This family-owned bakery is a great addition to the neighborhood! Fresh baking done on premises. The staff is friendly and helpful. I came here specifically for hamentashen cookies and it turned out to be the perfect time - they were warm and fresh. read more

See all

Sherlyn's is an excellent and charming new family-run bakery. The staff go out of their way to be super friendly and helpful and all of the desserts are great. The mini-cupcakes are a delight. (As an aside, cupcakes are already kind of a way to microdose cake. And now, you can microdose even a cupcake). These mini-cupcakes are perfect though: moist, sweet and packing full sized flavor. read more

See all

Sherlyn's is my new favorite bakery in Astoria! I love everything they offer. Personal favorites are the mango and passionfruit mini mousse and their tres leches cakes. I've also picked up desserts for friends and family and they have always been a big hit. Sherlyn's Bakery, welcome to the neighborhood! read more

There are many bakeries around Astoria, and what I love about this bakery is that the cakes are not overly sweet. The cakes also taste "home made". If calories weren't an issue, I would be here every day, from opening to closing, eating my favorites. When I visit, my go-to is the bread pudding, tiramisu, and tres leches cake. Both taste amazing, and I've never had a bad experience. They offer a wide variety of cakes, and I haven't tried them all yet, but I hope this bakery stays open for a long time! read more

Service was fast, amazing and the sweets were delicious! I had a variety of cupcakes, some cake slices and croissants. I'm more than happy with this establishment. I've used them for regular purchases and for Too Good to go. Each time they're equally fresh and tasty treats. Almond croissant was so good and the red velvet cake was as well. There was a PB&J cupcake that was so unique and delicious. I love it here and will continue to come back. read more

Sherlyn's Bakery - Cafes Near Me - Astoria, New York

See all

I asked when they made the berry napoleon, and they said the morning, so I got a slice. It was so crispy and good! I put in the fridge for a couple of hours after taking a few bites and noticed the crispiness got dampened even during that short time so I'd recommend eating as soon as you purchase. I also got the chocolate layer cake - it doesn't have a deep chocolate taste but not bad. I got a cheesecake slice too, and it's decent if you like lighter cheesecake but I prefer richer slices. Each was about $8 a slice. read more

Sherlyn's Bakery - Cafes Near Me - Astoria, New York

See all

First off, I guess welcome to Broadway! I came into this place last week a little hopeful that I would have a new dessert place but Boy was I wrong. I literally walked in and felt like I was in the twilight zone, the front display facing the street should have warned me. This place is a dead ringer for a Martha's Bakery 2. I mean everything about it screamed Martha's bakery. The setup, the desserts, the menu, the writing of the menu ... it made me sad! Hopefully since they're still new they can bring their own take on what a bakery should be like and revamp. I bought the flan for $9 to try them out. It was poorly packaged, the covering was plastic wrap and the caramel sauce cake out and made everything in the bag so sticky. It did have a good flavor though but for $9 the slice should have been bigger. I may or may not come back to this place. I guess we will see in the next couple of months since my eyebrow lady is around the corner. read more

See all

Not really a fan of this bakery. While they have the standard cakes and desserts, the display cabinets made them look rather dull and a little unappetizing. Nevertheless, I thought I would give them a try with some chocolate cake and coffee. I was now definately not impressed. The bakery, which a former employee launched (of another well-known Astoria cafe and bakery) was not nearly as good as Martha's and had much less to offer except late-night desserts which I gess was a plus in a way With so many new and excellent bakeries opening in Astoria, especially along the Broadway stretch down to the East River, it is hard to see why many would come here except for a late-night bite. As for my cake, well, it was unmemorable, and I would give them a miss. read more

