Great find - thank you Yelp! Fantastic spot, big menu, accessible, and family friendly. We got here late on the July 4th holiday weekend - so happy they were open. There was live music in the back room, so we opted for a booth in the front room so we could have quiet dinner conversation. Alisha was great. She explained the menu, the Mac & cheese, and the dairy bar in the adjacent bldg. We ordered dinner and it was out quickly. Hubby had the entree of brisket & pulled pork with a side of veggies and the Mac & cheese. The Mac & Cheese is so, so good. We ordered some to take home for my son! My balsamic chicken entree was delicious - I loved the side of carrots & zucchini- very fresh & unique! Great dinner, no hesitation to come back here. And, we did have to wander over to the dairy bar and check out the ice cream too! On the way, we noticed lots of outdoor seating and maybe a little stage too. There is live music regularly! Hubby got a shake & I had a dish of hard ice cream. It hit the spot! Thanks so much! read more

See all

Service by Laura D was very friendly and attentive. Back area of restaurant was very busy and Laura still kept checking on us. Spicy peach sauce on chicken wings was very good. Goulash special was great. Large portion. Ruby red Ruben was good. French Fries, some of the best I have had. Fresh, hot and tasty. Parking lot was packed but most people were at various events in their back room. Front of restaurant had booths , counter and tables. Worth a ride to this gem. read more

See all

A delicious lunch in a quaint country diner, less than 5 minutes off NYS Thruway Weedsport exit 40. Great service. Excellent lunch. Open 7 am - 8 pm seven days a week. We'll be back. Enjoy! read more

See all

Some good food, huge beer selection, overcooked burgers. We stopped by Potters Farm to Fork at Port Byron, NY in July 2024. Reviews were somewhat mixed but mostly OK and there weren't many choices around anyway. Taking a look at the menu we were immediately impressed by an enormous beer selection. We tried Sour Summer Haze IPA and it was excellent. For appetizers we ordered Jalapeno Poppers and a cup of chili. Jalapeno Poppers came quickly, were delicious, and went well with the beer. Chili never came. We ordered burgers for entrees and based on reviews explicitly asked to make sure they were cooked medium-rare and medium. We haven't finished Jalapeno Poppers yet and the entrees came. Both beef burgers ordered were fully well-done :( I couldn't believe it. We explicitly asked to make them right and they did not. It's not a rocket science to make a right temperature burger...Oh, well. After we almost finished our meals the waiter brought the chili that was ordered as an appetizer... I tried it, it tasted more like thick tomato sauce with some chunks of meet rather than chili. The waiter apologized for the mistakes, chili was taken off the bill, and we got a 15% discount on the bill for overcooked burgers. It's nice that at least they take responsibility for the problems but I would prefer a rightly cooked burger than a discount. It's hard to recommend this restaurant based on our experience but as mentioned, there were good points too :) Hopefully, the restaurant will improve based on this other reviews. Food ordered Jalapeno Poppers - fresh and delicious. Chili - came at the end and wasn't good. Cowboy Burger - would be great if done medium as ordered. #88 Knox Burger - would be great if done medium-rare as ordered. Smothered Balsamic Chicken Burger Dinner - was very good, my son liked it and finished in no time. Kids Chicken Fingers - good. read more

See all

This restaurant is adorable, the food and drinks are amazing! The staff is friendly and the food and drinks came out quick. I highly recommend this cute little place , very country themed and always had country music playing which was a nice touch read more

See all

Went here for Mom's Birthday and they have an extraordinary deal for wings on birthdays. Free wings up to your age (limit of 50) with purchase of $35 or more. The wings were big and cooked to perfection. Service was really good and I really liked the country style ambiance! Prices are decent overall great place to eat! read more

See all

The food and ambiance was nothing to write home about. We sat in the front in a booth and it was depressing to me. Service was satisfactory.

