Very good pizza. Great specials . Friendly service. I definitely recommend it. Location is kinda small, but there are plenty of tables still available . They deliver too. read more

Got the Italian beef with the hot peppers on the double dough crust. Let me tell you, that was the sloppiest pizza I've ever had. First slice I pulled from the pie ripped all the cheese and toppings off. Maybe this was because they put the cheese on top of the toppings? I'm not sure. Usually pizza the next day is desirable, however, I don't think these leftovers will be edible with the amount of grease that was on those tasteless little square slices. Next time I'll toss in a red Barron ‍ read more

Best pizza ever. We are from out of town and we're craving pizza. Not many options around but we decided to try Sal's. Delicious with every bite! read more

Sal's Pizza - 18" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

Always a good time at Sal's. Pizza is a bit pricey but the slices are big. If you're in need of a quick bite with a buddy this is the place to go. Not the ambiance of a stay a while place but oh well, ample seating. Service is always good with rotating college students eager to do service work. I would recommend, I go there at least once every few months. Highly recommend the bbq chicken pizza! read more

Love the sauce! Overall a great place for delicious pizza! Best in Waukesha in my opinion

Overall Sal's pizza is pretty good (maybe a bit too much sauce for my liking) but the toppings were fresh and proportioned well. We ordered the breaded veggie combo for an appetizer. I should know better to order fried foods like this for delivery as the mushrooms, zucchini and cauliflower were mushy and no longer crisp. Ordering online was super easy and our food came right on time. read more

Sal's Pizza - Sausage Combo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

Once a year, we get pizza in January at our family reunion. The last few years the other places we chose were mediocre. NOT SAL'S! They had great deals. Friendly staff answering the phone. The pizza came promptly to our hotel and it was still PIPING HOT! Everyone really loved it! Thanks for a great end to our evening! And the leftovers were amazing for breakfast lol. See you next year read more

We ordered a large par-baked stuffed pizza and what we received was a pizza without sauce, you read that correctly, no sauce. In addition, we didn't received no instructions on how to finish baking it. Contacted the owner and explained what happened. He apologized and said we should have received sauce and baking instructions. To correct this he gave us a $12 credit to be used the next time we order. Mind you the inedible pizza we received was almost $30. What we felt he should have done was at a minimum given us a correctly made pizza equal to what we ordered. We have always enjoyed their food in the past and have even recommended them to others but now we not sure we can do that. In fact, not sure if we will ever go back. Please consider this experience when you are deciding on a restaurant in Waukesha. read more

Sal's Pizza - This is the stuffed pizza we received- no sauce! - Pizza Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

This was today's restaurant to support so I stopped by for lunch. It's takeout or delivery still so I called my order in. The place is in a strip mall with plenty of parking and small with 10 tables that was off limits. I looked at the menu and I saw a garlic bread appetizer and a cheesy beef so I was going to combine the two and build my sandwich. I ordered the house beef with cheese on garlic bread with hot peppers which was ready in 15 minutes. The package was pretty hefty as I left I thought so I couldn't wait to open it. When I opened up the container the sandwich comes with a huge pile of crinkle frys and the beef sandwich looked amazing with plenty of melted cheese. The cheesy beef on garlic bread was really good with plenty of melted mozzarella and nice tender Italian beef that was moist but not dipped. I'm very picky about frys and I don't like most frys, especially crinkle cut frys. The frys were the thin crinkle cut and just ok that needed salt. read more

See all

My favorite take out pizza place. Pizza is always cooked perfect with no complaints about the amount of toppings they put on it

Haven't had Sal's for years finally decided it was time to get the best pizza in Waukesha! Great crust and sauce had just the right flavor. Toppings where excellent and plentiful. I now know what I've missed not making the drive. The Eggplant was good with excellent sauce and pasta with lots of mozzarella but Eggplant was a little tough. Garlic bread very tasty! Will be a regular from now on! read more

See all

Got takeout and delivery here multiple times during the course of a hospital stay. Great pizza, generally very fast delivery.

Great food and pizza. Service is top notch. Fish fry are so tasty. Everything I have ordered was good. Best pan pizza ever.

