I called Poplar Pizza to inquire about catering for a birthday party. Due to my hectic work schedule as a healthcare worker, the party was on a Sunday. The person who answered the phone said they usually don't do catering during Bills game Sundays, which is completely understandable, but since this was a morning Bills game (London) they could probably do it and would call me back. I never received a call back and spent days waiting. I think it's just very rude and not customer friendly to not even call me back. If you can't do the catering, just be honest and say so. read more

I moved back in April and I kept driving by this restaurant and I decided to give it a try one thing that I do like is that I can order all flats and the chicken wings were done perfectly my only suggestion is to add just a little bit more sauce to them I have been here twice since I moved and also another reason why I decided to give this place a try was because of the ratings for the place and how good they said the chicken wings were and the service was very friendly it was fast and it's right next door which makes it very convenient for me read more

Poplar Pizza - Chicken wings all flats - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cheektowaga, New York

This place is no longer called Bob's, but just Poplar pizza. Came this evening because Poplar pizza, is one of many places participating in the Shop 716 gift card program. The pizza was good, especially if you like thick crust edges. (great for dunking in blue cheese) I would've really enjoyed the pizza more, if it had some seasonings on it. It was just a little to plain, of a flavor to me. The wings was good, nice size and crispy. read more

See all

Ordered 2 fish fry's. They were discussing. I tried fish, wasent bad but as my friend continued on we threw it all out. 2 hours later we were so sick. Vomiting and diarrhea. Don't eat. Run for your life..... literally read more

I like this place. It's a typical Buffalo neighborhood pizza joint. I can't think of anything that stands out or differentiates it from most other Buffalo neighborhood pizza joints. I did find a particular pizza that they make well that I don't get from all the other neighborhood pizza joints-the Taco Pizza. I know that a lot of other pizza joints have taco pizzas, but they all put their spin on it. I don't love the taco pizza as advertised, but 1 extra ingredient takes it to the next level for me: black olives. So I've found a favorite. Their wings are pretty good also. They don't have a wide variety of flavor, but by request, they'll cook the wings like I like them-not too crispy; as soon as they are legally allowed to take them out of the grease. Toss them in a sauce with a little bit of a kick and my taco tuesday pizza night just turned into an event! read more

Well always order the fried chicken filet sub and the 4 piece chicken dinner. The sub is usually spot 0n..this time the chicken was over fried, close to burnt. The roll was dry and no mayo or oil as requested. The fries with the dinner were dry and way over cooked. Very disappointed read more

This is the second time I ordered a pizza from here and it's been over baked, to the point of being burnt read more

Poplar Pizza - two pieces of pizza on foil - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cheektowaga, New York

New ownership has made this a go to again. Great food and service. I especially love the Steak Tacos and their wings.

Used to love them esp their chicken fingers but they are hard as a rock all the time and they serve like 10 hard as a rock fries. I think they got new cooks cause the food has been disgusting for almost a yr. When I call in ill tell them to do it this way or that way since the cooking was so bad the last time but then I get it and it's just as bad as the time before. Pizza is usually pretty bad too it's all crust and no pizza. When I tell them to not overcook it it's overdone when I get it. And they hardly put any sauce on. I finally wrote a review cause I'm fed up with horrible food and whenever I say something no one apologizes or offers a discount. I'm back to partners and carbones. Even though I moved away from them I have no choice but to drive there cause Poplar is so bad! You need new cooks! read more

This place is hit or miss. Never outstanding. I just had the worst, driest chicken finger pizza I've ever tasted. Definitely dont recommend. Sometimes the wings are decent. read more

Ordered their catering service for supper last night and had to change the order twice because of extra guests, etc. With two days' notice they did the change cheerfully. Delivery was on time and quiet enough not to disturb what was going on. Servers were quick in setting up. The food was great--roast beef, macaroni and cheese, vegetables, rolls and butter. Napkins and cutlery were provided. Prices were reasonable. I was skeptical about ordering dinner from a pizza place, but, boy, was I wrong! I recommend their catering service to everybody. read more

Good pizza. Number 4 currently in my best tasting pizza in WNY.It's not a thick deep dish pie and its not a thin style pizza either but the perfect Buffalo style.Double dough is offered here and is a must! YUM!If I had one complaint it's that I wish it was loaded with a bigger "portion" of ingredients. They are tasty but I'm left wanting more! The sauce is great! I absolutely love it! Best around! 1) Imperial pizza (Buffalo) 2) Leonardis (Amherst) 3) Bella (Hamburg) 4) Bobs Poplar (Cheektowaga) 5) Zips Wise Guys (North Buffalo) read more

See all

I ordered a small julienne salad on my way home from work the other day. It was hot out and very hot inside the pizzeria so I told the woman I was going to sit in my car to wait. She told me she would bring my salad out to me. She did (Thank you!!) and when I got home I was totally amazed at the size of the salad. It was huge! And better yet, it was delicious! I've been a customer for years and I have to say I love all of their food. The pizza (my favorite pizza of all Buffalo), the cheeseburger sub (the best), the wings and the loafers and the ham sub, and the baked roast beef. Oh, how could I forget the fried chicken? It is totally amazing! I think I mentioned all my favorites now... Thank you Poplar Pizza! And they cater too - yummy - lazy pierogi is awesome... Just saying. read more

