Killed that flight--coconut cream pie was creamy and smooth with subtly layered depth of flavor!! Mississippi mud is a fudge pie with ice cream! Very RICH! And the slice on the end is buttermilk with pecan!! Service was great! And the coffee was delicious!! Definitely a great quaint place for coffee, light bites, or a dessert!! read more

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. - Bakeries Near Me - Conroe, Texas

See all

I stopped by today and got a piece of Coconut Crème to go. The pie was slightly spoiled with a sour taste. Having eaten this pie version for decades, I'm confident that in fact, the slice I got was dated and just not fresh. Always be careful especially with any desert with dairy! read more

What's better than one slice of pie? How about 3. The pie flight is the way to go. Had the bumbleberry (4 different berries), chocolate truffle, and the classic coconut cream. The bumbleberry was served warm with a scoop of ice cream. The tartness of the pie paired nicely with the ice cream. The truffle pie was also served warm with ice cream. The truffle pie has a silky texture. Then there was the classic coconut cream. Out of the three this was my favorite. Lots of coconut and the perfect amount it meringue. If you don't know what flavor of pie to get the flight is the way to go. They will give you a to go box, The waitress was very attentive and friendly. read more

My son and I visited Pie in the Sky for breakfast. We were warmly greeted and offered beverages. Service throughout was on point. I ordered the market skillet which was excellent. Everything was seasoned perfectly, the eggs were just right (not dry), and the mix of veggies filled the skillet. I had a croissant with it and it was beautifully charred. My son had the lone star platter with pancakes, eggs and bacon. He said the pancakes were light, fluffy and delicious, bacon was cooked perfectly and the eggs well seasoned. They have a display of homemade pies and we took home a chocolate truffle pie for later. Absolutely excellent experience and food. read more

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. - There's an outside eating area too. - Bakeries Near Me - Conroe, Texas

See all

I can't believe this!!!!!!!!!!!!! I should know better. I won't be back. Exactly 1 month ago today I ordered a salad and soup. When I got back to work there was no salad dressing. (Yes I should have looked) Now, today, I ordered an Apple, Pecan salad. When I picked it up I looked to make sure there was dressing (focusing on the dressing) and there was. I get back to work and open the salad, put the dressing on it and noticed it didn't look right....THERE WERE NO APPLES AT ALL ON IT!!!!! WHAT GIVES PIE IN THE SKY??? Are yall in that much of a hurry you can't get it right. I feel like I'm always on here complaining about PIe in The Sky. This will be my last complaint read more

I've never had chicken pot pie and French toast on the same table, but a four hour drive can change a lot about a person. Everyone I spoke to looked legitimately happy to do so and this trend continued throughout service. Good vibes, eclectic styling, and good food! Started my brunch with a sweet and savory dirty chai and it was the way to go. I haven't had a chicken pot pie since Clinton was in office, and the nostalgia was immediate. This was something a human being created with effort and joy, which comes through in every buttery, flaky bite. The French toast was just was fabulous! read more

See all

It's been a couple of years since I have been so my wife and I decided to try it again. Chicken pot pie was meh. Very little flavor. Need to consult Cheddars on how to make these. The pies were way off. Placing a few trails of drizzle looks awesome but does nothing to add flavor to the pie. We had the coconut crème and the key lime. The crust was not fresh on either and was more soggy than crisp. Ditch the whipped crème as it adds great visual but is tasteless. Reminded me of something I remember called Pastry Pride. You might do well to add a real crème topping on the pie before serving. It appears that P in the S is becoming another restaurant that is living on their past and not keeping their standards up to par. No reason to revisit anytime soon. read more

Heard from a neighbor that Pie in the Sky was a good place for lunch so last week we stopped by to give them a try and have an early lunch. The inside of Pie in the Sky was nice, relaxing and reminded me of a Panera or a Starbucks type of atmosphere. We took a look at the board to figure out what we wanted to try. It wasn't terribly busy at the time we stopped in, but one of the first things we noticed was that the staff was not terribly friendly or helpful toward us or anyone else. My wife decided on the Pulled Pork Sandwich and I went with the Cuban Sandwich. We picked a table to sit at and in a short while our meals were brought out. Both sandwiches were presented well and tasted even better. We really enjoyed our food but were too full for any dessert. We really wanted to try out the delicious looking pies they had to offer, so we got something to go and had it after dinner. I had a slice of Chocolate Truffle Pie and my wife had the Peach Cobbler. Even several hours later, both pieces of pie were still delicious and worth going back for. Next time we are out and about, we will consider stopping by for a nice breakfast early lunch or even a just a piece of wonderful pie and hopefully the staff will be a bit more friendly toward its customers. read more