Best pizza on the planet - and I know pizza. I'm from Chicago. From the friendly gal that takes your phone order to the delivery person with your order, every one has been super kind. Aside from Italian pastas, there are Mexican items, too. Daily specials, also. Go for it! read more

Driver tried to scam me I told the lady who took the order for a delivery that I would pay cash and the driver said he didn't have his wallet. Called Sals anf they defended him, Thieves read more

Always quick delivery always hot and fresh. We love the thin crust pizzas. The tossed salad is a great bargain too.

Sause was tasteless pizza was warm cheese was herd and the green peppers where to chunky and bitter

We'll, we now have our favorite restaurant in Waukesha. We had previously only picked up pizza here, but today we decided to go there for their pasta. Needless to say it was some of the best pasta that I've had. My wife had the meatball sandwich and I had the pasta with eggplant . I hadn't eaten much for breakfast so I was hungry. I couldn't even finish my plate. I could only eat half of it. Along with my pasta I got a plate of awesome garlic bread. Please try this place, you won't be disappointed. read more

I'm from Memphis Tennessee so we don't have a lot of Italian restaurants that are actually worth anything but Sals pizza is probably the best pizza I have had on the road in the last 15 years I would put it head to head with any mom and Pop store in Brooklyn New York I can't wait to come back and try some of their pasta dishes. Next time the pizza was amazing real sauce, real meats, and real mozzarella cheese and the crust was amazing. I don't think there's any other pizza place in Waukesha that I will ever or need to ever try again Sals is the real deal. read more

Had 16 inch Saturday special deal 1 Topping ordered at 330 for 500 pickup -- was hit and ready at 500 - pleasant staff - Pizza was great

We come to Waukesha often to lord BIG xformers. We have ordered pizza from quite a few different pizza joints. I must say, Sal's did a fantastic job on our pizza. It was the first time we ordered from here, it won't be the last! read more

Ordered a pizza and panzarotti yesterday, Delicious. The Panzarotti is the best I've had, and the pizza sauce to dip it in, is the best too. Very generous serving. The gal at the counter understands customer service very well. First time ordering here, we will be back. We were there in the afternoon on a tuesday when one would think it would be dead, nope, a steady stream of customers. I am looking forward to trying some of their other dishes. read more

Done ordering from here!! Have always loved their pizza but the last 2 times were horrible!! The 1st time the pizza wasn't cut and the toppings were off entirely. This time the pizza was cut messily and upon taking a bite - Hair was on it! Never again!! read more

i can't believe the way I was treated over the phone, while I was ordering, I stated an issue that happened last weekend where the delivery driver said he didn't have my numbe, so he thought yelling Sals pizza in my apartment complex hallway was a good idea! Well the lady on the phone didn't care either. now I simply asked for packets of crushed red peppers and said your delivery driver forgot on two occasions, can you please make sure, SHE RUDELY REPLIED..... we're busy we forget! Will that complete your order! No thanks I'll take my business elsewhere! read more

Im giving this a 5, because I cant give it 4.5.. only because the "thin" crust was not very thin... however.. the sauce, cheese and ingredients were amazing! I got a sausage, green pepper and onion.. this will be my go to spot and next time I will see if they can make it thinner. read more

Sal's Pizza - Sausage, green pepper and onion - Pizza Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

Divey place with awesome pizza. You can immediately tell it's premium Grande cheese. The best!

I am visiting my sister here in Waukesha and had my first Sal's Pizza last night. The pie was as delicious as my favorites back in Chicago. Thin crispy crust, plenty of Wisconsin mozzarella, great sauce and excellent sausage. I had the pleasure of speaking to Sal on the phone and he made sure our order was perfect. You won't be disappointed having Sal's Pizza in your life!!! read more

I decided to give it a try and man was that a bad decision. Pizza was flavorless and every bite I choked on the cheese , our boneless wings were soggy , and the mozzarella sticks were always flavorless. Lesson learned if I want good pizza have to go to Milwaukee read more

I can't believe we waited 20 years to order Sal's Pizza. Easily our new favorite pizza in Waukesha. Lots of toppings. Great tasting crust. Awesome when fresh and reheated well too. Fantastic pizza. read more

