I don't order from Marcello's as much as I should. Their food has been consistently great since I…read morewas in high school over a decade ago. Truthfully, I have a pizza shop located slightly closer to me in town that's pretty amazing too, but don't get me wrong: there are plenty of pizza-shaped spaces in my Italian heart for everybody who deserves it. Marcello's typically has the best prices in town. If Domino's is bottom tier, M's holds the top shelf. I ordered a large pie through an app a few weeks back and it was incredibly good, but for only $1.49 more, today I opted for the square-shaped Sicilian crust and my gosh is it awesome!! The crust is toasty, the sauce is robust. The cheese is baked in and stays in place. The texture is soft yet crispy in all the right spots! This might be a "plain" in terms of toppings, but it's anything but plain in flavor. I actually prefer it sans pepperoni because it's a lot less greasy and there's a lot to savor there that meat eclipses. It's also a generous amount of food if you're hungry and want leftovers, usually they're just as great the next day. I might not be able to return to regular crust! In fact, I was full after one slice, but I really wanted more. I have no idea how they get the perfectly baked texture throughout, but I have no doubt in my mind Marcello's is an amazing choice for a pie. If you're new to the area, you won't be disappointed. You'll instantly see why this is a Carlisle cult favorite!

I really enjoyed the food from here! The lobster ravioli is very very good! Very large portions! I…read moreordered a medium stuffed pizza, and I can't imagine what the large looks like! It is huge! I also ordered the breaded mushrooms and it would've fed 3 people! How are they making money with portions this big! The service was top notch also! I can't handle spicy food, not even pepperoni, and I have a hard time speaking some times because I had a full laryngectomy but the young lady at the counter was very kind and patient with me, and helped me find some substitutes and they didn't charge me anything extra! The place had a nice vibe going on, everyone in the kitchen was busy, but all seemed to be enjoying what they did! I'd highly recommend this place if you're looking for top notch Italian cuisine! Very tasty!

What a special place! The food is good, we tried the cheeseburger, cheesesteak, and their chicken…read moretenders all with fries and no complaints! But what makes it special is the ambiance. This is the perfect "not too pricey" date night restaurant which could easily turn into your favorite spot period! A really cozy feel to the place. And a really good menu variety. Pizza, pastas, cold and hot sandwiches, paninis, seafood, salads, appetizers, and more. It was a really memorable experience. I highly recommend everyone try Italian Village Restaurant.

The atmosphere and the staff were second to none! From the hostess to the waitress to the busgirl,…read moreeveryone was smiling and pleasant. It wasn't the best Chicken Parm I've ever had, but wasn't the worst. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area.

Fire fire fire!! I had the Philly cheesesteak and it was delicious. The meat was so tender and…read moreseasoned to perfection. All of the ingredients that I ordered were added and nothing was missed. I also ordered the penne ala vodka and boyyyyy! I was a little skeptical because I wasn't in NYC but it did NOT disappoint. Not to mention, the service was impeccable and the place is absolutely spotless. I look forward to chowing down some more things on the menu. If ya'll got time, take a lil trip up there and enjoy some delicious eats!

the pizza was moldy i saw the green crust it was burnt and it looked like there was things crawling…read moreon it. some lady i think wasnt even a real worker threw a slice at me. i saw a mouse crawling on the floor. and worst part of all in the back, you can clearly see moldy things and the floor wasn't even mopped. i think one of the workers like put his hair on my pizza worst place ever. i'm never coming here again. disgusting one i could go star never come here again worst place ever never recommending this place to any of my peers zero stars get out of my you gross restaurant in fact, i wouldn't wish this pizza on my worst enemy.

Order food for take out this place looked really good everything was well put together but honestly…read moreit was very lackluster in the flavor department. I did the shrimp and scallops in white sauce it was just really missing something 2.5/5 for me still haven't tried desert yet

Had a delightful delicious lunch at Cafe Roma. I had piping hot baked ziti with bolognese sauce. It…read morewas delicious! My mom had a beautiful dish of vegetable lasagna. We then splurged and had creamy delicious Crème Brûlée. The service was fantastic as well. The price is right for the quality and quantity of food.