Not a fan. The key lime pie was different from what I'm used to but it was good. The cherry pie wasn't good at all it had little if any cherry taste at all. read more

Summary: can't believe I haven't been here more yet. Food: I have only been here for pies, so I can't say very much about the rest of the food. Service: I would say this plays feels very much like a homey feel and very relaxed. The service reflects that and is more chill versus in your face and that totally works for me Ambience: it's basically a big room, but there are some spaces that make it feel a little bit more cozy. However, the decorations are pretty cute with a bunch of doors on the ceiling. To be honest, conroe doesn't have very many cute places, so it's really nice to have a cute place right off the beaten path (336) Value: again, i've only been here for pies, but I do think the quality of them is pretty darn good and the prices are decent. Tea is two fifty and lattes, I believe start around three fifty. Cake pops are I think 3. Parking: this has its own lot, so there's no issues with parking. It also has a space for quick pickups. read more

Re-discover Pie in the Sky. Not just for pies, banana bread and sweets but an excellent place for breakfast and lunch. You get a lot for the money. Friendly service and great foods. Breakfast tacos were great. Their bacon is impossible to beat. Eat and take a pie home. read more

Remodel looks great! Place is really nice and bright now, food is still great as usual and portions are still large. Will definitely be back read more

Mississippi Mud Pie - looking for something chocolaty, gooey, sweet- this is it. Served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Perfect. Service was friendly and attentive without being intrusive. Breakfast tacos: do NOT be fooled like I was due to the price. ~$13 gives you 3 normal size tortillas filled to the bream with filing of your choice. I had to pack 2 to go! read more

Was referred to come here. Don't! Not worth the price ! Ruined Christmas Eve until we went to HEB to save the holiday. The pecan pie was watery as seen in the video posted. read more

How I'm able to resist living in Conroe just for the pie: because it's 100F every day except between Thanksgiving and New Years! Service is just what you expect: Southern Hospitality. Brace yourself if you're one of the many LA or NYC transplants to Greater Houston! Dog Friendly outdoor seating has nice informal ambiance. Not a Parisian Cafe, but not Pie's fault! read more

See all

Great place for breakfast/brunch, good coffee. Love the place, food has been so good that I haven't got to eat the pie yet. lol. Servers are attentive even though they were pretty busy. I like the older look that they are going for, more like a southern charm kind of place, but still clean and comfortable. read more

ruined the Christmas Eve Desserts ! Coconut cream pie was $25 save your money! it was runny water not even like pudding ! horrible taste! thought the Pecan Pie might be better ...NOT .. runny just like water as well! THANK GOD for HEB !! they have great pies and Save $$$$ read more

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. - Runny Pie ! - Bakeries Near Me - Conroe, Texas

See all

Amazing food and good service. The pies are obviously the best part! Lots of seating but it can get quite loud on the inside.

1/19/26-i've been wanting to come here for a while. I'm glad I got that out of my system. Very disappointing. We waited quite a while for our drinks. Never did offer a refill on coffee. My husband's pancakes were good. I got a chicken salad sandwich on a croissant. The chicken salad was shredded chicken with very little chopped up grapes, what I think was mayonnaise, and what was supposed to be "fresh avocado", was mashed up avocado stretched with something added to it making it loose. I thought it was going to be slices of avocado. I should have asked. No nuts were in it, no celery. There was some type of lettuce. It could've been a lot better. Again, I should have asked. The fries were very good. Bumbleberry pie could've had more filling, and the crust was very very thin. My husband's coconut cream pie was average at best. It even had a slight bit of a sour milk taste to it. The staff does not seem to work together as a team. It seems like they don't even want to be there. Hot and stuffy in the restaurant, even though I complained. read more

Pie In The Sky is a must-visit! I stopped by for coffee and ended up staying for food and pie--and I have zero regrets. Kaelyn made my latte and it was fantastic! The entire staff is friendly and the service is quick without feeling rushed. Whether you're looking for brunch, a sweet treat, or fun drink, Pie In The Sky should be your go-to! read more

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. - Inside of the restaurant - Bakeries Near Me - Conroe, Texas

