What an amazing place! My daughters and I went there since it was Thanksgiving break and we wanted to have some pizza before all of the turkey. This thin crust pizza may be the best in Oklahoma City. We decided on sharing a 14 inch pizza half supreme and half all meat. We were super impressed with how many toppings were on each side. One of my daughters said that it's better than any pizza she's ever had in her entire life. Admitted, she's only 11 but that's still a pretty strong statement from her. The owner stopped by our table, a couple of times to check on us and was super friendly. This is the type of Mom and Pop restaurant that I miss from childhood. Check this place out and I promise you will not be disappointed. read more

Sicillian Pizza Cafe - Half Supreme and half All Meat Pizza (14'') - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

We ALMOST drove off when we arrived because there was no one in the establishment. What a mistake that would've been! Decided to stop and try the pizza everyone had raved about and we were NOT disappointed. We split the 12" half Italian sausage and half veggie with added jalapeños. The crust is as described in another review, slightly crispy at the bottom without being super thin. It's light, not doughy, and so deliciously tasty. Ingredients were fresh and sausage tasted authentically Italian. We split a salad which was served family style. Again, veggies were fresh, crisp, and nicely blended with iceberg lettuce and spinach, black olives, tomatoes, onions and cucumbers. Super kind and attentive owners. I can't believe this place doesn't have a crowd of people waiting outside for a table but understand how they stay in business - they had people in and out the whole time we were there picking up to go orders. We're now regulars going forward. read more

See all

The BEST thin sliced Sicilian pizza in town. Hidden gem. No frills, but so good. I am not a fan of plain cheese pizza, but I cannot get enough of theirs. Owner is very friendly. Buffet at lunch. Carry out perfect. Just try it. You will not be disappointed. read more

What wonderful folks! We visited OKC in January and got lots of great pizzas from the nice owners at Sicilian Pizza Cafe. We were back last week and went back again. Not sure which is better--the food or the owners! Loved both! We will certainly return next time we are in Oklahoma!! read more

Food is delicious. Hands down our favorite. Nothing fancy about this place-- but the owners Alex and his wife are so nice. I can call for pick up-- 15 minutes it's ready. Just great, traditional pizza! read more

Came in tonight and got a thin crust pizza and an all meat Calzone. Both were fantastic. Side note: the owners found that someone dropped some cash on the floor, They asked if it was mine (it wasn't). Then they called the last person that came in before me to see if it was them. Love to see honest people with integrity. Hard to come by these days. Definitely the kind of place I want to support! read more

Pizza and calzone were great! The couple who owns it are delightful. Reasonable prices. We will be back!

The pizza was delicious and the owners were very sweet and wanted to make your pizza just the way you wanted it!!

Sicillian Pizza is the best pizza in Oklahoma 100%! I've been going here since I was little and I have never been disappointed. Not only is the food awesome, but the owner is super sweet and always makes sure you have what you need. Everything on the menu is excellent. If you haven't been here yet, you need to try it! read more

Great place! A Mim and Pop Italian restaurant. Good pizza. 43 years they've been in business. Probably one of the better pizza's I've eaten in Oklahoma since our move here 3.5 years ago. Great place to eat before going to a hockey game down the street. read more

5+++++. This Pizza was awesome. Some of the best pizza I've ever eaten. We got a pepperoni and sausage pizza. So so good. The crust was sturdy and all the ingredients stayed together. The prices are really affordable. A medium pizza for $14. Not to bad and well worth it. This was a perfect pizza. read more

The deep dish pizza is phenomenal! The crust, I don't know how they do it but it's almost crunchy instead of being soggy like so many deep dish pizzas are in this area. The people are very kind. This is our new pizza place! read more

Have been going there since before they moved to that location. I was 15 and am now 55. My children and grandchildren love the pizza , chicken , potatoes and gyros. A great neighborhood loyal and family owned business. Hope it's around for many years to come. read more

Good stuff! Owners are super nice and friendly. My kiddos were makinf themselves at home and the owners didnt seem to mind at all. We ordered a supreme "thin" which I felt was more of a normal-ish crust and a "pan" which was a little thicker and more bread-like. My kiddos loved it though! I would definitely return for some other things! read more

Sicillian Pizza Cafe - Pan sausage - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

See all

Talk about a hidden gem! This place serves some amazing pizza!! These gentleman sure know how to make a yummy pizza! Highly recommended!!

