Great food & pricing Get the Claudio pizza it is great…read moreVery welcoming staff, Marianne the manager was great Intimate location with lots of heritage & history on the walls

At first we had trouble finding the restaurant. We went up and down the strip mall, but turned out…read moreit's on the side street facing Milan's. There's a small lot next to it but you can park in the main mall parking lot as well. Walking in, you may think this is just a take out place, but snaking down the corridor you will reach the dining room. Of course if you come here you have to try the star shaped pizza, which has a generous dollop of ricotta in each star corner. While there are a few star-shaped pizza on the menu, you can order from the pizzas on the first page and request it to be made star shaped too. They are well known for their pizza, though I personally find it too thin. I like it with a little more chewt, airy doughy texture. But that's just personal preference. Service wise, maybe our waitress is new, but out of four things we ordered two came out wrong. The billing was also incorrect.

The pizza was excellent. Most of all the customer service offered by Facundo, a young man serving…read moreand working the register. The owner should commend this young man who treated us so well

Craving pizza one night we wanted to give this mom and pop shop a try! Needless to say we will…read moredefinitely be eating here again! The pizza was delicious, it was hot and fresh. The garlic knots we ordered smelled so good on the way home we almost ate them in the car! They were also delicious! If you're in the area give them a try you won't be disappointed!

Another visit to this location and again not a single disappointment! The food was delicious. The…read moreservice wonderful. Okay, maybe the only thing is the location is a little small. It's worth the little wait though. Our pizza was delicious again. The garlic cheese rolls, amazing! I highly recommend this location.

The service here was very helpful. I would have liked to see more person pizza options. The pizza…read morehere was a pretty good deep dish, but not the type of pizza to blow your socks off. The ambiance is a suburb area near a calm quiet neighborhood.

The food is delicious here ! Also, Steven provided absolutely outstanding service. From the moment…read morewe arrived, he was warm, friendly, and genuinely welcoming, which made the entire experience even more enjoyable. He has a great knowledge of the menu and offered excellent recommendations that we ended up loving. What really stood out is how attentive and personable he is. He makes you feel taken care of without being overbearing. Every visit feels a little more special because of him. My family has also had the pleasure of being served by Steven, and now they specifically ask for him whenever they come in as well. If you're visiting, I highly recommend asking for Steven. You won't be disappointed!

Great Italian restaurant in a Pinecrest shopping plaza. There is free parking; however, the kit can…read moreget busy. We went for an early dinner and we're seated promptly. The pizzas (cheese and hot honey) were delicious. I ordered the salmon with lemon sauce which would have been so delish too - I just wished they would have made it a bit less salty. They also offered a yummy burnt basque cheesecake. Solid 4.5 stars review!

My go to for pizza. I have been ordering here since they opened and I Always get the Bacon and…read moreonion X cheese, well done and it always comes out great. I ordered a few for my Draft party and everyone loved the pizza. They are great their service is amazing they even ran outside to offer me 2 free cheese pizzas that someone ordered and never picked up. Now that's customer satisfaction. Thank you guys you are the best!!

For me it's a Great place for authentic New York-style pizza, delicious food, and tasty favorites!read more

GREAT GEM! Johnny is awesome with my son... they always…read moremake his pizzza crispy. And great staff and we love going in just to say hey!!! WE LOVE PIZZA JOHHNYS!!!!!

Damn, this pizza is good! We ordered a cheese pizza and a 5 cheese white pizza! Both were super…read moredelicious! Thin crust with just the right amount of sauce (for the regular cheese pizza) and cheese (for both). If you haven't tried it, give it a try! You won't be disappointed!

Time for an updated review because it's been almost six years haha. The Big Cheese is still an…read moreiconic local pizza and pasta place. Love the staff that's been there for so many years and service is always amazing and attentive. The ambience is old school with all the UM frames and dolphin merch up on the walls. Prices have gone up but the quality is still great and the portions are massive! You can definitely share the pizzas and pasta plates. There is additional parking in the back if you can't find any in the front. My favorite dishes are the Chicken Franchise or Chicken Cutlet Parm. Pizzas are all good and shareable. Highly recommend to anyone to check them out if you haven't already. ^.^

I have been coming to this place for years and it has been consistently good. There is not much to…read morethis place. It looks like it has been here for years but it is clean and the seating is comfortable. As soon as you enter they always greet you and seat you right away and a server will come to your table to give menus and take drink orders and will always be available. They always have specials posted on a chalkboard. They have a very full menu with a lot of choices. Their portions are big and the food is fresh and the prices are very reasonable with friendly and quick service. Sometimes this place can get very busy and Parking can be a challenge but most of the time it's easy to get in and out. This is a great local place to come with family and friends. The noise level is perfect, it is great for conversations. I would definitely recommend this place.

