First time here. We stopped in after lunch to get a frozen dessert. Food: The place has an excellent selection of frozen yogurts, with lots of interesting choices. I ended up getting the Gelato Cake Batter and Southern Caramel Pecan. The others in our group came up with their own amazing combinations. The counter with all the toppings was well stocked and organized, making it easy to put together whatever combination you wanted. I grabbed a bunch of different toppings, with most of my choices somehow involving chocolate. All three of our cups ended up filled with an assortment of yummy ingredients. Service: There was one employee there who seemed to be taking care of customers while also keeping the serving and dining areas clean. I would say they were efficient, but not especially chatty or friendly. Atmosphere: The place is well designed. It's easy to figure out the process for making your own dessert, and there are lots of different areas for sitting. Big windows let in plenty of natural light and make the space feel open and inviting. One thing that really stood out was the number of signs mentioning that the premises are being monitored by cameras. Even in the bathroom, there was a sign saying that if teenagers are suspected of vandalism, the cameras may be used to identify them. It made me wonder if this location has been dealing with issues involving younger customers. There wasn't any trouble while we were there, but all of the signs definitely made an impression. Overall, this is a good place to go for a delicious frozen yogurt treat. I would definitely come back and try another dishful. read more

See all

I love Smart Cow! I've visited a number of times since I was a kid. Absolutely love every visit. The inside is very bright and cozy and my favorite part is the trivia shown on the tv all day every day. You can go in, get some fro yo and sit and do some trivia! Or even take to go. They change their flavors around. My absolute favorite is the cookies n cream mixed with cake batter. I love how the machines have pre mixed flavor or you can mix whatever flavors of your choice. They also frequently have a dole pineapple flavor very similar (better in my opinion) to the famous dole whip sold at Disney. It's self serve and there's a number of toppings from cereal, gummies, cookie doughs, and sauces like peanut butter, marshmallow, caramel and hot fudge. Pricing is based on the weight, at the register you weigh your fro yo(s) and pay based on the weight. Not sure what the prices is per ounce but I paid $4.98 for a medium sized cup (the green cup shown in the picture). I also love how portions of their proceeds (or all I'm not sure) on Tuesdays are donated to selected local schools. Give it a visit if you're in the area, you surely won't regret it. read more

See all

There ice cream......AMAZING!! Service...... so sweet and nice! Ambiance.........SO CUTE! It's very relating to the name, smart cow! They also have these super cool chairs AND a chalk table read more

Sooo good, I loved my choices!! Kinda wish they had the tester cups but I understand if that got out of hand the kids I was with were sad the chocolate froyo machine was not working but besides that oh and it being pretty expensive it was very yummy! read more

Smart Cow Yogurt Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

Smart cow is a frozen yogurt place with multiple self service machines featuring different flavors. You can make your own bowl with as many (or few) flavors as you like and deck it out with toppings. Everything is based on weight of the bowl. Smart Cow is a clean, nice atmosphere and the frozen yogurt is tasty. Good option if you want frozen yogurt. They also have a couple dairy free and sugar free options here. read more

See all

It was great, miss yogurt shops! Good variety of toppings, lots of sweet offerings. Will be back

This was not our first time visiting Smart Cow, and this visit was just like any other. We were greeted as soon as we walking in the door, which is usually a 50/50 chance here. We opted for the smaller size of container, not quite sure on what we were looking to try. It is quite disheartening knowing they no longer offer sample scoops. We would love to see that come back. The camera signs posted all over the store really send the message, but not sure if it's the message they intend. I like to get 3-4 flavors; raspberry sherbet, cheese cake and the dark chocolate with juice filled boboa balls. I would definitely recommend giving these flavors a try if they're up your alley! Their flavors seem to have a rotation which is refreshing, hats off to smart cow. My partner when a different route and enjoyed the Cookie Monster (new flavor), cake batter and salter pretzel. It seems smart cow has recently had an addition of cotton candy toppings. I was in favor of this topping, it had a slight taste of cotton candy but mainly just sweet. After a blind test tasting of the three frozen yogurts we can attest these flavors really embrace their name! Overall our experience was quite swell, and ordinary. I will give Smart Cow an even 4/5, great frozen yogurt, nice employees. read more

Smart Cow Yogurt Bar - Three flavors with boboa balls - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

See all

The best dairy free 'ice cream' hands down - always beats store bought. Was sad to see the place empty but overall it was very clean and the toppings bar had all the good stuff. The lady working there too was so so nice!! Definitely recommend read more

Love this place. You won't be disappointed. Took my grandson. Great alternative to ice cream. Good price too.

