Pizza Cottage - Pickerington

Legit some of the best pizza around the area, have been eating here for many many years. Very…read morefriendly employees and fast service, employee even brought my pizza out to me !

Just had a carryout large 3 item pizza and 1/2 order of Italian garlic cheese loaf. Cheese loaf…read morewas not toasted, had no garlic butter or seasonings so just warm bread with melted cheese. For the pizza, we have eaten here for over 30 years and this was one of the worst pizzas from here. Sauce almost nonexistent, toppings didn't fully cover the crust, some toppings not spread but piles. Could have gotten better pizza elsewhere at much cheaper price. Could be just a Sunday crew issue.

Where pick up are gotten

Check your box BEFORE leaving.

See all

First timer. Finally.

Shirkys Pizza Zone

4.6(66 reviews)

8.4 mi

Great pizza, wings as well. Has Consistently been good quality food. The owners are involved in…read morethe quality checks of take out orders, as well as a friendly environment dine in.

Been meaning to try this place. I love mom and pop pizza places. This place did not disappoint…read more The drinks selection is great. The specialty pizzas all sounded delicious. The cluckin loaded fries were delicious. We got the sweet heat sauce and it was really good. The bbq white meatball pizza was amazing. I will absolutely get that again. The all the way was your classic supreme. It was really good too. Almost edge to edge toppings but left just enough crispy crust which I love. We will definitely be back.

Fried pepperoni appetizer

See all

Beyond Dough Pizza

3.7(15 reviews)

0.9 mi

good so Right, let's talk about this pizza, because this is what pizza is supposed to be! Look at…read morethat crust--golden, blistered, beautifully crisp on the outside, but still soft enough in the middle. That cheese is melted properly, not dumped on like some lazy afterthought. And the sauce? Bright, rich, seasoned--there's actually BALANCE here! You take one bite and immediately know someone in that kitchen actually gave a damn.

Ever since I first tried this place, I've been nothing but satisfied. Everything is prepared in a…read moretimely manner, the service is good and the food is delicious and filling. I've had the "build your own" calzone, lasagna, wings, pizza and fettucine alfredo (added chicken) and salad. Never had an issue and always met with a smile. I usually order online, being a member and I enjoy how easy it is to accumulate points towards discounted purchases. You all definitely have to try this place out.

Fettucine Alfredo with Chicken

See all

Nice atmosphere inside. Totally empty though. For a reason.

Gionino's Pizzeria of Pickerington

3.7(65 reviews)

1.2 mi

Had some at a party. Got there still pretty hot. I grabbed a slice of pepperoni…read more First impression, which I shared with others: "it's not great." But that's not fair. It's not bad. It's fine. Just maybe a bit too floppy and greasy for me at that moment (and in general.) Square cut. Fairly doughy thick soft crust. Lots of cheese. Enough sauce to hold things, and it tasted fine. A minimal amount of pepp, but what there was was tasty. And all in all the taste was pretty good. Just the schloopiness and doughiness and greasiness didn't do it for me. I didn't go back for more. But it'll probably fill your basic pizza needs.

Parking: This location shares parking with nearby…read morebusinesses, I've never had an issue with finding parking, but it's a little tight for big trucks and the asphalt is not very well maintained. 2.5 stars Food: As Yelp knows, this is my favorite franchise of pizza in the world, so far. This location did not miss, it was very good pizza. 5 stars Staff: When I arrived, the girl was outside for 15 minutes on her phone, then went inside. Guy at front desk was chill, but seemed to be doing all the work, he asked the girl for help, but she was too busy on her phone and ignored him, so I had to wait while he rang me up and got my pizza. 2.5stars Ambience: no customer seating. Restrooms: no customer restrooms. Overall: This is a great place to order takeout pizza, but if you want a place to sit down and eat, then go elsewhere. I'm a person that is capable of only loving 1 thing forever, I love this pizza franchise, no other food has ever compared. I'm back in LA now, I wish my love was here... (2.5+5+2.5)/3 = 3.333 stars.

Uncooked, doughy center soaking wet

See all

Menu-Front

Pizzeria New York

3.4(102 reviews)

0.3 mi

Had Pizzeria New York delivered. First time having it. Was delicious! Had the white pizza,…read morepepperoni pizza, garlic knots and meatballs. Everything was hot and tasted great! Will be ordering again.

