Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Potbelly Sandwich Shop Takeout or Delivery

    Potbelly Sandwich Shop Photos

    Business Info

    From this Business

    POTBELLY SANDWICH SHOP ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    More like Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    Recommended Reviews - Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Kyle P.
    1021
    314
    2242

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    Dave's Cosmic Subs - #1 Original

    Dave's Cosmic Subs

    4.2(84 reviews)
    0.5 miUniversity District

    Dave's Cosmic %hit Subs... Where do you want me to start?…read more We're in town for the CBUS Blue Jackets and Door Dashed this bull %hit to our ABnB. To start, we ordered at 6:27, our Door Dasher picked up the food at 6:36, but it wasn't delivered until 8:57... Completely unacceptable. Granted the extremely late delivery wasn't the restaurant's fault (necessarily)... However, because they use Door Dash for delivery, they're ultimately responsible by proxy. Add in that the delivery driver spoke no English, tried to kick our English Staffy who ran out whilst smiling to say "hi" (if you know anything about Staffy's, you know they love people and don't have a mean bone in their body), our food was cold because it was delivered 1.5 hours late, and I was about to lose my flipping mind. Now onto the food... These were quite honestly some of the worst subs we've ever had. Subway is miles ahead of this hot garbage, and it's not remotely close. The food was $50 for two puny half filled subs, inedible coleslaw (absolutely disgusting), a pickle, and a GF cookie (that was not delivered). Now onto the really bad part... Within 30 minutes of eating this trash, both my wife and I had to run for the toilet (I'll leave it at that). Bottom line... Screw this place. PS - If I ever run into Cosmic Dave, he's going to get a piece of my mind for charging people $ for this crap.

    Really good sandwiches. Right across the street from THE Ohio state University Student Center.read more

    Photos
    Dave's Cosmic Subs
    Dave's Cosmic Subs - Dave's Peace Steak Sub

    Dave's Peace Steak Sub

    Dave's Cosmic Subs

    See all

    Fat Arnie's Sandwich Shop - Pork Belly Chicharron  @ColumbusFoodDude

    Fat Arnie's Sandwich Shop

    4.8(20 reviews)
    3.4 miClintonville
    $$

    So if you looked at my pictures remember this location is inside a bar, pictures don't really do it…read morejustice. The food was outstanding, we started with two Empanadas one of each chicken and beef. These are so good, and are a nice size. The sandwich was loaded with flavor had a small kick for the the meats but so tasty, It had capicola ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese and all the sub toppings. However the real reason I wanted to stop here was for the Pork Belly Chicharron! I need to let you know these are some of the best. The box is huge and loaded full. I was super excited to have a few left over for later that night. Thet are getting ready to open an additional location soon, a stand alone and I can't wait to try the new location. Until then don't wait get in there, you be very happy you did!

    Mr found out about this spot earlier this week, so we made time on a Sunday afternoon to pick up…read moresome sammies to go! Couple things worth noting: it's tucked inside a neighborhood bar on Indianola. Parking can be tricky but there's more around back and just down a bit closer to Savor. Inside the bar, just head to the back inside window to order. They have a menu with some notes and updates, also. Seems chicken sandwiches will be back soon which might be the thing I try next. Also, on Saturdays, you can order a pound of chicharron for $20. A bit about costs: I think it's a bit expensive. A single empanada is $5. There are price breaks for larger quantities ordered. Italian sub and double patty burgers are each $13. The Appolonia Italian is a decent size, but the buger, even with double patty, felt small. The service is super friendly! The quality of their offerings is much higher than average. Everything tasted really good, no notes. The spicy Italian is a bit spicier than I prefer with their version of a giardiniera on it, but Mr loved it. All in all, a generous 4. I'd get it again and recommend it with my notes so you know what to expect. (Sorry I forgot a pic of the burger)

    Photos
    Fat Arnie's Sandwich Shop - Bar

    Bar

    Fat Arnie's Sandwich Shop - Arnie Burger

    Arnie Burger

    Fat Arnie's Sandwich Shop

    See all

    Frenchi’s Deli

    Frenchi’s Deli

    4.7(75 reviews)
    0.7 miUniversity District

    The sandwiches are absolutely incredible, but the best part is that we rarely even order off the…read moremenu anymore. We just tell them, "Make us something amazing," and they knock it out of the park every single time. Fresh ingredients, great combinations, generous portions, and clearly know how to build a seriously good sandwich. There's something pretty special about walking into a place, putting your lunch in their hands, and knowing you're going to leave happy. If you go to Frenchi's, try skipping the menu at least once. Tell them what you like, let them work their magic, and enjoy the surprise.

