I don't usually leave negative reviews, but I wanted to share our honest experience. Ralph picked up our dinner tonight, and unfortunately we had mixed results. My calzone was very overcooked to the point that I wasn't able to eat it. Ralph ordered the chicken parmesan, which was actually good. However, the spaghetti that came with it was disappointing and reminded him of SpaghettiOs in both texture and flavor. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Cheese Calzone and Cheese Stick - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

We met the owner this evening. What a lovely man. He served us himself. The TVs are installed and, Monday, a new era of sports television will begin on the walls of this esteemed establishment. We had pizza and traditional hot buffalo sauce wings. It was all good, hot, and made to order. We had a medium pizza made half with olives, artichoke, & sun-dried tomatoes. (I know! Didn't those go out of style 15 years ago?). The sun-dried tomatoes were a nostalgic touch. The other half had mushrooms, pepperoni, & sausage. Neither of us cared for the other's half but enjoyed our own. Still happy with Piu Bello Buckhead. read more

Amazing food and service, always take home pizza when in atlanta highly recommend ny style

Going big vs doing well are different ideas that I think restaurants need to understand, especially if you're going to be in Buckhead where the food scene is fast and unless you've established yourself, it's not going to last long. Considering Piu Bello seems to have just opened, but that they're not too shabby in terms of food, I'm pretty sure they'll be here a while. It's a small joint that seats about 70 easy. Tucked away near in the plaza by the Publix and the Starbucks. Piu Bello has pretty good service. It's a sit down restaurant and the server is prompt, courteous, extremely personable, yet professional. So I'm there for a birthday lunch and I've not had many great Italian restaurant experiences in Atlanta so to come here as a first timer is gutsy because Italian can be hit or miss depending on how passionate the chef and the owners are (Watch kitchen nightmares if you want to see how owners who lose passion for food tank their business). The food here looks great! The pizza was definitely NY style as it was greasy, cheesy, and looked flavorful. The baked ziti looks cheesy, savory, and filling. The pasta e figoli soup looked thick, rich, and pure home comfort of the Italian countryside. The fried calamari wasn't overly cooked as the mollusk pieces still had that rubbery texture that was accentuated by the fried batter which also had flavor between the two. But what I had was known as the Chicken Arabiato. A tomato creme sauce infused with garlic and spicy cherry peppers. The spice adds just the right amount of kick that threads a very pleasant touch through the tangy of the tomato creme as the savory sweetness of the garlic just lightly rests on top providing a smooth spicy savory goodness. The chicken was a bit dry as it was stringy and tough to chew but for the record, not too shabby. And their fettuccini was cooked al dente. All in all, not a bad experience to say the least and definitely recommend this place for a cozy date night or gathering with friends. read more

Pasta and chicken were delicious! Everything was perfectly cooked and served promptly. The rest of the service was great, and the portions are HUGE! I had a lot of food to take home. There are cute little booths, which I love but also a lot of room for groups. Will definitely be coming back!! Tip: To pay, you have to go up to the register! read more

Delicious New York style Italian eatery in Buckhead, Atlanta, Georgia. The Owner and staff were very nice. Seating was plenty and the place was fairly clean. Restrooms were fine, tables wiped down, etc. Theres plenty of items to choose from, from pizza to calzones to pastas. My wife ordered her favorite, linguini and clams. I ordered my favorite, the tortellini alla panna. We came here because it was close, was one of if not the only place nearby serving this option, and had good ratings for being quick to serve. Piu Bello hit all the good notes. My tortellini was fantastic and reminded me of the creamy ristorante style, almost like a cabonara but not and with alfredo sauce. It was so good, exactly what I wanted for that moment. My wife's linguini and clams disappeared quick so safe to say she liked it. The homemade focacia bread that comes with your food is delicious and smells awesome too. I was so full from my plate I did not finish the bread, which is uncommon because I usually fill up with bread first at Italian restaurants - a good sign. When I come back to Atlanta I would absolutely eat here again and plan on it. My understanding is that the restaurant is so new that our hotel needed guidance on how to take us there. I also heard the Bar & Grill next door has the best wings in ATL. Nice little gem area there. read more

