We waited for a bit, but not too long considering Christmas and a Friday. The food was great, especially the chicken Parmigiano. Our server Jennifer was amazing. She was quick, efficient, friendly and professional. The place was very busy and she handled it wonderfully. Our table alone had 8 people at it. The new place is very nice and cozy!! Will definitely go back!!! Much better than the old place!!! read more

Justice was our server and she was awesome! We had a large group-25! She kept all of our orders straight and attended to any and ALL of our requests! Request Justice when you go! read more

We stopped in here after a community event held in the Columbus Commons on a Saturday evening and were able to get right in. With two little girls, we were so impressed how attentive the staff was and they made sure we had quick service. We had multiple staff come and check on us and everyone was extremely friendly - especially our server, Crystal S. While we miss the nostalgia of the original location, this is a great option for families downtown looking for quality food that won't break the bank. read more

Ran into this place while I was downtown Columbus. Amazing food and our waitress was amazing thank you Crystal

Went to dinner tonight had a great experience. Will definitely be back. Had a server named Crystal. Very nice and respectfull. Thanks again. read more

Went for dinner last night and it was delicious! I had beer chili spaghetti and it was even great today reheated. I'll be back soon!

We still miss the former location, but we had a great server (Crystal) and we will return. Everything was great!

My family adored the original Spaghetti Warehouse. Excellent, memorable, craveable food. Today's visit was a real disappointment. Parking is an issue. That walk in the winter will be dangerous for some. They say they validate parking but they just added the parking cost to the bill ?? Valet service is a must. Our server was poor and plain disrespectful to me. She didn't understand what vegan was, offering me shrimp or chicken for my salad. My parents were so upset by the quality of the food. The sauce was not like the old Spaghetti Warehouse. At all. They said yes to cheese on their lasagna, not realizing this would be an additional $6. It seems there were a lot of up charges. No more sourdough bread. Now there are rolls and not very good ones. My sister's chicken parm was dark and almost like yesterday's food reheated. My husband got the meatball appetizer and was the only positive - great meatballs at a $7 deal! His Cheesecake Factory cheesecake was $8. It was Dad's birthday and instead of the dessert he wanted, she put a bowl of 'free' ice cream in front of him. A nice gesture but for $167 bill, Dad should've at least gotten the dessert he wanted at no charge. This meal was a giant miss. The server was lucky my Mom paid today, as if I paid there would not have been the 20% tip. More like $1 or $2. Learn to be a server. Learn special diet restrictions. Do not reach hot bowls of soup across the table instead of walking around and serving the individual person. This causes spills. If there is a spill, like there was today, do not just mop up the liquids and the utensils and shove them back in the food. Lose the attitude. read more

So disappointed, the food was not good, not the same as on Broad Street. The beer chili used to be delicious as well as the bread. They serve rock hard, dry rolls and the beer chili was terrible. The salad was okay but who could mess up a salad? The service was not up to par as well. The server did not ask or provide refills and was very slow and annoying. The parking was ridiculous, their instructions online of where to park, is incorrect at the Commons, make sure you use the correct area of the Commons. Instead of $2 parking, it was $6. I will stick with Little Italy in Groveport! Worse comes to worse, drive on down 71 South and go to Fazoli's on Stringtown Road in Grove City. Trust me, it is better than this. read more

This review is for food only and I never write a review. But this one needs said. I've been in the restaurant business since I was born. You may want to remove the Chicken Marsala from your menu and have the Chef re visit the recipe. I tried it and it wasn't even close very poor quality and bland. Not worth $19. The small piece of chicken was not breaded and looked pounded and was cut into strips. The meal was just a bunch of veggies, can mushrooms the chicken was swimming in a watery broth not a creamy sauce. I ordered a side of mushrooms and never received them. I didn't mention it and was not billed. I have worked with Chefs, Room Chefs, and cooks for many, many years from high end steak houses, to casual. Will I return? Doubt it unless I'm asked. read more

Had an awesome time at Spaghetti Warehouse. Food was fantastic and Reggie is hard working and the best bartender ever.

