Cancel

Open app

Search

PJ Buckets Seafood

4.2 (161 reviews)
Closed Closed

Order PJ Buckets Seafood Takeout or Delivery

PJ Buckets Seafood Photos

PJ BUCKETS SEAFOOD ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Dogs allowed
Outdoor seating
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - PJ Buckets Seafood

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

This was the best seafood boil by far. Nicest staff, huge portions, amazing flavor. PJ is awesome, will definitely be back.

Jenny K.

this place was so good we got it for dinner 2 nights in a row! their lobster boil was chefs kiss. the garlic butter was so flavorful and not too salty. i also really enjoyed the king crab soup! cole slaw was fresh and made well. the crab spaghetti was also perfect! the noodles were al dente my son got the crab mac and cheese and said it was super yummy. he also really enjoyed their kielbasa their cornbread was also so fresh and made wonderfully. the king crab was cold though so i definitely wouldn't get it again. the only thing i have a comment on is their spicy carolina hot sauce. it wasn't very good and tasted like old bay mixed with hot sauce. i wish it was more flavorful!

NEW ENGLAND - SINGLE
Erin H.

If you're ever thinking not to go off the beaten path. Think again and go here!!! It's a quiet street with just the right amount of noise and lovely music. Street parking. The outside is perfect with 3 picnic style tables. If you're lucky enough to meet PJ he is great with showing you around the menu, helping with substitutions, and accommodating any diner in his restaurant. He's kind and funny and treats you like a guest in his home. Your silverware comes out in a bucket hence the name "buckets". We ordered 2 singles one Jersey style and one create your own New England style. We also went for the Alaskan king crab soup. With the boils you get corn bread. Really warm, fresh and delicious.

Lobster roll animal style
Shannon P.

The store is very small so either hope you go at a time and can eat in or take out. If you eat in, the staff is super nice and will keep up with anything you need or want to order! Very friendly, you can just grab drinks or some things around if you need it and the staff will keep track for you. The lobster rolls were filled and tasted great! We also got some a la carte seafood, the 25 muscles, and it was amazing in the garlic butter lemon sauce! We even added more of that sauce to our lobster rolls.

Jane K.

A total let-down... I was so excited because of the high ratings, but the food overall was so dry and salty. However, staff were friendly and service was good. There's a few tables indoors and outdoors. Not ideal for large groups indoors; it's probably better outdoors for larger groups. My husband and I ordered the snow crabs ($19.99 per lb) with potatoes and corn (additional ~$5), lobster rolls ($24.99; animal & traditional styles), New England clam chowder ($4 for 8oz), mac & cheese ($3.99), and corn bread ($1.99). I was super excited to have snow crabs, but had difficulty enjoying them because they were so salty and not very meaty... The lobster rolls' lobster was super dry, and the roll tasted crumby and old. The New England clam chowder was my favorite of the night, but SOMETHING if not everything gave me a stomachache... Side note: FYI, the main difference b/t the traditional and animal style lobster rolls is that the traditional (salad) style is colder than the animal style lobster roll.

Lobster roll

Hands down the best lobster roll in the state. We had the BEST Experience here for dinner. The owner was SO nice and hospitable. The crab Rangoon and homemade Mac and cheese are phenomenal. And the lobster roll was EASILY the best I've ever had. Can't recommend this place enough.

Lobster Boil
Dennis P.

This is a no frills seafood restaurant and that's exactly what it is. Food was ok but not great. Lobster was overcooked. Waitress was not interested in waiting on us. Warm soda, no lobster bib and it was quite messy ( table next to us got bib's from a different waitress!)

Crab Cake

I was super excited to try this place and I ordered a crab cake and I'm not entirely sure what happened to it :( This was not what I was expecting when I opened the box. No lemons, tartar sauce, or cocktail sauce... All just mushed and broken up. Disappointing

Maryland Boil

See all

5 years ago

Friendly staff, great seafood! its just what ventnor needed

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 5 of 5

Ask the Community - PJ Buckets Seafood

Are you open off the summer season?

Both locations, Ventnor and Ocean City NJ are open year round. Check our website for hours and days www.PJBUCKETS.com

Can you accommodate someone with celiac (strictly gluten free)?

Yes we can with most of our menu

Do you have a spot for dogs outside?

We’re very pet friendly

Are you open Christmas Eve?

Happy Everything from PJ Buckets! As our Gift to You we’ll also take 10% Off! thru Dec 31, 2021 (not available with UberEats or DoorDash although it is available for PJ… 

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Barbera Seafood Market - Hair in food

Barbera Seafood Market

4.6(312 reviews)
2.4 mi
$$

Really amazing service. They were still cooking and serving patrons up until the last minute of…read moreclosing. I ordered the clam platter. Delicious and fresh. Excellent prices. I'd love to return to pick up fresh fish as well as the fish sandwich which seems popular. Also tried the hush puppies. They were ok. I just prefer a more traditional southern with crispy fried breading. I definitely recommend if you are in the area. Nice selection of sodas and drinks as well.

