Rusty Jimmies

Third time here and they succeeded every time. 1) Had soft…read moreshell crab sandwiches - very tasty, plus corn on the cob which is always a nice add-on for me. 2) Ordered crabs packed to travel - beautifully packaged in a cooler with free ice plus extra Old Bay. 3) Got a half bushel of medium large crabs to go - made for a classic Maryland crab feast for 6 of us. Hot and tasty and all good sized with two claws still attached (not always the case at many places!) Nice family owned/operated business and just over the Delaware line from Ocean City which means the taxman took no share of our dinner! We'll be back.

We have ordered crabs from here in the past and they have been good by last night we paid $140 for…read morea dozen extra large crabs that were large at best and not fresh. They definitely reheated them! Very disappointed.

Bahama's Crabshack Carryout & Seafood Market

Shrimp

See all

Bahama Mamas Seafood Outlet

3.2(13 reviews)

0.2 mi

They are awesome! I got crab claws and theY were very good. They season them as you request. Thank…read morefor the excellent service I will return.

Awesome. Good shrimp and awesome crabs. The kingcrab is the best!!! Small outside eating area…read morethough. Really a take out place.

“The Best” Crabs Seafood Company

4.1(69 reviews)

0.4 mi

Ran out of medium/large crabs by 5 pm. Took 1/2 hour for the…read moreorder to be prepared. The food was good nonetheless.

I would try this place again. However, There were about 6-7 of our crabs overcooked out of 2 doz…read more They also put a ton of seasoning on the crabs so some had to be rinsed off. A few of the shrimp were also over cooked. As weekly seafood and crab eating connoisseurs we know immediately that when the meat of a crab is mushy it means it's over cooked. The size of the crabs were great as well ad the taste. Just couldn't enjoy them as usual because some were just over cooked.

See all

Blue crabs, crab legs, steamed shrimp, crab cakes.

Matt’s Fish Camp

4.2(229 reviews)

0.2 mi

This rating is only based on one dish that was ordered - the salmon kids meal…read more I ordered the salmon kids meal, subbed with mashed potatoes and green beans. Looks small in the container but was a decent amount of food when divided between two littles. Tasted delicious and wasn't overly seasoned - perfect for kids.

First and foremost, the service here was absolutely outstanding - the best I have ever had. Upon…read morearriving I noticed the trendy and inviting appearance of the restaurant both inside and out. It was also extremely clean in both the bar and the seating area. The menu has a range of fresh food, and everyone in our party had a few items to choose from for dinner. We ordered a seared tuna bowl, the rockfish, the catfish, a fried shrimp dish, and a fish sandwich. I do not say this lightly, it was all phenomenal. There was not one bad bite at the table. Whatever you decide to order, just get the house rolls. I could not write this review without mentioning our all-star server who was incredibly helpful and understanding to all but especially our teenager with autism. She was a godsend and was incredibly knowledgeable about Matt's Fish Camp. This place is a must if you are in the OC, Fenwick, or Bethany DE area.

Snickerdoodle ice cream sandwich with a carmel sauce

See all

Outdoor seating

Fenwick Tackle

4.0(7 reviews)

0.1 mi

Walked in for help on where to fish and licenses. Guy behind the counter didn't seem to want to…read morehelp. He just pointed at some Maryland dnr magazines and said it's in there. I needed bait and tackle too and was hoping to purchase all together. We are not from the area so just needed guidance.

In town for one week and my first time trying surf fishing. Didn't have any luck over my first two…read moredays so came here. They made some quick recommendations and offered a specific type of bait. Didn't upsell me. Super polite. And advice was spot on. Caught 3 in the first 2 hours.

JR's Seafood Shack

4.0(83 reviews)

0.7 mi

Found a great restaurant in Fenwick Island. Our waitress Stacy was great. Food came out quickly…read moreand was delicious. We had the low country boil, crab cake over corn salsa, and a salmon special. Tuesday is half off entrees. This restaurant is part of the Fins restaurant group.

Old school seafood restaurant decor. Went for happy hour twice. Lots of fried goodies and…read moreoysters. Fried shrimp and grouper were best. Big oysters the first night - not so big the second. $4 drafts and other drink specials. Nice staff. Older gentleman (owner/manager) made everything run smoothly.

Interior

Low Country Boil

See all

These Mahi Tacos are all you need this summer!

