Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Shelly Pie

    4.0 (288 reviews)
    Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated 3 months ago

    Order Shelly Pie Takeout or Delivery

    Shelly Pie Photos

    Business Info

    SHELLY PIE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Casual
    Happy hour specials
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Shelly Pie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Well loved Shelly Pie!
    Rebecca W.

    First time customer. Got delicious pizza here! Hearty....yummy slices of heaven! Will be back for the rest of the menu! Great service as well!

    Menu with desserts
    Kat Y.

    Everything was delicious! We tried pizza with sausage, Reuben sandwich, and white pizza with spinach & tomatoes. It was the best red sauce I've ever had. It had a slight hint of sweetness but not too much. I usually don't even like red sauce pizza. The sausage was spicy and big clumps of it! The Reuben was saucy and delicious. I will definitely be back. Service was great too. It was definitely a hometown feel.

    Large Pepperoni with stuffed banana peppers
    Tom C.

    Great service from Tabby and the pizza was good....but overcooked. I got a carry out Sicilian for my in-laws and they were very unhappy with how burnt the crust was. I will treat this as a bad day for the pizza chef, because they get it right 99% of the time....but not Thursday.

    Buffalo chicken
    Anabel A.

    Service: 5-star! Attentive, patient, and welcoming! Fast and accurate service. Restaurant: 4.5 Outside building doesnt look like a restaurant but as soon as you walk through the door in the front, it's a very intimate and warm atmosphere. There is a bar area inside and TVs on the wall if you want to watch college football. Food: 4.5 - LOTS of toppings on the pizza, wedding soup was good. The half point deduction went to flavor. The crust was soft, fresh and doughy but didn't have any distinctive flavor profile. I'm not easily overwhelmed but their pies, especially the EBUT (their supreme) overwhelmed me with the amount of toppings. The Buffalo chicken pizza could've used some garlic/a bit more kick but loved that their pizza isn't dry. LOTS of cheese...more than Mineo's if you thought Mineo's was over the top... BTW, I highly recommend heating their leftover pizza up in a frying pan--the bottom of the pizza gets crispy while the generous toppings are warm/heated/provides flavor.

    Cheeseburger soup
    Ricardo S.

    So as I said, in my other post that I judge a place by whether or NOT my dollars and feet will return, and as I said, my dollars and feet would be back to Shelley Park. I came this evening with a party of eight and they had more than ample space. Our waitstaff, a young lady named tabby was excellent! She took everyone's order with surgical precision, nothing was wrong. Everything came out piping hot, and it was excellent. The food met AND exceeded everyone's expectations and like I said the waitstaff was great. One of the people in my party had another pizza and Isaiah knocked it OUT-OF-THE-PARK AGAIN!! two times in a row kudos Isaiah Kudos. The ambiance was great, they have multiple T. V's with a variety of programming that should appeal to mostly every personality. The playlist was very eclectic and had me tapping my toes. . Like I said last time, I want to compliment the management because the management here have empowered. The staff to be in a word...... Phenomenal. As I said before my dollars and my feet will be here again Shelley pie take care and have a great rest of the day.

    Mike M.

    Stop 12 with pizza passport and first time here. Heard the story of the connections to Vincent's and eager to try. Staff very friendly. My slice of pepperoni was large. The dough was thick and slightly floppy and doughy. Heavy layer of cheese and very little layer of sauce. Top layer of pepperoni cooked nicely as some were double layered to where the bottom wasn't as crispy. Eats like my childhood pizza shop with the heavy cheese layer

    Pizza
    Chardae J.

    You either hate Shelly's Pizza or love it! I love it! It's doughy and perfect amount of carbs on carbs and a small pizza will take you a long way after a night out. I love the prices as they're affordable, the people are nice and treat you like they care about the brand, and the diner feel makes you feel like you're welcomed. They also have free parking which is absolutely hard to find now a days.

    Chicken Parmesan Hoagie
    Julie Anna E.

    Fantastic food! Cheap, family owned and family restaurant vibe. Big place. Full bar. Huge menu- something for everybody. Large cocktail menu as well. The stuffed banana peppers are fabulous and so is their pizza. Great place. Definitely check them out, you can keep coming back and get something different every visit- the menu really is that big

    See all

    10 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Lisa C.

    Lisa C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Lisa C.

    Lisa C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 8 of 8

    Ask the Community - Shelly Pie

    Is their pizza dough vegetarian?

    It is not. We use lard.