This place is awful. My pizza was not even cooked. In the service was also very very rude. People…read morehurt my feelings.

Interesting tip jar

See all

Ella's Kitchen + Wine Bar

3.7(50 reviews)

3.8 mi

Ella's We went to…read moreElla's on Saturday, 5 September 2026. We'd been here before, but some things had changed. The management is different, and they now offer full table service. In the past, some nights they made us go to the bar to order. They have also made some changes to the menu. For the most part, the menu changes were positive, but they no longer offer the shrimp basket, which my wife liked. Reagan was our server, and she was very attentive. My wife had the chicken parmesan, which she thought was very good. I had the Barbacoa Steak Tacos with chips. The tacos were disappointing. The steak in the tacos was a little tough. The steak either needs to be cooked differently or shaved instead of sliced. This is a swell spot and could use a little more notice. If you are looking for a place in the Canal Winchester area for date night or a night out with the girls, give them a look.

Friendly, attentive staff in a casual atmosphere. They have great pizzas, salad options, and…read morebar-style appetizers. The FRESH smash burgers are delicious. There is a good variety of draft and bottled beers. The manager is very knowledgeable about wine and they carry a nice selection. There are live-music days and I have had the pleasure of hearing some great performers here. There's a game room available and pool table for those wanting to hangout for a while with friends. Definitely worth stopping in. The Vibe: Relaxed. The manager, Brian, did a great job breathing life into this place.

Dining Area

Meatball Appetizer

See all

High Top

Cardo's Pizza & Tavern

3.8(74 reviews)

2.1 mi

Our friends are regulars here. We pop in with them here and there. It's always good. Always busy…read more They have a nice variety of options. The pepperoni pizza is so good. Thin crust. Crispy. The good little pepperonis that curl up. The donors sub is delicious as well. It's your classic Italian sub. The pork nachos are delicious as well. Don't forget to try the meatballs.

Judging by the foot traffic coming and going from this festival place, it's a regular place for a…read morelot of people! I found this on google when i put in find gluten free near me. I was delighted to find a lot of options! Keep in mind there may be cross contamination so take it as you will. I ordered the Italian sub on gluten free and it was so very close to a normal sandwich I was very excited! I also ordered a gluten free pizza and found it great! The big restaurant held a lot of people and was pretty comfortable.

Gluten free pizza and gluten free Italian sub

Italian sub on gluten free

See all

Double ? Sausage. Nope

Kingy's Pizza Pub

3.7(119 reviews)

4.3 mi

Just had another Kingy's All the Way and it rocks it!! The drive thru window makes it so easy to…read morepick up my favorite pizza. I love this place!

GREAT VIBES!! My best friend had her surprise birthday party there recently and the food came out…read morefresh and it was all very delicious. Didn't get any pictures of the food, but just know it was amazing. We will be back.

On the back patio

Mini cheeseburger with big flavor. Fries on point

See all

Kingy's special

Homestead Taproom & Kitchen - Canal Winchester

4.0(49 reviews)

4.7 mi

They are fantastic!!! Stan, Kayln, Aliyah, and Katelyn are alllll amazing!!! The food is great and…read moredrinks are even better! #Katelyn is the best Service has been amazing. Ambiance is beyond the best, the bees are no more.

I had been here with my wife, but totally forgot to post about this place . I then brought my…read moredaughter here after school, to enjoy some time with her before college comes around. Totally chill vibe inside, customer service is very friendly, and the cleanliness is nothing but spic n span. Wings are legit, very saucy, and definitely a choice not to pass up on. The burgers are where this place really hits on. The reason it's very delicious is because this place doesn't go on too fancy of a presentation for a burger. Simple is best, and this burger doesn't stuff you to where you can't breathe, but hits the spot satisfactorily. The pizza is a pizza, my daughter is very simple with cheese pizza's being her go to choice. Overall, I like this place, as I said, very chill inside, and definitely a great spot to enjoy the outside atmosphere patio setting and enjoy a beer.

