This is an excellent place. Great atmosphere. Food and drinks were outstanding. Kevin was a very…read moregood waiter and very helpful. Would definitely go there again. Highly recommend

Great restaurant on the waterfront of New Buffalo inside the Marina Grand Resort. They have a…read morefantastic bar along with some of the best seafood in the area. They also house a bunch of locally brewed drafts along with harvesting locally. The staff is very friendly and the ambiance is very relaxed. I highly recommend making a reservation.

They won't allow gay and lesbian patrons to enter and hide behind the guise of it being "members…read moreonly". Oddly enough when gay and lesbian individuals try applying for membership they wind up getting silence in response to questions on the process to join up. Steer clear from this throwback to a more hateful time and head to other options around town.

This is a fun kind of retro hangout. You have to be a member to get in but its open year around so…read moreit's a reliably good place for dinner when every place in new buffalo is jammed in the summer and also good for a leisurely repast in the colder times. A limited menu of appetizers and sandwiches and a respectable entree section as well. They even have a vegetable napoleon made with mushrooms, eggplant and asparagus and drizzled with balsamic that is worth the trip by itself. The broasted chicken is another personal favorite. Still got to say the vibe of a 1950s yachting experience is a throwback to another simpler time and place. Hard to beat that!

We had a fantastic lunch at The Stray Dog in New Buffalo! It was busy when we arrived, so there was…read morea short wait, but it was well worth it. We grabbed a beer and a glass of wine at the bar while we waited. The atmosphere is one of my favorite things about this restaurant. It's open, welcoming, and full of personality. I loved all of the dog photos throughout the restaurant and their "Sit. Stay. Eat!" theme, it gives the place such a fun, relaxed vibe. The menu is awesome, I honestly had a hard time deciding because everything sounded so good. We started with the truffle fries and they were incredible. For my entrée, I chose the grilled red snapper tacos, they were delicious. The fresh pineapple salsa paired perfectly with the fish, and I especially loved the pickled red cabbage on top. The snapper was grilled perfect. My husband and daughter shared the grilled shrimp po'boy which turned out to be a great decision because it's a generous-sized sandwich. They both liked the Cajun remoulade sauce and the soft telera roll it was served on. They also ordered a side of onion rings. My son enjoyed the cheeseburger from the kids menu. Our server was friendly and attentive. The Stray Dog has great food, a fun atmosphere, and excellent service. It's easy to see why it's such a popular spot. We will definitely be back the next time we're in New Buffalo!

Went here for our second visit to celebrate my husband's early birthday. We sat on the rooftop and…read morethe wait was less than expected (excellent)! We ordered the poppers as an appetizer- so delicious and so many in the order. My husband got the spicy chicken sandwich and I got the el Diablo burger (veggie burger version). We also shared an order of onion rings. Everything was so delicious and filling and wonderful. We probably could have skipped the onion rings, but we still enjoyed them. Our waitress was great and the scenery was even better. Will hopefully return for a third trip!

The staff was great! I got the harbor burger and it was soooo good. Homemade ranch and delicious…read morefries. :) My only downside was I did feel like everything was a little under seasoned. I wish I had sat outdoors, but it's more of a bar! So just be prepared for that. :) It was quiet and laid back at lunch time on a Saturday which is always a plus

We had dinner tonight at Casey's New Buffalo, and it was such a wonderful experience from start to…read morefinish. The food was absolutely delicious, but what truly made our visit special was the outstanding service and their genuine dog-friendly atmosphere. Our waitress, Julia, went above and beyond--she even surprised our dog with a pup cup, which was such a thoughtful touch and made us feel incredibly welcome. That level of kindness and attention really added to the enjoyment of our meal. If you're visiting, we highly recommend: * Perch Po' Boy * Perch Fish and Chips * Mahi-mahi Fish Tacos * And definitely start with the housemade chips with sour cream dip--it's the way to go! Great food, excellent service, and a place that warmly welcomes furry family members--what more could you ask for? We will absolutely be back and highly recommend Casey's to anyone in the New Buffalo area.

We've been here at least three times. Sitting with windows wide open and not a mosquito or bird…read moreflying in to fuck up a meal. Last time I went their steak salad was delicious. Went today but they were out of steak. (Night before took care of that with meat eaters just like me.) Their chicken salad was just as good. My wife enjoyed the Ida Benedict. She licked the plate.