I was excited to see the new place and was a bit disappointed. It is very modernized and they did not keep any of the old things from the old place at least from where we were seated. Seems way smaller than the old place, like about a fourth of the old place. The service was ok, when it came to refills on our drinks, not so great. I had to ask at least 3 times for a refill from our server as well as twice from other people. I asked when the food was served and my refill finally came well after I was done with my meal and right when we were about to leave. We did not receive our complementary bread. The food was nothing spectacular. Too much black pepper in the wedding soup and carbonara. All I tasted was black pepper. My husband liked his chicken parm but was over cooked to the point where it was on the verge of almost burnt, really dark brown and a bit dry in my opinion. Our daughter loves spaghetti and meat balls but did not touch much of her food. Their "famous" garlic cheese bread was soft and very bland Texas toast. I have very fond memories of the old place and this was not somewhere to make memories with our daughter. Too expensive for what you get. Probably not going back. read more

I never got the chance to eat at this location. The original people at the front were nice. Even change the TV from a Bengals game! The waiter that was seating us was my issue. When we got to the sitting area, he put us by a wall that appeared to be near the waiter doors ( I say appeared because I was focused on the TV on the other wall near the windows). I asked if we could sit closer to the tv because I wanted to watch the game. He gave me this look like, how dare you ask me to do that. I said, well ok this is fine. We' lll just sit here. My friend said, this isn't Burger King you can't have it your way. I responded, I can if I'm paying for it. She repeated the BK comment and I repeated mine. The waiter bends over towards her and says, "you can't take them anywhere." Who is them?? Them? I simply asked to move to a table, A: to be away from the kitchen. B: cause it's closer to the TV and my Seahawks are on the screen but who is them??? The audacity of me asking for a better table. So, I tell my friend, I'm not eating here and start walking out. Please explain to me the attitude, condescending remark and the need to place my friend and I by the kitchen with a fully open floor beside a main table near the tv? Addition: I thank you for the offer but, I do not live in Columbus anymore and my friend who does says, it's not an option anymore. The first impression was horrible and the (description only) middle aged, semi bald, gay gentleman would ruin any dinning experience again. If you would, donate that meal to someone who doesn't have the opportunity to eat in any establishment and have the defined gentleman above deliver it. Maybe being humbled by those less fortunate will help him to be a better host in the future. read more

Extremely disappointed how this amazing restaurant went to crap after the move. Granted You do not eat the decor, but it leaves one to question what is the theme, however it may have had only slightly less taste than the red sauce read more

This place is absolutely terrible. The food and the customer service was the worst. do not waste your time and money.

This is the worst meal I have ever had . I will not return. How they could change to this is an absolute tragedy. The food is completely different no seasoning or taste whatsoever. Even the. Read is different. This absolutely broke my heart read more

Service was like a fast food restaurant that made McDonald's took a five-star restaurant

I have to start out by saying I have only done one YELP review in my life, so therefore, I feel strongly the need to do so now. When we heard about the Warehouse making a comeback we were thrilled! Visited yesterday around 2:45pm to avoid any crowds and due to my daughter and her fiancé having tickets to the Blue Jackets game. First, the trolley...or should I say no trolley, ok, no biggie. Our server wasn't pleasant at all! She took our drink orders and came back with my daughter's fiancés very expensive 3/4 poured beer! He was kind and just accepted it as we all did since we were just so darn happy to be there! Three of us ordered the lasagne and one had the chicken parm. We ordered the meatballs as an appetizer. Now what we were all very anxious for - THE BREAD & BUTTER! Um, where is the small, warm, soft sourdough bread? Nope, small not warm not soft Italian bread came. We all looked like we lost our best friend. None of us were given a bread plate so made a little mess cutting into that bread. The butter was delicious. Salads came out quickly and our server yelled "MA'AM" at me so loudly to grab my salad I jumped! The kids laughed. No more big bowl to share of salad either. Small portions. Still no bread plates so had to ask for those. Our salads were just about gone when our appetizer arrived. We did agree we liked the meatballs app. When dinner arrived my husband's chicken parmesan was overcooked and dry. He still ate it, of course! The lasagne is different. Still large in size, but noticed large cut up Italian link sausages inside. I never remembered that part. Seemed a little watery. We were very disappointed. Had to maneuver around our dirty dishes since no one came to collect them. Our bill was given to us when we slowed down eating. The kids bought our meal which was sweet and we exited the tablefull of dirty plates and glasses carefully not to knock any over! I know it's new, but when you don't have the food staples that helped make you unique it's sad. read more