Homestead Taproom & Kitchen - Canal Winchester

See all

Pompeii's Inferno

4.6(10 reviews)

1.2 mi

I discovered Pompeii's Inferno at a "Pizza on the Patio" event at Wyandotte Winery. Upon seeing…read morethe tiny set up (basically a wood burning oven on wheels), I really wasn't expecting much. Boy, was I pleasantly surprised. PI pushes out some pies out of this oven on wheels that rival, if not beat, most pizza joints with wood burning ovens. The crust is what you would expect from this type of oven - thin under the toppings with lots of joyous air pockets and char-spots for flavor around the rim. The sauce was fantastic and the toppings were all quality. Due to the nature of PI's business (mobile pizza parlor used for "events"), the toppings were a bit limited (hey, they had pep and shroom, so what do I care?) The wait for the pizza was also extremely LONG, but I had to forgive them this for two reasons: this was a VERY crowded event with only one food option and, oh, did I mention I was at a winery? To their credit, PI finally stopped taking orders so they could focus on the backlog and push it out. This may be the wine talking, but that was one great pizza! If PI is near you, I'd definitely check them out (or hey, maybe hire them for an event - this is quality stuff).

So good. My husband got pepperoni and I got the buffalo chicken at the last farmers market. I wish…read morethey would open a brick and mortar:)

Things to do in Pickerington

See all

Pep and shroom

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Al K.

16 years ago

Despite the negative (and only other) review I decided to try Pizza Cottage since I've heard excellent word of mouth. I've ate there three times now and have to say it's some of the best pizza I've ever had! The subs are huge with the Ruthies Way steak sub being my favorite. read more

David B.

7 years ago

I absolutely love their pizza and one of the only pizza joints I know of that offers green olives. Excellent Pizza, casual atmosphere, and a friendly staff read more

Michael W.

8 years ago

What GREAT pizza and wings. I think the prices are a little high and the service is ok, but the food makes up for those short comings

Jennifer S.

5 years ago

Chef Boyardee taste better than this place. Not worth it. if I could give no stars or negative stars I would

Ted M.

13 years ago

Best and most consistent pizza in Pickerington! Costs a lil more but worth it

Jayne F.

15 years ago

Paper thin crust is not my thing.

Brad B.

15 years ago

Great place, never disappoints.

Austin G.

158

11 years ago

deffinetly great ZA

Pizza Cottage - Pickerington - pizza - Updated September 2026

Best of Pickerington

People found Pizza Cottage - Pickerington by searching for…

People who viewed Pizza Cottage - Pickerington also viewed

Possum Holler Pizza

3.5

(66 reviews)

Got pizza delivered via Uber Eats...it was fantastic…read more Great sweet and tangy tomato sauce An absolute avalanche of toppings on the pizza, never seen so much crispy pepperoni and giant pieces of bacon Really tasty garlic butter sauce The breadsticks were great as well Would definitely order again

I got a supreme pizza and it was very light on toppings and this is the third time in a row little…read moredisappointed

Joseppi's Pizza - Hilltop

3.1

(69 reviews)

Every thing was ready when they said it would be. Also, the staff was very nice and friendly.read more

It's pretty common these days, post-Covid, for restaurants to abandon dine-in efforts. Joseppi's…read morebeing one, as what once was a breezy throwback to wooden chair diners of the mid 20th century is now just an echo of itself- seemingly abandoned to neglect. If you do dine-in, however, you will get a nice view of the world outside. The help is pretty standard customer service. Nothing offensive, memorable, or special about it. Finally, as for the food, I absolutely love their baked spaghetti with a side of garlic bread. I will definitely be coming back for that. I didn't care for the sausage sub I saved for lunch the next day, though. Maybe it doesn't hold up well cold, after sitting in a fridge for 12 hours. Not sure. Overall, I will be back. It goes on my list for good food. Post script: Owner has informed they are about to remodel. It's sad, but at the same time, I'm glad.

Tammy's Pizza

3.4

(87 reviews)

I am addicted to tammy's pizza. The crust is always crispy and tasty, the sauce is good, I've been…read moregetting a pizza every week from there lately. Really happy to have discovered this gem so close to me, beats Flyer's and Joseppi's by a mile in my opinion. Joseppi's is really good and Flyer's is just good, but this is excellent.