See all

I came here with my sister and husband for some dessert and coffee after dinner. I wish I didn't! We had the banana pudding which tasting nothing like pudding! It was TERRIBLE! The next worst dessert was the banana bread pudding. The bananas were only on top and not through it. The texture was more like a flan without the caramel flavor. The chocolate cake was mediocre not bad, but not great either. The carrot cake was the best out of all 4 of the desserts. The carrot cake itself was very good and it had delicious raisins in the cake. The frosting on top wasn't good, and tasted like a bland cream frosting. It had no cream cheese flavor at all. The coffee was even terrible at this place! I can't see this bakery lasting long in Astoria with all the good dessert shops! read more

See all

I discovered Sherlyn's Bakery through TooGoodToGo and wow -- what an amazing find! My bag came with such a great variety: a slice of tiramisu, a slice of Beso de Ángel, a cheese danish, a black & white cookie, a raisin scone, and a multigrain croissant. Every single item was fresh and delicious, but the standout for me was definitely the tiramisu -- hands down the BEST tiramisu I've ever had! Perfectly creamy, balanced, and full of flavor. The Beso de Ángel was light and delightful, the danish had just the right amount of sweetness, and even the multigrain croissant (which I wasn't expecting to love as much) was flaky, hearty, and so satisfying. It's clear that everything here is made with care and quality ingredients. The value through TooGoodToGo was fantastic, but honestly, I'd come back happily to buy these treats at full price. read more

3.5 stars. This review is solely for their gelato. I've started noticing that there seems to be a lot of bakeries along Broadway between 29th and 35th Streets (Jhoanes, Omonia, Parisi, French Workshop just to name a few). And a new one just opened last weekend, Sherlyn's. Rumor has it that the owner was former head pastry chef of Martha's. I went on opening day and it was packed but the staff managed the lines well. The space isn't large but there is a small dinning area. The pastries all looked good but there was a lot to choose from. Prices are on the higher end, but that seems to be par for the course in NYC these days. Given the intense heat wave, I went straight for their gelato. They had about six flavors available, and I opted for Pistachio and Hazelnut ($7 for two scoops). The gelato was fine and hit the spot on that scorching day. It didn't have the intense nutty flavor that I was looking for but otherwise a solid satisfying choice. I'm looking forward to going back on a less hectic day to explore their full pastry lineup! read more

See all

I'm picky when it comes to ice cream. In Manhattan, I enjoy places like Chinatown Ice Cream Factory, Rivareno and Laboratorio del gelato. I tried the pistachio gelato at Sherlyn's and it was great! Also, one large scoop is about $6, which is a good value. I will be coming back soon! read more

A new bakery in Astoria warranted a quick visit! Offering a wide array of pastries, cookies, and cakes, this unassuming gem is a welcome addition. The cookies are bursting with almond flavor and strawberry shortcake is fluffy and refreshing. Service was quick and attentive If only they offered bread! read more

Sherlyn's Bakery never disappoints! We ordered an assortment of mini cupcakes for my girlfriend's birthday - everything was incredibly fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The service was excellent; Sherlyn had everything ready on time and even included a few extra minis, which was such a sweet touch. Everyone at the party raved about them! This was my third time ordering from Sherlyn's (the first two were for family events), and each time has been consistently amazing. It's so rare to find a local bakery with great products, friendly service, and true pride in what they do. Couldn't recommend Sherlyn's more - a neighborhood favorite! read more

Sherlyn's Bakery - Mini cupcakes - Cafes Near Me - Astoria, New York

Walked in on a cold day and enjoyed a hot coffee and an amazing slice of Berry Napoleon. Sherlyn's is a family business and I felt right at home from the first bite! I could eat berry napoleon every time but I heard the tres leches options are also very popular and I'll have to try that next time. read more

Sherlyn's Bakery - Berry Napoleon - amazing! - Cafes Near Me - Astoria, New York

I love this bakery but I don't like how rushed they make you feel and I've been multiple times and they always miss something on my order. I've tried many of their desserts and yes they are amazing but I think they need a little better customer service. I'd like to say to this I really like the lady that only speaks Spanish, she's pleasant and she feels welcoming. I'm ok with the others they just need a little more training. My favorite is of course the Berry Napoleon. read more

Another solid spot with coffee that hits the spot! Staff is extremelyyy friendly. Amazing red velvet cupcakes.