The kitchen is open Mon - Sat 10-5 at this cheap family run seafood market! Many choices of fried…read moreor sauteed seafood with veggies and slaw, with counter service takeout or eat in at stools in the small lobby. If the weather is better, a pocket park offers outside tables steps from the door. An outgoing young man was our cashier, and then busied himself preparing for closing when we came in late on a Saturday. I ordered a sauteed flounder fish platter which came with simple mixed vegetables and coleslaw. The fish was so moist and tender and swimming in a mildly seasoned lovely broth. The veggies were seasoned and buttery, simple and delicious . The cole slaw was homemade but unremarkable. $8.99 for this healthy meal. Sign me up! Spouse ordered the soft flour shell, fried shrimp tacos and boy were they huge! He asked for the slaw on the side so it wouldn't make the tacos soggy, and got two full-sized side orders of coleslaw with his two tacos. For $5 each. No frills just good food.

Photos
Barbera Seafood Market - Storefront interior

Storefront interior

Barbera Seafood Market - One of the best sandwiches EVER! HOT AND FRESH FLOUNDER SANDWICH

One of the best sandwiches EVER! HOT AND FRESH FLOUNDER SANDWICH

Barbera Seafood Market - Inside

See all

Inside

Dock's Oyster House - Fried Oyster with Tartar Sauce

Dock's Oyster House

4.3(1.7k reviews)
2.3 mi
$$$

The same owners of Knife and Fork and it shows! Such amazing seafood and I got to try a bunch of…read morenew things! The place was beautiful but it does get crazy right at open for happy hour at the bar so make sure youre there early if you want that. There's literally a line waiting... We started off with the Shrimp Ceviche. It was super flavorful and tasted very fresh. Then we got the Grilled Octopus and it was FABULOUS! The flavor just encased your mouth when you take a bite. Its not overly chewy and the beans underneath made a great addition to each bite you took. I had NEVER tried oysters before and I finally mustered up the courage and tried one and im glad i did. It was delicious and im so glad they allow you to try just one so you don't waste money if its not your thing. The server was so nice to offer because I told her id never tried one. After that we tried the Maine and Manhattan Chowders. Both were super yummy and had a great taste and a good amount of clams.... another thing I had never tried before... WORTH IT. Then came the main course. I got the Flounder and Crab while my boyfriend got the Brazino. Both were so delicious and so light and yummy. I honestly can't say one thing i did not like about the food at this place. It was all so good. To finish off dinner, we got the Creme Brulee and an English Coffee to share. Again AMAZING. If you're ever down in Atlantic City, this place is a MUST GO!

