We always like the pizza here and I realized I have yet to leave a review! They have a small spot on Oklahoma but plenty of parking. The inside waiting area is a bit small but it smells like delicious pizza! We saved enough of the box coupons (10 of them) to get 50% off our stuffed pizza. However, at the register, we saw a note that they'll stop accepting those as of Sept 2026 so be sure to use your pizza box coupons soon! We ordered earlier in the afternoon because it was Super Bowl Sunday and were told an hour fifteen wait which wasn't too bad of a wait considering the circumstances. The pizza smelled and tasted delicious! read more

See all

This is mostly takeout because the dining area is small. Pizza was recommended by many people. Crust 8 it was not cracker thin but had a good yeasty taste Sauce 8 the sauce was very standard. Not overly sweet Toppings 9 the Italian sausage was very flavorful and they didn't put on too much or little Value 7 I thought paying almost 20 bucks for 10 inch Milwaukee special was a couple bucks on the high side I like the pizza but if you want real cracker thin crust this isn't the place but the crust is still really good. read more

Pizzeria Scotty - The specials for the day. - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

I ordered this for take out and was not disappointed!! Decent price points as well for the sizes, I paid about $30 with tip included. The lasagna was soo delicious and a good size too!! The sauce is a bit sweeter which I'm not really a fan of but it wasn't so oversaturated that I couldnt enjoy!! The bread was the perfect pairing for it too. The salad was my favorite, like I said the portions were great and I enjoyed the ranch with it as well!! Delivery was pretty quick and the delivery guy was super nice!! Would love to come here to try sometime in person!! read more

See all

I ordered around 5:30 on Friday and the wait time was 50min and we came right on time for carry out but still had to wait an extra 10 minutes. The restaurant was busy but as expected for a Friday evening. Inside there are 2 small tables, most likely for patrons waiting for their food. I heard good things about their thin crust and obviously had to try their stuffed pizza. We got a 16in pepperoni thin crust and a 10in cheese stuffed pizza. This was a lot of pizza for 2 but we had to try both kinds! I'm a big fan of their thin crust but thought it could use a little more sauce. But it's a great tavern style pizza. I'm glad I tried the stuffed pizza but it's way too crusty. I recommend getting a side of sauce to dip it in. It was soft and cushiony. The 10in was plenty and would be a good taster for a larger group. We'll for sure be back for Scotty's thin crust pizza! read more

Pizzeria Scotty - 10in cheese stuffed pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

The food was bland, dry I only ordered a 10 inch and that took over an hour to get to me it's the middle of the day on a Thursday. I won't be getting food from here again! read more

Pizzeria Scotty - Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Pizzeria Scotty Stuffed Cheese Pizza: My favorite style of pizza is pan pizza, but a close second is stuffed pizza. Pizzeria Scotty serves Chicago style stuffed pies but is located in Milwaukee. Their stuffed pizza contains a sweet and flavorful tomato sauce on top of a thin layer of crust (so for you other pizza aficionados out there, yes I realize it's not technically Chicago style). Below this first layer of crust is stuffed double portions of cheese (along with any other desired toppings) and then the base layer of crust. I'm a huge fan of cheese and usually order extra cheese, but their pizza has had generous amounts of cheese every time I've visited. The crust is simply superb. It's a soft doughy crust with a hint of butter and just the right amount of chewiness. Honestly, it's the best stuffed pizza I've had, and I've visited all the big players in Chicago. For those of you that are not into stuffed pizza, they also offer thin crust, double dough, and pan style. Doughboy approved! doughboy_food_reviews *I think the crust could potentially be even better if they offered a version brushed in garlic butter My favorite stuffed pizza parlors: 1.Pizzeria Scotty 2.Gino's East 3.Giordano's read more

See all

Been wanting to try this place for awhile and finally pulled the trigger. First red flag was when the person taking the order was rude right off the bat. Delivery on a Tuesday took 2 hours. Food was all cold. Super disappointing, would never go back. read more

Pizzeria Scotty - This beautiful raw "Mozzarella stick" - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

This is my favorite pizza restaurant in the Milwaukee area. I've been getting delivery from here for years. I must say the food is excellent and an hour wait is worth it. Get one and enjoy. read more

I wish a took a picture of this pie. Work ordered it for lunch. The all meat was amazing. Great topping quality. Loaded w cheese. Definitely will go on my own! read more

Recently ordered and picked-up for a birthday party. The thin crust pizza, salad, ravioli, and wings were all delicious. We were all happy with our meals. Everything was ready when we arrived and the staff members were friendly. Very easy to park and pick up the food. Will definitely order again and try the stuffed pizza! read more

I tried Pizzeria Scotty recently when my mom ordered it for everyone; it's one of her go to's. I was a bit skeptical because I had never heard of this spot. I can say that it's the best Italian-American style pizza that I've had in awhile. You can't compare it to other mainstream, NY or Detroit style pizzas, it's just different. There wasn't a sit down area but the store was clean. read more

Have been a customer for years. Our favorite pizza in the whole area. The Chicago Stuffed is the best! Highly recommend!