I got the chicken fettuccine and had high hopes. No. The actually fettuccine had no flavor! The only reason it tasted okay was because I added pepper flake and Parmesan. The food and ordering the drink toke an eternity. Service was okay. The actually scenery was more modern. Disappointed. read more

Never never never again. Reservations before a show and still didn't get seated 35 min after reservation time. Second time we had a problem like this. read more

Prices have doubled had to walk two blocks from the parking garage ambience is gone reminds me of the diner been going to the Spaghetti Warehouse for 30 years will never go back they said the rail car was still there it's not all the Tiffany lighting is gone looks like any diner that you can park at the front door read more

I really like the view and food. The server was very nice and knew her stuff. It helped because that was the first time I've been since the new one opened up. She reminded me of all the things I used to love. She was a very good server and I will try to and request Crystal if I see she is working next time. Lasagna is good as ever. read more

We made a reservation for 6P as we had a 730P commitment. When we arrived at 6P we were told it would be a minimum of 25 minutes and that there were two groups waiting ahead of us. We only came here for convenience and won't return. There are too many better restaurants to deal with poor management and average food. read more

My now 8yr old was upset when the old building closed and she kept up to date on the opening of the new location so of course poppa bear made sure his princess got in on opening weekend and had her spaghetti and meatballs we loved it and it made her smile ear to ear read more

A group of us went for an early dinner after a Broadway Show. The meals each ordered was fine. If you are looking for a gourmet Italian restaurant, this is not one. But it was tasty and the children in our group enjoyed their meals. The ambiance was bright because of all the windows facing the Columbus Commons. However, the shining star of our meal was Kayla, our server. She is without a doubt in my top 5 servers culinary list. Kayla checked with us the appropriate amount of times, promptly checked with the kitchen about food allergies in dishes, very professional and after the children finished their meals, she served them a Popsicle from her private stash kept in the kitchen. If you go, ask for her! read more

Good food, good service. Lunch was speedy! Lots of butter and bread also! Good place for work lunch!

I hate to complain, I'm not sure if our server was new, the whole staff was new, or what was going on here today. We stopped on our way home 2 hours away after my daughter's dance competition. When we walked in there was one small booth for waiting which was taken, very tight quarters for multiple parties to wait, multiple servers were rolling silverware up front, and we had a wait with tons of tables open. Our server took FOREVER to bring our drinks and salad, we had to ask for the bread that's included, and our food came out shortly after so we didn't even have time to finish the salads. He did not clear the table, we had to pile things up ourselves to have room to eat, and we did not get refills without asking and had to again wait forever and by then we were done with our food. Just really not impressed with this location, we have been to others and had way better experiences. All the restrooms(they were individual) were dirty and had full trash so much so that paper towels were all over the floor. I hope for this business things improve at this location. The old location had a much better vibe, decor, and the service was much better. We were bummed to not have a good experience after my daughter's successful dance weekend. To add, we had to find someone else to cash us out so I went to the takeout girl. She couldn't so she went to find our server. A manager brought us our receipt and didn't even speak to us. Pathetic. read more

Forgetful service. Mediocre food. Won't go back. Location was nice though. Forgetful service. Mediocre food. Won't go back. Location was nice though. read more

I ate at The Spaghetti Warehouse today with my aunt and I thought that the food and the staff were Great! Our server, Filando, was very kind and gave us a lot of nice bread to eat while we were there. The atmosphere was Beautiful with a more modern, updated feel to it while still combining the rustic old charm of the older and original building on West Broad Street. My Aunt and I thought it was great and I would highly recommend this place to anyone in town! It also has a Beautiful, Picturesque view of the Beautiful Columbus Commons Park! I thought the experience here was Great! read more

Party of 7 visited Friday December 22. We did not have a reservation. Put our name in and we were seated within 30 minutes. I wish I could remember our servers name. (She use to work at Olive Garden in Grove). She was wonderful. Our food came out perfect. There are many items on the menu that are not available yet. We will go back when everything is available. read more