I was visiting some people out in Cypress and needed a quick gift. So we decided to drop by here on our way from Dallas to pick up a pie. We were instantly impressed upon entering by the many selection of flavors they had ready. There were your classic pies and more unique ones like their Lavender Haze. They also had individual pies, smaller pies for small groups, and larger pies. They also had a full on menu of food items if you are hungry and want to sit down and eat. We got their Banana Cream Pie which ended up being a hit. The pie was a little pricey. I think we paid about $17 for the pie but it was heavy, large, and oh so good. The crust was perfectly flaky and the fillings had the right balance of sweetness. The girl at the counter was really nice and helpful. She was really knowledgable about all their pies and answered all our questions. The inside of this place is pretty large with plenty of places to sit and hang out. I recommend if you're looking for a pie. read more

See all

Now listen up, folks, I'm here to tell ya 'bout the finest brunch I ever laid eyes on at Pie in the Sky Pie Co. in Conroe, TX. This ain't just some eatery--it's a downright masterpiece of a meal stop, and I'm speakin' plain truth. From the moment we set foot in there, the staff was sharper than a mountain man's axe. Friendly as all get-out, quick on their feet, and makin' us feel like we was kin--service like that'd make any man stand up and salute. The brunch menu? Lord have mercy, it's a spread that'd make a Tennessee boy's heart sing. Hearty, flavorful, every dish hittin' like a well-aimed shot. Fresh ingredients so good you'd swear they was grown in Eden itself. But the real prize, the thing that'd make you wanna carve your name in glory? Them pies. We tried a few kinds, and I'll be danged if each one wasn't perfection--crusts flakier than a Smoky Mountain mornin', fillings so fine they'd make you wanna hang up your apron and call it a day. No wonder these pies got folks talkin' like they found the Holy Grail. Pie in the Sky Pie Co. is a gem, plain and simple, the kind of place that'd make any American proud to call it theirs. Food that lands like a haymaker, pies that'd make your grandma retire, and service with more heart than a Basterd on a mission. We're already plannin' our next visit, itchin' for more. If you're in Conroe and you ain't eatin' here, you're missin' the mark. Highly recommend--now go get you some slices! read more

This was a great little place for a casual lunch, I split the Cuban and the BLTA with my grandaughter and both were good, This place was like a little slice of home. We were too full to try the pies but I will come back specifically for a pie flight. read more

See all

Love all their pies as do do my grandkids especially the cake pops! It's a real treat to take those lil ones in and let them pick out ! Husband loves the cherry pies as that's his favorite ! Soup runs a bit small to go, could use a bit more in too besides broth but taste is excellent ! Will go back to try more on the menu! read more

I love this little restaurant. This became my favorite place to stop for a snack or meal. Over the course of a month, I tried their red velvet cake ball, their raspberry swirl cheesecake bars, their lemon shortbread, their chicken salad sandwich, and their Waldorf salad. Everything was perfection. The only thing that I would change is that the crust of the raspberry swirl cheesecake bars was a bit too salty. read more

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. - Chicken Salad Waldorf Salad - Bakeries Near Me - Conroe, Texas

See all

So frustrated and annoyed Loved this place until two of our party got the worst food poisoning last Sunday. Salmonella from the salads. I called to try and speak to a manager about it because being immune compromised this is something that is very serious. Never got a call back. Tried to reach out via email- never got a response. A week later nothing. There's too many other good restaurants to bother going somewhere where 1. They don't take food safety seriously and 2. they can't bother to reach back out when there's been a problem. read more

I love this place. I'm not going to lie and say I spend 100s of 1000s of dollars here but I do frequent this restaurant every few months. When friends and family come into town, I take them here because it's special with a variety of options and thankfully it's not a chain restaurant. That being said, the last 2 times have been less than stellar. Today was the topper for me. I went around noon to order some desserts for 3 coworkers celebrating birthdays. These desserts would be for takeout. The girl at the counter, whom I've experienced before, is definitely an order taker and not there to create an experience. No biggie. I wanted ice cream (which comes with the desserts) to be put on the side but I was told no. They don't do ice cream with to-go orders. The reason: "ice cream melts." That's a stupid reason on many levels but ice cream should still be an option regardless because why cheapen the experience just because you are taking it to go??? After the girl at the counter saw me getting slightly frustrated with the ordeal, she offered to sell me 3 scoops of ice cream to-go for a dollar a piece "as a favor." A favor is NOT selling you an item which usually comes complementary with the order. The whole debacle was pointless and tiresome Do better next time. And maybe get someadults in the room. read more