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    The Commoner

    The Commoner

    4.0(997 reviews)
    9.3 miDowntown
    $$

    LOVED our dinner at this place…read more We came here for dinner while visiting Pittsburgh. The first thing that struck me was the interior decor. Very industrial and moody with an open kitchen/preparation area that adds some intrigue. I do like to see the happenings of what's going on as someone with zero attention span. Service was excellent. George was fantastic. He kept a close eye on us without being overbearing. He anticipated what we might need so we didn't spend one second waiting to order anything. The menu is not endless or overwhelming which, presumably, allows them to focus on the items that are listed. I have decision panic so it was kinda nice to have less things to choose from. They asked if there were any allergies or dietary restrictions so I mentioned my vegetarianism. George went through the menu and pointed out the vegetarian options including what seems like it is vegetarian but isn't. They had TWO vegetarian entree options and fortunately the non-mushroom one was something I probably would have ordered anyway: pesto with walnuts, arugula, and a very generous amount of grated cheese. To start, I ordered the Brussels sprouts whichc I was warned had fish sauce. This was fine but nothing that blew me away. GF, on the other hand, loved this. GF ordered the wedge which was brought to our attention as vegetarian with the bacon on the side, which was her request. We ended up sharing both, a large part of that was because hers came out first and I couldn't wait but I'm so glad because the wege was FANTASTIC. The dressing? holy fuck pure ecastasy. The wedge was more like a filet shape which was much easier to eat. Who decided on the wedge shape anyway? The lettuce was so fresh and crisp and went wonderfully with that orgasmic dressing and breadcrumbs. Back to my pasta. Also delectable. Noodles were al dente. The sauce was creamy and packed that pesto umami flavor. The walnuts were a really nice contrast in texture. Everything about it absolutely fucking slapped. GF ordered the mushroom entree which came served on a bed of barley which, don't mind if I do, had a few forkfuls to "sample" for "my review". Again, so fucking good. Because it was my birthday, George provided a dessert (yuzu maybe?) that was served inside a meringue-esque igloo, creamy perfect balance of sweet and tart custard with some berry business underneath. Wonderful. I almost forgot their spectacular cocktails! Holy shit, literally they have a CORN CHIP cocktail that I could not pass up. It comes with two massive cornchips on top of a flavored foam. When you bring the glass up to sip, the cornchips are right in front of your nose and their aroma sets the stage for the drink which was STRONG. It wasn't as corn chip forward as I expected but I understand that flavor is probaly hard to create. For my second drink, I ordered the blue one which was refreshing, light, and really good. GF ordered a spritz which was gorgeous "it was good". For second round, I picked out some uranium thing that was very cucumbery, GF says, "it was good". I just read it outloud to her. "it's true!" Fantastic meal at a great place.

    Decor was impeccable, service was top notch, and the food was solid. Wasn't the biggest fan of the…read moreseasoning of the half chicken, but the cook on the chicken was perfect. Really liked this spot. The staff was great, the location was central, and its very upper crust. Great place for date night, drinks, and fellowship. I definitely will need to try another dish on my next visit.

    Photos
    The Commoner
    The Commoner
    The Commoner

    See all

    Fig & Ash Wood Fire Kitchen - Short rib and pork belly meatloaf

    Fig & Ash Wood Fire Kitchen

    4.5(351 reviews)
    9.8 miNorth Side
    $$$

    We went to Fig & Ash for our anniversary and I'm still thinking about this meal…read more We both ordered the Herb Falafel and every part of that plate worked. The saffron rice, grilled zucchini, and blood orange chili glaze all came together in a way that actually felt intentional. Nothing was bland, nothing felt like filler... it was just really well done. My husband ordered the King of the Jungle and I ended up stealing a few sips. It's very pineapple forward with a nice bite at the end that keeps it from being too sweet. It paired perfectly with the food. Chef Cory was incredible. Not only clearly talented, but also kind, funny, and genuinely present. You can tell he cares about what he's creating and about the people he's serving. The staff as a whole were warm and welcoming, and made the night feel special from start to finish. It was the perfect place to celebrate our anniversary and we will absolutely be back

    A quaint, intimate spot with a lovely covered patio that works year-round. The host was especially…read morewarm and welcoming, and the atmosphere makes it an easy choice for date night. The locally inspired, seasonal menu is creative, though that creativity can be a bit hit-or-miss. The Ain't Got Thyme for That, Honey! cocktail was too bourbon- and bitter-forward for me, drinking almost like an Old Fashioned. I was excited about the linguine with lobster curry cream, but unfortunately, it was too spicy for me to enjoy. So I had my husband's yellowfin tuna instead and it was delicious, though the skin made it surprisingly difficult to cut. The standout was the corn and avocado salad with cilantro-lime crema--creamy and refreshing. Service was okay. Overall, a charming setting with an inventive menu, but the dinner itself didn't leave a lasting impression.

    Photos
    Fig & Ash Wood Fire Kitchen - Table setting

    Table setting

    Fig & Ash Wood Fire Kitchen - Eggplant caponata

    Eggplant caponata

    Fig & Ash Wood Fire Kitchen - Cast iron skillet Kahlúa brownie a la mode

    See all

    Cast iron skillet Kahlúa brownie a la mode

    Shelly Pie - newamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...