Wow! Why haven't I heard of this place before?! Stopped in to give it a try and I was blown away at how delicious and fresh the food was. The owner was so nice and helpful. I ordered the veggie calzone which came with loads of delicious veggies and even jalapeño that gave it a nice kick. The cheese was melted perfectly. The bread was absolutely delicious as well as the homemade marinara. Highly recommend! read more

Sicillian Pizza Cafe - "Small" veggie calzone - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

The BEST calzone in the world!!! So good!!! Great pizza too! Locally owned, super nice family. read more

Some of the best pizza in OKC! The gentleman running this place is always so kind and the service is always quick! Wish they had delivery but it's always worth the trip. read more

Sicillian Pizza Cafe - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

I love love their pizza! It's family owned business and they are very friendly! I also love their calzone. I would recommend it.

We almost always order for pick-up and take out; they haven't done the buffet since COVID. The pizza is always outstanding, and the calzones are the best in the OKC/Edmond area; only calzones better were when Sammy's Pizza was around, and they have been gone for years. We love the thin crust; the dough is delicious. The owner, Alex, who makes the pizza, is super friendly and always ready to accommodate. We have never been disappointed with their food. read more

We love their thin crust pizza! We always get takeout and it's ready by the time we get there.

Hands down the best pizza in the city! Wonderful people and excellent food. I will definitely be back!

Ok, here's the deal. Go easy on these guys as they are a owner/operator type business, which I truly respect. I can only speak to the experience I had, and would like to treat this review as advice to the owner moving forward, as I hope they succeed. Anyway, I was excited to try a new pizza place and we ordered a Large Supreme. I wanted all the veggies etc etc. The main 2 issues were the lack of sauce (made the pizza somewhat dry) and the fact that fresh produce was not used. In particular, they use canned mushrooms which are gross. Dear owner, if you read this..... Please switch to fresh produce and put enough sauce on your pies to make them more moist. If you want to give me a new pie with these standards, I would be HAPPY to update this review for you. If not, I assume you just don't care and have the take it or leave it attitude. The ball is in your court.... God Bless, I wish you the best. read more

Excellent pizza!! Highly recommend this place for sure. Recommend the supreme pizza absolutely. And the owner could not be nicer.

Ordered pickup from the Sicilian pizza cafe. The pizza was phenomenal. Excellent quality food and ingredients. The deep dish crust was deliciously impressive. Friendly service. Looking forward to ordering pizza here again in the future. read more

Sicillian Pizza Cafe is some of the best pizza in Edmond. My boyfriend and I decided to try it the other day on a whim, and it did not disappoint. We had to go back today and get another thin crust pepperoni pizza! The owner is incredibly friendly. If you want to support a local business and have delicious pizza while doing it, check out the Sicillian Pizza Cafe! read more

Sicillian Pizza Cafe - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

The food is alway good the owners are always cordial you cannot miss trying a pie or calzone here !!

We tried the deep pan Sicilian Supreme, it was very tasty. The crust was made to perfection. Step outside the chain stores & try this pizza. read more

Best pizza in the Edmond area!! Crust is always cooked to crispy perfection and fresh ingredients! The owner clearly loves what he does and it shows! read more

Sicillian Pizza Cafe - Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Yummy thin crust pizza. Location is easy to access with ample parking for take-out. Been looking for this PIZZA in OKC/Edmond AND HERE IT IS! read more

Great tasting pizza at a very reasonable price. We order delivery from them and they are always punctual. Also, the manager is very friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend this place for a great pizza! read more

We usually get the gyros which we LOVE!!! Because this is what we know this place for! This time we decided to be adventurous and try the pizza!! OMG!!!! This was by far the best pizza EVER!! New favorite pizza place I will not eat pizza anywhere else!' read more

Sicillian Pizza Cafe - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Pizza was ok. Had way too much cheese and my delivery was 20 min late but other than that I would just say ok.

I can't say much for the atmosphere, but the pan pizza and Sicilian style were great. They came to our table fast. Very friendly service.

"Alex's magical meat pizza". It's not on the menu but it is amaze'ballz! Pepperoni, sausage, & gyro meat. Boom!!! Ask for it by name you won't be sorry. read more

Ordered Postmates a few times from this place but this would be my last. I've enjoyed the pizza but disappointed to find the broccoli in my gyro salad that seems off. It looks as if it's not fresh anymore. I stopped eating right away after I noticed the broccoli. I usually don't write bad reviews but I'm disappointed. read more

See all

I really like this place the food and the people. They've been in this location since the late 90's.

We came in 40 minutes before closing. They still happily served. The food was fresh and excellent. Some of the best we have had.

My fiancé and I were a little nervous when we walked in and no one was here, but it was a very nice surprise. The food was excellent! My fiancé got a calzone and I got a pizza. We were so happy with our food and the service. The guy was so nice. I would definitely recommend trying this place out. read more

Sicillian Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

My family of foodies, which includes my picky kids, enjoyed this restaurant. The owner was very friendly.