Great late night food. Hard workers there at Sal's. I highly recommend this place because who doesn't love quick delivery while your food comes perfect. read more

Some of the best pizza I've had in a while. Sal's special was a excellent choice. Loved the thin crispy crust. Just enough cheese and sauce. I like my cheese slightly browned and they cooked it to perfection without any special instructions. I like that the toppings were all bite size and evenly distributed so each bite had everything in it. The chicken wings are also top notch. Super crispy and juicy. I'm glad we did sauce on the side so we could do them up to each person's liking plus they tasted great just on their own. Salad was crisp and fresh. Large size was perfect amount for 4 people to share. Great value for all the food we enjoyed. The service was fast and friendly. Place filled me with nostalgia and felt good to enjoy a family dinner somewhere that's been a part of the community for so long. We will definitely be back! read more

Sal's Pizza Place - Sal's Special - Pizza Near Me - Huntley, Illinois

See all

Nice small restaurant with good pizza. Service was excellent and the waitress made you feel like part of her family. I highly recommend Sal's Pizza Place. read more

Sal's has been one of our favorite pizzas, but our last order didn't hit the mark. We always order double mushrooms sausage pie cut. The amount of mushrooms wasn't even a regular order. We are happy to pay for what we want. Some much for the McHenry people voted top marks. This never happened at the Algonquin store. read more

Sal's Pizza Place - a person holding a receipt - Pizza Near Me - Huntley, Illinois

Excellent thin crust pizza. Cooked exactly right and the sausage and sauce are spot on read more

Sal's Pizza Place - Thin crust sausage and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Huntley, Illinois

I've previously opined about the original Sal's Pizza location, an unassuming walk-in/delivery (only) storefront on the backside of a strip mall in Algonquin, IL. If you read that piece, you'll remember I found no fault with their pizza, in fact, for my personal tastes, I found it to be superb. This review is about Sal's Pizza newer location in Huntley, IL, which has a full menu, seating, full-service bar as well as video gaming area. I had been in this joint under its previous ownership, and I really can't even remember the name or how I felt about the product. But it's of no consequence now that Sal's has landed here. It's the same great menu as Sal's in Algonquin, with pizza, sandwiches, dinner entrees, including pasta and chicken. I gotta say again, I love Sal's Pizza. I've tried so many different places in the NW burbs, and disappointment after disappointment, I'm back to Sal's. And while carryout and delivery is fine, it's nice to take a little drive to Huntley and have a relaxing dine-in experience with the same great product. Sal's thin crust is flaky around the rim, and chewy as you work your way in, just the way it should be. Sauce is flavorful, on the thicker side, yet not overpowering. I love their sausage, don't know where they get it, but it's large 'hand-pulled' chunks of flavorful, seasoned pork, not those pre-cooked nuggets so many chains used. Finally, their cheese blend is applied in very liberal quantities, has great flavor, melt-quality, and pull. You're going to experience that ultimate pizza cheese experience where you lift a slice and see those delicious stretches of cheese. To me, that's living. Especially when you do that and the toppings don't end up falling into the pan. It's very important that each slice of pizza remains intact until it gets to your mouth, I say. Pies are cut into square slices, common in Chicago and the Upper Midwest, and sometimes referred to as a "tavern cut." Again, that's one of my ideals for pizza perfection. At the table, we also had the fried chicken and an order of onion rings. No complaints there. The coating on the chicken is crispy and flavorful. The rings are thin cut with a little cornmeal in the batter. Service was attentive. Didn't catch the waitresses name, she had a bit of (my thought) accent from somewhere in the British isles. In any case, she was attentive without being overbearing. Good show, Sal's. Of course, we'll be back. Sal's also offers great value catering for your family, company, or school event. read more

Sal's Pizza Place - Medium, thin crust, sausage, pepperoni, olive pie - Pizza Near Me - Huntley, Illinois

Husband turned me on to Sals they have to the best thin crust sausage & cheese pizza in town

