made incorrectly. he calls the restaurant, is put on hold for a total of 18 minutes (several people picked up the line, but none had answers, they just told him to hold). finally i told him to hang up. then i took the sandwich to the store where two tables of four were currently eating. i also noticed that the phone was not ringing off the hook as one might expect after waiting more than an hour for an incorrect partial order. no manager was to be found, but i was greeted by an extremely rude employee who wasn't in any hurry to rectify the situation. i requested a refund which he hemmed and hawed over before opening the register (even though i still have no food to show for this debacle). i left the restaurant after informing the staff on duty that i would not be back, despite having been a loyal customer since the week they opened. i said perhaps they should work on their customer service but their dumbfounded response tells me they probably haven't. after this two-hour customer service nightmare, we drove to ingredient on ninth street where we enjoyed a delicious, properly-made meal in a timely fashion. read more

I go to Picklemans every week I love the sandwiches. For 3 weeks their coke machine has been down. I really like my coke zero with my sandwich. I will call next week and if down I will go somewhere else. Shouldn't take 3 weeks.... this is Picklemans off Oak Kansas city mo....... read more

I loved Pickleman's when I was a student and still do! I was traveling through Columbia and got hungry but wanted something quick and relatively healthy & Pickleman's immediately came to mind. I had the buffalo chicken on wheat and half a pickle and it hit the spot and gave me enough sustenance to continue traveling :) For a sub shop, it definitely has an upgraded vibe in comparison to other places. It's clean, has a friendly staff, quick and is priced well. I don't thnk I could ask for much more. read more

There are three locations in Columbia and even though I try to eat/shop/entertain at local establishments instead of franchises, I must say Pickleman's is a good sandwich shop and they kind of have a local feel. Their downtown location is always clean, the customer service is top notch and they are pretty affordable. If you are thinking about jimmy johns, which wich or subway, think again. They less expensive than sub shop, though if you are going for quality subs and ingredients over price I would definitely recommend looking into SubShop instead. The Asiago Chicken sandwich is phenomenal and their pizzas are actually really good too. Did I mention that they deliver? Online ordering for delivery or carryout is quick and easy and I've never regretted it. So if you are in need of quick, tasty options go here. read more

Stopped here while passing through on a road trip and ordered a pizza. It took kind of long but the nice boy behind the counter said it was because he dropped it and took 50% off, so no big deal. The problem is that this was not pizza, but crackers. If you are a native Missourian you probably won't notice that the pizza is, in fact, crackers but as someone from NJ I can tell you that it is definitely crackers. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - These are crackers. - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

Missy that works here is the absolute best. An actual angel! And the rest of the staff is amazing as well I've never had a bad experience here and my sandwich is always perfect! read more

Pickleman's tomato soup is to die for. I always get it when I eat there and the sandwiches are very good quality. I avoid eating here too much, however, because it is costly compared to other sub shops in town. I did have one bad delivery experience where I feel they totally overcharged me and thus, I will never order delivery from them again because of it. I ordered a sandwich and soup. I dunno how it happened but when all was said and done I had to pay $18 total including tip for a tiny sandwich and a soup to be delivered about four blocks (I couldn't leave work otherwise, I would have drove there myself). I remember I ordered delivery once before and yes it was expensive but not as horrible as that. read more

I am giving this establishment a 4 star review because of my last experience with them. If my next visit/delivery goes well I will update the rating. The food here is always great. The last time our office ordered I received a half order of salad instead of the whole. The half order was not impressive at all as far as size goes, we got a chuckle out if it. It was the avo-cobb salad, pretty tasty overall. I think it would be better with a blue cheese though. The dressing was awesome. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

Amazing service as always! Delivery driver was on time and had great customer service. Will be returning.

Just about everything's great here! More often than not I get the Turkey sandwich on wheat. I love that they toast all their sandwiches. The meat, bread and toppings always taste very fresh. Turkey might sound boring, but it's especially good when I get the Tomato Basil Bisque and dip my sandwich in it. I'v also tried the Italian Chop and Garden Chop salads. They are both very generous portions, and excellent salads. Definitely can be eaten as a meal. The Asiago Chicken Pizza is AMAZING! Probably not the healthiest item on the menu, but it's very delicious. I'm pretty sure it's the asiago caesar dressing that makes it so wonderful. They also have sandwiches and salads that feature the dressing, but I haven't tried those items. Added bonus is that they deliver. Also, bonus points for being open late, though that feature is often overshadowed by El Rancho's location a block away... read more

Favorite sub place in town! Good food for a good price and they deliver. My work lunch go-to place.

