My friends and I were camping at Shaver Lake and decided to grab some lunch in town at Shaver Lake Pizza. We ordered the XL combo pizza, potato skins and some jalapeños and ranch. Food was made to order so it took some time. The spot was pretty small, so there was limited seating. Seemed like there were lots of phone orders too. Potato skins and pizza were pretty good. Ranch was good as well. Pretty solid lunch spot. Did have to knock down a star for my vegetarian friend. She ordered vegetarian calzone and well... as she was eating it she noticed there was bacon in it and she didn't speak up. After years of being vegetarian, she accidentally ate bacon and it absolutely tore her stomach up during camping. read more

Shaver Lake Pizza - Potato Skins - Pizza Near Me - Shaver Lake, California

For a small mountain town, Shaver Lake Pizza dishes up some seriously good food. Their pizzas are outstanding, the potato skins are always a hit, and the fresh salads make for an easy and satisfying dinner after a day on the lake or exploring the mountains. I've been stopping here every time I'm at Shaver Lake for several years, and it has become one of our family's traditions. Seating inside is limited, and during the busy summer season you'll want to call ahead because there can be a wait, but it's absolutely worth it. Our family favorites are the Pepperoni & Sausage, the Combo, and the Veggie pizzas. We usually add a salad, an order of potato skins, and make sure to get the homemade ranch, which is as good as everyone says. Their garlic bread and appetizers are also great options if you're feeding a hungry group. Whether you've spent the day on the lake, hiking the trails, or just relaxing at the cabin, make Shaver Lake Pizza a regular stop during your time in the mountains. Good food, friendly people, and one of those places that keeps you coming back year after year read more

Good food in a vastly understaffed kitchen. Tables not the most comfortable so takeout and preordering suggested

This pizza is small friendly pizzeria. My son is very picky when it comes to pizza and he ate every slice. I ordered a small pepperoni pizza. The restaurant was clean. The vibe was chill and had cool interior decor. I recommend if you are in the area. read more

After spending some time at the lake me and my friends decided to stop by and grab a snack we walked in it was a cozy spot it wasn't full we order pizza and some wings pizza was good and wings as well read more

See all

Always packed but always deliver a good pizza. I got the loaded potato skins and they are a must try. The buffalo wings are also good, just need to ask for them crispy. A bit pricey and takes a while to get your order but it is worth it in such a small town with no other options. The inside is tiny but very cool with a small town vibe. All of the workers are extremely kind and are always trying to get you your order as fast as they can. I would recommend, as it is a stop I always make on my drive through Shaver Lake. read more

A Slice of Heaven in a Small Town Why did the pizza maker go broke? He just couldn't make enough dough! Luckily, that doesn't seem to be a problem for Shaver Lake Pizza. We tried the pepperoni and the BBQ chicken pizzas, and the crust was shockingly fantastic. Both pizzas were awesome, and the quality of the food overall was impressive for a small-town spot. The buffalo wings and potato skins held their own as well. The restaurant itself is cozy, which is a polite way of saying it's small and fills up quickly, so don't be surprised if it's bustling. The service was great, with a genuinely friendly staff. It's a solid choice for families--they had bottled apple juice which my son absolutely loved, proving it doesn't take much to please a child's palate. I would definitely recommend this place for anyone looking for a quality pizza meal, especially for those with kids. read more

Just had a veggie pizza for lunch. One of the best pizzas I've had in a long time! Crust was delicious and perfectly crispy on the bottom. Ranch dressing was on point. The people I was with all enjoyed their pizza as well. Cutest little mountain pizza joint! read more

The food is great and everyone working there seems to be happy so the service is good. It's a great place to go. It's very clean and welcoming. The only negative is they don't answer their phone. read more

Shaver Lake Pizza - Barbecue chicken - Pizza Near Me - Shaver Lake, California

See all

I would rate Shaver Lake Pizza 10/10. But we had a bad day. I ordered extra sauce and extra cheese. Didn't happen! Anyway wish it had extra - for 40 bucks a little sauce shouldn't be an issue. And I tipped well. read more

Shaver Lake Pizza - Not mush sauce! Ordered extra! - Pizza Near Me - Shaver Lake, California

Pizza! Wings! It is hard to mess this up, but this place does it very well. My group and I were heading to the lake and wanted to grub on some food while we were there. My friends recommended this place and I am glad they did! Note that this place is small. There is not much seating inside and the tables are close together, which can also be next to people who are waiting in line to order. Definitely not a big deal though. We ordered a X-Large half Pepperoni and half Shaver Combo pizza with buffalo wings. The pizza tasted very good, with a great amount of toppings and cheese. The dough was not too doughy and baked well. The buffalo wings did have anything special to them, but still tasted good. A good local spot and perfect meal to enjoy your time at the lake with your friends and family. Heck, you could even enjoy this yourself! read more