Happy Hour Review…read more Preface: My wife and I were visiting AC to celebrate her birthday. As frequent visitors to AC, I'm a bit embarrassed that we've never been before but here we are. Before I get into the details, I'll simply say this place is SPECTACULAR!!! I was thoroughly impressed by the ambience, food, relative affordability (for seafood), and customer service. Additionally, we were so impressed that we came back the next day for another Happy Hour! This will be a long winded review because Dock's deserves the accolades and future potential diners! Oyster on the Half Shell ($1.50 each): Incredible, clean tasting oysters. I prefer a brinier oyster but I can't ignore the quality and freshness.. It was served with lemon, horseradish, and a homemade vinegar mixture. I asked for tabasco on the side. As mentioned earlier, I do prefer a brinier oyster but these oysters were a clean palate for you to customize as you please. Regardless of your oyster preference, order a few to start off your experience. Broiled Oysters ($1.75 each): There were two options: Rockefeller or Champagne Leak. We only ordered 2 (Champagne Leak) because we wanted to explore more of the Happy Hour Menu. The broiled oysters were presented on the half shell with what looked like a creamy leek infused sauce. Beautiful flavor! Fried Oysters ($1.75 each): They offered 4 different types: plain, buffalo, parmesan, and wasabi encrusted. I loved them all. We ordered 2 of each and it was served with tartar sauce. All 4 offered different flavor profiles. The Plain sounds boring but it's the perfect vessel for you to dress it as you please. The Parm was one of my favorite bites here. It was breaded, fried, and topped off with cheese and red sauce. It was fabulous. I can't give an honest review of the Wasabi and Buffalo fried oyster as my palate was bombarded with multiple plates, condiments, and drinks at the same time. Fried Calamari ($7.25): Simple, fresh, delicious. Although fried, it didn't come out greasy. Simple breading or flour dusted and fried served with lemon and cocktail sauce. No curve balls with this fried calamari. Lobster Mac and Cheese ($11): Beautifully presented Mac and Cheese served on top of a half split lobster. Great traditional casserole style Mac and Cheese (in taste, not presentation). Bits of lobster incorporated as well. It's a nice change of pace from oysters galore.I understand it's lobster but for the most expensive item on the Happy Hour Menu, I expected a little bit more meat. Tuna Tacos ($7.75): Star of the Show! Raw tuna chunks are diced and served in crispy wonton tacos. The crispy wonton had an incredible crunch. Wonderful upfront flavor but it doesn't stop there. There are back notes of something I can't pinpoint...a touch of wasabi and/or sesame oil??? I honestly can't tell you but it brings such a complexity to the dish. This is a must order. Even if you don't like raw fish, please do yourself a favor and try it! My favorite bite of 2026!! Ambience: old school but upgraded and grand design. Beautifully stocked upstairs and downstairs bar. The pianist played classic music. Customer Service: although we weren't seated. The bartender accommodated us to stand on the side of the bar, he told us it was against policy to serve food to standing customers (understandable) but he obliged. The bartender's name was Joe. Excellent bartender/server. Overall: we were so impressed we told ourselves that we had to come back the next day and we did. Day 2 food reviews below. TOTAL: $141.58 + $30 tip, 4 alcoholic drinks ordered. Day 2 Food Review House made Meatballs ($6.25): Great choice if you want to switch up away from seafood. Great presentation with 3 meatballs drenched in red sauce and topped with a Parmesan crisp. Overall it was tasty but I prefer a slightly sweeter red sauce. Deviled Eggs ($6.25): The Deviled Eggs here are topped off with a fried oyster. I'm a huge texture guy and traditionally deviled eggs are a mushy hot mess but here the crispy fried oyster is the perfect contrast. Served with a honey drizzle. Will order again! Clams Casino ($6.50): Clams topped off with charred red and green bell peppers and bacon. Aesthetically beautiful and colorful. More importantly, it was delicious. Notes of bacon are felt but surprisingly the charred peppers come through with a slight sweet profile. Mini Crab Cakes ($7.75): Traditional crab cake with a red pepper sauce. Good serving size, good amount of crab, and very little filler inside. No frills, must order. Steam Mussels Marinara ($8.75): Mussels served over a red sauce. Served with garlic bread on the side. The garlic bread was the unsung hero of this dish. Great garlic and butter flavor. The bread stands tall against the flavorful mussels and red sauce. Customer Service: Harry was our barbartender and looked like he was enjoying his time. All the staff truly provided great service. Total: $181.17 + $40 tip, 6 alcoholic drinks ordered.

Photos
Dock's Oyster House - Upstairs Back Dining Room

Upstairs Back Dining Room

Dock's Oyster House - Oyster Rockefeller

Oyster Rockefeller

Dock's Oyster House - Clam Casino, Rockefeller Oyster, Grilled Shrimp

See all

Clam Casino, Rockefeller Oyster, Grilled Shrimp

Steve & Cookie's By the Bay - Warner's Bouillabaisse

Steve & Cookie's By the Bay

4.2(547 reviews)
2.6 mi
$$$

We enjoyed an outstanding dinner here! While staying nearby in Atlantic City for a conference, we…read morereally wanted to get away from that nasty area and one of our colleagues lives in the area and suggested we try Steve & Cookies. We got there and it looked, calm, simple, and plain from the outside - until we walked in... this place was PACKED! Clearly, since we didn't make reservations, we weren't going to enjoy seating at their white table cloth tables in the main dining room, but we went around back to their bar and scored one last table there. Our server, Brian was amazing... engaging... and on point! They have a nice wine list and perfect spirit list. They also have an outstanding menu loaded with so many options, that I really just needed to settle on the first thing I saw that looked good. For me, I love cucumbers and when I saw they had a cucumber salad, done Asian style, I was completely in!!! Then I saw their soup of the day was split pea with bacon and since no one serves split pea and when they do, it's rarely what I expect, I got that too! Both of these came out looking GREAT! The cucumber salad had a nice spice to it and the flavors overall were sooo on point! That split pea soup was also great... almost perfect! It had the exact texture this soup should have and the flavor was very nice. For my entrée I saw a few of the halibut as I was walking through the dining room, so that is what I chose. The halibut came out looking great! It was PERFECTLY prepared too!! The flavors were spot-on, and the accompanying veggies were great too. We were enjoying dinner so much that we didn't want it to end, even though we were full... so, we ordered desserts too. I opted for the banana cream pie, as this is another item I rarely see on a menu and when I do, it's rarely done right, but not here... they did it perfectly! Overall, amazing meal... Highly recommend stopping in, but make reservations first!