Great spot! Friendly staff, roomy and clean. Great selection and prices. Really great cold brew!

Wish I had a photo but I was so busy didn't get to take one. Was able to get a 6 inch red velvet cake and 6 dozen mini cupcakes mixed flavors the day before I needed them for a work baby shower. The cakes were fluffy and moist and the butter cream not too sweet. Everyone loved them. read more

Just had the cupcakes for the first time today for Father's Day. They are the best cupcakes in Astoria... remind me in a way of my other favorite, Magnolia Bakery. My son loved his "pink cupcake" and I had the vanilla. read more

The cake I got was the strawberry tres leches it is really tasty absolutely love it .Good vibes. And the service is amazing. HIGHLY RECOMMEND read more

Food is always consistently great here, not expensive at all, as far as what i've ordered. read more

Sherlyn's Bakery - Crème brûlée cheesecake - Cafes Near Me - Astoria, New York

Excellent bakery All pastries fresh and delicious Seven layer cake is outstanding Tripe chocolate layer also delicious Martha's Country bakery has been hit and miss lately.. Last two cakes were not fresh from Marthas.. Check out Sherlyns Bakery! read more

Amazing flavors.. all the bakery looks and tastes fresh, service is unbelievable, and you paid for what are you looking for!! Always our place!! read more

Went to Sherlyn's bakery with the impression all is welcome as I noticed friendly people inside the restaurant, this would include my pup who I consider family. We were told we could Not bring him inside due to health code violations. A friendly older couple stops us while they were just leaving saying they were more than welcome to bring their pup who is the same size (xs) that they sat down to eat with their pup inside. While I agree with the idea I felt disappointed with the way the staff treated us ,gaslighting us as if we were being told that never happened. I was ready to treat my family with their desserts but I did not want to stay longer as the environment felt very hostile after the fact. The situation could've been handled differently in my opinion but overall the desserts were alright. read more

lovely bakery!! Will be returning to try the rest of the pastries. The service was amazing as well.

paid $10 for a lava cake that was puny, tasted like plastic, and there wasn't even lava I have trust issues now read more

Excellent rainbow cookies! Fresh, soft, perfect balance of fruit jam and chocolate. And very kind, attentive staff.

First and foremost, the service was top tier, they welcome you as soon as you walk in. You're immediately greeted with the smell of coffee and a beautiful array of desserts. We came for the Napoleon Cake, which consists of numerous flaky layers of puff pastry with a filling of berries and custard. Simply said it was so fantastic we ordered a whole sheet cake for our Christmas party. While there we tried one other dessert each, Strawberry Tres Leches and a NY cheesecake, delicious, I can't emphasize enough how utterly well made these desserts are. Also while enjoying our coffee and dessert they kept coming out with more with more freshly baked products. Finished our delicious experience and we had to share with family so we bought more desserts to go. Chocolate Fudge cake, Tiramisu, Passion Fruit Mousse, mini strawberry cupcake, more Napoleon cake and some pastries. Needles to say family raved about the desserts. We will definitely return to savor different flavors. read more

Amazing desserts. Great coffee. Highly recommend. Fresh pastries everyday. Great cakes and pies for all occasions.

Delicious slices, perfect amount of sweetness, staff very friendly and atmosphere is very cozy!

Cupcakes are amazing. Matcha lattes are great- not too sweet and they add a little vanilla. Staff is kind and welcoming. Adorable, family-run business with delicious cakes. read more

Authentic, gourmet and so delicious! I am working my way through the menu. So far, everything is my favorite!

Food 10/10. Service was above and beyond a scale- super sweet family running the bakery. Ambiance was very welcoming and cute. Definitely order from here for your special occasions read more