Had an excellent experience here the other day with a co-worker for a quick lunch. We both opted to get a "garbage plate" and were very pleased with the results. The meat sauce had just enough of a kick and everything was prepared perfectly. Service was good and the restaurant was very much a farmer style joint. I definitely be back the next time I am in the area. read more

What wasn't horrible about this place? Live performers' music was way too loud for the small crowded space. Food was undercooked and took forever to come out. Waiters seemed incapable to deal with a dinnertime rush and had no interest in checking in on our table at all. We had trouble taking the undercooked burger off the bill as well. Forget going here to have a good time, just find a spot that actually cares about their customers. read more

Only my second time here. Would definitely go back. The chicken wings were spot on (which they have a birthday special for) and the beer list has to be one of the best in the area. (Blew me away actually). Service was over the top also. Hope to head back soon for more wings and trivia night. read more

Potters Farm to Fork - The Potters Plate - Diners Near Me - Port Byron, New York

Homestyle food, enough to take home leftovers and a great price. Big parking lot; was able to pull in with our RV.

Casual dinner in port Byron, not far of the Erie Canal trail. We stopped in for lunch after a Morning of riding. It was packed--waitress said it's the first time she's seen a full restaurant at lunch! WE got their 'signature' Mac-n-cheese (with pulled pork) and a grilled cheese sandwich. Food came out quickly. Everything was tasty. Better than standard diner food. read more

Potters Farm to Fork - Mac-n-cheese with pulled pork - Diners Near Me - Port Byron, New York

See all

A wonderful restaurant to take your family to they have a wonderful buffet they dress up for the kids for the holidays the services incredible their award-winning restaurant read more

Oh my goodness. We're traveling from San Antonio, Texas to Vermont. I was looking for REAL food off the highway. Stopping here was the best decision of the trip. Thank you Little Baby Jesus for Good People and Food Made Right. My faith in humanity is renewed. read more

Potters Farm to Fork - Paprika Huhnchen - Diners Near Me - Port Byron, New York

I would give it zero if that was an option. Went there for Easter this morning. Had reservations. Large party (more than 6). The hostess after 1 hour came over asked us to pay and leave. She had people waiting. What the what? I understand it's a holiday. I get it. But the check was large and you only allow for one hour for a large party. Seriously. Money hungry. Food mediocre at best Server came to table twice. Once for drinks. Second with check. Never checked to see if we were enjoying. Nada. Unbelievable read more

First time stopping in and our family of four all give this place a 5/5 rating. Great service and speeding food. We definitely recommend! read more

Potters Farm to Fork - Kids Macaroni & Cheese - Diners Near Me - Port Byron, New York

Stopped here on the way back from a road trip. Was worth driving a few miles off the way. Definitely what I would call comfort food, and friendly service. Also very kid friendly. There's also a nice ice cream stand next door. read more

Potters Farm to Fork - Dining area - Diners Near Me - Port Byron, New York

See all

This place has only been open a few months, but we were finally able to stop in a check it out. We got there after all the lunch rush on a weekday afternoon and were seated immediately. It was really hard to decide what to order. I wanted to try just about everything! I was in the mood for fish though and that was on the specials board. I ordered it with the Mac 'n Cheese and my boyfriend got it with fries. We were both very pleased. The fish came in several chunks that were coated in panko and deep fried. I tried a few if his fries and they were really good. I think they may have been coated in something before frying as well. The real hit, however, was the Mac! It was delicious! Not sure how they made it, but I ate every bit and if I were at home instead of in a restaurant I would have licked the plate!! Potters also has a cool gimmick if you are from the area. The restaurant is located in Port Byron right between PB and Weedsport and these schools have had a longstanding rivalry. If you order one of the huge, stuffed baked potatoes they will donate a $1 to the school alumni association of your choice and they have a "scoreboard" to let everyone know who is ahead in the baked potato rivalry. Fun and for a good cause. I'm excited about stopping in again sometime and trying other things on their menu. As a small town local restaurant I wish them all the luck!! read more

We had a long drive home ahead of us and my hubby said to look for farm to table. We started with the poutine which was so delicious! I then had the open faced turkey sandwich with real mashed potatoes. They had some octoberfest specials which my husband had and said reminded him of his German neighbors food as a kid. Wish we had room for dessert. Such a great local place read more

We decided to try them again and they redeemed themselves the wings were really good. Service was excellent it's clean and organized.

