Decent variety of flavors to pick from. The place is great during the summer months when you want a…read moresweet, cold treat. They have a big menu with even some flavored sodas. The toppings for sundae or even the ice cream are really good. They have many to pick from! Love that they have waffle cones, those are delicious. They even offer pints if you want some ice cream to go. This location serve Chocolate Shoppe ice cream, I think the store has about 30 if not more options to pick from. Service is always good. When it's busy, have patience, everyone is doing what they can to serve the customers. Location has been clean each time we went in. Pricing is on the higher end, but I find it worth it. Just wish they had bubble gum flavor!

Such a cute ice cream shop! The perfect location, just down the street from the lake and right next…read moreto the Glacial Drumlin State Trail. The building is newly renovated with a good sized parking lot, bike racks, and outdoor seating. I love the shop decor and their fun colored walls. They have delicious Chocolate Shoppe ice cream. I had "heaps of love" in a homemade waffle cone, it was delicious! They have tons of flavors, sundaes, pints, etc. They also sell candy and shop t-shirts. The staff is extremely welcoming and friendly. A great first time at Jerzey Junction, can't wait to go back! Lake Mills is lucky to have them.

So I drive by this all the time on my way to Madison. Have been wanting to stop for a long time and…read moreit's never been open on the day I would drive by. So today it was open. So excited to try it. Everything in there looks so delicious. It was a hard choice. I opted for the Keylime pie. OMG so yummy. It was the perfect balance not too sweet not too fluffy. It had a good base. It wasn't too thick. It wasn't too fluffy it was just perfectly balance between the crust, the filling and the topping and not overpowering with anyone of the flavors we did have the lemon bar ice cream that was very delicious tasted just like a lemon bar and then we did get a lemon bar and have not tried it yet. I'll give you an update when we eat it but if it's as good as the Keylime fantastic. The lady behind the counter said she was the owner so sweet nice lady like definitely a place you wanna go. If you're ever in the area stop by. Or if you're near here, it's definitely worth going out of your way to find. Would definitely like to try lunch sometime. Very cute interior.

The owner was very generous sharing all the delicious unique flavors as samples before we ordered…read more It was hard to decide with so many options but I went with a scoop of cherry almond and a scoop of Purple Moon (citrus/almond flavor). Very friendly service, bright clean store with comfortable outdoor seating!

The owner was super nice, just as everyone mentioned. She clearly loves the shop and the ice cream…read moreher family produces out of Milwaukee. You don't need to ask for samples, she'll just start handing them out. Their flavors are inspired and unique but still have classics available. The mint cookie crunch was exactly what you would expect, they don't have smaller cups so no matter what size you get the same one. I got the cherry almond which was good, but could have had more almond in it. It was very distinctly almond extract flavored. Otherwise, I didn't love all the flavors but appreciated all that they were trying to do

I love the frostie freeze. After trying it one time I was completely sold. I will be back. Thank…read moreyou for all you do there. Best ice cream in town.

If you're looking for a slice of small town Americana, you'll find it here. It also doubles as the…read morelocal hub for teens. There's about a dozen parking spaces here and thankfully they do have a drive up window. This place was founded in 1983 and the prices on the menu seem to reflect the same time period. A large sundae and large dip cone with tax is $10. If you plan on visiting, you need to know that they do not accept credit cards, only cash and believe it or not............personal checks! There's no indoor dining, just picnic tables situated outside. Not sure how that works in January. Coming here was like stepping back in time.

Okay. I hate that I have to leave this review... Timber Creek has always been a stand up place. But…read moremy recent experiences here have been awful. They just keep getting worse too! The girl I've encountered in this place has the worst attitude. She's stared at me (like stared me dead in the eyes for multiple minutes straight while I was ordering) and made me feel super uncomfortable. She's never acknowledged customers when I've been in there and saw her. Then she made me a sub today that I can only describe as scary. The lettuce was brown and the meat was slimy. I didn't even eat it. $15 out the window. The poor guy who was working with her was incredibly nice however was clearly not trained in the slightest. He didn't even know if they had mint ice cream. Let alone what was in it. He also didn't know how to use the cash register. And let's face it he was alone with Miss Personality and I would be scared to ask her a question too if I were in his shoes. Also the interior is beginning to look more and more like someone's garage sale. There's crap everywhere. The counter shouldn't be so cluttered with ratty dirty signs that you can't even pay your bill without have to step around the corner and almost put it in the register yourself. There was junk mail wedged in some of the signs too. Random pieces of paper advertising specials but could just be scraps of paper. I love the cabin decor but the grinch costume clearly being stored in the corner of the front window needs to go. As well as the two elf on the shelf toys that make reading the already cluttered menu difficult. The arcade games are a nice touch but shouldn't be right next to the register. There's so much going on in that corner and it makes it hard to order. I don't know what happened to this place. This was one of our favorite places especially in the summer. And was one of the reasons we moved here.

