On the box, it reads: "You have just purchased the finest cheesecake that money can buy." They're not lying -- it's the best cheesecake, the best dessert anything really, that I could ever potentially imagine. It's creamy, but not too sweet and they're not messing around. I had an issue with quality one time -- it was a little weirdly creamy like it was undercooked -- but otherwise, just amazing. read more

This once legendary cheesecake, is no more. Since the original owner has past the business to his son in law, the recipe has been changed and the quality degraded. The taste is basically the same, but that famous silky-smooth (S&S) texture is gone. Nowadays, the cake is more crumby and not creamy. I assuming the new owner changed the recipe to cut production costs. Disgraceful!! If it ain't broke don't fix it!! I have been loyal S&S customer for over 50 years, I implore the current owner to return to the recipe or he will be losing many more loyal, lifelong S&S customers...as myself. read more

I consider myself a Cheesecake connoisseur , I make one that I've been told is amazing and I should sell them. So until I make that detour in my life, this place has the best I have ever eaten outside of my kitchen. Junior's is very good but this is worlds apart better on many different levels. I have sampled nearly all their flavors and they are all excellent but I am a purist in Pizza and Cheesecake so the original for me is the best. It is dense. creamy and light all in one Bite. read more

Parts deleted to reflect new preference over Junior's. Cheesecake from S&S in the Bronx is a Lex C. family tradition. For many years on special occasions my dad has made a run down to S&S to pick up one of their legendary NY style cheesecakes (Kosher, I believe, for those who keep)... and now my cousin brings one up every time he visits. S&S is a Bronx institution that deserves a special trip and knocks out the competition for me. I've only actually been to the place once or twice (preferring, naturally, to have my cheesecake brought to me), and it's nothing to look at, basically a storefront to the factory, but if you're in the neighborhood and want to bring a special treat up from the city, stop by and grab one; your hosts will thank you (THANK YOU G!!!). Update 1/3/07: My dad brought me an S&S cheesecake on Xmas Eve and I ate it throughout the entire week. I don't know, but I think that I prefer it again over Junior's! The only solution to this dilemma is to have a side-by-side taste test. Anyone want to partake? Never mind, I don't want to share. read more

I am not the biggest fan of desserts in general but I do like this cheesecake. I was surprised to learn that one of the most famous places to get cheesecake happen to be in the Boogie Down Bronx. WAY UP by 238th street, but its true as it was mentioned before this is the place to go to buy a cheesecake for the office or a big family gathering. The prices were honestly not that bad the last time was dad did go in the area to pick one up. Still I can't believe this place is mentioned as one of the most famous places to get Cheesecake in New York. I highly recommend a visit to go there read more

Holy cheesecake! Seriously one of the smoothest, creamiest and delicious cheesecakes I have ever inhaled into my chubby Irish face. Zagats (if you follow them) ranked it the #1 cheesecake in New York. Also try their carrot cake...heaven has sent an angel, and it is in the form of a cake with carrots. This is a New York institution and has served the community for well over 35 years. Definitely try one of their cakes when you are in the area. read more

I'm driving through the Bronx, walking towards a metal door, ringing a doorbell waiting for a response, "What's the password?". No seriously, I felt like I was going in to exchange some illegal paraphernalia. You walk in, and you're like what in the hell is this shady dungeon of a factory? And then you see that glowing refrigerator and you're like.. JACKPOT! I got the NY cheesecake and it was just such a dense, creamy, smooth texture. After cutting the cheesecake, I took some time to lick off the remaining cheesecake off my knife. I don't care what you all think, I ate all of it, cleaned off my knife, made sure I didn't lose a bit of that cheesecake. THAT GOOD! Rarely do I ever find myself truly enjoying a dessert. read more

When the future becomes now and sci-fi declarations of a totalitarian fascist government are realized, S & S will supply the people. The sole 238th street store is so devoid of pretense (or decorations, tables, checkout counter) that there can be no motivating factor other than the love of cheesecake (and making bank, but it's NYC). The cheesecake is pure. Cream cheese, sugar, butter, eggs. They've got fruit topped ones, but that's like getting butter on your H & H bagel - some cakes don't need icing. Business transactions are brief and unadorned - both parties know why you're there so why dawdle. Memorize the location in relation to the subway station down the hill. When the man cracks down on your culinary happiness, you'll need to know how to find this place under cover of darkness. read more

Bought a large strawberry cheesecake and I should have known something was up when the gentleman took it out of the display and said, I'm going to the back, I just want to add some more strawberry to the top of it. When I got home and we tried it, it tasted like it was made a week ago. The cheesecake was crumbling and hard inside. Not the same quality I've know to like, especially at almost $50 a cake. read more