I lucked out with a seat at the bar at this busy, popular restaurant. My Farmhouse Shrub drink was…read moretasty and I loved the live piano music. I clearly ordered wrong. The fried sushi roll was tough on the outside and soaked in a spicy sauce. I only ate the tasty tuna interior. My seasonal crisp was apple. Really? In June? And it arrived covered in whipped cream AND ice cream. I clearly should have gotten the blueberry pie! The crisp was okay but the fruit was lost in the toppings. I'll try again another time.

Photos
Steve & Cookie's By the Bay - Bar area

Bar area

Steve & Cookie's By the Bay
Steve & Cookie's By the Bay - Walking out, we saw the sunset

See all

Walking out, we saw the sunset

King’s Pub

King’s Pub

4.7(65 reviews)
3.1 mi
$$

The food was great & fresh. They accidentally put an unwanted ingredient on my sandwich, and…read morewithout even bringing it out, they prepared a new one. It was a nice sized bar with a bunch of seating. Service was good too! Attentive and quick.

I found Kings Pub on Yelp while in Atlantic City. The establishment was easy to find and had a…read moredecent amount of parking. I entered and made a beeline straight for the restroom because I had to gooo . I quickly discovered the bathroom doors were locked and required a key code. Next thing I know, the bartender, Domingo, starts yelling from behind the bar and then comes around questioning why I was in the establishment. He made it very clear that the restrooms were for paying customers only. I firmly replied, "I plan to dine in, but need to use the restroom first. Is that a problem?" He didn't seem too happy with that response and walked away. As intended, I sat at the bar and ordered wings and truffle fries. The food wasn't particularly memorable, but the wings were a decent size. The truffle fries were fine, but nothing that stood out. Antonio clocked in about halfway through my meal and was a breath of fresh air. He was friendly, attentive, and completely changed the tone of the experience. Overall, it was a good visit with decent food and great service from Antonio. Unfortunately, my first interaction with Domingo left a poor impression and took away from what otherwise would have been a positive experience.

Photos
King’s Pub  - Bar at the Kings Pub

Bar at the Kings Pub

King’s Pub  - Dragons breathe wings.  Old fashion cocktails.

Dragons breathe wings. Old fashion cocktails.

King’s Pub

See all

Knife & Fork Inn - Seafood Tower

Knife & Fork Inn

4.2(772 reviews)
1.5 mi
$$$$

Such a beautiful place inside and out! Its a cute old building that really makes you feel like…read moreyou've stepped in time. The food is amazing and the service is very friendly and efficient. They had a great special you get a Corn Chowder but they allowed us to switch to French Onion Soup without the croutons. This was so sweet of them and the soup was AMAZING! The cheese was so goey and the perfect amount of cheese to soup ratio! It also came with a Tomatoe and Mozzarella Salad eith Balsalmic which was so fresh and delicious! The main course was Lobster Thermadour and a Filet. I had never had lobster thermadour before and it was AMAZING AND SO YUMMY! If youre ever in the Atlantic City area I HIGHLY recommend trying them!

I'm torn between a three and a four star review. In the past, I would've given them a 4 to 5 review…read moreand I honestly can't believe I haven't posted a review before at this restaurant as it had been one of our favorites for years and a place we frequent when at the shore. I recognize menus change, but I'm guessing the chef changed as well. So many items are called the same name as they were on the previous menu yet they are not same, like a shadow of its predecessor. I will say the cowboy steak was amazingly prepared and delicious. If I was reviewing that alone it'd be a 5 star review. Our waitress was nice but I definitely got the feeling of disappointment when we didn't order appetizers, we prefer to order extra sides and drinks which more than make up that in the end. Just some people don't and it sucks to feel like you're not a table worth waiting on. The saddest experience was the dessert. The sticky toffee dessert was my favorite thing in the world. It was fabulous. It's still on the menu, but it is not the same dessert by any stretch of the imagination. It now tastes like someone cut the bran muffin in half and poured some sugary sweetness on it and then served it with clotted cream that was not tasty. It used to be a tiny dessert that came with ice cream. It was so rich and was beyond delicious. It is actually a challenging dessert to make, so I'm guessing they've changed to this new version to save time but honestly they should just take it off the menu if you're not going to do it properly. If that plate was served on Top Chef and they would've crucified the chef as it looked and tasted horrible. I'm sure we will go again in the future but I left with a tinge of sadness that they changed a historic restaurant so much.

Photos
Knife & Fork Inn - Upstairs Dining Room

Upstairs Dining Room

Knife & Fork Inn - Lobster Thermidor

Lobster Thermidor

Knife & Fork Inn - Outside

See all

Outside

PJ Buckets Seafood - seafood - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...