I can't believe this place has such a mediocre yelp review rating. Is it a conspiracy from rival pizza parlors?? This place is my hero whenever I'm driving my son nearby for basketball games and practices. The food is reliability good. Pizzas and pastas are great and prices are reasonable too. It's a throwback hole in the wall type of place that reminds me of back in the day in Brooklyn. I had the linguine with broccoli rabe and grilled chicken and it was superb. The portions were huge and there was so much chopped garlic and olive oil to create and maximize the flavor which I really appreciated. The margherita pies here are top class too. They aren't salty unlike most other pizza shops but taste great with the fresh cheese and basil. Romeos is a hidden gem and a bright side for trekking to the Manalapan area. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Linguine with broccoli rabe and grilled chicken - Pizza Near Me - Manalapan, New Jersey

Good food. Love the subs and cheese steaks. Gennaro is a great guy from a good family. Def a go to place

This was the worst pizza I've had in my entire life. Ordered an x-large cheese pizza and it was missing about 40% of the cheese that the same order at Vinnie's & Krispy Freehold gives you (see picture of Romeo's pie). The sauce is extremely sweet. The wings were actually really good but you have to pay $1 each for a semi-filled soufflé cup of blue cheese which would automatically come with any order of wings from any other place in the area, chain & independently owned. If you like to be nickel and dimed, this is your place! read more

Romeo's Pizza - X-large 18" Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manalapan, New Jersey

See all

If you're in the Manalapan area near Rt. 33 and looking for some delicious Italian food, look no further than Romeo's Pizza. This restaurant has it all: amazing red sauce, great salad dressing, friendly staff, and some of the best pizza in the area. One of the things that sets Romeo's Pizza apart from other restaurants is their amazing red sauce. It's rich, flavorful, and perfectly complements any pasta or pizza dish you might order. I usually get the Chicken Parm dinner or pizza, and I love adding meatballs to my pizza too. The pies are XL and huge compared to other pizza places in the area. The staff is always friendly and efficient, even on busy Friday and Saturday nights when the place is packed with to-go orders. Despite the crowds, they always manage to get people in and out quickly. One thing I particularly love about Romeo's Pizza is that they offer heart-shaped pizzas on Valentine's Day. It's such a fun and unique way to celebrate the holiday with your loved ones, and my family absolutely loved it when we ordered one. This place is a go-to for me and never disappoints. read more

Romeo's Pizza - Heart Shaped Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manalapan, New Jersey

Large menu ,great service, willing to talk to you and recommend items on the menu. Takes the extra step to make you feel like your business is important! There's a steady crowd and has been in business 23 years! read more

Last night I threw my husband a surprise birthday party. I originally ordered Walmart catering and when I went to go pick the food up, they did not make it. So I had no idea what I was feeding 25 ppl at a party that started in 30minutes. I called Romeo's and they came to my rescue! the guy on the phone was amazing and gave me everything I needed. not only that but they delivered everything early then expected! I am beyond grateful for everyone that works there! And the food was amazing!! read more

Disgusting, watery, greasy and tasteless! Vodka sauce is horrible! A 1st and a last. Note the photos of how my ordered was delivered. Never again read more

Romeo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manalapan, New Jersey

See all

My job buys their pies on occasion and they're just as good as the other pizza houses I grew up knowing

I found myself dying for one of the cauliflower crust veggie pizzas! It was so delicious I had to eat a slice in the car. It would take me hours to cut that many vegetables and make a pizza and it could never be as delicious as it is from Romeos! read more

Romeo's Pizza - Cauliflower crust veggie pizza, delicious - Pizza Near Me - Manalapan, New Jersey

The food is amazing! They have so many great options here. You can order wings, pasta, Pizza, sandwich's, wraps and many more. The service is also good. The only thing I would change about the place is the seating. The seating can be a little tight and not spacious. read more

Best food ever from pizza to dinners and OMG their salads are addictive!!!All the employees and owner are so professional and hard working !!!Cute and cozy place and very clean!!!I love this place and so will you!!!For sure one of my favs!!!Keep up the good work Team Romeo!!!! read more

HANDS DOWN ABSOLUTELY GREAT EVERY TIME! the difference between this place and the rest is, everything on the menu is great. From pizza to chicken to wraps and healthy alternatives, you will not find a better, more consistant restaurant. Thank you Rino for continuously bringing quality first!!! read more

Honestly this place is good but also bad. For example, the pizza is great especially the meat lovers pizza. One thing that I dislike about romeos is the cheesesteak, the meat is so dry and cardboardey. Overall this place is mid. read more

Amazing Pizzeria best in Central Jersey. Loved everything on the menu I tried so far.