Took a chance during our long drive and we were so pleased! The service was wonderful and my open-faced turkey platter with mashed was absolutely delicious! The hub totally enjoyed his bacon cheeseburger and fries When we first arrived, there were just a few cars, but it was jamming by the time we left. Octoberfest menu and music underway! read more

Love the place had a nice hometown field to it was busy, but didn't feel cramped. The ambience and vibe of the place was nice. The food was delicious. Highly recommend the fried cheese curds. read more

Wow! Worth the very short trip off I 90. Delicious grilled cheese, balsamic chicken sandwich, poutine, Mac salad and Mac and cheese! read more

See all

Stopped in at the end of long day, and it was my birthday. I hadn't gotten to celebrate with family that day since we were all working on my husband's film nearby, so it was an incredible surprise when I walked in to pick up my balsamic chicken and Greek salad order to find a gluten free chocolate cake in the bakery cabinet! It was a delicious devil's food cake that felt like a warm hug on a special day. The balsamic chicken was perfect. Simple, balanced, and fresh. The salad was large than expected. Everything was just delicious and felt homemade. The waitress inside was friendly, even at the end of their day, when I'm sure she was ready to go home. Hidden treasure! read more

Potters Farm to Fork - Hidden gem! - Diners Near Me - Port Byron, New York

A great and very interesting menu and wonderful staff! We will be back! They have room for large parties.

Great local place, came for breakfast and the food was great, portion sizes were great and the waitress was so kind and very attentive. Cute place with plenty of room. They do have an up charge if you use a card, I recommend bringing cash. But no complaints! Overall very good restaurant. read more

I got the pulled pork and Mac and cheese. Very good. Large portions and fast service. Another in our party got the pot roast with gravy over bread. Looked wonderful. Glutin free Mac and cheese available. We also got the haddock which was good read more

Been a semi-regular customer. Minor issues in the past but this visit was a nightmare. Breakfast take out. (Our wedding anniversary 7/16/2025) The omelet I ordered was greasy. Someone obviously didn't think to drain off the grease. Ordered the same prior to this and other than a little fatty it's been good. Also the toast was barely toasted and limp. Toast should be packaged separately so it doesn't get soggy. Later that day we ordered dinner for take out. Cheese curds were greasy. We've ordered these before and they weren't that way. Our main course were boneless chicken wings. Also greasy. Way to much batter coating on them in addition to them being over saturated with two types of sauce. Later that night I started to feel ill. Up in the middle of the night and all the next day getting sick from the overload of grease. Spent most of my day in the bathroom getting sick and not being able to eat or sleep. How hard is it to drain off fat and grease before serving a meal ?? We eat pretty heart healthy the majority of time. Wanted to do something different. Had no clue I'd be sick and have to pay for it the whole next day. Hope you'll correct this before someone else gets sick. read more

Service and food were outstanding!!! I do t live in that area, I live in Georgia but was up for my dad's funeral. I ended up seeing friends from my youth eating there so it was perfect!! read more

I'm very happy this restaurant is fairly close to my house and I like to go to local family run business. It is very cute inside and was greeted right away and my sister and I sat at a booth. Inside is decorated farm style and very cute. I had a Mac and cheese with brisket and my sister a club sandwich on sourdough bread. They both were huge portions and very good! I took more than half of mine home. I was told the pies were homemade from other reviews but today some were not. I choose the raspberry with ice cream and my sister the coconut cream. I think I'm a pie snob so I'm picky but mine was very runny and the crust was just ok. My sisters had too much whip cream and not enough filling. I would have given 5 stars but I just don't think the pies were that great. I will go back for the food and skip the pie. They charge a fee for takeout containers so bring your own ( they encourage it). The portions are big you will be bringing food home. read more

See all

This place is great ! Food was delicious and staff was very nice. I had the open face turkey sandwich and a side of Mac and cheese. I couldn't eat it all. The Mac and cheese was creamy and tasted out of this world ! It tasted like a blend of several cheeses were used. The hot turkey was real turkey with mashed potatoes and gravy. The atmosphere was country/farm related and very attractive. We drove an hour to get there and we will do it again. read more

