Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Spicy Pie

    4.0 (42 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:30 pm

    Order Spicy Pie Takeout or Delivery

    Spicy Pie Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Spicy Pie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Tikka Masala Pizza No taste no flavor.
    Pea A.

    I would give 0 stars. Absolutely disappointed going to eat here today. We did our usual order of Tikka Masala Pizza and Spicy Pie, and when we opened the boxes, I was in utter shock. It literally looked like frozen pizza, maybe worse. My family would go here often. The last time we went was January 2025 and it was delicious. we just went today (December 2025) and complete 360 in the food and quality, just horrible. I'm not sure if management changed or their previous chef left, but something is not adding up. Never going back. Also, look at my pictures and compare it to what is on their menu. It was like a "what I thought I ordered vs. what I got situation."

    Tikka Masala Pizza
    Nikki Z.

    The dough is good - soft and chewy with a little bit of a bite. The Tikka chicken topping was tasty, but I didn't care for the sauce or the cheese. I had asked for extra sauce on the side which they couldn't accommodate (reason not given). I wanted to try the sauce separately and dip my crust in for later. The spot is located in a short strip off of Baltimore National Pike. Inside was clean and bare. There were one or two tables to sit. In conclusion, the flavor and components are there but I wasn't enthusiastic by the combination. It made me want chicken Tikka masala and a pizza on its own.

    If you want good fast service, a nice quiet ambiance, and especially delicious middle eastern twist on traditional American cuisine you eat here, the food here is phenomenal and I honestly cannot recommend it enough, I'm surprised this location isn't packed throughout the week.

    Wings masala
    Kendoll C.

    As a lover of spicy heat food & being all about toppings, toppings, toppings, Spicy Pie was a drool-worthy discovery (found via an Instagram recommendation)- very hard to decide what to order, between all their various Indian pizzas, sandwich options, & side dishes- I couldn't just choose one option- I had to wait until a night when friends could join & would could order a bulk variety, trying a lot! We chose chicken tikka masala, spicy pie w.paneer added, chicken biriyani, & side of wings masala Overall, we expected everything to be a lot spicier- maybe our hot sauce loving palates just have too high of a spice level bar, but was fairly disappointed everything was on the mild to no heat side- All pies had a delicious fluffy, well charred crust- the pizzas were 'wet' which means don't expect a crunch; instead they had what's called 'tip sag' where the toppings weighed down the pie- but I enjoyed doughy chewiness the sauciness created. Chicken Tikka Masala- could have used more chicken- the sauce was creamier, with a very mild back-end spice- had more of a tomato sauce flavor- our 2yr old easily downed 2 slices with us, managing the spice Spicy Pie- a very robust flavor combination from the quality roasted peppers- I enjoyed the combination, especially with the hearty paneer added, creating a heftiness to each slice- but wouldn't label it an "Indian pie"-more traditional roasted pepper pie Chicken Biriyani-could also have used more chicken- while the sauce was deliciously creamy, with a bold flavor profile, the pie was really just dough & sauce- Wings Masala (5count)- hearty, juicy wings- heavily breaded, smothered in ample sauce- had a great taste, but again wasn't spicy, just creamy (2yr old downed 1 wing, managing the spice) Overall, pro: I enjoyed the creamy bold Indian flavors & the wet doughy chewy crusts, but felt the pies could use more toppings & felt let down they weren't as spicy as the expected hype- Glad to try them out for ourselves. Was a fun new dining experience, but wouldn't be a regular customer, as I would rather just order traditional high spice level Indian food & use leftovers to re-create the pies at home with dishes w.more heat. Also while the sizes of the pies were hearty for their price, the lack of toppings left a bit more to be desired-

    Chicken Tikka Masala pie
    Adam K.

    3.5 Stars This place is different, coming in hot with an Indian take on your local pizzeria! Believe the name, there is a kick to everything! My wife and I got our children a pepperoni pizza to be safe, and they liked it, but said it was spicy. Their masala spice mix is blended into the tomato sauce. I loved it, but if you're someone sensisitve to spice, this might not be the place for you. Even the fries (regular masala fries and the garlic-parmesan fries) have this spice blend all over. The chicken tikka masala pizza was a safe place to start and I rather enjoyed it. We wanted to try the palak paneer pizza but we had to cut ourselves off. I'll try that next time. Out of curiosity, we also got the buffalo chicken sandwich which had a delightfully vinegary sauce all over it. Would get again. The inside is small and unassuming. There are tables for dining in, but I ordered takeout and the one guy at the counter was ready when I came to pickup. Very business-forward. I think I'll try them again even if only to try some of the unique offerings to be found here.

    Chicken tikka pizza. Delicious! :)
    Jannet C.

    This place is amazing! Today, I went there and got a paneer pizza and chicken wings. Everything was very delicious! I love how they take very familiar concepts and put in unique taste to it. The paneer pizza has curry spinach, peppers, tomatoes, mushrooms, paneer, mozzarella and parmigiana cheese; all on top of their perfect, fresh Naan crust. The chicken wings were crispy on the outside, and tender on the inside, and has a great curry flavor. I ordered online, and the food was ready when I went to pick it up. This is a great place overall. I'll be back soon, to try their other items, I heard their burger sandwiches are delicious too.

    Palak paneer pizza
    P P.