Service is pretty. They have a consistent customer base. Catering is above average. Stores appearance is a typical pizza joint. The pizza which I have tried several times over the years is not my favorite. The rating is based heavily on the pizza. read more

Romeos pizza is our hometown favorite. We must order from Romeos three or four times a week and we're never disappointed. The food is always delicious and the customer service is always friendly. We are very lucky to have such a great pizzeria. From wings, cheeseburgers and pasta hands down delicious. Family owned and family dedicated to our community. Bravo read more

The best vodka and scampi sauce! Love love love Romeo's food and staff! Simply the best

Convenience is what it has going for it... Cleanliness is not. This place always feels like there is a layer of grime everywhere. They constantly use the 4th booth for staging boxes, deliveries.,etc., so that only leaves 3 tables to eat-in and the space is very tight. In my opinion the pizza is "doughy" and the sauce too sweet. Grab a quick slice there?... Maybe. Eat a meal? Nope - I go another 2 miles down rt. 33 to Tre Colore whenever possible. read more

I don't know what happen to this place but it is going down hill fast ... forget that the pasts sauce had more water in then my glass. That could be a new person just don't know they have to drain pasts before plating... but when I order pizza and ask the person for EXTRA well done and they write on the ticket and get a half cooked soggy pizza for the 2nd time .. just need to find a new place .. if you order from here don't waste your time asking for your pizza the way you want it cause your not going to it ! read more

Romeo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manalapan, New Jersey

Sign on door says "no mask - no entry" Any restaurant who knowingly and willingly ignores and violates healthful practices during this horrendous pandemic should not be patronized. Sun 10/25/20 7pm That being said, 5 young men were behind the counter. 3 of whom had NO MASKS whatsoever; one was prepping pizza dough; one was packing food for delivery etc; one was performing kitchen duties and came briefly to the front. Two others had masks BELOW their NOSES; one young man handled and packed freshly made food; another handed it off to delivery persons and customers. A sixth man, older than the others and probably the MANAGER/OWNER, who wore NO MASK at all. Enough said. read more

Love the Flounder Francaise and the white spinach pie !!!! I moved from Brooklyn to Staten Island to Jersey and the pizza is awesome here

When I'm done working a shift at the county jail I have to stop at Romeos and pick up at least one cheesesteak pizza slice, one rice ball, and one other specialty slice before heading home. Fast and friendly service!!! One specialty slice can be a meal for a normal person.. these suckers are huge and cheap!! $3 SPEC slice and $4 for the cheesesteak slice which is a steal. See my pics. Rice balls beat out every local pizzeria within a 15 mile radius. read more

See all

It's a casual pizza place that does mostly take-out & delivery. We were at nearby Sportika for a basketball tournament and had 90 min to grab dinner between games. This was the perfect spot! They have a large menu with everything from vegan wraps to the meat lovers Stromboli. The Eisenhower (spinach, eggplant, roasted peppers, balsamic vinegar) hot sub, Milan (ham, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni & mozzarella) Stromboli & white broccoli pizza were all delicious. The $7 small garden salad was huge! We finished it off with some cannoli to go. The service was fast and personable. Would definitely stop by if we are in the area again! read more

The baked ziti was the worst I have ever seen. To help them get better, they should at least use some of the better store bought jar sauce. The better ones I have routinely bought have cheese mixed in, usually 2 or 3 types. Garlic might also help the ziti/pasta Bacos pizza is much better The chicken strips were over cooked, hard, dry and very thin. To improve the strips, try buying wegmans organic chicken tenderloins. Also they need a better honey mustard sauce. read more

One of my favorite pizza joints in Jersey. I prefer this location over the other two Romeo's. It's a small place in a strip mall off of 33. In all my years of going here, I've never had a bad pizza. Its the traditional big NYC slice- the kind you fold with your hands, the way pizza was meant to be eaten. The crust, cheese and sauce are all delicious. We even ordered the fried ravioli this time (not on the menu), and they whipped us up a batch. I'm going to keep coming back without question. read more

Delicious pizza every time!!! Love the penne vodka pizza!! Best sauce I've ever had.