Excellent options of frozen yogurt and plenty of options to put on! It's clean, well organized and the staff are friendly and helpful. This is always a great place to no matter what the weather! read more

Nice clean place. Great flavor selection. No rewards program. The thing I really didn't like was that the yogurts weren't as stiff as I like. Might have been that I got there when they just opened and the machines didn't have time to freeze the mixes properly but they were a little runny. But I'd try them again - just later in the afternoon. read more

Getting the yogurt was very crammed, and right when we were about to put our bowls on the scale a customer bumped into my sister and she dropped her whole bowl on the counter upside down. The young girl at the register didn't say a thing and my sister cleaned up the mess. The cashier not saying a thing, besides some quiet mumble. And yogurt was mid. Cake batter gelato was orange? And didn't really taste like cake batter at all. read more

Finally! A frozen yogurt store. With 16 flavors of frozen yogurt and more serve-yourself toppings than you could possibly count, you can make your own "flavor of the day" every day. The best part, no waiting with a number at a table. You make your own original frozen yogurt masterpiece with toppings and dig in as soon as you make it. Menomonee Falls has more frozen custard locations than I can count (some good - some not so good). We had been going to a store like Smart Cow Frozen Yogurt Bar downtown in the 3rd Ward. Now we only have to drive 1 mile for a great dessert! I came in with my 2 teenage sons after school to try the frozen yogurt and "buy local." We will definitely be back. The store is immaculately clean, and well staffed. The owner was out and talking to customers. We were there at about 3pm and the store was full of everyone from local kids on their way home from school, to college age girls, families and some more elderly couples. There are great tables for the kids that have chalkboard tops and chalk sticks in the middle to draw. There is also a "patio" area that faces Appleton. I assume that will get some use this next summer. We had 16 flavors to choose from, and you can mix and match. There are small tasting containers if you want to try a small sample. There were some sorbets, white chocolate mousse, triple chocolate, red velvet cupcake, cookies and cream, cheesecake and others. There was even a no sugar added flavor. The frozen yogurt is sold by the ounce and is self serve. After we created our mix and match frozen yogurt flavors, there were toppings consisting of every manner of cereal, crushed candy bars, nuts, cookie dough, oreos, fresh fruits, and glazes and sauces at the end to cover it all. There were also "to go" containers of frozen yogurt available. We WILL be back - probably more often than we should :0) ps: Ask for the loyalty card. read more

Smart Cow Yogurt Bar - Smart Cow Yogurt Bar - on Appleton Ave in the old Fast Signs location, near the old post office. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

See all

HANDS DOWN BEST FROYO PLACE! a MUST stop for the whole family! We have been coming here for almost two years now (since we moved to the area). We come multiple times a week as a family, with friends or with the dogs! You have many options to choose from flavor wise. They also have gluten-free and dairy free flavors if you ask the workers for the flavor sheet, it has all the information about each flavor on it. As like any FroYo place you can choose as many toppings as you would like but I swear they have more options than yo mama or orange leaf. The staff is usually younger high school students and they are very sweet and friendly. They do a great job at maintaining the cleanliness of the shop. I think it's very important to ensure that the tables and counters are wiped down especially with their being limited tables to sit at inside. The staff ensures that the inside looks up to par. The price is based on weight but I swear it's cheaper than yo mama. They also offer doggy FroYo treats with a dog treat inside of them for one dollar. They offer complimentary water as well. Also the spoons glow in the dark, super neat! They have a nice area to sit inside and a beautiful patio outside. They always have trivia on the TV inside which makes the dining experience even more fun. My favorite thing that I love most about smart cow is that each month they donate a certain percentage of their proceeds to different schools within the area. They have a board that is very colorful and pleasing to the eye to show where the proceeds have gone recently. It is pet friendly on the patio in the back and they have dog water bowls placed outside for our furry friends. Hands-down would never go to another frozen yogurt place again. This is our families favorite desert place! read more

Amazing yogurt, awesome atmosphere and the prices were relatively cheap compared to most frozen yogurt places

DO NOT COME HERE. None of the employees are wearing masks, yet every customer I saw go in wore a mask. These employees are working with the yogurt and the toppings everyday. The owner should be requiring their employees to wear a mask, when every food service store in Menomonee Falls and Germantown is wearing a mask. Ridiculous. read more

The staff is now wearing masks so it is safe and clean to go in. I go between 4-6 on Monday and Wednesday for the Happy hour.

Best froyo place yet! The setting is perfect for the young and young at heart. Chalkboard tables are set throughout next to modern seating. They have a vast variety of flavors - both standard and limited, holiday flavors. Not only do they have for oxen yogurt but also gelato. I have been to many froyo places in Wauwatosa , Milwaukee and cities within Washington county. This is the best place yet. read more

Easily the best fro yo spot in the area! Always have great toppings love the salted Carmel flavor and coffee.