Pizza was mid at best. Freezer quality pizza. It took 45 minutes for this pizza. They also gave it…read moreoff to the wrong table twice. Staff were snotty and rude. Tables were dirty. Soda was flat, water came out pink. We regret not going to McDonalds

This shop was right across the street from our hotel. We decided to check it out and we were not…read moredisappointed. They didn't have a lot of flavors but I did feel like they had pretty unique flavors so I loved that. My mom & I split a flight. We enjoyed all 4 flavors we tried, the peaches, peaches, peaches one was probably one of my favs. It was a smaller shop, only a couple of seats to dine in but I did see that people were sitting outside so that's an option.

Madison is lacking in good, artisanal ice cream spots - but this one fills that gap tremendously!…read moreThat and the business's continued mission of donating a portion of their profits to local social justice organizations makes it a no-brainer for you to stop by and spend your money here. This is my must-go spot when I have friends visiting from out of town. The flavors are constantly rotating, but if you follow their Instagram they update it with whats in stock. There is some indoor seating and outdoor as well during the summer months. I don't think I've ever had anything I *disliked* here. But the stand out flavors for me includes: lavender honeycomb, harvest moon, and fluffy the mint slayer!

Excellent ice cream! Huge variety of flavors. Portions are huge which makes prices a better value…read morethan meets the wallet. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable - also patient with first time customers like ourselves. Though I haven't been to other ice creameries in the Lake Geneva area, this place really impressed me. Note: I don't think there was any indoor seating.

Small line when we got there but they move quick!! We…read moreordered at the window and the menu was posted a couple times so you can look before you get to front of line. They have a ton of options! I got brownie cascade and it was delish! I love the little chocolate caramel candy in it. My fiancé got the mint chip.

We were passing through the area with the grandkids so we scheduled a tour and lunch. Got there…read moreearly, so had an early lunch of grilled cheese sandwiches and soup or chips. My habanero grilled cheese and chips were very good, and everyone liked their sandwich and soups. Kids meal included ice cream, which was very good. We enjoyed the tour; especially the grandkids who loved seeing and petting the goats and cows. Nice clean bright facility with friendly service and family atmosphere.

We went on a Thursday in November at 11 am…read more Food 3/5: if you like grilled cheese and nothing else, this will be your favorite stop. Overall not many options besides grilled cheese. We all got grilled cheese variations with apples, salad and soup as sides. The chicken bacon ranch grilled cheese was overall the best. Both of the salads had rotten leaves, so best to avoid that unless you're ok picking through for good leaves. Service 5/5: the food came quickly and the staff was very friendly. Ambiance 1/5: we were very disappointed overall since they hype themselves up as an experience that includes cows. There were no cows in sight. I know during the summertime they will have baby cows, but overall to me there should be more transparency around not actually seeing cows when you visit the creamery. Other than that there is a small parking lot that can get very busy at times, but plenty of places to sit. We did love the kids playground outside but all of the bikes were broken/didn't work and the bags put away for corn hole. Overall we were really disappointed at this trip. No cows and lunch was just ok. If you are looking for a spot just for ice cream, they have amazing options and plenty of room for the kids to play, just don't tell your kids there are cows because you likely won't see any.

New ice cream shop in town! Went for opening day and there are definitely some fun flavors on the…read moremenu. They have a wide variety of Babcock ice creams to choose from for cones and dishes and there are unique flavors of shakes, floats, and sundaes. We ended up ordering the cold brew coffee float which features Let It Ride cold brew coffee and the hot honey mango shake. Both were quite tasty, but the shake was a standout. It's a flavor we haven't seen around Madison before and it's wonderfully balanced between the sweetness of the mango and the slight spicing of the hot honey to make a delightful shake. Staff was very friendly and we were able to try some samples of the ice creams to decide what we wanted. There is also a nice patio setup off of the bike path in the back. As it was opening day, they are still working out some kinks and working on some fun other options for the menu. We spoke to the owner and it sounds like there will be some vegan options coming in the very near future in some sorbets.

I was there on a Saturday evening. This is an ice cream counter, there is no indoor seating. There…read moreare some outdoor tables behind though. I went for a 4 scoop - churo, Berry proud parent, s'more years, Irish cream. S'more years was my favorite followed by churo. Berry proud parent was also a good flavor. Irish cream was ok.

On our way home from Madison we were looking for a local ice cream stand. The great reviews brought…read moreus to Cone Zone. On a Sunday afternoon the place was packed including the drive up line extending into High Street. No biggie, we parked next door at the auto shop. The cones here are HUGE and the ice cream is very good. I really should've gotten a smaller one. Cone Zone was a great stop and we'll definitely be back.

Make sure to take cash! You do not want to miss out on this experience! It is a cash only…read moreestablishment. The value and quality are worth the detour. Our threesome had two of the large "Creations" (lots of choices for add-ins) and a Turtle Brownie Sundae. The large even left the teen boy saying, "that was a lot!" We all received generous amounts for our money. The vanilla and chocolate base flavors were excellent, with the chocolate having a rich slightly dark taste, making it stand out from other similar soft serve ice creams. It is order at the window place, with plenty of outdoor seating in a small community setting. Even on a mid Thursday afternoon there was a steady stream of customers.