5 stars Friendly service! I thought I'd try something new, And I'm glad I did! The pepperoni & the sausage With the jalapeños....OMG DELISH ! read more

Pizzeria Scotty - This awesome pizza! - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

I usually order on a Friday or Saturday night so the wait time is typically an hour or longer. However the pizza is always hot and delicious. This time I ordered some garlic bread and I was not a fan. It smelled great but didn't have a lot of garlic flavor to it. Sorry This will not stop me from ordering pizza again though. read more

Pizzeria Scotty is at it again. My mother wanted pizza so I've had bad experiences with peter Scotty but my mom says we'll give it a try I ordered it said 45 minutes to an hour. OK no problem. Then I got a text from the driver. It's gonna be another half hour so an hour and a half for pizza Are you serious? I wonder how they can stay in business with having an hour and a half pizza and the pizza is mediocre. read more

Best thin crust pizza around, only downside is they are always busy so it takes a Long time for delivery, but we'll worth the wait.

Ordered on Door Dash. Arrived on time to pickup order. Was told order was almost finished and it would be a few more minutes. Waited nearly 50 minutes in the lobby for food. Staff was unhelpful and unapologetic for long wait. Pizza was ok but probably will stick to other West Allis pizza spots. read more

Pizzeria Scotty serves up delicious deep dish/thick crust pizza. We recently ordered some pizza for takeout. Pizzeria Scotty is exclusively a pick up or delivery spot as their shop is quite small. They serve their pizza with your choice of crust--Chicago pan, double dough, thin crust, or stuffed. We opted for their Chicago pan style and were pleased with the thick crust and ample toppings (no sauce on top). Their website makes it easy to order and pay before picking up and they work hard to get your pizza done as quickly as possible even though they're very busy. When I arrived to pick up our order, the service was friendy and efficient. Get to it! read more

We've been ordering from this place for years. But this previous Friday 12/13 was a horrible experience. We called and ordered for take out. We told the person on the phone the exact way to get to our house because we live right next to Candy Cane Lane. Well, the delivery driver decided to first bang hard on our door. When we have a door bell. Then proceeded to say "in the future Candy cane lane is off limits." Excuse me....We live a couple blocks from Candy Cane Lane. After us spending so much money at this place. We will never return. So disgusted by the rude customer service. It's not our issue that the delivery driver doesn't know how to listen to our instructions that we verbally told them. So sad that they lost a valuable customer. We have a ring footage to even share. read more

I just wanted to bump this 11 YEARS LATER... and say this place is STILL my favorite in the area. We go as often as we can. If you havent tried this place yet, do it soon. And be patient if they tell you delivery times are long.. its worth it. read more

Sauce seems to have changed from prior, much sweeter from what i recall,I prefer no sugar in my sauce. Meatballs good but sauce distracted. Older guys at cash registers diving up tip on my order in front of me. They did not seem friendly on phone or in person. Help hard to come by I understand completely. read more

Pizzeria Scotty - Meatball sub $6.15, added cheese $2, Hot Giardiniera $9, $10 total - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Why did I wait so long to try this slice of pizza heaven!? I have seen the great reviews and heard about Pizzeria Scotty but haven't gotten around to trying it...until this week. Just on the food alone I was blown away, but the service as well. We had the Chicago Pan Pizza. It was fantastic! The sauce was great and the perfect amount of cheese. When we picked up our pizza we were greeted by a friendly guy who asked if we had ever had their pizza. We stated this was our first time and he gave us a 10% discount as well as suggestions as to what to try next. This will now be our go to pizza place. It was fabulous! Can't wait to go back. read more

Pizzeria Scotty - Chicago Pan Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

I've been coming to Scotty's since their old location a few blocks from their current spot. I've always loved them but I'm finally throwing in the towel. Food quality has become wildly inconsistent and I've had multiple orders were incorrect in the last year. I even had a reasonable phone chat with whoever was managing the shop about 8 months ago and they swore they were working towards improving the issues. Tonight I show up and my order is screwed up again. I'm done. Thanks for roughly four decent years, Scotty. You've lost my business. read more

Pizzeria Scotty - The waiting area - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