See all

Amazing pizza and service! I heard this was the place to eat, when driving through Shaver Lake, and we were not disappointed! Small, clean, great menu selection and drink selection as well! read more

Worst pizza we have had in a long time. For years we loved Shaver Lake Pizza when we stayed at our cabin. The crust was the best. Now it tastes like cardboard. The sausage is like premade little pellets not like The amazing sausage they used to use. Will never go back! Will make our own pizzas at the cabin! They are also very unorganized. They said an hour wait to pick up. Had to wait an additional 30 minutes when we got there. read more

I have visited Shaver Lake with my family for almost ten years, and we enjoy the many activities and places to shop and eat around the lake. One of our regular eating spots is Shaver Lake Pizza. This location has a local, small-town feeling, with a small dining area and a few tables to enjoy your meal. The majority of visitors order for take-out. In the last few times, we have been able to call in our orders with a 20 to 30-minute pick-up time. When it gets busy, orders will take longer, naturally. Some of our favorite items are the pepperoni pizza, Shaver combo pizza, Hot Hawaiian pizza, veggie pizza, buffalo wings (the sizes of the wings fluctuate, unfortunately), potato skins, and salads. Sandwiches, desserts, drinks, beers on tap, and more are also available! Now, is this the best pizza ever?! No, but they are consistent, mouthwatering, and will satisfy your pizza needs. We look forward to eating here every time we visit the lake. The staff has been hardworking and pleasant for the most part. There's usually a friendly atmosphere, even during busy times. read more

See all

Best pizza I've had in a long time, The service is great everyone behind the counter is amazing professional and very friendly definitely recommend this place try the pepperoni and bacon read more

Service is fast considering how they cook the food and never take any shortcuts to get the food out faster. The staff are very nice and pizza is amazing read more

I will be dreaming of this calzone until the next time I go up there because I have to stop there if I end up in shaver. stop at this cute family owned restaurant and eat really freaking good pizza. read more

You ever go to a small, unassuming, random place not expecting much but get pleasantly surprised. Yeah, this is one of those places. I mean, don't expect gourmet Neapolitan-style pizza up in the mountains. But the food is actually really good. Has a Shaver combo pizza and buffalo wings. Both were great. Service was even better. Try this place. You won't be disappointed read more

Great fresh ingredients and yummy crust. Had a delicious pesto calzone at a great price - the chicken was juicy, and the tomatoes and garlic were fresh. Would go there again for sure if in the area. read more

They do great pizzas whether very busy or slow times in shaver Lake. Call ahead if possible and pick up. Great team employees

The place is so cute, and the pizza is stellar! Great crust, cooked perfectly, outstanding options. A fantastic spot in this beautiful community. Prices are very reasonable. A great meal during our stay. read more

Shaver Lake Pizza - All meat, large pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Shaver Lake, California

See all

Great pizza. The young men working were honest and let us know before we ordered the wait time and that they were only making pizzas, calzones and salads for the time. You probably should order ahead of time because for us it was an hour and a half. But when picking up it was a two and a half hour wait. So plan ahead. The pizzas were very good. The garlic chicken had a-lot of chicken and it was not dry. The pepperoni pizza was great. The crust was not too thick. The filling in the calzones was just right. We will definitely order from them again. read more

Unfortunately, we were unable to become customers after being denied service because of my service animal. I was questioned about what type of service animal he is, and after explaining that he supports me during extreme panic attacks--several of which have required emergency response--we were still refused entry. This is both unacceptable and deeply disappointing. It should not matter what my disability is or "what kind of service" my dog provides. Additionally, my fiancé, who has been deployed multiple times, experiences similar recurring panic attacks that our dog is trained to help with. The lack of understanding and respect for service-animal protections reflects extremely poorly on your business. This experience was not only frustrating, but it also showed a complete disregard for individuals with disabilities. Because of this, we will not be returning. read more

Thank you shaver Lake pizza for the greater pizza and good customer service. One of the Best pizza I have taste. read more

Everything I've ever ordered and eaten from our local pizzeria has been delicious! If you ever come to Shaver Lake try it out. You'll love it! read more

Always great pizza. I've been back and forth across the country and still dream of this pizza.