    Frenchi's was on my list to go to. I was in the area and decided to give it a try. This is a small…read morespot, meant more as a order and take to go place. The service made this experience memorable. The gentleman working asked me if it was my first time. He made some recommendations. They were out of corned beef for the #3 The Eiffel Tower so he substituted bacon for me instead. I liked that the buns are smooshed flat, the meat and cheese heated and melted, and then the additional toppings diced up into smaller pieces. I had about a 20 minute drive that could have made the difference, but once I started eating the sandwich it was good but aa bit chewy. It might have been less chewy if I would have ate it right away. I also ordered the specialty croissant. The staff person asked me if I was okay with the price, it was $8. I appreciated he let me know the price and made sure I still wanted it as it was a bit pricey. The croissant was amazing! This was also a food that was better ate day of. I had it the next morning for breakfast and although it was delicious you could tell it was getting stale already. It was beautifully made. Frenchi's was good, just eat it right away for optimal freshness!

    Photos
    Frenchi’s Deli - #5 Le Buckeye Combination

    #5 Le Buckeye Combination

    Frenchi’s Deli
    Frenchi’s Deli - Menu  @ColumbusFoodDude

    See all

    Menu @ColumbusFoodDude

    Catering By Scott - The Schmoozer

    Catering By Scott

    4.9(749 reviews)
    5.2 miEastmoor
    $$

    Scotty's Cafe came recommended by my wife's OSU colleague Isaac and it did not disappoint on two…read morefamily visits. First time my wife and daughter stopped before our daughter headed overseas for two years in the Peace Corps. Scotty''s is super close and convenient to the airport. Scotty learned of the imminent departure and came with cookies and treats for the long flight! And now this morning it was another airport drop off. It was my turn, dining alone but nothing about a table for one at Scotty's is lonely. The staff are immediately welcoming and every customer is every employee's charge. Four different people helped me or just checked in. The Gina breakfast combos have lots to offer for breakfast. But I was thrilled this 9:30 am to be assured the whole menu was available. I was looking for something less common and was excited to see potato latkes with sour cream and apple sauce as an option. That would have been great but then the waitress (Salome maybe) said, "Do you like corned beef?" The Schmoozer is 3 enormous latkes with thinly shaved and lightly grilled corn beef on top with an over easy egg atop that. Seriously, I can declare victory for finding something I'd never had before. Never would have found it without the nudge. Had to cut myself off with all the coffee offers. Just a great vibe. You rarely see a 4.9 rating and even more rarely that high based on so many reviews. But I understand why - like in so many things in life, it is about the people. And the joy they bring to every conversation. And I will just add, in this age when some would divide us, this dining room is filled with all manner of folks, reveling together over food in fellowship.

    As someone who considers herself a pancake connoisseur, theirs were genuinely the best ones I've…read moreever had. They have such a wonderful vanilla flavor, I could eat them plain. Their baked goods are also a must-get, especially the lemon cookies and oatmeal raisin cookies! The workers were so kind and attentive and made our first experience there absolutely amazing.

    Photos
    Catering By Scott - COVID 19  dining room

    COVID 19 dining room

    Catering By Scott - Cake of the week!! I mean no better combination than Chocolate and Peanut Butter! So here is the Buckeye cake!

    Cake of the week!! I mean no better combination than Chocolate and Peanut Butter! So here is the Buckeye cake!

    Catering By Scott - The Schmoozer, Pancakes, and the Big Breakfast.

    See all

    The Schmoozer, Pancakes, and the Big Breakfast.

    Potbelly Sandwich Shop - salad - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...