The Station

4.1(92 reviews)

0.7 mi

We had family sunset photos at Fenwick Island State Park with our two dogs, and The Station was the…read moreperfect place to end the evening with dinner outside. We arrived about an hour before closing, and even though the parking lot was very full, we had a great experience. I immediately loved the place settings and decor. Everything was so thoughtfully arranged, especially for an outdoor patio, and it created such a welcoming atmosphere. Our waitress was friendly and attentive and quickly brought out bowls of water for our dogs. It was a small gesture, but I really appreciated that she thought of them too. We were also very happy with our meals. My son and I both ordered the tuna rare, and it was cooked perfectly. The tuna practically melted in our mouths and was absolutely delicious. My husband had the fish sandwich and enjoyed his meal as well. The combination of the beautiful outdoor setting, great food, friendly service, and genuinely dog-friendly atmosphere made it a wonderful end to our evening. I would absolutely return with our dogs for another dinner!

This restaurant was so aesthetically pleasing. I'd describe the decor as effortlessly beach chic,…read moreand the atmosphere was definitely one of my favorite parts of the experience. I ordered the tuna poke bowl, which unfortunately was pretty mediocre. The tuna just didn't have much flavor and tasted a bit "meh." My husband ordered the shrimp and grits, though, and that was a completely different story. It was perfection. I loved that they use nice, thick shrimp, and the seasoning was excellent. The service was probably the biggest disappointment. Our server seemed visibly frustrated and rolled her eyes several times, which I didn't particularly appreciate. The whole staff seemed a little off when we arrived, almost like they had just come out of a rough staff meeting and were already bracing themselves for the mid-morning rush. I'd absolutely come back because I loved the atmosphere and there are clearly some really great dishes on the menu, but I do think there's room for improvement when it comes to both the food and the service. Hopefully they take this review in the constructive spirit it's intended, because there's a lot of potential here!

Bar/ dining Room

2026 | $9 Chocolate Cream Pie - This was my wife's, and she loved it. Just the right amount of sweetness.

See all

Patio

One Coastal

4.6(440 reviews)

0.1 mi

We made reservations here a few weeks before our trip in May because my DIL said we had to eat…read morehere. The Chef looks familiar, I think I tasted his food before at one of the Celebrity Chefs Brunches for Meals on Wheels. I remember it being fantastic. There is outside dining but I booked inside as we weren't sure how warm it would be in May. It turned out to be a cold and windy weekend so we were very glad to be inside, plus the outside tables have a view of the highway. What a cute little restaurant inside; it is very tiny. We were crammed into a table in the corner. It was difficult to get past the other diners at their tables, and we could hear all the conversations around us. Every table was packed, I can't imagine what it's like in this room during the busy summer. Noelle was our server and she was amazing; very knowledgeable and friendly. She described the homemade bread service to us, and we ordered 2 Coastalpolitans which were made with Tito's Vodka, lime, soju, St. Germaine, and cranberry. They were sweet, and tart, and bright, and delicious. We decided on crab toast instead of the bread, and Noelle said we made the right choice. Wow, she was correct. The crab toast blew us away. It was chunks of crab on fluffy, crispy milk bread with pickled scallions, radish, lemon aioli, kelp powder, and lime. So beautiful and so delectable! RJ ordered the Pork Chop, which Noelle said One Coastal is known for, and I ordered the NJ Day Boat Scallops. We had no words. We sat there and quietly enjoyed every bite while listening to the surrounding tables, and knew we found a maybe not so hidden gem. My scallops were delicate and buttery and sweet, and melted in my mouth. RJ said his pork chop was tender and juicy, and the best he ever had. That is saying something. We finished with bread pudding because who doesn't love a good bread pudding, and we like to try it whenever we see one that looks interesting. It was salty and sweet and just so perfect. What One Coastal lacks in space and view, it makes up for with food and service. What a delightful place, and Noelle was a pleasure and a joy. We will definitely return to try all the other things and be lucky to sit anywhere inside or out.

Decor/service: cute place with a nice bar. It is small so the tables are pretty close together…read more Staff was friendly but the food service was on the slow side. We waited pretty long between our appetizers and entrees. They list gluten and dairy containing products on the menu. Food: the food was fresh and you could tell everything was made in house. The menu changes frequently and what we saw online was different when we got there. The salad was good but could have used a splash or 2 more of dressing. They had a bread appetizer special which tasted like an upscale Texas Roadhouse bread and butter. The duck breast entree had great flavor but it didn't fully mesh well together. Some bites were great while some lacked. The duck itself was good very well

Coast Smore dessert

Seasonal peach margarita

See all

Fenwick Pub

4.0(33 reviews)

0.0 mi

New place in Fenwick that was across the street from the place we were renting so we were excited…read moreto try them out for a lunch while vacationing in the area. Friendly and prompt service from our lovely waitress. Comfortable seating and a nice bar area. Refreshing drinks and tasty food for adults and children! There is a little of the menu for all appetites and preferences. Happy to have this addition to the area and we will return!