If you live in the area or close enough to Sal's and have yet to taste this pizza, then shame on you...you don't know what your missin and you don't know how lucky you are. By far, some of the best tavern style pizza to ever cross my lips..Chicago & burbs. I picked Sal's on a whim based on pictures because I was in the area and to my unexpected surprise..this pizza really knocked my socks off. We loved it. Crispy, flaky, thin crust with a perfect chew...Our sausage and mushroom was piled with mounds (yes...mounds) of house made Italian sausage. Flavorful, heaping pulled sausage..large glorious mounds. You might think it's too much, but I think it's a sausage blessing. (you can ask for easy sausage). Everything (cheese, sauce, mushrooms) about this pizza was perfect. In fact I'm really missing it now. Why are you so far away Sal's?? Located in downtown Huntley (an hour from me). Old school, local friendly vibe, small casual interior with bar. Pick-up window located in dining room. I was craving wings and ordered a small naked. These were great too. Really crispy and not at all greasy. Comes with choice of ranch or blue cheese. Didn't care for the blue cheese, but who cares cause the pizza and wings made up for anything wrong that day.. Service was very friendly. Our waitress asked if we liked the pizza and wings. I couldn't stop shoving it in my face. Not many beer on tap choices, one IPA. Full bar. Full menu including pasta, sandwiches, chicken, shrimp.. A MUST STOP. Sal - please open another location in the NW suburbs!!! Grazie. read more

See all

Our favorite pizza in Huntley...always fresh ingredients and baked perfectly! Gotta love the small town charm too!!

Great service, excellent pizza and wings. I especially liked the pizza sauce and barbecue wings. Do recommend and I would go again.

BEST Pizza and BEST Staff in the area! Always A GREAT experience when Kathleen and Nate are in the house!!! I drive from Carpentersville just to "hang" while I wait for my pizza ( I never call ahead) GREAT STAFF! GREAT FOOD! GREAT ATMOSPHERE! (I order a thin crust well done Sausage and Pepperoni pizza) read more

Our go to for pizza, and wings. Before Sal's, it was Luigi's, which was so awesome. And, a nice dine-in dinner option when kids were young. Somehow, Sal's pizza is even better. Their dining room has a small town ambiance. Friendly wait staff and a busy kitchen. Whenever I pick up an order, I love the aroma coming from the bustling kitchen. It's not a trendy looking place. But, the food is great. read more

Really good pizza! We got a sausage, mushroom, and green pepper pizza. A large one. It had three times the toppings than other pizzas! We had sticker shock but soon realized that is was 3 meals and at 32.00 was a bargain. Our reason for a 4 rather than a 5 was that the sauce was not as tasty as some! read more

Always good pizza. Service is good and efficient. Highly recommend. Very friendly staff. Hometown pizza place!

Sal's pizza is 2.4 miles away from my house. Can someone tell me why they would choose not to deliver to us when we are in Huntley. We used to get Luigi's pizza all the time. They always delivered to us and it was great. We tried again about 2 weeks ago. They said we want to make sure it's as fresh as can be. My question is, why would you have me pick it up. I don't know when it's done so it probably sits there longer and then I still have to drive it to my house. Your file very team could get it fresh from the oven drive it 2.4 miles away and deliver it FRESH. The pizza is good but the delivery policy is crap. FYI Papa Saverio's always delivers to us and it's over a mile further away. read more

Every time I come back to Chicago and to my mom's house in Huntley, we order classic thin crust pizza. That used to be from a place on Randall Rd - they closed. Then our go-to place was Buddy Zs on Algonquin Rd. Tonight was going to be pizza night, so I look up the number for Buddy Zs....and, tragedy! CLOSED. I was crushed. Then my mom pipes up - "there's Sal's pizza in downtown Huntley!" Looked at pics of their pizza online, looked like it might be okay? I figured it was worth a shot, so we got pizza and an italian beef sandwich. Well. First off, the pizza was excellent - piping hot, TONS of toppings, a nice crispy crust just as it should be. Perfect. Then my mom's italian beef was HUGE. And also delicious, with great bread and tasty beef. And did I mention huge? Everything was ready right when they said it would be, and the people who work there were VERY friendly. So yes, it took us a while to discover this place, but better late than never. Edit: I just want to note that the next morning, my mom is STILL raving about the italian beef sandwich. "The biggest sandwich I've ever seen! It was so good!" So there's that. read more

Great pizza every time we order! The closest you'll get to Chicago pizza while living in the suburbs! Super generous with the toppings especially the cheese! This will always be our go to spot, hopefully one day we'll get stop by and eat inside. read more

Sal's Pizza Place - Half cheese for the littles and Chicago style for us! - Pizza Near Me - Huntley, Illinois

Great food, dine-in area is small but service is usually pretty good. It's a family favorite for dine-in and carry out

Best pizza in town! A bit pricy but they load the toppings so totally worth it. Bonus, tall guy in the kitchen is hilarious

