A shore legend when it comes to pizza spots. Old school charm and decore with paper thin pizza…read morecooked to the perfect level of crispy crust. We came in a busy Saturday night this time so did have to wait, but the hostess was spot on with the quoted wait time. This time my husband tackled (and suceeded) the pie challenge by eating a full XXL pizza himself on just 30-minutes! Wow! Meanwhile my dad and I split and XL Special Pie with peppers and mushrooms.

Love Pete and Elda's! I don't live in NJ anymore, but I…read morelove coming back here. The food is good, service is great, and it's just a good time. I haven't tried the pizza challenge, but many did when I was there. The pizza is delicious. Great pasta. Highly recommend the garlic bread too! Cannot wait to come back!

Just had dinner there tonight. It's still the quintessential neighborhood Italian Pizza restaurant…read more I had yet another sausage parmigiana sandwich just as good as everyone I've gotten there. Michael recognized me and we caught up with each other it was a really good time.

Great local pizza. Crisp all the thru Fresh sauce and tasty pepperoni Ice cream next door !read more

I usually don't do updates unless there is a problem but just felt this place deserves one…read more The food is Still Great; this is not just a Pizza Place - the have one of the Best Cheese Steaks on the planet, meat balls & Ricotta is off the hook (pardon that pun) and there is soooo much more to the Galley than just their Fantastic pies As for the service - Marley & Lucy stand out as Super polite, professional and friendly - they make it a pleasure waiting on the food. Chris - I said it before and I'll say it again - Well Done.....!!!

First time here we enjoyed the food: wings, cheesesteak, vodka upside down pizza, meatballs, penne…read morevodka all were very good. Let me start by saying they have a HUGE MENU Casual and low-key vibe BYOB Indoor/ outdoor seating Street Parking in front Service could have been better but the staff noticed and were helpful with getting our waitress's attention and made a point of being friendly & apologizing when they had a staffing issue that night. We would definitely come back as the food was very good and there is truly something for everyone. ENJOY!

We order from here quite regularly. Today I ordered 3 small subs and a large salad. When serving…read morethe subs to my visitors, we found that at most there was one thin slice of meat and cheese on each sub. In fact, on one end of a sub there was only lettuce. We also ordered a white tuna sub and it certainly did not taste or look like white tuna more like chunk light. We ended up embarrassed to feed this to our guest and tossing most of the order. Definitely very disappointment to pay for food we had to throw away. Will rethink ordering from here again.

Ordered take out here the other night and was disappointed by my sandwich. First off the chicken…read morecutlet was cut up and the sauce was just thrown on top. Everything didn't meld together to create the nostalgic, comforting taste of a classic chicken parm. The chicken wings on the other hand were nicely cooked with no fatty parts to them and the sauce had decent flavor to them.

Recently went down to Jersey shore to visit family and found this place on Yelp, I have to say they…read morehave one of the best ultra thin pizza ( bar Pizza)I've ever had anywhere. The crust and dough is outstanding great sauce and cheese and they offer many different toppings as well. The chopped antipasto salad is a must, enough for 4 people. Was in the mood for cheese ravioli and this dish was just way overcooked and very mushy... definite disappointment. Carafe and half carafes of red and White House wine, decent and goes great with the fantastic pizza. Fish, eggplant, chicken, and veal dishes. The veal dishes are cubed veal didn't order. Waitstaff is hit or miss. Some very friendly others not. Place is very busy and many locals love this place. Definitely recommend for the pizza. Truly one of the best.

Old School traditional Tavern setting established 1947. Friendly Service and a straightforward…read moremenu. Formica tables, Carpeted Floor, Wood Paneling. It's 1965 in here and it's fine with me! Vic's is unapologetically traditional! They do what they do and do it right. If you're searching for a traditional Bar/Tavern style Pizza. Look no further. Its good reputation is well earned. Thin Crispy Crust, Sweet Sauce and gooey cheese. Can be a little greasy but actually in a GOOD way! Flavor bomb! Pepperoni, Sausage and Onions is the way to go! Fried Calamari appetizer is just the right size and if you order the Antipasto Salad; it can be shared by 4 people. It's BIG! Seating can be a little trying on busier nights (weekends/Summer) etc but moves well enough, and worth waiting.