I've never been a fan of their pizza but my son told me the food was pretty good so we decided to give it a try. What a mistake. I ordered mussels marinara and the were gritty and overcooked. My husband ordered pasta with clam sauce and if was completely bland. $75 later and all I can say was that it was one of the worst Italian take out experiences ever. Never again! read more

I can not even put into words what this means to us!!! My husband was recently fired from his job leaving our family of 7 in a very scary situation! Gennaro came across a post about our family and wanted to donate food to us for New Year's Eve to help us with hope of a fresh start. Let me just tell you this is beyond touching and OMG sooooo DELICIOUS!!! Thank you so much Gennaro Romeo and your amazing pizzeria familia for this wonderful food! Bless you all!!! Happy New Year all!!! Now we are gonna go eat! read more

See all

Romeo's never disappoints, their Romeo's salad, their veal dishes, and seafood dishes are amazing, their pizza is also the best in the area. Delivery service is always on time. read more

I was gonna give two stars, but I really can't. Every time my family and I order from Romeo's, it's bad/wrong/cold. We've dined in, had delivery, and catering trays. They just seem to be consistently poor quality and service. I really can't recommend them to anyone until they revamp their menu and get new cooks/delivery people. The pizza is shameful. The pasta is dry and flavorless. The salads are almost always wilting or starting to turn brown. The dressings taste like the plastic cans they come out of. I really recommend going literally anywhere else if you're in the mood for mediocre Italian fare. Sorry, Romeo's. Your Juliet is in another castle... probably having decent pizza with someone else. Just sayin. read more

Terrible stale pizza sits in the display for hours and looks rank. Terrible service and dirty. Workers don't wear rubber gloves and handle the food with their hands. Not to mention the sneezing that took place while I waited for my food which was 30 minutes late. Slobs. read more

Always a great place! They even delivered to the emergency waiting room for my grandson.10 stars!

We decided to order eggplant and veal parm subs- bread scooped out.minestrone soup ordered as well. Their eggplant meals are absolutely delicious. So many other pizzerias offer big thick slices that are deeply fried- Romeo's is super thin and well-seasoned! 20 minutes later, we had the most delicious and fresh tasting subs! The minestrone was also phe They are so easy to order from as well. Will keep ordering from here! read more

Would have done 0 stars if that was possible. Ordered my food and clearly gave my address, after waiting over an hour I called and they brought the food to the complete wrong address and were very rude. Told me they were gonna send another order and food never came. If you're looking for bad service I'd really recommend this place. read more

Love love love the food. Been going here for years when it was located at the old place. The owner always took care of me. Made me whatever I wanted. My favorite one time was a veal parm pizza with vodka sauce well done. It was so freakin good. I have no problem spending money on AMAZING food. Stick to the basics and you won't go wrong. If you got a problem talk to the owner and he will make it right. Ciao read more

I'm not one to come on here and make a negative review but damn! I ordered a vegan parm via the website and Moments later I got a text that my order was cancelled. A TEXT. We then called the place and the guy on the phone was incredibly nasty. I asked why was my order canceled he was giving me attitude that he's short staffed and that my $2 tip wasn't ok cause "it costs the driver more to get here" fuck off. No one tips delivery drivers astronomical amounts of money. Maybe try having adequate staff and try being nice to a potential new customer. Lost my business. Don't send me a menu if you're not going to deliver to my house. Also seek therapy man on on the phone thank u read more

Incredible pizza, chicken parmigiana and Italian salad! We normally get delivery. Super nice folks working there. Be sure to get the Tartufo (ice cream dessert). We even have that delivered without melting. read more

I don't usually write reviews but I will make an acception. Delicious food, always delivered on time. What more can you want.

Really really not good. The ingredients are not fresh and everything seems like it's been sitting for days. The service is so-so at best. This is the only place I've ever seen put red sauce on a buffalo chicken pizza. It was disgusting. There are many better pizza places in the area that I could name, but then you'd think I worked for one of them, so I won't bother. Stay away from this place, though. read more

I have eaten at hundreds of mom and pop pizza joints and this one definitely stands out with their pink cream sauce and the pepperoni roll. I have only been in the area a few weeks, but this is definitely going in regular rotation for take out and delivery. read more