My husband surprised me with a reservation here the second weekend they were open. We sat outside on the front patio and, although it was very chilly that night, we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves!!! Admittedly, I was hesitant for the opening of yet another Italian restaurant in the area since we already have quite a few (Amis, Tredici, Teresa's, Fellini's, Pietro's, etc) but I have to say I was very pleasantly surprised and I do believe Rosalie is unique enough to standout among the rest. Frankly, I find the poor reviews of Rosalie to be comical as it is not at all deserving of 1-2 stars, in any capacity.
Firstly, the space is absolutely stunning... which I was not surprised by since Fearless Restaurants are known for their unique and intriguing decor. Rosalie's interior is a far cry and most certainly an upgrade to what it was while Paramour occupied the space. In addition to the interior, the front porch is such a fun spot for tables and I hope they continue seating out here even if/when Covid is no longer the problem it is now.
Secondly, the staff was IMPECCABLE. I was truly surprised just how well they did. Even restaurants under the best names experience hiccups with service when they first open but everyone at Rosalie was fantastic only 10 days in and while navigating limitations due to Covid. We received our drinks quickly, food was timed just right, the staff was knowledgeable and helpful, water glasses were kept full, etc.
To address any 'issues' with the menu... are the dishes named in Italian? yes. Where there words I didn't know? of course. Can you ASK YOUR SERVER for clarification? most definitely (Also there's a thing called 'Google' if you're too proud for the former). If a menu is seemingly difficult to navigate that indicates, at least to me, a learning opportunity. Once upon a time I didn't know what Foie Gras was either... but you live and your learn. Not to mention, it should be expected that an Italian restaurant's dishes are named in Italian... no?
Now, my reasoning for 4 stars rather than 5 does have to do with the menu and that is this: the menu is a small plates/shareable/tapas type menu and I did find that, on several occasions, the portion sizes were small for the price. I'll explain...
We ordered two shareables, the Pork Shank Fritti and the Mushroom Suppli. Both are small (two per plate) and both were about $10?? To be honest, the pork shank fritti was the worst plate of the night and didn't have much flavor at all (needed more meat)- the plum mostarda was the saving grace. The suppli, however, was DIVINE. It's very similar to arancini and the mushroom filling was amazing. Next we ordered the beef tartare and the lamb skewers (I forget their Italian names and forgot to take a pic of the menu!). The beef tartare was a slightly larger plate (a tad pricey at around $18?) but it was, hands down, THE best dish we had all night. My husband and I both agreed we could've eaten the whole dish alone. The lamb skewers were very good but paled in comparison to the tartare. These, mind you, were another small plate with only 2 skewers but I forget what the price was. For our main courses, my husband ordered the agnolotti which, again, was VERY good but relatively small for the $20ish price tag (see pic). I ordered the gnocchi in brown butter, as recommended by our server, and it did NOT disappoint. These gnocchi were little fluffy clouds that melted in my mouth, so light they felt like air and THAT'S how you know gnocchi is done right. I was very impressed. This dish was a little more sizeable than the agnolotti. Lastly, we had to order dessert just to try... only a few options so we went with the olive oil cake which was prepared and presently perfectly. If you don't want anything overly sweet, this cake was sweet-tooth-satisfying without giving you a stomach ache. I did find the desserts to be appropriately priced. Another note: I am no expert in wine but the wine list seemed like a very comprehensive and approachable wine list- there were some VERY reasonable bottles (starting around $40ish) and there were some more intimidating bottles (ending around $300ish). The sommelier helped us choose a very good and relatively inexpensive Italian blend that we both enjoyed.
Overall, I have the highest of hopes for Rosalie. I will most certainly be back and I can't wait to try the rest of the menu. If Rosalie is anything like its sister restaurants, it will do well, if not better than them. read more