Great place, great food, great employees!!! They will even make things that aren't on their menu. I wish I had a picture. My grandkids ordered waffles and once they got them they asked for whip cream, blueberries, and a strawberry to make a face on the waffles and the waitress kept getting their stuff and did it happily read more

Great food but need more cooks, serving personnel and better coordination. We have been here 3 times and it takes 45-1 hr to finally get your food. read more

Totally unassuming little building on the side of the road, it may be easy to miss! Beautifully newly renovated inside, with lots of cool farm memorabilia on the walls. Huge menu with tons of deliciousness to choose from! I went with the garbage plate, it was awesome. The sauce was a smidge heavy on a fragrant spice, maybe cinnamon or allspice. The Mac and Cheese on my garbage plate was excellent (also, Mac and Cheese on a garbage plate, what?! Heck yes!) They have these gigantic one pound potatoes that you can get stuffed with a variety of options, and $1 is donated to a local school (Weedsport or Port Byron) I'll probably try that next! The appetizers are also great, we got the poutine, my friends got the jalapeño poppers, both delicious. Biggest tip I can give you: SAVE ROOM FOR DESSERT! Ugh the FOMO is still stinging, I filled up on my garbage plate and totally didn't consider all of the amazing dessert offerings. My friends got a berry cobbler with ice cream, it seriously looked so amazing I'm considering going back just for that cobbler! read more

Potters Farm to Fork - Tanner's plate garbage plate (two cheeseburgers and mac and cheese) - Diners Near Me - Port Byron, New York

Wow, this place was outstanding! The portions are so big. And the nightly specials are great. The chicken parm and mac was insanely big but delicious. I got one of the burger specials, which came with 2 patties, bacon, blue cheese, onion straws, and horseradish. Fries were also very good. The cheese curds were fresh and crunchy. The side salad was a good size. We beat the rush and had great service. It did get very busy just as we were leaving. read more

Potters Farm to Fork - Huge serving of cheese curds, more than half gone. - Diners Near Me - Port Byron, New York

See all

I wanted to like this place so so much. I've had the popcorn chicken, the fried fish, mac and cheese and fettuccine alfredo. The popcorn chicken was good, the fried fish tasted like straight cinnamon? and the mac and cheese and alfredo sauce tasted the same?? Alfredo sauce is supposed to have a parmesan base and I didn't taste any Parmesan and it needed a lot of salt. The staff is friendly but the food is barely mid... just constructive criticism... read more

Great breakfast! French toast with bananas, peanut butter and chocolate syrup is a marvelous treat, butcher's frittata is loaded with shaved prime rib, cheese and home fries. Nicest folks, too. Wish I'd saved room for a slice of pie. read more

See all

Great variety of decadent, stick to your ribs fare. I enjoyed the Mac and cheese with brisket and a fresh salad. It's a bit in the middle of nowhere but it was a nice change from fast food as we travel home. Super fast, friendly service. read more

Delicious breakfast! Big group of us for a birthday celebration. We were seated at a large table that accommodated all of us. Our waitress Candy was very pleasant, experienced and very efficient. The breakfasts all came out together, hot and all the special orders perfect. There were several Egg Benedict specials this morning. My husband had the Irish Benny made with sliced corned beef - looked delicious! The restaurant is updated and pleasantly decorated with photos of area farms, a large mural of the Potter Family farm. Owners Brian and Bonnie came out and visited our table. Overall a great experience. read more

See all

My brother and I had lunch here (his turn to buy) and we were served by a friendly waitress. The food was good, nice portions, but nothing stellar. He made some small request (can't remember what) that normally would have been free gratis about anywhere and was charged quite a bit for it. Knowing restaurants are not a 'Get rich quickly' business, I understood, but he'll never go back. It doesn't take much to ruin a reputation these days, so the better a profit margin is hidden, the better it is for all. As for the atmosphere, there were some improvements (over the previous ownership, Brenda's) but still needs more work to warrant charging extra for little incidentals. read more