I stopped in this unassuming little place for lunch on a recent trip visiting the Shaver Lake area. I ordered the Barbeque Chicken Sandwich and was completely blown away. This has got to be one of the best hot sandwiches I think I have ever enjoyed. I can't speak for the pizza's and other items on the menu, but this sandwich was fantastic! read more

Shaver Lake Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Shaver Lake, California

See all

This pizza is freaking awesome! After a full day of skiing, you gotta eat some Shaver Lake Pizza. So good!!! Ordered the pepperoni & honey as well as the Vegetarian. Both.....PERFECTO! Crust was perfectly crunchy and soft on the inside. Took these to go as our cabin we were renting was too cute not to enjoy. Definitely need to try this place if you haven't. read more

Ridiculous prices. Pizza quality was OK but pizza was small. Terrible value. Not going back.

I'm a born and raised New Yorker, and this pizza ranks among the best I've ever had! Their crust is brilliant - super soft and pillowy, and they fold it over so that with each bite of the crust, you get some of the sauce too. The dough, cheese, and sauce are all well seasoned and delicious on their own, and the toppings were excellent (I got pepperoni and green peppers). They even had blue cheese dipping sauce on the side. We ordered two nights in a row - the second night, a Saturday on a holiday weekend, there was a line out the door and it took about 1h45m for the pizza to be ready, but it was absolutely worth the wait. read more

Shaver Lake Pizza is located on the 168, on the main drag of Shaver Lake Village. Parking all to the sides, around 5 tables inside, order up front and self service drinks. It's the total small town Mountain pizza joint vibe. Normally, the pizza is 3/5, bordering a 4. Normally, the pizza is covered in sauce and cheese, and the crust is a folded pillow of love. We ordered the Lg Cheese Pizza and the Cheesy Bread Sticks. First, the cheesy bread sticks were literally our cheese pizza we ordered. Flat, almost cardboard, almost, with just cheese. The pizza, was much of the same. Lacking in sauce, making it the same bite as the "cheesy bread." Disappointed to say the least. read more

See all

Delicious pizza and great vibes! The pepperoni pizza was loaded with toppings and had a satisfying crunch to the crust. The garlic knots were a great addition warm, buttery, and packed with flavor. The staff was friendly, and the place had a lively energy. read more

Shaver Lake Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shaver Lake, California

Pizza was really good, no complaints there, but it was very small inside, we waited about 25 minutes for a picnic style table. Service was good though and people were friendly! read more

See all

Was visiting Shaver Lake with my big family and we were getting hungry. Decided to try this place out and was not disappointed!!! The pizza was amazing! The food was made to order, so it was hot and fresh! There's some seating inside, but there's not too much room. We were able to find enough seats though! Definitely want to come back again! Especially for those churro donuts! So crisp on the outside and soft on the inside! read more

It is not just the mountain air that makes the pizza taste so good. Freshly made and ready just when they said to would be.

what a place!! this is the best pizza I've ever had and I've had quite a few in my lifetime. It was perfect till the last bite! The staff was also very amazing and very nice attentive and they looked like they really enjoyed what they do. I'm not from this area, but on my way out we're definitely taking one to go.!! also the place is very well taken care of and clean!! read more

Shaver Lake Pizza is always high on the list of the can't miss spots to dine near the lake. First, it is just a mile away from Shaver Lake. Second, the ordering process is pretty seamless: you wait in line by the steps, place your order and expect a 30 minute wait for your pizza to-go. (As of this date, no dine-in allowed due to COVID restrictions.) Lastly, the pizza is actually pretty darn good! I ordered a 7" mini three-topping pizza, which was surprisingly filling and a great deal for only $8. The crust was chewy and crispy at the edges. The dough and sauce tasted like they were made from scratch. Generously layered with cheeses and your favorite toppings. The pizzas get right to the patrons as soon as they come out of the oven, piping hot. read more

Shaver Lake Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shaver Lake, California

See all

My family & I love to stop by Shaver Lake Pizza after playing in the snow at Tamarack Snow Park! The staff is always friendly and accommodating and they make such flavor pies! We always have to get a large cheese pizza and garlic cheese bread and a salad. We are always so satisfied! read more

See all

Love their pizza! The crust is fluffy and a bit chewy. So so good. The wings are good too. They have great ranch. The service is ok but they're young kids so if you think you've been waiting too long ask. We've had a few times where the pizza was ready but hadn't been called out. It's rustic tables are big a sturdy. Great after a long day of skiing or hiking. read more

I'm not usually a complainer and I definitely love your pizza. I don't even mind waiting for pizza. Last night, we paid $37 for an X-Large pizza that was the thinnest pizza I've ever had. There was hardly any pepperoni on it. I will still try it again, but I won't tell others to go there. Please make them more uniform so we know what to expect. read more