My random go to when I need food right after work. This place is right off the thruway on William making it SUPER convenient. I find the pizza to be just ok. The boyfriend enjoyed a turkey sub that I grabbed him. Then, I discovered the "LOAFERS" and all is good. It's kinda like a calzone where you can have pre-determined ingredients or build your own. I've done both. First attempt I had a salami and ham Loafer with added hot peppers which comes baked with cheese and red sauce to dip on the side. I was NOT a fan of this one because while the salami was sliced like deli meat the ham was in chunks...I did NOT understand. Also, the sauce should be served warm not cold. I worked in a pizzeria for 5 years as a teen and we always heated it up b4 giving it out. Tonight I tried just salami and boy did it hit the spot. I wasn't thinking about reviewing until my friend said the pic I sent her looked delicious, so here I am. I usually order through https://eatstreet.com/ and it's always ready when I get there. read more

Poplar Pizza - Salami and Cheese Loafer! - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cheektowaga, New York

A five star rating when considering quality and price together. You shouldn't have to spend a fortune to get quality pizza and wings and Poplar delivers without charging you close to what you fork over at the big name local joints. The service is always excellent, food is ALWAYS ready when i arrive. They always give a total on the phone and are pleasant as well. The menu has a ton of variety too! Ribs, specialty fish fries, and things you dont find at a typical pizza place. My wife says the fried mushrooms are her new favorite. This is a great bang for your buck place that checks all the boxes you'd want in a local shop. read more

Nasty pizza. And I love pizza save your money little ceaser pizza tastes better I ordered medium pizza and it was nasty I say it was the sauce I ate a couple of slices through it in the garbage never again master pizza not from there taste better read more

We ordered a tray of pizza and 50 wings med extra saucey. The wings has no sauce on them and they were not even cooked they were practically raw so disgusting we couldn't even eat the wings. We called the place back next didn't care said there was nothing they could do. Talk about horrible service. We will tell everyone not to come here to give them business if this is how they run there company. Horrible. read more

I'm updating and taking some stars Away....ordered a small side of macaroni salad and small it was! It was in a condiment cup. They should be ashamed of themselves to charge $1.89!!! for one bite!!! All it was were tiny shell noodles, mayo and celery. I could make a pound of it for that cost. Greed! Will add picture. I could write a lengthy review but I won't. This is the pizza for which I judge all others against. Pizza is so subjective, everyone likes a differently style and has their go to place. To me, this is what I consider to be "perfect" pizza. I am not a huge pizza sauce lover but I could drink this stuff. It has the right amounts of everything which you would think would be simple to get right but it's not.... The dough has a unique flavor to it ( maybe seasoned pizza pans?) and is delicious...cheese? Perfect. They don't skimp here. BBQ wings are the perfect pairing. I find their sauce to be slightly different than most other BBQ wings. They remind me of Duff's BBQ wings....when you order them extra crispy they have no trouble getting that right either. If I had to have one negative I would say the thickness of the dough is a little inconsistent. Sometimes it's perfect and other times it's so thin it's hard to pick up. No worries, I have plenty of forks and knives! read more

Poplar Pizza - "Small" macaroni salad for $1.89!!! what a joke!!!! - Chicken Wings Near Me - Cheektowaga, New York

I ordered with them through yelp and it was a easy set up! They even called to confirm my address! The wings were amazing we got the char BBQ and they didn't skimp on the sauce! I even was able to pay the tip for delivery through the online order so it was a very easy transaction! And the delivery guy was very nice! Overall it was a great service and good food! And I'm glad they allow you to order through the app! read more

By "Poplar" they mean "Popular"... the person who named the place had a slight speech impediment, and that is fine. I think someone mis-spelled "popular" when naming this place, because if this place isn't popular, it really should be. Mmm-hmm. The first time I went there, it was a really fantastic slice of Pizza... but this most recent time I went there it was absolutely appalling... I mean it was 2 or 3 star worthy at best... it was lukewarm and tasted like it had been sitting out all day and was a frozen pizza. I've reduced them to a 4, but I'll need to try it one more time to see if it's going to sink to a 3 or lower. My original review said: it doesn't get much better than this. It was the 3rd in my 5-slice tour of Depew-Cheektowaga, and was tied with Tony's as my favourite. Absolutely delicious - full marks! It was piping hot and fresh out of the oven (she knows how I like it!) so that helped, but the taste and texture and the dough and everything were perfect - quintessential Buffalo Pizza at its best. It's right around the lower reaches of the top 10 slices in Buffalo, which is really saying something given that there are probably a hundred good slices in the area! What is it with Pizza in Buffalo? It is simply the best I've ever tasted and there are probably 200 good options. I recommend these (my personal faves), which are Bozanna's (Clarence), Avenue (Broadway & Bailey, East Buffalo), Blasdell (southtowns), Imperial (South Buffalo), Zip's (North Buffalo), Francos (Eggert location in Amherst), and Yogi's (Akron). The last one is more Brick-Oven style than typical Buffalo style. All 8 slices are pure heaven and must not be missed under any circumstances. I can't say it enough - if you're just trying a slice, make sure the Pizza is either straight out of the oven piping hot, or reheated in the oven. Chicago Pizza is amazing, and NYC Pizza is special, but Buffalo, for me, beats them both. Please don't talk to me about STL Pizza or Cali Pizza (ew). Buffalo Pizza is fluffier, doughier, cheesier, saucier, and pepperonier than anything you've ever had. If Chicago is a crusty pie and NYC is a huge flat slice, then Buffalo is quintessential Pizza. It's just so good. They also do excellent Buffalo Chicken Pizza and Steak Pizzas here in Buffalo. Dreamy. I will stand under oath and swear that Buffalo Pizza is the best in the land. Please don't ever order Pizza from Domino's, Papa John's, Pizza Hut et al. Those major corporations don't need a penny of your money, and they are bland cookie cutter chains that spend all their money on advertising. Please frequent your locally owned Pizza shops. They need it more, they're real local people, and the food is almost always wildly superior, anyway. read more