Best Cheesecake in NYC, maybe the whole Eastern Seaboard. My wife does not even like cheesecake, but loves S&S Cheesecake. Yes it is a "factory" with very limited hours. Locals know the convenience stores nearby stock cheesecake that can be picked up at almost any time of the day. By the way a small is a good 8 slices and is $11. Large is only $20. read more

I was skeptical, but had heard about this place for so long, I thought I'd buy a cheesecake to share with my nephew who is a cheesecake lover. Wow, it is as everyone says. S&S makes a seriously sick cheesecake. Definitely the best I've ever had. REALLY! Just don't think about the calories you must be consuming. The cake is so rich! But there's a nice lemony taste that balances out the flavors perfectly. It's true, the hours are inconvenient and it's far to go. But do it and you will not regret your trip. If you can't make it during store/factory hours, you can pick one up at a nearby supermarket, The Gourmet Garden on Broadway between 233rd and 234th, which is where I got my cake. The day I went, there were about 10 S&S cheesecakes in the refrigerated section, but a friend who lives in the neighborhood says they sometimes sell out, so you might want to call ahead. If you drive, there's even parking in the back (or you can park at the huge Staples lot across the street and run over). Do whatever is necessary to get your hands on one. So worth it! read more

I first learned of S & S in 1978 or 1979, when the NY Times raved about it and said it was served at the Palm, Christ Cella, Smith & Wollensky, and many other great Manhattan steakhouses. Since I was residing in Riverdale at the time, I drove over and picked up their "industrial-sized" one. I now live in Manhattan, where the small one (2-pounder) is sold at Zabar's and is extremely cheap--something like $14. My opinion? It's still the best cheesecake I've ever had, and I'm 57, though a diner on Broadway in Yonkers, right over the City line, baked great ones back in the late '70's. Dunno if they still exist. Carnegie Deli's is also great, but S & S is definitely the finest. As for Junior's, I hate to even mention them. The first time I ever tasted it was after I took a subway ride to Junior's only for that purpose. What a disappointment! I consider Junior's to be a vastly inferior cheesecake compared to the others I've mentioned. There are many that are better--including Eileen's in Nolita. read more

Whenever you're looking for a good cheesecake SNS cheesecake in the Bronx located on 238th St. between Broadway and Bailey Avenue they have one of the best cheesecakes if you can't make it to Juniors You will be surprise just as good if not better than juniors this cheesecake is fabulous read more

Okay. There is good cheesecake and then there is juniors cheesecake. This stuff literally disappears when it is brought home. People on diets always make exceptions. People not in diets just go for the whole cake! It is creamy, melty, smells so good, tastes like a dream, whipped up with air and love and deliciousness. Oh so good. Go and get yourself a slice immediately! read more

S&S Cheesecake - Original cheesecake with raspberry sauce - Desserts Near Me - Bronx, New York

Believe the hype! This was the hand-down best cheesecake I have ever had. Luckily I live right in the area. Keep in mind that if you go and they are closed, they sell the cakes right next door in the deli. Large cakes (i haven't bought the small yet LOL) was $22 and by large I mean huge. read more

Without question, the best cheesecake in New York. My folks introduced me to this heavenly cheesecake many years ago. They used to bring it home and actually freeze it for a frozen treat. Hands down -- MUCH better than Junior's ever was! I don't get up to the Bronx often anymore these days, but when I am out on the town having dinner and find out that the restaurant serves S&S brand cheesecake, there is NO WAY that I leaving without having a piece. Glad to know that they are still making and selling them out of the same factory that they apparently have always made them. read more

Rarely do I feel compelled to exercise brevity when writing a review. The beautiful simplicity of this business makes this review one of those instances. This place lacks ambiance, seating and evening hours. The neighborhood does not give you a warm, fuzzy feeling. If you want to sit down and eat cheesecake, you're really better off going to one of their retail buyers. If you miss their 3pm closing, there are 2 nearby shops that sell their cheesecakes; this is what I ended up doing. For my tardiness, I paid a mere $1 premium on a $13 small plain cheesecake, which really isn't all that small. And the price? An absolute bargain. This is an actual, no-frills "cheesecake factory" which allows the price to stay low. Yelp is the reason I found S&S, and their glorious product is the reason I will return. Extremely minimal crust, perfect sweet-to-creamy ratio and moisture level. "Doing one thing well!" is their mantra, and it couldn't be more accurate: this is the best cheesecake I've ever had. read more

S&S Cheesecake - I took a picture of the box, which features their proud mantra. - Desserts Near Me - Bronx, New York