If you name a sandwich Cheesy Cheesy, it should be full of cheese :( this one had 1/2 a piece of yellow and 1/2 a piece of white. We have been here many times and not had any problems with the strawberry salad but this time it came with an oil for the dressing and instead of the candied pecans they have substituted for sliced almonds. With allergy issues this is something they should have mentioned before they brought the salad to the table. On a high note, the outside patio was nice, it was a pleasant day to sit outside, and the flowers were gorgeous. Also, our food came very quickly even though placing our order took forever. read more

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. - Bakeries Near Me - Conroe, Texas

See all

The owner just sold this and told us she comes in to check on her customers of 20 years. Her words were, 'if I could choose the perfect person to buy the business the new owner is it.' The restaurant is small and charming. We stopped in on our way to Houston on "Pi Day". The burger looked juice and enormous. The pie was wonderful. The pie was served on a shallow bowled plate with light swirl of a complimentary flavor. My coconut cream was perfect in sweetness so the coconut was still the primary flavor. A thin ribbon of butterscotch complimented the coconut flavor. The key lime was beautiful and had a balance of sweet and tart. All of the pies were as beautiful to see as they were to eat. Highly recommended stop. Life is short. Eat dessert first. Would give them 10 stars if I could. read more

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. - Bakeries Near Me - Conroe, Texas

Everything, and I mean everything we ordered for the holidays was incredible. I'll admit, my grinch came out this season. Seeing the pies at the Nutcracker market, I assumed they were not fresh baked. Seeing them upon pick up at the store, I disappointedly assumed the same. These look mass produced- I said, These do not look like they were made with love-I said, but I was wrong! If you have an opportunity, I highly recommend their untraditional but delicious Mississippi Mud pie, as well as their bumbleberry (similar to triple berry), apple streusel, and strawberry rhubarb pies. And yes, I ordered all four pies, and they were with every calorie. read more

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. - Exterior - Bakeries Near Me - Conroe, Texas

See all

We've never had anything we didn't like here. The food is extraordinary & of course, the Pies are Perfect (especially the Bumbleberry w/a scoop of blue bell! read more

What a lovely cafe! It's my husband's birthday weekend and he always requests a pie or any pastry for his special day. I am still new to Houston and the surrounding areas. I researched several pie shops close by and found this business 16mins from my area. I will say of your not familiar with the location, you might miss the turn. There was plenty of parking available. I noticed the outside patio lit with lights. Inside I was greeted by a lovely girl who was personable and informative. What like most about this place is knowing EVERYTHING is made in house or locally. I forgot to mention Pies In The Sky is female owned, and has been around for 20yrs (I think), BRAVO! I spent some time talking to the staff at the register - they seemed very happy to be there. Even the kitchen staff looked in good spirits. The wall closest to the entrance has a variety of pie flavors along with local coffee, wine, free range eggs, and more. I don't recall seeing a price list posted so I asked the nice young lady restocking the shelf. 9 Inch Pies are $20 6inch are $10 (Be sure to checkout the half off rack. Half off pies expire within the next few days but are still great for freezing and eating later) I was shocked at the price points of the pies, I was honestly expecting them to cost much more. This is SIGNIFICANTLY cheaper compared to other shops that charge $36 for a 9inch pie. TASTE The million dollar question. Are the pies any good? YES!! If your a new customer like me and don't know what to purchase, are free samples available at the register. I tried the strawberry rhubarb then purchased a 9inch plus a slice of the bumble berry. My husband hasn't tried his pie yet- but I hope he likes it. If not I will eat it by myself. I look forward to returning here for a full dining experience. I really like the ambience and live music - the menu looks impressive. Also, they offer mimosas AND sangria! read more

See all

Unfortunately I did not take any photos. I ordered the West Coast Salad and was not impressed. They do not carry ant diet sodas, so I ordered unsweetened tea. My son ordered a BLT and sadly, the bacon was too burnt. My other son ordered a waffle and an apple streusel and he said it was delicious. My husband ordered a pulled pork sandwich, it was ok. I also ordered a cappuccino, it was ok but it took forever. I think they forgot I had ordered that. Since I am not eating carbs, I looked for sugar free options. I found one keto cookie for $4dls. I did not try it because I felt it was too pricey for the size. They did have some free samples of Red velvet cake, my family said it was good. read more

I did not love the food, the service was mediocre only come for pie cause that was great and service was better with the pie.