Came here for a late night food pick up. I ordered a pizza and a pasta dish. There is plenty of seating in the dining room. The service is slow, my order took a while. The pizza was just OK for me, lacked flavor, crust wasn't as crispy as I would've liked. The pasta was overcooked. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I had a petty good lunch then I ordered garlic knots to go in addition to some I ordered for lunch and when I got home, this is what I got...burnt rolls!! You all actually sent me home with these?? So disappointed... read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - To go garlic knots 5 Piece Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I did not get any photos :( I was with a group of 6 adults and 3 kids. The place is small but they accommodated our group amazingly. We were immediately greeted and a table was created for us. We needed to feed the kids first, so ordered garlic knots and cheese pizza. They understood the assignment and left our tab open and got on the pizza. We ordered a salad and 3 pastas to share - Fettuccini Alfredo - Eggplant Parmagiano - Carbonara without the meat They provided suggestions for our group! The potions were large. We were given extra bowls, tongs, and plates for our large group. Our meal with 1 large pizza, 2 orders or garlic knots, 1 large salad, and 3 pastas was $140 including tip. Service was great! Wanted to try the pizza by the slice but the pasta was great and I was so full! Thank you for accommodating! read more

It' s been a little while since I have been here, they have gotten so much better. They weren't even bad before but now they are top notch. The food itself is incredible. I remember it being greasy low end Italian and now it rivals many sit down places even though this is an order at the counter type of place. The salads we got were incredibly fresh. The Romine was crispy and bright. It was well made and had a wonderfully rich and creamy dressing. The sandwich itself had a crunch bread but was easy to eat. We also got a few small dishes and it all was just great.  We were also impressed by the people working. They were incredibly friendly and helpful. Even though it was order at the counter they kept coming by to see if I needed anything. When we were done, they cleared our table for us. It was almost like we did have table service.  Overall this restaurant is great and I will definitely be returning. read more

Service was horrible. Pizza was horrible. I'm spend a lot of time in NY and this isn't it. Over priced. Just because you have Buckhead location doesn't make you over charge for trash pizza. I'll never be back ever. Buyer beware. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Trash pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I was craving ooey cheesy Italian goodness and this place delivered! If you're wanting a Brooklyn Italian place, then this is the place to go. Affordable prices in the buckhead area with great eats. Also unassuming so can show up in your street clothes and still have a great time. Tortellini alla Panna- a good cheesy tortellini dish. If you're wanting just pure cheese and carbs then this is the equivalent of some cheesy white sauce mac and cheese goodness. Tagliatelle alla Romana- Fettuccine with chicken, prosciutto, and portobello mushrooms in a rose sauce. The rose sauce is what makes this dish stand out as the rose sauce creates that bright tang that keeps things balanced. Eggplant Roletini- stuffed with ricotta cheese and spinach in tomato sauce topped with mozzarella This was a clear winner out of all the dishes we ordered. The eggplant breading was incredible and the side of tomatoey marinara pasta contrasted nicely with what would have been a heavier eggplant dish. 2 large stacks of eggplant with that crucial amount of ricotta and spinach was excellence. One of the best eggplant italian dishes I've had in a long time. Staff was attentive and friendly and laid back. Area is very unassuming and felt like a canteen but the food was very good. Would come back for that eggplant dish. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Eggplant Roletini - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

So, I tried pizza from here thinking it was artisan enough to meet my NY standards. The pizza was terrible. Not crisp, soggy in the middle like most of the crap you find in Atlanta. So I ordered pasta for my idiot roommate and he really liked that. He even hated the pizza. Big question Atlanta! Where does one go to get a NY pizza that has a crispy crust and is not soggy and overloaded with cheese? Granted, I won't order from here again, but where does one go for decent pizza?? read more

Food was really good. I like ordering slices as the bottom comes out crispy. When you walk in the place is clean. Staff friendly and come to check up on you. The lasagna pizza was a welcome change and the sauce was lasagna sauce instead of regular pizza. It was excellent. I also like that you get the full range of salt pepper oregano cheese hot pepper and garlic powder at the table. read more

See all

My wife and I decided to check this place out and was not disappointed! The food is phenomenal, very fresh ingredients and a good pizza. The staff and owner were very nice, answered all our tedious questions along with giving us recommendations. If you have the time, stop by for food made with love and great ambiance! read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Margarita Slice - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Amazing staff always friendly. Lasagna pizza, one of the best things I've ever had. You gotta try their tiramisu as well fantastic!