I ordered this for delivery last night. Service The guy on the the phone was nice, delivery guy was nice, and the pizza got here in less than 45mins. Food I ordered a large with sausage and pepperoni. I tried, but I'm not a fan on Buffalo Style pizza. It was good, but not in my Top 10 Places (across all styles of pizza). The crust was right between a pan pizza and a thicker hand tossed-that part I liked. The sauce was there, but nothing stood out to me about it. Cheese was good, pepperoni was fine, sausage was good. Essentially, it was a fine pizza. The only thing that stood out as being specifically Buffalo about it was the pepperoni. The pizza was nowhere near bad, but I wouldn't go out of my way to get this style again. My disclaimer is that I'm from Chicago. I love deep dish & stuft pizza, but I can also dig into uber-thin/crunchy crusts. read more

We ordered 60 pieces of fried chicken & an antipasto for a graduation party. Our guests raved about the food. Everyone said it was the best fried chicken they'd ever had. The salad was perfect too. This business does a fabulous job. read more

Hairy Pizza? No thanks. Ordered in because it was snowy outside and we didn't feel like cooking. Took an hour to get pizza and wings - bit into a slice and found a dark curly piece of hair baked into the dough. Had to stop eating everything that came because I couldn't fathom what else might actually be in our food at that point. read more

Very good pizza, great subs and wings. Loafers and lots of other stuff made fresh and taste it! Love Poplar.

I tried it based on some reviews I read. Personally, the pizza was too saucy & doughy. Very expensive too. The guy who took my order was very polite & the shop looked very clean. Just not the kind of pizza I prefer. read more

I've been ordering here for years! The prices are really good in comparison to Picasso's or other pizzerias. There food is always fresh, and I've never had the food be cold. Still go there regularly! read more

Probably some of the worst pizza I've ever had. Gave it 3 chances and each time have been disappointed. Dough is tasteless, have had better frozen pizza dough. Sauce is bland, grocery store pizza is better. I gave it a 1 because at least the folks are friendly... read more

Terrible customer service. Messed up our order, and when we called to tell them, insinuated we were lying. And were laughing in the background. Good food, but absolute ignoramuses working there. I strongly suggest not ordering food from there. read more

Overall good..posted a tip..but best fried chicken by far! And the loafers were the calzone like thing i was talking about.

I ordered pizza and it was wonderful. Delivery was fast and food was hot on arrival. I think prices are reasonable. Great place to get food! read more

Ordered the beef on hogie, pizza and wings. We loved it and all the food was gone with great reviews. The food was delivered on time and I'm ordering again. I gave it a five as I've never experienced the Beef on Hogie, which was awesome! My order was a referral from other employees, who really like the food. read more

I placed an order over the phone while looking at the on line menu and was quite surprised that an order I added up to about 40.00 plus tax and delivery now was 58.57 due to price increases and they did not know what menu I was looking at.it was their menu on their website that apparently was not updated in awhile but it sure is a bit of a shock when the price jumps from a advertised price of 28.79 for the family pack and you find out it is now 35.09 plus the other items I ordered also went up.not happy when prices are falsely represented on a site they should be monitoring,sorry lost a customer.Brian J. read more

My favorite pizza in the area!! Super cheesy and I loveeeeee cheese !!!! Totally recommend this to all my friends.

Yuck, I just tried to eat the order of hot wings I ordered. The worst I can remember having. No amount of Franks Red Hot can mask the smell and taste of rancid, old and or burnt oil. Never again. read more

I had picked up a fish fry tonight. When I picked it up there was a guy with a bandana on that was very rude and smelled of alcohol. He had very little patience, was very loud at the register and dropped a few F-bombs. He was extremely intoxicated and his eyes and breath showed it. The manager needs to learn how to hire people. He must be dumb. I will never order again from this place because of this angry drunk man. He also said my food was "made with love". The food tasted like a leather boot. Maybe he was passed out and dreaming because of the alcohol he was drinking on the job. read more