OH, I really wanted to like this cheesecake! I have dreamed and searched (and nagged) for a week, finally my husband, on his lunch break, drove from connecticut all the way to the bronx and got me the cake!! $14 for a whole cake, what a steal! I enjoyed the flavor of the cake- not overly sweet and a little tangy, but what killed the cake for me is the texture, it has a pudding center layer that was way too soft for me. I like a more dense cheesecake with a little more "cheesy" and tangy flavor. However! My husband took the rest of the cake to work the next day, and everyone from his office raved about how creamy and delicious it was, so it is definitely a personal preference thing. FYI. For those of you who want to give it a try, Zabar's in the city sells the cheesecake (you will have to call and order, they do not sell it online). I have called Wolfgang and Palm, they do not serve S&S anymore. read more

The best cheesecake period. (4.5 stars rounded up) Perfect consistency and texture, not too sweet and deliciously creamy. Could use a little more crust to cheesecake ration, but ll forgive them. is it worth the trek to the Bronx? Kind of, but more so if you get the carrot cake at Lloyds, then its really worth the trip! read more

Simply the best cheesecake in the whole wide world. As they say in affidavits: "further deponent sayeth not." I have nothing more to say. read more

I schlep all the way across the Bronx from Throggs neck to Riverdale for this cheescake. It is the best available, anywhere. Pay attention...if you go on Sunday and they are closed look for the sign in the bodega across & down the street. They sell the S&S cheesecakes there. read more

I've had Junior's, which I found too sweet, and homemade, which was way too creamy. Nothing compares to S&S. It is the right balance of creamy and sweet. S&S has started making chocolate mousse cake, and it's just as delicious as the cheesecake. Like the cheesecake, it's not too sweet and it's the right amount of creamy goodness. read more

Great cheese cake and good service. This is just a place to pick up what you want. Low and behold, it is literally a factory where they produce and ship out cheesecake. Thank you S & S Cheesecake. read more

I'm still vegan, but everyone I bring this cheesecake to says it's still the best. The prices have gone up over the past (6!) years, a large is now $29, but it's still good, it's kosher (though not sure if Chalav Yisrael, forgot to ask, but given the hechsher fairly sure it is...) and everyone will love you if you bring this to the office party. Yes, my office loves me because I brought this to the office party. Bring cash! read more

I'm the first sub three-star review here, so feel free to take this with a grain of salt, but I'm not impressed by S&S. The cheesecake is okay - rich and smooth - but it's not fantastic. It's plain cheesecake, with only cream cheese to give it flavor. We also tried the cherry cheesecake, which was also alright, but kind of heavy on the corn syrupy, processed taste of the topping. I was initially going to give S&S three stars, but the crust, or effective lack thereof, was a huge disappointment. Even if you're not going to do anything special with a crust, you still need a detectable one. Did S&S' entire crust department get fired during the recession? The prices at the factory? Reasonable, but let's be real - it's the factory, not a dressed-up retail location (Juniors). If you want a cheesecake that can blow S&S out of the water, try this recipe - http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/New-York-Cheesecake-102592 (but preheat your oven to 500F instead of 550F). Use cinnamon graham crackers in the crust and you will be a rockstar. read more

Say hello to the nation's best cheesecake, at least according to Zagat's. The small and large pies emerging from S&S Cheesecake are packed full of the freshest, most natural ingredients for a taste unlike any other. I trekked out to their ONE location in the Bronx and bought 2 small cheesecakes: original and carrot. Although I am not well versed in cheesecakerey, these cheesecakes were delish. What makes S & S cheesecakes so good? Perhaps it is the fact they use only the freshest ingredients in their pies--no artificial anything. The cakes are dense and creamy with no funny aftertaste. Perhaps it is the crust; baked to perfection without being crispy, soggy, or flaky. Maybe it's the fact they have not sold out like so many other places (see Junior's (yes I said it. Have you been to Times Square??)). Every single S&S cheesecake comes out of the tiny windowless warehouse off 238th Street in the Bronx, as it has for over 50 years. As I write this review, I am eating one slice of the original and of the carrot. S&S Cheesecake is the real deal. It has set the bar so high in cheesecake land that I will never be able to eat another slice of cheesecake without thinking of S&S. In fact, I am not sure I will ever be able to eat another slice of cheesecake from anywhere other than this place. S&S Cheesecake is open M-F 6am-3pm. If you can't make those hours or are scared to trek out to the Bronx, the surrounding stores sell their cheesecakes plus several other stores and restaurants throughout New York City. They also ship to anywhere in the United States. Pies come in 6 varieties and start at $12 for the original New York Style when you buy it from the warehouse. Cheesecakes are certified kosher. read more