Food & service are both wonderful! I have had the chicken piccata and the eggplant parmesan them both are very yummy.

Small and unassuming I had to seek out Piu Bello in the strip mall it sits within, but happy i am happy I did. It offers both counter and table service but definitely feels like more of a counter/quick service place than a sit down restaurant. The staff was friendly and helpful and my food was served very quickly. I had the chicken Parmesan with Alfredo sauce and it was delicious. The portion of chicken was so big I had to take half of it back to my hotel, and the Alfredo was creamy and had a very good flavor. Given the portion size for what I paid there is definitely a good value here. read more

Absolutely bomb! Staff were friendly and helped give me some suggestions on what to order. A casual ambiance. I got the meatball sandwich. Savory and cheesy. Came with either fries or a salad. The portions were pretty big! I was surprised. Would definitely come here again! read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Meatball Parmigiana Hero - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Horrible UberEats experience. The main dish was incorrect and my garlic knots were burnt. As per usual, UberEats was not helpful. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Burnt garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

So I stopped inside the strip mall that had pizza by the slice. It was actually a pretty good establishment. I have the garlic knots, which were great. They came out super hot and filled to the brim with all the garlic goodness. I also had a slice of the meat lovers and then the slice of the barbecue chicken pizza. Overall they were good. Maybe we're left in there a little bit too long, but I'm sure that was just by accident. Because the crust got a little harder than it needed to be in some parts. But the flavor was good. The barbecue sauce was good on the barbecue chicken pizza. I loved it. There wasn't as much sauce on the meat lovers, but I think that the meat man made up for it. The pizza slices were very big, two of them were more than enough. Everybody at the restaurant was friendly. When I wasn't sure what pizza I was looking at, they had no issue with coming over to point out the specific types. I would go back for sure! read more

See all

I was intrigued with the rating of the place, ambiance is very simple and casual, very friendly staff. Food was superb. Al dente pasta, flavor was on point. Exactly what I'm craving for. I didn't think I was gonna be able to finish my food because of the healthy serving but I ate everything! Price was reasonable. Will definitely come back to try the pizza read more

See all

We had the lasagna, chicken parm, and garlic knots-- all delicious! We'll definitely be back. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

It was mediocre. Nothing to write home about. Slices are premade and reheated for convenience. They seem to be busy because of location. Nothing about this place really stood out that made me want to try again. For something so simple as dough, sauce and cheese, any pizza lover owner should be able to whip up something that is unforgettable that creates a need to return. For this place it did not hit the mark for me, even though there are some that enjoy the flavor. I have found much better in the metro area. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - By the slice or by the pie - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

We have been eating here for years and I can't believe I never wrote a review! We love it and stop in for quick slices on the weekend while out for lunch. We are there two times a month minimum. I get two slices of Meat Lovers and my wife gets one slice of plain cheese. We also like the Garlic Knots (a lot). We have seen people in there eating complete meals and the food looks really good. Staff is really friendly too. Give it a try :) read more

If I could give this place a 10 stars, I would the food the atmosphere was great. the lasagna is made fresh daily. The Parmesan sandwiches are incredible and the pizza is great when I come back to Atlanta this is the place. I will come back to so delicious if you live in the area blessed to have this place. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Lasagna with a house salad made fresh daily! - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Had the pleasure to stop by Piu Bello over the past weekend, I know we are late to the party since they have been here for over 15 years, but it was really good! Can't believe it took us this long to come here. Just what we were looking for. A simple, classic, Italian spot. Lasagna, spaghetti and meatballs, chicken parmigiana, etc. We started with the calamari which was cooked to perfection. A lot of places can't get this right. I had the tagliatelle alla romana and it was delicious. My husband had the chicken francese with pasta which was also very good. On top of great food, the staff could not have been nicer. They greeted everyone who walked in and were eager to help in any way. read more