This is like any other self serve froyo place, but I love them all! Nice job Smart Cow! It's totally kid friendly with a variety of flavors and toppings. It is again paid by weight, but the money per ounce isn't ridiculous. Love ya Smart Cow, keep doing what you're doing! read more

Outstanding! As a Yogurt Bar aficionado, I'm happy to say this one is the perfect spot to indulge. They offer flavors that are creative yet approachable, and the selection of toppings is "TOP notch"! Oh, and, THEY HAVE MARSHMALLOW SAUCE!! They offer a rewards program that is simple to use, and a free 4 oz. serving for downloading their app. The staff members were friendly and the place was clean, even with a steady stream of customers on a Saturday night. It can be a little hard to spot from the road and to make your way through the parking lot maze to get there, but it's totally worth it. Best ice cream option in the Falls. read more

Delicious frozen yogurt and wide array of toppings to choose from. I especially love the fresh fruit toppings.

We love Smart Cow! It's a good treat and fun for the kids (and adults)...giving everyone the opportunity to customize their frozen yogurt. They have so many different flavors and such a wide assortment of toppings - you really can get whatever you're looking for. Love that they have dairy free options too! My son loves eating inside so that he can watch and play along with the trivia that they play on the tv. The outdoor patio is nice for those warm summer days too! Also, love that they give back to local schools - it's a great opportunity to get a treat and support the community! read more

Oh the best yogurt place in the Falls area. I am so glad we have a nice family owned business instead of soulless chains.

I love this Fro-yo shop, I have been to almost everyone in the Milwaukee area and this is hands down the best. They have great flavors, toppings, it is clean, they have trivia to play while you eat, and they even give back to the area schools. Their customer service is amazing!! My daughter left her hat their and the lady working there called me too let me know. Thankfully I am a rewards member and she had my number on my receipt. I can not say enough good things about this place and their company values. Plus the frozen yogurt is creamy, just the way I like it. I try to stop in at least twice a week. read more

This is my daughters favorite place to get a frozen treat. The staff is always nice and the place is very clean. Fun flavors and toppings make for a delicious treat! I also love that they help support local schools. read more

Very nice interiors and designs. If you're looking for brats or hot dogs, I highly recommend this place. They also serve yogurt ice cream so its a great combination. Only drawback of this place is its hard to see the sign. But its like hidden jam. Very quiet and cozy place. Sometimes I get sick of eating sandwiches or burgers so its good place for something else. I would definitely come back for this place. read more

Best yogurt in Milwaukee! I'm a froyo snob and have been to my fair share of places all over the US. This one is clean, has great service, and offers great flavors of creamy yogurt. Good prices and even 20% off for teachers and military with a valid I.d. Definitely stop by here- you'll want to come back! Love that they support local schools too! read more

Love it here! They always have a great verity of flavor and the toppings bar is vast! From other places around here this one is the best! Prices are a little high but they're no different from everyone else pause I like being able to bring something home for my pooch too! read more

By far my favorite frozen yogurt place! Always have the best flavors and the best toppings. Frosted animal cookies and peanut butter sauce...? How can you go wrong?! read more

This place is dope. The ice dream yogurt stuff is great. Lots of flavors to pick from which are great. The strawberries and cream is great. The toppings are good and lots of options. The price isn't bad and is fun for everyone. read more

Love this place! They have a great variety of flavors and they change them fairly often too. I find myself stopping in just to see what's new (the S'mores flavor is great)! Also, we've brought our dog to their outdoor patio several times. It's nice that they sell frozen dog treats at a reasonable price. Clean place and friendly staff! read more

So many flavors! Crazy amount of topping choices!! Always clean, staff is always friendly. Love the chalkboard tables and patio. Pup treats are adorable. Best part is donating back to the community!!! read more

They have a good variety of flavors and a lot of toppings, I would like to have a "plain" flavor because the vanilla (don't remember complete name) yogurt was very sweet and sometimes you just want the plain flavor plus toppings. Is a cute place, clean, staff friendly. I would return soon. read more

I could eat tubs and tubs of this yogurt. It is just delicious and there is such a great selection of toppings. Ive been to a few different froyo places and this is my favorite. The manager was really helpful and nice. She liked my cup of frozen yogurt so much she took a picture of me with my girlfriend for facebook. Cool place in a cool town. Definitely recommend it for its price and taste. Oh and theyve donated thousands for the local schools. Branching out to other locations I will continue to support them! read more

Go almost every other week with friends. Big selection, fun atmosphere and delicious fro-yo!!!!!

Downloaded Yelp just for this. Best frozen yogurt shop around. I went in for a good time, and those men, those fine men behind the counter gave me the best froyo experience of my life. True top of the line service. I would recommend smart cow yogurt bar to anyone looking for a great snack. I feel truly changed by this experience. If the workers behind the counter on the night of Sunday, January 22, 2017 see this: you are the greatest humans to walk this earth. Don't stop being the best. I love all of you, and I love smart cow. read more

By far the best frozen yogurt place in the area! Always a great atmosphere, love how they have trivia on the tv's. Wide array of flavors and toppings. Great customer service as well. read more