My employer offered me a slice of her pizza. It was their Tomato & Burrata one. The description on…read moretheir website stated - Vine-ripened Alta Cucina tomatoes, local burrata (made fresh daily!), garlic, olive oil & fresh basil. It was SOOOO good, that the next day I visited myself to check them out. They have a mini sit in area and a few tables and chairs outside. Service was friendly and efficient. I think this place mainly services pickup and delivery. But you can sit in if you like. I ordered their Wild Shroom pizza. Their description online states - Crimini mushrooms, thyme, shallot, mozzarella, garlic confit, caramelized onions, parsley, sourdough breadcrumbs. This was also good. I adored the smashed garlic on it, and wished there was more of it. The middle of the pizza was a bit soggy, but it was still an excellent pizza. Their pizza dough base is sour dough, which made all the difference. I recommend.

The pizza here was pretty good reminded me of when I first tried NYC style pizza . I service was…read moregreat the ambiance was similar to that of a an upscale restaurant yet this was a pizza spot. My only critique would be that pizza here is overly expensive.

I hadn't been here for a very long time.. but we came yesterday for an early dinner…read more We ordered a Caesar salad to share to start. The portion was fine, and I liked the dressing, but I didn't like that the dressing came on the side as opposed to being mixed in.. I'm not a fan of paying for a sit down and then feeling like I have to work for my food. We ordered a carafe of the red wine Sangria. It was nothing special.. the only fruit was the little fruit in our glasses, none in the carafe. It was like boozy watered down wine.. I don't recommend it. There is no Children's menu here which is a shame. My kids dont like pizza but they love pasta.. they wouldn't eat any of the pasta options on the menu as it was so I asked for penne with Alfredo sauce that they could share. They did like it, but it wasn't enough food for them. I ordered the Ravioli Lombardía (pear and Gorgonzola) however the waiter came back and advised they were out, so he recommended the Mezze Maniche Bronte (pistachio pasta). The Mezze Maniche Bronte was dry.. it didn't have a sauce to it, it was basically pasta out of the pot with pistachio and stracciatella on top.. so I mixed in the stracciatella so it kindof becomes the sauce (again, working for my food). My mom ordered the papardelle bolognese (and I also ordered one to go for my husband). It looked really good.. but my husband said it was okay at best, which is how I felt about my pasta as well. Since the kids were still hungry we ordered a dessert pizza 'chocolate and strawberries' it said. We were pretty sure they'd forgotten about it because it took a long time. Nutella always tastes good.. but the strawberries were very few small slices and they looked sad, perhaps strawberries that had been frozen and thawed. The Nutella goes all the way to the edge, rather than a pizza with an outer crust that you can grab and pickup from, so again, more working for food because I had to cut it up into bites for the kids despite it being a 'pizza'. The ambiance here is very casual and the service isn't great (there was a shift change during our time there - the first server was good). They have booths which I like, but the vinyl on the seats is cracking so my son was complaining that it was hurting his legs. The space is much larger inside than I had realized (I ate here years ago but in the covered outdoor area). The prices here are very high for what it is. We were not at all impressed.

This is a cheese pizza with one basil leaf in the middle. Very disappointing!…read more Where's the fresh tomatoes and fresh mozzarella? And basil???? Also ordered a salad that was supposed to have avocado and it had none. There was also no vinegar or lemon on the salad. I had to doctor it up. It did have a clump of anchovies though! Did not like! Safe to say I will NOT be ordering from here again.

Ordered pizza when I try to pick it up they asked for $.54 cents for buffalo sauce…read moreHow pathetic!

I have been ordering from Anthony's in Pinecrest for years... and the food has always been great…read more(thus why I keep ordering) my go to are the baby meatballs and pizza. Well, today I was greatly disappointed... I get home and open the three orders of baby meatballs which always feed about 10 people. And... well... a picture is worth a thousand words. So dissatisfied that I don't think I'll order from them again. As for the pizza? Tasted like cardboard... how does a restaurant like this mess up an order so bad. Whomever is the manager... do your job! Look at the order to make sure all is up to your quality before you hand it over.