I'm in LOVE !!! So I have been searching for a new place for great stuffed pizza because my favorite place stopped making it and I have finally found it! It definitely exceeded expectations. I had spinach, mushrooms, and sausage. Best sausage I've ever had! The sauce reminded me of a homemade authentic Italian sauce and could compete with the Chicago pizzas any day! Also, the staff were all very friendly and spoke highly of the food. The only negative is it is a little pricey but worth it for a treat. I highly recommend overall! read more

Sal's Pizza - 14in Chicago stuffed pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

My #1 place to order from! Great food, great customer service & great atmosphere. We ordered a 16in thin crust w/ sausage & pepperoni & also got a house beef w/ cheese sandwich. The pizza is amazing as always, the thin crust is great choice because it's thin but not too thin that your pizza will flop over! If it's your first time ordering pizza from here you should try the thin crust or the Chicago style stuffed crust. Also the sandwiches are so amazing also, the Italian beef is seasoned very well & the sandwich came with fries!! read more

Sal's Pizza - sausage & pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waukesha, Wisconsin

See all

Pizza was really really good hot and fresh drove up for the holiday lights show. cheese pizza was perfect for the drive through the lights

This place is the bomb! They have a wide variety of items own the menu but, we keep ordering the pizza. If you've ever had the pizza, you'd understand why. But, we've heard good things about the Mexican cuisine too. Usually get it delivered. Friendly and professional staff. Ditto for the delivery crew. Our pizza, go to. read more

Lover the pizza, but they need to update thier website. THERE IS NO NEW BERLIN LOCATION. So last night we decided to go out for dinner, I wanted pizza so my wife said let's go to Sal's in New Berlin, it just a few minutes from our home in Brookfield. So we drove down there only to find it was not Sal's, but ragher a Rossotties. Well what now, here we are in New Berlin and Sal's is all the way in Waukesha. Tired and hungry we went for Mexican instead. Ok, Sal you got lucky, my Mexican dinner was not every good and I was still craving good pizza tonight. I braved the drive down Bluemound Road and got some of the best pizza I have ever had. You could open a New Berlin if it would be easier than fixing your website. read more

Eat at Sal's! Do it now! This place is great. Our family moved to the area 10 years ago and since then we have been driving past Sal's on the way to Woodman's and other Waukesha locations without ever stopping in. I am a firm believer that guys named "Sal" make the best pizza and Sal's in Waukesha is right in line with that belief! Yesterday we ordered from Sal's for the first time - three pies: one thin, one double dough, and one Chicago style. They were all delicious... so good that I was moved to write my first Yelp review! Each pie had its own unique qualities and all three were delectable... top notch ingredients and cooked to perfection. I cannot wait to try Sal's other menu items. Eat at Sal's!!! read more

Sal's is our go-to place for pizza. It's a little on the pricier side for pizza, but it's well worth the splurge. It's much better than some other 'gourmet' pizza restaurants. You're also supporting local instead of a big chain. read more

Sals is my go to when I am feeling lazy and I don't want to cook dinner. They are always fast with delivery and have great daily specials. Believe it or not they have a huge menu and we have yet to try anything bad. If you're looking for a great sandwich try their Italian beef, you won't regret it! read more

Usually my go-to pizza place for delivery. Pizza is fantastic and I know it'll get to my house when they say it will. One of my favorite places in Pewaukee. read more

Very accommodating, ordered lunch for large group 25+, same day, 1 hour prior, had on time, ready for takeout. Dining area very clean with several tables if you were to eat in. Everyone enjoyed the food, a few pizzas, garlic cheese breads , and salads. Has cold Pepsi products in 2 liters and cans. read more

On a Friday night my boyfriend and I tried this place for the first time. We wanted to try a bunch of stuff and have leftovers so we ordered cheesy garlic bread, carbonara, wings, Caesar salad, and the classic sausage pizza. Overall, the food was bland and over cooked. I won't waste my money on it again. Cheesy garlic bread- could barely taste the garlic and herbs and the bread way too dry Mild Wings- chewy with a tangy sauce. The wings were tough and dry. Carbonara-THE BIGGEST DISAPPOINTMENT! This is basically linguine SMOTHERED in mozzarella with three pieces of Canadian bacon. It tasted NOTHING like carbonara should Classic sausage pizza- the pizza was loaded with toppings (very tasty) but they slid off the crust. The sauce was watery and bland on top of an overly chewy and tough crust. read more