We have been living in Huntley for a year now and finally tried Sal's pizza this past weekend. I wish we hadn't waited so long because we have been missing out on delicious pizza! Needless to say, Sal's will now be our go to place to order thin crust pizza. We ordered a medium spinach special and a medium Mediterranean. Both were phenomenal! They are pretty similar, but the spinach special has mushrooms, and the Mediterranean has olive oil instead of pizza sauce. Their thin crust was crispy and the ingredients were plentiful. You could tell the pizzas were made with love as their secret ingredient. They also have some great coupons to choose from. The customer service from placing my order over the phone to the delivery was top notch. Thank you for making and delivery quality pizza in Huntley! read more

We love Sal's! This is the only place our family orders pizza from. It never disappoints! Besides the pizza and other long list of great food (my husband is a HUGE fan of their wings) I just want to point out the bar area! If you live in Huntley, you know there are a handful of places you can go for a good cocktail in the downtown area. But do NOT rule out Sals. When we were sitting their last night, I noticed they had an awesome $6 drink menu. I got the Mango Tango and it was fantastic! Tasted like summer in a glass! Sals is a "MUST" for food and drinks in my book! read more

Sal's Pizza Place - $6 drink menu - Pizza Near Me - Huntley, Illinois

Tough to find but well worth the hunt. Excellent thin crust pizza. Maybe next time we'll try deep dish

Great pizza and Italian beef. Casual and small town friendly atmosphere. Good for meeting up with friends.

Excellent pizza Lots of cheese, huge pieces of sausage, plenty of vegetables, nice crunchy crust, superb pizza - highly recommended. read more

Finally good pizza in Huntley!! We've tried them all but last year finally discovered Sal's Pizza Company in Algonquin. It was a 30 minute drive for us (Pingree Grove) and when I saw they took over Luigi's in Huntley, I couldn't have been more thrilled. I was slightly disappointed with our first order as I expected Sal's quality. Slight burn & a little dry. I thought perhaps they were working out kinks & ordered again a month later. Everything I hoped for. Absolutely mouth-watering, crunch of the crust, melt in your mouth, fresh cheese. Heaven! The handful of subsequent orders have been just as good. Tip: Every time our pizza was ready at pickup (25 minutes). The first time I think they overestimated & perhaps that's why it was dry. The last 3 times, I went in 5-10 minutes early & it was still ready. Hot, FRESH, and the epitome of perfection. I'll be picking up a few minutes "early" from now on. read more

Expensive. Pizza was just meh. Bland sauce and crust was dry and tasted like cardboard. Cheese was sparse.

Very disappointing! Was seated and ordered/received a drink. Waited for service despite 4 people standing around in the kitchen and no one else seated at tables. We are new to the area and had hopes of finding a great pizza place. ‍ read more

I have been looking for a good pizza place around Huntley area for quite awhile, WELL I FOUND ONE. We tried Sal's for the first time today. The pizza was the best I have had in a long time. There were lots of toppings on my pizza. It tasted like a good pizza should taste. Believe it or not I can't wait to go back and have another pizza. Next time I'm going to try the deep dish, saw that another customer had some and BOY did it look good. I guess you can tell I would highly recommend Sal's Pizza. I will be back soon. read more

Sal's Pizza Place - GREAT PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Huntley, Illinois

Wow a great pizza place in Huntley off the main street. What more could we ask for Manny's for Gelato and Sal's for Pizza. The pizza had a wonderful amount of toppings and the cheese was stringy and the way it should be on pizza and served piping hot. They are a Coke product place with what appears to be a full bar. BTW we also tried the corn dog appetizers and they were crispy and tasty. Kathleen was our server and she was attentive and friendly and managed all the tables on her own. The location has a bar, pick up window, video machines and a very casual basic dinning area. If I was to make recommendations, I would say jazz up the dinning and bathroom area but trust me I will be back for that pizza.... Wish they had a location near my home... If they did they would be my new regular pizza place.. read more

Sal's Pizza Place - Yep that is the regular amount of cheese.....It was GREAT - Pizza Near Me - Huntley, Illinois

I can definitely recommend Sals pizza, my wife and I have been frequent customers and I've also tried there spaghetti dish. Located right in the town square downtown Huntley. read more

Consistently good pizza and the free six pack of soda coupon is a plus for take-out. Convenient location in downtown Huntley. My only comment is I wish they used fresh rather than canned mushrooms for pizza toppings. Other than that it is a decent pizza read more

This a great pizza middle of downtown Huntley. The pizza had good favor and plentiful ingredients. The service person was friendly. Definitely worth additional trip for quite dinner out. read more

Recently moved to the area, checked yelp for pizza reviews and came across Sals Best choice we made and by far the best pizza and establishment! * Food is delicious and perfect to our liking * Awesome coupons * Every time we call, the employees are nice, friendly & professional * The drivers are exactly the same being polite & friendly Thank you Sals! read more