We had made reservations for 21 but 16 came. I was hoping it was similar to the old spaghetti warehouse. It's not. It's much smaller probably due to being downtown. Its very crowded, table to table. The bright spot was that our server, Justice, was right on top of things. Everyone got served and drinks were refilled right away. Since we had a large group they had put tables together (no problem) but the lighting was only on half of the group. About halfway down the tables it got dark, don't know if they didn't have any lights down there, they were out, etc. Food wise the lasagna orders were not very tasty, the pasta had to be cut by knife it was so not done. The spaghetti that one person had was watery. The calamari was good and so was the ravioli. When we got the check, it was strange, we were told that everyone that was parked in the garage that their tickets would be stamped for a two hour stay. Well, the vouchers that were given to everyone for the parking were added to our check (two dollars for each one given out). As far as ambiance goes, it's great outside. All the Christmas lights are beautiful. Inside I suggest keeping Justice as a server or promoting her! Respectfully, Becky read more

Jordan was amazing, and that pixie martini is delicious!!!!! The view from the restaurant is admirable.

Great service , Jordan was amazing. The atmosphere is very welcoming. Food was delicious!!

My server Cassie was absolutely fantastic! She was so polite and had a very personable personality. Food was pretty okay for it out getting reopened. The restaurant itself was very nice and the vibe was modern! Will be coming back and asking for her again! If I could give 6 stars I would! read more

We loved our time at Spaghetti Warehouse! The staff and food were great! I really enjoyed the new menu items and the robust wine selection. Will definitely be coming back!! read more

Had a great experience at the new spaghetti warehouse. Thurs at 5:20 p. Seated immediately and our server (Quncie-H) wasted no time getting our drinks and order. Can't say anything bad about the meal, taste and portion size were the same as I remembered from the Broad street location. Started to get busy and a bit loud by the time we left. Noticed some very large table seating for large groups. Definitely will return. read more

Great food, service and atmosphere! We enjoyed seeing new menu items and everything tasted great. We can't wait to go back

We always liked Spaghetti Warehouse at its original location on W. Broad St. However, at the new location in Downtown Columbus, you must pay for parking. The restaurant's interior is not the "warehouse" concept. The "trolley car" is not a trolley car, but a series of booths. The food is comparable to what it was, but the service is not good. Last night, we had a party of 13. Some of our party ordered glasses of wine. No one got their correct orders. One who ordered pinot grigio, got sauvignon blanc. She had to wait another 20 minutes until they brought her original order. When our food orders were taken, one of us was skipped. Had to hunt down the waitress to get the order in. Before ordering, we identified to our waitress how the bills would be split. When our bills were finally brought, she said she couldn't bring the paper receipts, so she had to take the orders again and each would pay accordingly. She ended up adding the orders to the wrong people. Won't be going there again. read more

I'm going to review as if I'd never been to the old location, because there is no comparison. This isn't that place anymore, at all. So, as a new Italian restaurant on S High, the plus is, it overlooks the Commons and the stage area. They can open garage doors facing the commons. The minus, the "Trolley" seating is just booths on the hallway between the bar/entrance and dining room, so a busy area to try to eat. Staff didn't seem particularly happy to have patrons there. Not rude just indifferent. Food came and the lasagna was just heaped on the plate with no thought of presentation, which for those prices, is expected to look appetizing. Three small meatballs with the spaghetti. Taste wasn't bad and noodles were correctly cooked. I honestly can get the same meal at Fazolis at half the price and similar atmosphere. Parking is either catch as catch can at meters on the street or a garage two blocks away. read more

My family and I came to this location (Columbus, OH) this past weekend to celebrate my father's birthday and everybody's food was horrible. The manager's name is Jim he came out and gave a discount but the way that food tasted he should have given us our food for FREE!! The hamburger was dry and over cooked very small. The chicken/shrimp alfredo was dry with barely no alfredo sauce. The chicken was dry. The steaks were over cooked and very small. The chicken Parmesan was not good either! The bread was good. The waitress did a good job serving us so we still tipped her, although it wasn't her fault the food was disgusting. The old spaghetti warehouse food was awesome I don' know what happened to the food. I heard from several people not to come here because the food wasn't any good but I just knew they were mistaken because the old spaghetti warehouse on W Broad St did not have complaints like the ones I've been hearing. My family and I will not be back and I will make sure that others know not to waste their time, money, effort, or paying to park to eat here!! This new representation of the spaghetti warehouse definitely leaves the old spaghetti warehouse a disgrace to their name!!! Jim should be ashamed of himself with this!! read more