It's you, not me I saw some recent mention of PS deep dish being better than one of my faves, Giordano's so decided to give it a try over the weekend. The ordering process was super easy but their online menu didn't describe the garlic bread so well as we ended up with three loaves when I was expecting three pieces. Anyways, let's talk about the bread. I could have skipped the deep fried verion. The garlic bread (with cheese) was good but could have used more garlic flavor. What was really disapointing was the pizza. I had been so excited to bite in but just wasn't feeling it. Everything was off. There was no buttery crust with cornmeal. The cheese, while plentiful lacked cheeseyness. The sauce seemed like it was out of a can. Definitely not Giordano's. I'd say the local Rosati's was more comparable. Staff was super friendly. The order was ready on-time. The place was packed with other customers when I went to pickup. PS just isn't my thing. read more

Pizzeria Scotty - Deep Fried Garlic Bread Sticks - Pizza Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

It was my first time trying this place and it was really good. I got the double pan pizza and the crust was really tasty. I will for sure order again read more

Their pizza used to be good a few years ago. Ordered a Chicago deep dish and it was bad. The cheese is like rubber and the sauce wasn't flavorful. Overall quality is not good. read more

So, to start, the pizza is very good. Every variety is solid and their wings are excellent as well. The garlic bread is mediocre, but it's garlic bread so that just kind of is what it is. The prices are higher than most places, but for the most part you get what you pay for. In my experience, the quality of the food outweighs the extra cost. But if you're feeding a family of 4 expect to pay $50 or more. The real knock on this place: I have no idea how a business operating in 2022 needs 2+ hours to make an order. If they're that busy, you'd think they could get another oven or hire more staff. We're probably done ordering from here for awhile after our last takeout experience. We ordered at 4pm. Had a scheduled pickup time of 5:20pm. Arrived at 5:25 and had to wait until 6pm for the food to be done. Staff weren't unfriendly but also offered no apology for such an insane wait...we could have gone to a restaurant, had a sit down meal (for about the same price), paid, and been home in the amount of time it took them to make TWO pizzas. read more

So, often I like to point out that I lived in Italy for around four years and that somehow makes me an expert on all things Italian. While it is not entirely true that I'm an expert on Italian food, I did live in Chicago for a decade and was found haunting the various pizzerie in the Windy City. Today, I'm hunkered down in Milwaukee. To say the deep dish world is shallow here is an understatement. So, Pizzeria Scotty was quite the find. Their deep dish does honor to the great founders of the genre in Chi-town. It's cheesy as Hell, gooey in the crust and tangy in the sauce. In fact, it bests Lou M's (our only other known deep dish provider. Sadly, Scotty is not the dine-in type of place but a quick trip to West Allis and an hour later one is set for the next few days of diet-busting manna from the gods. read more

The pizza always has an abundance of the best ingredients! It's rare to find a pizza that has sliced tomatoes! Love how they put it together (not an empty space on the pie!! read more

Good food, good enough you may have to wait a while to get it, but it's worth it. On the pricy side for pizza imo... on the other hand it's on par with other non pizza restaurants nowadays. Better than pizza chan pizza for sure but they are at least 2 other pizza restaurants i prefer. read more

Great food and service Recommend to all. Great pricing for all items Pick up and delivery read more

Great deep dish pizza. The toppings are very fresh and the pizza is super filling. The toppings are actually inside the two layers so nothing falls off while eating read more

Yummy pizza! Pick up or delivery. We had gluten free pizza & double dough. Both crust great.

I wish, I could post negative stars... this place has gone down hill over the years, even the pizza is questionable these days... I stopped and ordered an Italian beef sandwich and side of fries to go, they were ice cold and I only live a few blocks away... Arby's would've have been a better choice and they suck... read more

Our go to pizza joint. Thin crust is our favorite and they are quickest if you pick up.

I love this pizza but I am getting sick of them saying it will take 1 1/2 hours and then I get my cold pizza after 2 hours. I live a few blocks away and it happens every single time. I thought when they moved, they would expand their kitchen and accommodate the growing demand, but nope. same old late delivery times, same old cold pizza. I only order ever few months now in hopes of better service, but nope 2 years gone by. same old, same old. this mouth does not get close to betting burnt good riddance read more

I ordered pizza here and was excited to try it since word of mouth was that they have good pizza for a reasonable price. I called and placed the order and went to pick it up when they said it would be ready. Once I got home I opened the box and saw that it was loaded with cheese which didn't bother me initially because cheese is delicious however the cheese was not great and actually caused stomach issues. I would be willing to try here again in 6 months or a year but be warned they have a lot of cheese - more than the usual amount places put on. read more

Delivery time said 60/65 minutes. Orderd at 5:30. 7:46. Still no food. Call them at seven fifteen and they said oh you're your food just went out for delivery seven forty seven I still have no food. read more

One of the best stuffed pizzas I've had and best in the area for sure. Will remain my go to deep dish spot.

Really solid pizza! It was our first time and we went with the stuffed pizza. It was really delicious and even reheated well. We can't wait to be back to try some of their specialty pizzas. read more