The pizza was delicious and delivery was so prompt the pizza was piping hot when it arrived. From ordering to eating this was a great experience. read more

Good pizza! We had one of their basic pizza creations with the cheese curds. All very yummy - nothing outta this world, but would come again if I were in the area. Good service, overall positive experience. read more

Sal's really is the best if you're looking for a classic Chicago-style thin crust pizza. (And if you read my other Yelp reviews, I'm not exactly the most friendly reviewer...so this review speaks volumes!) Our family has had many-a-pizzas from Sal's over the past few years...both as delivery and as carryout. We have never dined there, being as we live so close by...and pizza is just one of those meals I prefer to enjoy as a family on the couch for movie night! There is some seating inside at tables and at their full service bar. This is a classic pizza joint...not dressed up or overdone aesthetically, but a "just right" casual and comfy feeling inside. I like being able to see through into the kitchen to watch the staff prep the pizzas. And they work hard in there...and they always look happy. Give a gratuity on your purchase, and each one of them chimes in to thank you (in their special "Sal's" way). The staff truly is wonderful, starting with Sal. I've only had very brief interaction with him on a sparse occasion, but he is genuinely a nice guy. I think perhaps his wife also works out of the front kitchen counter, and she's very pleasant, too. But I think my favorite staff member at Sal's is our delivery guy. (He's a Tampa Bay Buccaneers fan, just like me...so that helps!) We've struck up a rapport over the past few years, and he always is extremely pleasant to me, my wife, my kids, and my dogs when he delivers. And a couple of times when I have done carryout, he has recognized me when we crossed paths. Now...as for the pizza...FANTASTIC! Pizza is kind of like Chinese food to me. We only get it every so often, so I never really stray away from what I really love...so I dont really try anything new. But I'm a fan of the Garbage pizza. The crust is cracker thin and stays relatively crispy for some time. But I recommend requesting well done, anyhow. Trust me...it won't be overcooked, but the crust will have a little extra char and blistering which (to me) brings out extra flavor. Just the right amount of sauce is spread out to within a few centimeters of the crust's edge. It has great flavor...not too sweet, not too acidic. Just right, and properly seasoned to boot. Sal's doesnt skimp on the toppings, either. Under that bubbling layer of cheese lies MOUNDS of ingredients on Sal's Garbage pizza. Not one square-cut piece is lacking. I've heard people say Sal's isn't cheap. It may be correct to state that Sal's isn't the cheapest thing around, but the quality of their product creates a great value. Look on their website for coupons to use...there's always something available to use. FYI...Sal's isn't JUST pizza. They have a full menu of entrees. Their lasagne and their meatballs are wonderful. Very generous portion size! Oh...and they have Creamy Garlic dressing for their salads which a lot of places don't carry. (And they use Romaine lettuce for their salads...so way better than the standard iceberg lettuce mix.) If you haven't tried Sal's before - or if you haven't had it in a while - I highly suggest calling up and ordering tonight! I know I will be! (And I'll be catching up with my delivery guy ahead of tomorrow's Bucs-Saints game!) UPDATE: 5 minutes after I submitted this review, I called and placed my order! Can't wait for it!! read more

Some of the best pizza we've ever had. So glad we drove here on our way home from Chicago. Look forward to visiting again!

Sal's special pizza is excellent. The sandwiches are fresh and the wait staff is attentive. Another hidden gem in Huntley. Italian home cooking that won't break the bank. A nice place to eat read more

Bad service. Horrible pizza. I got a frozen pizza from Costco that was better than theirs. Chicken wings undercooked and server was quick and sloppy. No ice to her meant ice and not very clean. There's great competition right across the street. Sal's gets pretty packed with what looked like usuals/locals. One server is not enough and it's unfair. Both server wise as well as kitchen staff needs to be increased. They have plenty of delivery staff and it appears they get a lot of delivery orders but if they don't concentrate on quality and properly cooked food they will fail. The place is tiny for in door eating and they are juggling too much while compromising taste and proper cooking. read more

Let me begin with in our opinion the food is ok, nothing special. Then we tried to add onions to a salad and they said they couldn't add any due to cross contamination. Then we ordered baked spaghetti and meatballs w marinara sauce and garlic bread , our order arrived with no meatballs no garlic bread and no marinara sauce but meat sauce. We gave them another try using the small credit they gave us for the error. Reordered spaghetti and meatballs with garlic bread with 4 extra meatballs. This time the meatballs once again didn't arrive. When I called the restaurant and spoke with Don the manager whom apologized and offered a $7.00 credit for all of our trouble. We have chosen not to go back to this restaurant again! read more