The wings were the best part of the meal. Delish!!! The atmosphere was good and the music not too…read moreloud. Grilled shrimp in the tacos had no flavor. I have that.They were out of Sweet Disposition pie, which was a good thing because I was full. I had fish and chips, juicy flavorful, nice portion. Service was good.

Bar area

See all

Crabby Burger

Our Harvest

4.3(306 reviews)

0.5 mi

Excellent service, delicious, farm to table fare & amazing cocktails. Start w/ the bread service…read more($12) but so worth it. We shared the whole fresh fish for two Chef filleted & always amazing. Save room for dessert. (Pic below bit blurry .. it's snapped from a video) Fresh peaches, blueberries grilled w/ honey & served w/ blueberry mascarpone.

I wanted to update my original review after speaking with the manager. He reached out to me…read morepersonally, and I appreciated that he took the time to listen to what I had to say and understand why I wrote the review the way I did. We had a good conversation, and I was able to explain my concerns and what led to my experience. He was very understanding and told me that the next time Im in town and would like to return to give him a call directly. I appreciate a manager who is willing to reach out, listen to a customer, and try to make things right. My original review was based on my experience that night, and I stand by what I said, but I also believe in giving credit when someone takes the time to address the situation. I look forward to coming back to Our Harvest and hopefully having a much better experience next time. "Thank you" to the manager for reaching out and taking my concerns seriously.

Things to do in Fenwick Island

Dining

Roasted broccoli with picorino

See all

Tuna Tartar

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

15 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jennifer L.

62

7

0

9 years ago

We went on a Thursday night in July-it was raining, so had to eat inside-but it was great. The food is very good and fresh. They were out of oysters, but she told us right away and there are plenty of other options. It is good to know everything is so fresh. They were delivering crabs as we were there. We had a large group (12) and the food did not come all together, but we had some eating ayce crabs and they started right away while the others could start on appetizers. It was great, we brought all our own drinks and they brought a large bucket with ice for us to keep them cool. Average cost per person is below $20 and that's will some eating crabs. IT's an amazing deal-and close to the beach! read more

Mattie W.

100

4

0

9 years ago

This place is AWESOME. Love the BYOB and they will refrigerate your beer while you eat. Best MD CRAB Soup I have ever had and I have lived in MD my whole life and grew up on that stuff! There is a liquor store across the street so if you forget it's BYOB then you can always run across to pick something up. Oysters, crab, shrimp, everything was AMAZING! So glad this place opened in Fenwick. The owner came out and talked to us for awhile too. It was overall an amazing experience. read more

Joe B.

0

1

0

9 years ago

This lil hole in the wall crab shack is by far the best place I've ever eaten at in ocmd! Best customer service I've ever experienced in a restaurant! Dude was super friendly and very personable! Very clean and homestyle seating. Bathroom was also very clean. Highly recommended! read more

Samantha H.

0

1

0

1 year ago

I ordered the soft shell crab with a side of mac and cheese, and it's the best of both I've ever had. Plus, everyone was friendly and the service was quick. It was a very homey environment and I recommend it to anyone looking for great seafood. read more

Emily K.

0

1

0

2 years ago

If you're looking for a hole in the wall restaurant with amazing seafood, this is THE place - went with family & Captain Chris was incredibly kind and knowledgeable!! Definitely will be returning! read more

Jonathan W.

0

2

0

4 years ago

My favorite seafood place! It's close to home and serves the freshest shrimp and snow crab legs in the area. You can have it boiled or done cajun style! Definteily a frequent read more

Bruce G.

0

1

0

7 days ago

Great crabs. They give you everything, butter, vine, paper, and seasoning. Everyone who works there is nice. Recommend highly!!!! We have been there four times this summer. read more

jeovany r.

0

1

0

2 months ago

Yes I do one of the best crab prices around. Best crabs rusty. Owner was very friendly. Recommend for sure also it Great music and was able to bring my own alcohol. read more

Jessie G.

0

1

0

2 months ago

#NEVERKILLYOURSELF!!!;!!;;;;;;; This food was so so so so so good and the service was so good I made a yelp account just to post this read more

Bobbi W.

125

3

0

5 years ago

Went last night and had a great time ... it was delicious..: only one server he did amazing would definitely try again...