Pie in the Sky Pie Company in Conroe, Texas has all the elements of a very good restaurant. It has a good but simple menu, great atmosphere and pie. Those are pretty formable things to have in a restaurant. The sandwiches are huge and the selection of pies are impressive. Although the menu is geared more toward sandwiches, soups, salads, and pie but if you're hungry for lunch or an an early dinner, I think you'll find something that you will find satisfying and filling. There's even a sizable outdoor eating area that you can take this and enjoy when the weather cooperates. If eating is not your objective , you just wanna piece of pie and a cup of coffee. They also have great selections in coffee, so the combination of the pie and the coffee tends for nice pause in the day. read more

See all

While back home visiting my beloved hometown in Conroe, some friends of ours wanted to meet up and have breakfast. They suggested Pie in the Sky, so we hopped in the car and headed that way. I moved away from my beloved Conroe in 2004 to seek greener pastures with my current job, so this place was not around when I left. However, something seemed a bit familiar about this place. Upon arrival, we strolled in to meet our friends. Upon walking in, we were impressed by the quaint little small town feel when we walked in. An open area with a pie shop, a counter, and a dine in area where you seat yourself. Menus were by the door, so this is an order at the counter and they bring it to you sort of place. The wife and I picked up a menu and perused. Lots of delicious looking items, so the choice was hard. After some back and forth on a couple items, I decided to go with the basics. The wife decided the same thing as well. Both of us ordered Dad's Plate. Two eggs, with German fries, bacon, and a croissant. The wife had the same, but regular toast instead of the croissant. The kiddos ordered a kids pancake of some sort. A side of good advice was supposed to come with the wife and I's plate as well. According to the menu, Dad's plate was a favorite of Ted. Then... it hit me... Now I remembered why this place seemed so familiar. I knew Ted back from my last job, and remembered the pies we ordered from the Pit Stop back in the day for our annual Christmas party. Our annual Christmas served hundreds of people in the community, and I remembered the amazing pies we used to get. I also remember Ted as a great no nonsense, down to earth, very stoic kinda guy. I was sad to hear of his passing, as I had knew him all through the years at J&B. The food arrived at our table in good time. The presentation was amazing and it looked delicious. Very hungry, I dove right in. The eggs were delicious. My only complaint was there was not enough of them. Four big bites and they were eggs were gone. The bacon was good too. A but overcooked and borderline burnt. I love crispy bacon, but not burnt. The potatoes were great, and the croissant was heavenly. We were shorted the word of good advice though. Not to be cheated out of what we paid for, we returned to the counter to demand what we paid for and did not get. The girls behind the counter were happy to oblige. The advice we were given? Drink water, be nice, and eat pie. Fair enough. Generic, but applicable. We were happy the girls made this right and completed our order. (We also were very humored they played along! It all was in good fun!). We finished our meals, visited with our friends, and were out the door. The family and I enjoyed the food, fellowship, and the environment of this little jewel. The next time we are in town, we will be back. Maybe next time I will catch some of the family and see if any of them remember me. This place will not disappoint, and I recommend you stop by and give them a shot. Merry Christmas, Yelpers! read more

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. - Dad's Plate (Ted Sr.'s favorite!) - Bakeries Near Me - Conroe, Texas

See all

Cute little cafe. Good pie and desserts. Service was pretty slow considering how empty it was. Food was cheap. Pie flight (3 whole slices when we were told they were half slices) 3 cake balls and an apple juice were only $27. read more

We came here after Church for a few years for lunch. Stopped after they made some changes to the menu. We came back today to give it another try. We like eating local and supporting local establishments. I'm afraid we won't be back again. The "service" was bad and the food was worse. Not sure how you can mess up a club sandwich. So disappointing. read more

The ambiance is great! The people and the service are great. However their breakfast option is vey limited. My wife likes their pancakes. My quiche is kinda okay. The chocolate cream pie is amazing m. read more

See all

This place is a gem! The food...was absolutely delicious and the pies, my goodness I could've eaten all of them! They are all delicious and did not disappoint! We did try the strawberry/rhubarb pie and goodness that was the most beautiful pie I have ever had! The actual breakfast and lunch did not disappoint! The staff is super friendly and helpful! And the atmosphere gave us hippie vibes and we loved it! Will absolutely be stopping by here again! read more

See all