Came for the carb-loading, stayed because I physically couldn't stand up afterwards…read more ​Stopped by La Bella Italia in Gettysburg, and let's just say the crew running this family-owned spot doesn't play around. Staff is ridiculously friendly and attentive--basically treated me like a long-lost cousin who hadn't eaten in a week. ​We kicked things off with their fresh, house-baked ciabatta paired with an herb-loaded olive oil and butter combo. The bread was so good I almost forgot I had actual food coming. ​The play-by-play: ​Fresh Calamari: Crispy, tender, and served with a killer marinara. Absolutely incredible. ​Braised Beef Ravioli: You only get four on the plate, but these bad boys are built like linebacker kneepads. Homemade pasta, packed with savory beef, and drenched in a sweet marinara. ​Spaghetti alle Vongole: Homemade spaghetti tossed with fresh clams in a rich red sauce spiked with garlic, white wine, and fresh herbs. Fantastic flavor. ​The Pizza: Hey, for Pennsylvania? Pretty solid backup options if you're not going full pasta mode. ​The best part? All their pasta is made completely fresh in-house, and the portion sizes are strictly "feed a Roman army" certified. ​Who knew Pennsylvania Italian food could punch this far above its weight class? 10/10, would willingly accept the inevitable food coma again.

Pros: Great menu choices, nice portions, fresh food, great service…read more Cons: none. Our favorite restaurants in G'burg. Always clean, always your favorite itailian dishes and service is always great. Tonight or server was Caleb and our compliments to Caleb who was top end, very friendly and attentive. TonightbI had Veal Parmigana with Spaghetti. Being from Phill originally I love thier Veal Parm which has a lite crunch on the outside but tender and quick inside topped with the right amount of sauce and cheese. Was perfect. I also had a Canolli for dessert which has such i light and fluffy filling drilled with chocolate sauce, one of the best. Cya next time.

Visiting my daughter at PSU and wanted some Italian and pizza and found this place via yelp. Not…read morefar from campus, parking is a bit tight, be sure to only park in spots for restaurant and not surrounding place. Now, down to the food and service! Service, great. Quickly seated and our waitress was then very attentive and food also came out timely. We shared a pizza and chicken parm with egg fettuccine noodles. They definitely cook their pasta al dente, it was a nice chew vs being soft and mushy. Chicken was cooked perfectly. Pizza was tasty with some of the best crust, light and airy. Nice inside with booths, tables and fun pizza decorations.

Well I'm going to not include parking in this review. I was there on a Monday and nowhere to park…read more I had to park across a 4 lane street. On to the food. Ordered a wood fired margarita pizza. It was very good. High quality ingredients and crust flavor. I will order again as long as getting it delivered. They don't have paper plates when you take out just keep that in mind. Good pizza and service. Only tried the pizza though. If your like me traveling solo might want to avoid at the busy times unless someone's delivering for you.

We are from out of town and went with the Yelp recommendation. Not far from the town center ,…read moretucked away at the side of the building. Meat lovers was great, crispy crusty... quick service, clean and the staff was very nice!

Their pizza is great and the lady at the counter is very nice. Really great pizza stop in…read moreGettysburg.

The wings were very small like bite size for a 7 year old. i think this is horrible for the price…read more disappointed.

The pizza was hot and delicious. The crust was very good. It was more of a takeout restaurant. It…read moredidn't feel clean and it was old. The bathroom was clean enough but again it needed a renovation. The servers were very friendly. It looked like there was a connected dirty bar for college students next door. Even though I loved the pizza I wouldn't go back though it's worth a. Try if you're driving in the area as we were.

Went to dinner here after other dinner plans got canceled. We did not know what to expect. At first…read morethe restaurant seemed like it was not the fanciest. The restaurant its self looked very vintage and dark. But once we got our appetizer I was surprised. The food was delicious and made fresh. The bread was warm and soft. Service was on the slower side but this made for a very calm dinner and made you kind of relax and enjoy the company you were with. The main entrees were delicious and we got stuffed fast! We got some tiramisu to go and it was out of this world. I will definitely go back again for another dinner night!

Food was good and the service was very attentive. Best part was their soup and stuffed salmon…read more Worst part was the noisy tipsy clients but that's of no fault of the restaurant. Overall I would come here again.

Our favorite local Italian restaurant. Good authentic Italian food cooked by a first generation…read moreSicilian. Great pizza, pasta and service. A definite "go-to" place!

Food, service, Ambiance was great. Restaurant was clean and staff was friendly! Budget friendly…read moretoo!!