Ziyad A.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Best softshell crabs Great service Highly recommend Crab cakes were delicious! ............. read more

Leigh K.

0

2

0

1 year ago

Wonderful local place for fresh sesfood!! Fat , sweet crabs & Coleslaw recipe is amazing!

H E.

0

100

110

10 months ago

The phone is disconnected and we went by and there was no sign of life. Have they closed?

Gabrielle B.

0

1

0

2 years ago

amazing food and 10/10 service. they're very friendly and the food came extremely quick!

Kathleen M.

20

1

0

10 years ago

Terrific crab feast in Sept.,2016. Will definitely be back.

Rusty Jimmies - seafood - Updated September 2026

Best of Fenwick Island

People found Rusty Jimmies by searching for…

People who viewed Rusty Jimmies also viewed

Victoria's Seafood & Crabs

3.2

(109 reviews)

We got the mini steam pot, sushi grade yellowfin tuna, and fried flounder tacos. Everything was…read moreready to pickup within 30 minutes. Everything was fresh and flavorful. We will be back again!

We ordered crab legs for take out. We paid $45 for a pound of legs which was two sets of 4 legs…read more No complaints on the crabs themselves, they tasted fine but we went to another place that night and got 5 sets of legs plus potatoes and corn for nearly the exact same price. The staff were cool but I'd make sure you compare the prices of other places before going here. Also didn't see a bathroom.

“The Best” Crabs Seafood Company

4.1

(69 reviews)

Ran out of medium/large crabs by 5 pm. Took 1/2 hour for the…read moreorder to be prepared. The food was good nonetheless.

I would try this place again. However, There were about 6-7 of our crabs overcooked out of 2 doz…read more They also put a ton of seasoning on the crabs so some had to be rinsed off. A few of the shrimp were also over cooked. As weekly seafood and crab eating connoisseurs we know immediately that when the meat of a crab is mushy it means it's over cooked. The size of the crabs were great as well ad the taste. Just couldn't enjoy them as usual because some were just over cooked.

On The Bay Seafood

4.1

(931 reviews)

Hands down the best place to get your seafood in OC. Not only they make things fresh to order but…read moretheir service and prices are great! Will definitely comeback here. Thank you for the great food and service! :)

I was really looking forward to this place. Reviews overall looked good. We got the crab cake…read moreplatter with two crab cakes, corn and coleslaw. Also got the creamy crab soup. The soup was a little disappointing. Watery and not a lot of flavor. I was expecting a Wow moment and didn't get it. I had to add hot sauce and a bit of their seasoning to make it a little better. The coleslaw was good but the corn tasted older and not very sweet. The crab cakes had a lot of crab but again, a lack of flavor. It was a so- so experience. I would try another place before coming back. Too many other competitors to choose from.

Steamers Crab & Seafood Market

4.9

(81 reviews)

I just got a phone call from Joe, the owner, explaining the process that Steamers handling phone…read morecalls, I appreciate Joe's care about client feedback. I like to upgrade the rating to 4 stars, since this has been one of my favorite place.

we picked up a large order of steamed crabs yesterday and MD crab soup. the crabs were the best…read morewe've ever had! the crabs were, fresh, meaty and delicious! this is our second time ordering from here. moving forward we will ONLY be ordering from Steamers! the market is so clean and the staff was extremely courteous, friendly, and helpful! 10/10!

Hooper's Crab House

3.0

(835 reviews)

The location is lovely! Our corner table had a wonderful view of the water. The Ferris wheel was to…read morethe right of our table. The water and boats were to the left. We could see Sneaky Pete's dock & restaurant. I would request this section again. It was awesome watching the seagulls flying and the geese hanging out. The boat activity was fun. Most people are having seafood. Hubby enjoyed the all you can eat platter, which includes corn (in the husk), shrimp, fried chicken, hush puppies and crabs. I don't eat seafood. I enjoyed a garden salad and fries. Our server was friendly and hands on. She kept the trash bucket empty and brought refills and other dishes. If she was busy, someone else served a dish. Capacity is 600 guests. I wonder how much crab is served each day. The decor is fun. There are cute statues all over the place (including the Blues Bros and a race car). We didn't feel rushed. It was a great experience.