Casual, open (loud) dining room with a full bar. Sandwiches look massive (certainly shareable)…read more Unfortunately, the menu pictures here don't match the current menu. I was really hoping for some clams casino and frutti di mare. But that's not the menu they have now. So, the sausage franconello was a really good choice, instead. I was hoping the roasted potatoes would be crispy on the edges, and they were at some point. But then it appears the whole dish (all the peppers, onions, mushrooms, potatoes, and sausage) were sautéed together until the potatoes lost all the roasty crispness. And the sausage was excellent. Good, friendly service, good food, certainly a place worth checking out.

The service was ridiculously slow. Took over 10 min to get a drink, 20+ min to get the salad and…read moreanother 20+ min for entree. The restaurant was not busy. There were no apologies made nor any excuses given. It appears this is SOP. They are also not afraid to charge $$$$. $17 for a side salad without protein, $8 for a Miller light, $17 for a mixed drink. Do they think they are in NYC??? The dinner was ok. Nothing to write home about. The dessert was over cooked. It was supposed to be beignets however the were flavorless rocks. The entire restaurant looks like it is a poorly decorated dorm room with the strings of twinkle lights.

Never disappointed. The food is always wonderfully…read moreprepared. Great quality. The service is top notch. Very attentive servers and busses. The ambiance is comfortable, a little on the loud side but everyone is having fun!. If you love soft zhell crab when its in season, Timothy's does zn amazing dish ! Thank you to Ayla and Samantha (Servers) for a wonderful meal.

Great service, food, cocktails and patio. Wish the patio music didn't carry throughout the…read moreneighborhood. Added. Music reference is to streamed music. The live music of 6/21 made me wish our dinner plans were to go to UPS for that experience.

Excellent food and beverage options! Amy our server was…read morefantastic! We had 6 adults and 2 kids , she never missed a beat :) The restaurant is clean and flows well.

Back again for supper. Must start out to recognize Erica, our server. She was gracious and very…read morewelcoming. Excellent service. My wife ordered the moderate cut prime rib, medium well. Cooked to perfection, very tasty. I had the one fillet of walleye fish, Sautéed in butter. Excellent. Side dish of squash. This place is one of our favorites when we visit the casino. Again great service and wonderful menu. Great place for Seniors like us.

The service was very good. The server was dope attentive, being at the table before we needed…read moresomething. I had the prime rib with baked potatoe and salad. The garlic ranch dressing was incredible. It was creamy and just the right amount of garlic. My prime rib was cooked perfectly and very tender. I liked the flavor and it was not loaded with salt. My wife loved her walleye.

Our server Stephan was outstanding! Give her a raise. The…read morefood was ok, The beer was good. Sorry.... Not a fan of the deviled eggs. The Seasonal Berry Salad was skimpy for the price point. The carrot cake was dry. 10 for service 5 for food

Afte ordering, food did not arrive. Was not told when seated or ordering that there was a…read moresignificant delay for food. I told the manager I wished to cancel and leave. Was charged nonetheless. Recommend better options with faster service in downtown New Buffalo. Do not recommend Kankakee Grille New Buffalo.

The food was no better than an Old Country Buffet restaurant. Lots of over cooked food or sitting…read morefor a while food. I took no photos because it wasn't photo worthy. We were there on a Wednesday which is their "all American" day. Would have much rather tried Thursday Seafood Day or weekend prime Rib day.

I went to buffet on Wednesday. The price was 35bucks. My husband and I paid 35+35+ tax 4... so…read moreit's a total of 75 bucks. I want to say... I reallyyyyyyy love Wednesday buffet also!!!!it's not included a sushi. But it's still have many meat and food in there. Pot roast, turkey, pork belly, chicken, bufflao wings, rib and other meats food a lot. And Chinese food ... And Mexican also.. I like Mexican rice. Actually, pork belly was another level! But I couldn't eat pizza. Because it's almost sold. And the left few piece was so cold, and hard... I went to there 3 times... but it's was still same. And I'm kinda sad... Italy food was not that much... I expected a pasta stuff... But no spaghetti no Alfredo pasta...