Drove down from Nutley for my favorite post-run ritual: a solid 5-miler on the boards followed by…read morethe best pizza around. Even with an hour's drive, this spot is always worth the trip! I placed an order with Anthony for the Peter's Special Square Pizza. It's a perfectly thin square pie topped with a bright peeled tomato sauce and a fresh mozzarella blend, all finished with a sharp hit of Pecorino Romano. The sauce absolutely pops! Anthony provides awesome service, and this has officially become my go-to reward after a long run. Keep it up, Anthony--truly delicious

On a recommendation from @OneBitePizza Dave Portnoy, we were in the area and wanted to try the…read more'famous squares'! The pepperoni and upside down squares were awesome and delicious. The service by staff very professional and outside seating was very comfortable and relaxing. A real pizzeria in Brooklyn Style.

Food is prepare is good. The food is always fresh and the management takes out time with the…read morecustomers.

Great food no matter what you order. Super friendly atmosphere. Never had to wait long for orders.read more

Tramonto's Pizza was amazing for so many reasons. Not only was the pizza next level, the service…read morewas above and beyond. My story - My fiance' and I were in the area for a saltwater fishing trip. We settled into our hotel and needed dinner. We decided on Tramonto's . We had never had their food before but the website looked good and the menu as well.. So we ordered and we used a third party delivery service, not affiliated with these guys, as I found out later. I received a text from the third party delivery person, around the promised time of delivery. The text simply said, " I am here "., but they weren't. I checked the hotel lobby, they weren't there either. I texted the delivery person and said, " Where are you"?. No response.....several more texts....no response. I called the number, which came up as an Alabama number and no one answered. I realized I had been dubbed and my food and generous tip were gone. I was pissed. I called Tramonto's to ask about my order. A lovely woman named, LeeAnna (sp?) answered the phone. I explained my situation to her and she was apologetic as well as sympathetic. She explained to me that the delivery service is a third party and they have no oversite over the food after it leaves their restaurant. She immediately said that she wanted to make it right and 'get us fed"....lol. She called the third party to sort it out while I listened in and the third party had nothing to offer. LeeAnna then offered to remake our order of two pizzas with several toppings,at a discount and get us a total refund (food+fees+ a generous tip) from the awful delivery service. All of this and they were closing in 20 minutes. I arrived 2 minutes before closing and my food was ready and hot. The owner Teddy, LeeAnna's husband shook my hand and apologized several times. Even the staff offered me apologies. They even threw in a brownie and and order of pepperoni garlic knots. So I am not just saying this because they went above and beyond, but because it's true. The pizza was amazing. It was everything I look for in a pizza and believe me, I know my way around some pizzas. The dough was flavorful and cooked perfectly, not soft or too crunchy....perfect. The sauce was bright and the cheese was delicious and the toppings were generous and fresh. And if you do stop in...get....yourself...a....brownie! OMG was that brownie good. They took a very negative situation and made it positive. They made me feel better to know that there are still people in the world that are good and that care. Not only is the food amazing here, the people ten times as amazing . If you are in the Neptune area, you should patronize this business. You will not be disappointed in any way. And....you can call them directly for delivery. Do not use a third party!!!! Thank you, LeeAnna, Teddy, and staff. There aren't many like you. I will see you the next time I'm in town.

The pizza was OK. Twp problems: the delivery person rang the bell, put the pizza on the deck and…read moreleft. Really. The next problem is management or lack thereof: I wrote them about my delivery experience and was ignored. So, OK pizza; shoddy delivery; poor communication. You be the judge.