Went with the family on our trip to ocean city. As soon as you walk in, you feel all of the…read moreMaryland crab house vibes. The smell of old bay, salty crabs, and open air feeling just slap you across the face in the best way. I ordered the snow crab legs because I personally hate picking blue crabs (I'm not originally from Maryland, haters gunna hate), but I was so happy I got to partake in the crab fun. My snow crabs were so plentiful and fun! Literally everything you want in crabs from a crab house. My husband got the triple trifecta and his quote, "definitely a good time on a plate". My kids were also a fan on their chicken tender meals. However, the real cherry on top was the dirt cup sundae in a sand bucket. It was a basic sundae, but it was so much fun for my kids that it came in a bucket. If you really want to feel liked you're at a Maryland beach vacation, this is the place to go. I'm also going to go out on a limb here... I'm not sure why it's only rate a 3 star. If I could give it more than 5 stars I would. Hoopers was perfect!

Crab Bag

3.3

(1.1k reviews)

Crab Bag has a reputation for fat, quality crabs, and I decided it was time to find out for myself…read more Ambiance: 5/5 It's on Coastal Highway in Northern Ocean City, so don't come expecting a waterfront view. But I wasn't here for the view -- I was here for picking crabs. The setup here is genuinely impressive. You've got an outdoor patio section, another outdoor area with a fireplace and TVs, and a nice air conditioned indoor section. Plenty of variety depending on what you're in the mood for. The whole place is clean and well maintained. Five out of five, they did a great job here. Service: 2/5 I'll be honest, below average but everyone was very nice and friendly. They were fast at getting us crabs, but getting drink refills and more butter...kind of a pain. Our crab bucket sat full of empty shells way longer than it should have. Food: 5/5 Let me be clear. I came here exclusively for crabs. That day, medium larges were $90 a dozen and larges were $110 -- about what to expect in OCMD. With a group of three experienced crab pickers, we went with the all you can eat at $49 a person. And wow. WOW. Fat, juicy, steamed fresh crabs that were incredibly sweet and cooked to perfection. I was genuinely blown away by the quality and size for all you can eat. The size, the freshness, the value. You don't find this combination often in Ocean City. I went absolutely crazy. Seasoning was a touch light out of the gate, but they had no issues bringing more, and they were very generous with the butter. Also got the corn with the all you can eat and it was great. You can't go wrong with that. One more thing. Even if you don't eat crabs, their menu is impressive. Great selection for the whole group and kids. Overall: 5/5 Crab Bag is one of the best all you can eat crab deals in Ocean City, and it's not particularly close. The service isn't going to blow you away, but the crabs absolutely will. Great atmosphere, great variety of seating, and crabs that back up the reputation. I'll be back.

Was staying in Lewes, DE and wanted streamed crabs for lunch. That's a no-go in Lewes/Rehoboth…read moremid-week, even in summer. Looked south and Crab Bag was the nearest option in OC. The drive was pretty easy and scenic. Was VERY pleased to find Jumbo crabs sold individually. As good as I've had anywhere. Hush puppies were very good. Cream of Crab / Crab Soup Blend ($13.95) is an amazing must-try! Great, friendly service. Highly recommend!

Tom & Terrys Seafood Market

4.1

(32 reviews)

Best quality seafood at the beach. Friendly staff and always fresh amazing seafood. Crabmeat is…read morealways from Maryland and their lobster night is legit!

I was very disappointed going to this market! The prices were exorbitant compared to, say Fin and…read moreClaw whose fish is also fresh and delicious!

Rippons Seafood West Fenwick

4.0

(27 reviews)

•$

Great seafood market. So convenient to those staying in Selbyville. Had the coconut shrimp with…read moredipping sauce. Was incredibly delicious with extra large shrimp cooked to perfection. Husband had the fish and chips which were delicious. Also had soups which were good and steamed corn was incredibly sweet and tender! Don't be put off my it's gas station location. Very clean and friendly service!

For the price , crab cake is very small. Flavor was ok , not great. Tartar tastes like mayo only…read more Need to add more relish to the Tatar sauce if it's homemade

Crabcake Factory USA

3.5

(745 reviews)

Crab cakes were very good and decent prices! The soft shell…read morecrab breading was a bit thick for my personal taste The sweet potato fries were not cooked long enough and were oily/soggy. Would skip and just get regular fries next time The crushes were good! Would go back when craving crab cakes Like the casual vibes

Ugh. You spend $60 for Wagu steak and crab cake and the…read moresteak is not medium, but well done. What a let down. Had this dish last year and it was delicious and plentiful. 2026 is a different thing. I had to resort to A1. Not to mention the shitty bathroom situation w one person only facilities. C'mon, that's ridiculous. Sorry, we could not wait to get here and I then could not wait to leave.

South Bethany Seafood Market

3.9

(49 reviews)