Canceled our order 30 minutes after ordering annoying af could've ordered somewhere else

We stopped in on our way through Columbia and loved being able to experience a bit of the student life at Pickleman's. Lots of local college students eat here and work here. We had an AvoCobb salad and a Pick 2 salad/soup (tomatoe basil)...very good although I had to remind them about my croutons. Cozy ambience, friendly service, good food, fair prices...perfect alternative to soulless chain fast food!! (and don't forget to check in with the Yelp app and get a free cookie!) read more

Walked in with 10 minutes left until they closed and manager refused to serve me. Very upsetting went home hungry and upset. Food is pretty good to be honest but the portion sizes are very small. Should probably go to jersey mikes instead. read more

Super overrated the sandwiches are good but very overpriced and way too small. If you're actually hungry you're gonna need at least two or three sandwiches. read more

Best sandwich shop in town! As a vegetarian, it's hard to find a sandwich that has enough veggies to fill me up, but the veggie sub here did the trick. I ordered online then picked it up at the restaurant. It's cheaper and more delicious than Jimmy John's, no doubt. You have to look no further than comparing the bread to realize that Pickleman's ingredients are fresh and of better quality than other sandwich shops in town. I also appreciate that their menu has pizza, salads, and soups. read more

I came to pickleman at 1:19am. They were closed. They were supposed to be open till 2am. I wanted an Italian club and they were not there. Bogus. read more

This place was highly recommended to me by many people, and it did not disappoint! The sandwiches were great! I had the veggie sandwich-- yum very fresh! My boyfriend had the meatball sub and didn't stop talking about it our whole trip! We also had the broccoli cheese soup-- also yum! My son had the kids meal turkey and cheese sandwich-- for a picky guy he sure did like it! read more

This is my favorite sandwich shop in town. Their salads are excellent, and their sandwiches are warm and toasty. However, their delivery is atrocious. I ordered one salad for my lunch at 12:15 today. It is now 1:45 and I still don't have the order, even though the store told me that it was out for delivery 15 minutes ago. This is unacceptable in the summer when there are many fewer people in this college town. read more

Great little sandwich shop! Fast, really good options, and an easy, local option for a sub.

Owner's son is totally rude and ruined my experience here. I do not recommend this food it is serve cold just like the son's heart!

I ordered a turkey sandwich with cheese only, a drink and a cookie and with deliver and tip my order was $15. I wouldn't normally be bothered by the price except for my sandwich had one piece of turkey on it. So I paid for a bread sandwich. The sandwich I got didn't look anything like the pictures posted on their site. So for the price I feel like they can do better. read more

Wow what a sandwich shop. I went here super late and the staff was very friendly even at the hour, I ordered The Bug Tuna, and got it my way, veggies oil vinaigrette plus spicy gardinaire and oregano. Prepared by a great and friendly staff. What an amazing sandwich. I will have to come back and try something else. Oh by the way there chocolate chip cookies are better than hot box. And it was free for a check in. I may be back just for them! read more

This is one of my two favorite sub shops - it is consistently tasty and worth every bite. Make sure to add one of their huge homemade pickles on the side for a complete meal! I could eat here for almost every lunch due to everything on the menu being amazing and quite different from each other. Everyone I have taken here has not been disappointed and has continued to come back for more. read more

I don't really get the appeal of this place! It is just a pretty basic sandwich shop, yet the locals seem to go bananas for it. Jimmy Johns is just as good, and a better value! read more

I truly like their food and the Baja Chicken soup is really, really good. The sandwiches are small and I feel like they are pretty pricey for what you get. For a small sandwich 1/2, soup and drink is over $11.00. I don't mind that if I am full when finished eating, but I'm not. Quality of food is great, price is not. I rarely go there anymore even though it's like a block from work due to the price. read more

Very good toasted sandwiches- don't like the veggie version as much a Jimmy John's, however. Others liked their toasted sandwiches as much or more than other chains. Endless beverage options, including super sweet bottles of lemonade. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Rachael and Katherine - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

I've generally been very happy with the service and quality of food I've received at Pickleman's. Besides toasted sandwiches, they also have salads and Pizza. Staff has always been friendly and responsive at the Fairview location. I hit the Southside location on a bad day once when the sole person on duty was too busy to even look up and acknowledge me. After 5 minutes or so, I walked out in a snit. But, all said and done, I have to recommend this restaurant. The only drawback is price. I've never paid less than $10.00. My favorite is #11 on the menu. It's called the Italian Deli and I like it with hot peppers. Once I asked for more peppers because my sandwich seemed a little bland and was told "We put peppers on your sandwich." But they DID finally give me a few more peppers to spice my sandwich up. Give it a try, if you've never been there! read more