See all

Nothing too bad, but nothing mindblowing either. Based on other reviews, this place seems very well liked, but my review is based on the quality of the food and I just wasn't a huge fan to be honest. The margarita pizza did not taste like much of a margarita pizza because it was basically cheese on pizza dough with a couple tomatoes on it. It didn't taste like a traditional margarita pizza with the tomato sauce and fresh modérela and basil like I had hoped (but totally my fault for not checking what the margarita pizza looked like on Yelp reviews). The wings were also pretty average. We were still hungry after the 12" pizza, so the wings did the job but other than that, they weren't the best wings. In terms of environment, there was plenty of parking outside so that wasn't something to worry about thankfully. The restaurant was really nice and casual. Plenty of dine in space and looked clean too. The staff did not seem too organized as they seemed to have gotten someone's online order mixed up, but they seemed to know some regular customers which speaks for their service. We ordered online and came to pick up in 25 mins and decided to just dine in once we got there, but they had the food ready by the time we got there so that was great. I'm not sure if we just ordered the wrong things, but I don't think I'll be trying this place again, not because there was anything wrong in particular, but it just wasn't my taste. read more

See all

FOOD WAS AMAZING. The service was exceptional! The food came fast and wasn't pricey at all. This restaurant needs more recognition. Please check it out! read more

I go here all the time because it's walking distance from where I work and the staff is so nice and welcoming. The food is pretty good, especially their bbq chicken pizza, and they've always got good music playing and it's never dirty. Only thing I don't love is their prices but that's what I get for living in buckhead. Overall pretty good place, always look forward to getting a nice warm big slice of pepperoni from here. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Pepperoni Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Best vodka pasta ever!!! Great service and super friendly staff! Me and my friends love this place!!!

If you're looking for a place with pizza by the slice, Piu Bello is it! The lasagna pizza is a must try. It really does taste like lasagna, just on bread/pizza dough. Overall, most of the pizza is good. Least favorite is the BBQ chicken pizza. Though this is usually one of my favorites, it's a bit dry and tough to eat here. Piu Bello also has meat pies, garlic knots, cheesy bread, etc ready to go at the counter, but of course there's a whole menu of things you can have made to order - calzones, pasta, etc. read more

I'm new to ATL and Buckhead and I've has several food misses within the neighborhood, especially delivery. So, I was pleasantly surprised when Piu Bello showed up to my front door with piping HOT pizza and pasta. The pizza was flavorful, even the ctust. Unfortunately, everything else Iwas just so-so. The spaghetti bolagnase nreded some work. It lacked flavor and was too dry for a pasta dish. I expected a reasonable balance between sauce and noodles, and this unfortunately was not. The pasta was also very sticky. I also ordered a slice of cheesecake and it was not worth the price. They sent The tiniest slice they could get away with selling. Als soon as I bit into it I tasted plastic. It was like the cake absorbed the smell and chemicals of the plastic wrap or box they store it in. It was so gross. I definitely will not be getting any dessert from this place. All in all, this is not authentic Italian, just a place for quick food. The pizza is the only thing I'll be ordering and I only plan to get delivery when I'm craving. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Pepperoni 12" - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Needed a quick meal after a long road trip and this fit the bill. The food was okay, (eggplant parmigiana and lasagna) but the portions are large and it was prepared quickly. Not sure I'd return but it was ok for a one time meal. read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

surprising amazing italian place... all the food order are all great... the place really like original italian food with all the basic read more

See all

Piu Bello is a cozy little pizzeria at Buckhead Landing Shopping Center. The NY Style Pizza is great especially when you order a whole pizza and it comes fresh out the oven. Their calzones are also made fresh and the dough and toppings are amazing! They even have Jamaican Beef Patties made fresh and you can add toppings to them. Don't sleep on this little Gem in Buckhead! The staff and management is so friendly. read more

Eggplant Parmesan was good and didn't need any seasoning, which was great. Caesar salad had way too much dressing, so much that I couldn't eat it, and tiramisu had too much alcohol. read more

What else could you want in a pie shop? This place has it all and what a great staff. 3 of us shared a large supreme pizza pie and Greek salad. Thin crust pizza with fresh and flavorful toppings. Crust had just the right amount of chewiness and salad was fresh and right amount of ingredients that complimented pizza really well. Did I mention the great and friendly staff, what a great bunch of guys that really appreciate their customers. They obviously enjoy making pizza pies. read more

Really enjoyed our visit! The pizza was great and they had seating inside. The staff was friendly and our food came out very quickly Drink options are a little limited. Nice place to stop and eat when the traffic starts to beat you down read more

Piu Bello Buckhead - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

The cannolis here are phenomenal!! Picked up 6 for a real estate house warming event post closing and they loved it! Licked the container. Thanks! read more