Horrible Horrible customer service. Been ordering from Tammy's for over 18 years. My family has…read morespent $1000s on their food. Today changed all that. Ordered multiple subs and cheesecake. One sub was wrong. We called and was told to bring all subs back, like they didn't believe. Not just offering a replacement sub is costing you a couple customer (myself and sister family). I will be posting this horrible experience in all places Grove City residents read.

Ange's Pizza

3.5

(68 reviews)

Service 100 % The Spaghetti and meatballs was not worth serving. The garlic bread was lacking…read moregarlic and just a sub bun buttered. Meatball was worse than GFS premium. Sauce ? Absolutely no labor or care went into the creation of this order. It was horrific. Thankfullly the staff had humor. Do not Order this for any reason!!!@

Great quality food. Always delicious! Delivery is spot on & food is always hot. Love Ange's…read moreeverything. The three cheese garlic bread is sooooo good.

Flyers Pizza & Subs

3.6

(39 reviews)

I have not had Flyers Pizza in a long time and the last time I had was in Grove City, it was nice…read moreto have Flyers Pizza again but in Groveport. It tasted like I remember. I enjoyed the Pepperoni. I thank Knox County Special Olympics for buying the pizzas for them and Franklin County Special Olympics. I will have to check out Flyers in Groveport soon.

Ordered a pizza and salad for take out today and we were very satisfied. The food was good and…read moreworth the cost. The pepperoni pizza was cooked well and had good flavor. The crust was a little chewy, sauce sweet with a little tang at the end and the cheese and pepperoni were very good. The salad was a basic salad, but was very fresh and crunchy. I ordered online and everything was ready with about 20 minutes. The young lady at the pickup window was very pleasant and personable. All in all it was a good experience and we will keep the place in mind for future.

Pizza Cottage - Grove City

3.1

(27 reviews)

Pizza was perfect. Hawaiian pizza is my favorite and I love the leftovers for breakfast. Service…read morewas quick. We sat on the bar side. We will be back.

Ready to go under, horrible stench. Out of many things. My table mates finished their meal…read morebefore I ever received mine. Not a fan, projected to close in 2026 unless big BIG CHANGES happen. Never again.

Massey's Pizza - Whitehall

3.3

(87 reviews)

Fantastic pizza! Visit Columbus from Cincinnati and asked my foodie Uncle for a good mom and pop…read morepizza place. He suggested Masse's and it did not disappoint. Hot, fresh, delicious, and loaded with toppings. Definitely try this place out. When in Columbus I will come here again.

I walked into Massey's to place an order and saw one of the employees smoking a vape on the line…read morelooking right at the customers. He put the vape down then walks back on the line and continued making a pizza he must have already started. He went to reach for something and I was hoping it was gloves since he didnt wash his hands but it was a cup of cheese. I asked the cashier who was taking my order if they could put on gloves and she said no. I said no what yall don't have to wear gloves or yall don't have gloves and she was saying no as I asked the questions. I placed the order because of the Superbowl. Going forward I will make sure to not make another stop to my once favorite pizza place.

Ange's Pizza

3.1

(25 reviews)

The super sub was excellent! Plenty of toppings and nice…read morecrispy bread. Not too much dressing so it got soggy. It is great for a late night nosh.

Good! The pizza's were good, I hadn't expected the square cuts. The pizza sauce was really good…read morealso! First time experience.

Zanzis Pizza

3.2

(35 reviews)

I visited this small establishment for the first time with my girlfriend. We were greeted by a…read moreyoung, laid-back white male who took our order. My girlfriend ordered a BBQ chicken pizza, and I ordered a build-your-own with three toppings. My girlfriend is dangerously allergic to onions and we made it very clear that the pizza must have no onions. Despite this, when the food came out, her pizza had onions on it. I addressed it immediately with the cashier, who looked concerned and acknowledged the mistake. He went to the back to speak with a female manager, but came back and told us there was nothing they could do. No apology. No explanation. No offer to remake the pizza. Just, "there's nothing we can do." I guess that's what you get when you order cheap pizza -- but risking someone's health and brushing it off like that is completely unacceptable. This was not just bad service; it was careless and dangerous. I won't be coming back, and I'll be warning others to stay away too.

Joseph -- Service was excellent and food was great!!! the owner was a pleasure to meet as well I…read moreWill be coming back soon!!! Thank You!!!!

Ange's Pizza

3.3

(55 reviews)