So underrated and hidden gym in Montclair this is better then nyc restaurants you def must try…read moreeverything on the menu is absolutely delicious

06/11/2026 Always love coming here…read more Came with wife and SIL and once again, Zeugma delivered. Pretty much the same meal as last time, with one exception. We tried the Antakya Hummus (Pine nuts, cucumber pickles, tomatoes, brown chili butter) and will be adding this to our list of favorite appetizers... So very good! The sea bass my wife and SIL were again, beautifully prepared and delicious as always, as were my lamb chops (Kuzu). While the lamb hummus was excellent, the miso calamari was.... not as tasty as I remember it. Different chef, different day... won't keep us from coming back soon.

Given the spotty reviews lately, went in with lowered expectations…read more Still the same large dining area, parking lot etc. We wanted seafood, and that's what we got. Seafood appetizer for 2 was not cheap, but they didn't skimp. Good portions of octopus squid shrimp grilled well in a nice sauce. Whole Bronzino was the ultimate test. They did fine. It was a big fish, enough for us to share. Grilled well, moist and with tasty sauce which didn't overwhelm. Lemon potato was a hit. Next time I would go for Greek salad instead of house. All in all, not a bad meal for about 83 for two. BYOB was a good thing for us.

This place is the absolute best! Of ALL the greek restaurants around, this one is the closest thing…read moreto being in Greece. Everything is cooked so well, tastes so delicious and the service is excellent. I eat here weekly because It has healthy options and I am obsessed with the Arugula & Beets Salad! Not enough people know about this place, it is the best!

Parking: Easy. Large parking lot attached to the strip mall Athenian is located in…read more Vibe: Casual. A handful of tables and a high top counter next to the window available. I've never seen it where seating wasn't available though I always get takeout. Food: VERY good. My husband always orders the Athenian gyro which he says is very good. I opt for the build your own with Chicken Shish- Grilled, diced cucumbers, Kalamata olives, power greens, Greco garlic spread dip, and drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette which is top tier. I always order with whatever platform has the best deal. Because this was a spontaneous trip I didn't do my research though and now realize I messed up. I used Menufy which is their business platform and was disappointed that I could only get 3 toppings though it says the toppings are "unlimited." DoorDash is up to 4 toppings and is actually $1 cheaper for the build your own. From what I've seen DoorDash is usually least expensive with the most incentives so try that first.

I ordered takeout from Athenian Grill, it took about 15 minutes to prepare. It's located in a plaza…read morewith plenty of parking. I went in to pick up the food, the restaurant was quite clean, it was small but there was some seating available. I ordered the platter (yiayias platter) and Greek salad. Yiayias platter comes with rice, beans, potatoes, chicken and tzatziki. I'd say portion wise, I wish there was more rice. But otherwise it was a lot of chicken for a decent price (I find Greek food generally more expensive). Everything was really good, cooked well and flavorful. The Greek salad was fresh, no gross yellow or rotting veggies. And the sauce and feta cheese was plentiful. I'll definitely be coming back here!

This establishment touts themselves as a healthy food restaurant, which they definitely have…read more However, they also have not so healthy items like an array of fried foods which are mostly on the kids menu. We tried a mango pineapple smoothie which is only made with almond milk. Unfortunately, with an almond allergy we asked them to use water only, so the consistency was different, but was still tasty. We also tried the crispy chicken wrap, Caesar salad wrap, grilled protein bowl, and a Dubai chocolate cheese cake. Everything was ok to good. It was all very fresh, but the steak in the protein bowl was chewy, some things lacked a little flavor, while others were very flavorful. So just a bit inconsistent. Service was friendly and helpful. The restaurant itself is intimate and cute. I would return if in the area, and try something different.

Stumbled upon this place from an instagram ad, and noticed it was close to my job. I came here for…read morelunch. Street meter parking is available. I ordered a chicken Caesar wrap, fries, and a soda. Everything came out to $20. The food came out relatively quickly. The wrap was good but the chicken was under seasoned. I wish it had more flavor. Other than that, everything was just ok.

Family at Easter Sunday brunch the service is always excellent. The food is delicious. The place is…read morealways warm and welcoming. We enjoyed our Easter Sunday.

Came here for lunch with my colleagues. Decided to have the Chilaquiles and they were very good…read morecooked fresh. They weren't soggy . It was very filling so I took some to go. The latte was also perfect, I added hazelnut which made it even more tasty. The mini croissants offered in the beginning were a delight... Service was decent. We were a table of over 15 so I understood the wait to get the food.

Amazing service, great food. Thank you Cynthia for the amazing service ! It was amazing !read more

Great tasting food. Very small intimate spot for grabbing a quick bite when in the area. However,…read moredon't be fooled by the fact that it's not a large restaurant. It packs a serious punch in terms of authenticity and service. Very pleased with the gyro plate that I had along with the authentic Greek sodas. Great spot.

Ordered a chicken souvlaki with 2 skewers and pita bread…read more Their chicken is seasoned. One of the skewers was so dry. Pita bread is also kinda dry. Comes with homemade sauce taziki. The pita bread gets soggy from the sauce. Wished they put the pita in a separate container. You order and they make it for you. I just wished one of my skewers wasn't so dry. One and done.

Tried this gyro spot recently and it was solid. The meat was juicy and well-seasoned, not dry at…read moreall. Pita was fresh, toppings were balanced, and the tzatziki had great flavor. Good portions for the price and quick service. Definitely a quality quick bite.

Great ambiance, food, staff, service, drinks, decor, I loved it all!!!!…read more I picked to come back for Mother's Day. We had reservations, and we were seated on time. We never sat inside so were super excited . And I must say it was absolutely perfect. We must have had 5 separate ppl taking great care of us. Made us feel like VIP. The food was beyond delicious. We finished all 6 Courses. Greek food at its finest! I can't wait to go back.

Our party of 6 had a great time at Elia! This was not our first visit - it's the food and service…read morethat keeps us coming back for more. I especially like visiting with a small group because I selfishly get to sample a lot more! The restaurant is aesthetically pleasing, with mediterranean vibes throughout. It feels like you're sitting in a beautiful courtyard in Greece. Seafood is the main attraction here. I never deviate, as I know the specials will be killer. They have a healthy wine list also. Nothing is better than a well-crafted pairing. The staff is always engaging and friendly. Reservations are highly recommended. Arriving early or a little after the dinner rush will ensure you land a seat. The bar area is nice for meetups and for shooting the breeze!