Has to be the best cheesecake I ever had. I am fortunate to live close to this place and most of the local markets carry their cake (I don't think you can walk into their location and buy directly from them). Anyway, make sure you let the cake sit out for 25 minutes before serving, the closer it gets to room temperature, the richer and creamier it is. read more

So I was surprised with a whole pie of this delicious cheesecake today on National Cheesecake Day, by my boyfriend! I've been craving cheesecake for so long and was already planning a trip to my local Cheesecake Factory. Thank God he Google'd where to find the best cheesecake because S&S definitely "takes the cake"! Lol! Smooth and creamy, the crust is light and tasty... can't eat enough! Great find on the perfect day! read more

S&S Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Bronx, New York

I pickup this cake all the time to surprise my friends and families. If it's not open, you can always go to the nearby deli. Out of coincedience, I had Junior's on a Saturday night then an S&S the next day. I love S&S hands down. I used to love Martha Frances in 2nd avenue, Manhattan, but she somehow has gone missing! read more

S&S cheesecake is simply SUPERB! Creamy & not overly sweet. Sold out of the factory by such a sweet elderly man. If you're looking to buy cheesecake after 3pm you can always buy some at the bodega nearby. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! read more

This place sent a cheesecake to my parents without dry ice. Shoved it in a box and it was left on their doorstep so it got ruined. Things happen. Called and emailed the business and got no response. My parents were 40 year customers. Rude! read more

Been going here 40 years ,not the same,threw out 3/4 which would have been sinful yesteryear.Sad but lost a customer,but from other reviews they probably don't care read more

Really good cheesecake! I got the small (well, 2 lbs!) plain cheesecake for $17 and it did not disappoint! I froze it for a couple of days, so just make sure you defrost it properly before you eat it so the real flavor comes through. The cheesecake wasn't too sweet and had a nice smooth texture. It had a sponge crust rather than a graham cracker crust (which I prefer) but was still very good. The actual store isn't exactly welcoming, but the person inside is prompt and gets you that cheesecake out of their huge refrigerated room in a jiffy. And FYI, the place is cash only. read more

See all

Amazing cheesecake, you say? Hell yes, I am going to hunt it down and try it. Verdict? I really wanted to love the life out of this cheesecake, but it boils down to what you look for in The Perfect Cheesecake. For me, density is a major factor. S&S dishes out a fine specimen, all creamy and smooth. But it's not dense and firm enough. That said, I still devoured 1/3 in a single sitting. It may not be The One but it's pretty high up there. I opted out on making the pilgrimage to Riverdale and trekked instead to Zabar's which carries the 2-lb. version for $14.79. read more

This is heavy, heavy, heavy cheesecake. But it's not all cement mixer goodness. There is a cakeiness to the texture. If you understand that the cake contains like 800 eggs you will be hard pressed to find a better cheesecake. I have ate the cake fresh and also through mail order. Maybe I didn't thaw it enough when I ordered it but it is consistently better when picked up. They also charge an arm and a leg to order it via mail. Bottom Line: The best cheesecake I have had. read more

WOOOOOOT!!!! Airy. Fluffy. Light. But still decadent. A thousand times YESSSSSS. When you are in the hood you might as well visit wave hill too. read more

On a good day the cheesecake is as good as it gets. What I like about it is that they seem to stop mixing the ingredients right when they come together but before it's completely smooth and homogenous, giving it a ton of flavor and texture. I'd compare it to pasta done al dente. It seems like sometimes it's slightly over or under mixed, which you can see if you read the other reviews, but when they get it just right it's truly unforgettable. read more

I would definitely put S&S' cheesecake up against any other spot in NYC. Best cheesecake I've ever had in or out of the city. If it wasn't for my diet, there would be a solid supply in the fridge. Best part is, after they close for business, the bodega next door sells their goods!! After stumbling out of the bar, a quick supply is a few steps away. Can't wait for their Steakhouse to open up! read more

The first time I bought one of these cheese cakes about 10 months ago, I was surprised at how good it was. It was so good, it made me want to make the trip back there for another one this Easter. This one was nowhere near as good. It tasted like they put evaporated milk in it. It was also VERY burned on the top. They raised their prices a few dollars, which I am fine with but I wonder if they haven't lowered the quality of some of the ingredients. Maybe they are just cooking them at too high a heat and that is causing the off flavor? I don't know but I will not make another trip there to find out. read more

Delicious and a variety! Never disappointed with S&S. There is cherry, strawberry, chocolate, origional, large and small. I've sent these cheesecakes to family in the south and upstate, and they rave about the flavor and quality! Never go to a function without an S&S cheaecake! read more