    11 stars out of 5. Absolutely blown away. Ya gotta be kidding me, INDIAN PIZZA baby!! Gonna work hard to to curse on this one. Service was lovely and helpful, the person at the desk took our order and brought out our 2 pies nice n quick. Very relaxed atmosphere in there, and only about 6 months old! We ordered the palak paneer pizza and the biryani veggie mix pizza. THE HOTDAMN CRUST is sensational! Whether or NAAT it's naan, it's delicious, fluffy and so well baked. The flavor of each pie was identical to the classic Indian dishes. Can't get over it, can't get enough of it. I wish I was spending the rest of my day swimming in a pool of all the flavors of these pizzas. Unsung Maryland hero restaurant. Here's to many more Indian pizzas.

    Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza
    Danny B.

    A little disappointed. Everything seemed of a respectable quality (above average compared to your regular pizza place), minus the weird cheap tasting parmesean crumbles on the crust. But it just didn't quite hit the spot for me. Wasn't the flavor bomb I was hoping. Would rather have regular pizza or regular Indian food. I think the tikka sauce, having dairy in it, muted the acidity of the tomato, which is a necessary counterbalance on pizza to the fatty cheese. Was just hoping for a big pop of flavor with every bite, instead it was just good enough to keep me satisfied.

    Mumbai Margherita Personal Pan Pizza

    Food is good, fresh & hot! Very flavorful! Chicken is extra crispy. Food was ready fairly quickly as well

    Palak paneer pizza ($15)
    Mike O.

    Down in Cantonsville visiting friends and almost immediately we debated pizza styles -- now that I have 8 years of Jersey under my belt. This concept is a delightful naan pie with the most amazing flavor combinations. Tucked in a strip mall opposite the Aldi's, lots of parking and bright signage shows you the way. Bright lights and few simple tables and chairs leave room for a huge line of customers ordering to go or picking up. If vote-by-presence is an endorsement, the number of Indian customers here says THIS IS IT. so many options! All veg for ours didn't matter. I did t miss my pepperoni (I know, right??) Ours were the spicy pie and palak paneer pie. Spicy was a bit moist because the caned jalapeño slices hadn't been dried, but the flavor was awesome. The palak paneer was also a huge win with a very nice spice level that left me bristling and ears burning! Great choice!

    Masala Chicken Burger
    Olivia H.

    I've been wanting to try their chicken tikka marsala pizza and I'm happy with it. it's not too think of a crust and has great flavor. I also ended up order the garlic parm fries and chicken marsala sandwich as well. all were yummy

    Chicken Biryani Pizza

    See all

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    fantastic new pie flavors - and delicious! don't let the location fool you - this is THE pie!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Spicy Pie

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Burgers 6,949 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Eataliano Market & Deli

    Eataliano Market & Deli

    4.1(241 reviews)
    5.2 mi
    $$

    "Tell me what you miss most," Ava Fremont, a witness to a murder, signs and expresses to Detective…read moreFrank Shaw, who recently lost his hearing, in Director Brad Anderson's 2024 film, The Silent Hour. "My daughter, S A M," Shaw signs back, "playing guitar," as he makes hand motions. "Being able to hear that." "You don't need to. Every spring, I go to the Boston Pops." "Why?" Frank asks disconsolately. "To watch...the feeling...the musicians...to see their joy. It's enough. To see that, to share it." Watching Ava recapture physically not just the performance in her retelling but the appreciation from both musicians and concert-goers alike, Frank starts to rediscover hope, even as he and Ava try to stay alive from the killers hunting them. The appetizers, entrees, and desserts from Eataliano Market & Deli, located at 5325 Phelps Luck Drive in Columbia, Maryland, prompt similarly unexpected overflows of culinary memories and joy. Upon our first visit of what we hope will be many, my wife and I placed the following takeout order: 1 order of Baked Meatballs 2 orders of Garlic Bread 1 ten-inch Empire Pie (I requested no ricotta or extra virgin olive oil) 1 order of Rigatoni Meatballs alla Vodka 1 order of Spaghetti with Homemade Meat Sauce 1 slice of Limoncello Mascarpone Cake 1 slice of Pistachio Cheesecake The garlic bread and pistachio cheesecake alone conjured spectacular reminisces. The pizza is the best we've had in Maryland, although my wife regretted my choice of no ricotta; and we would gladly reorder our pasta dishes if we didn't have many more entrees that we want to try.

    What a fabulous neighborhood gem! How did I not try this place sooner? Eataliano is tucked right…read moreinto the Phelps Luck neighborhood, not far from Route 108 (Old Annapolis Road) and Columbia Palace Plaza. I had heard there could be a bit of a wait, which isn't surprising since this well-established market and deli draws not only local residents but also people from nearby businesses. I happened to be about 15 minutes away, so I placed my order through their website. By the time I arrived, I must have missed the lunch rush--there was no line, and it took just a couple more minutes for everything to be wrapped, packaged, and ready to go. The market itself is intriguing and packed with all sorts of house-made specialties and popular Italian brands. There were also plenty of brands I had never heard of, giving the place the feel of a little Italian countryside market. I can only dream of traveling to Italy someday, so for now, I'll happily get a little taste of Italy here! Parking: As mentioned, parking is very limited. The street alongside the shop was also undergoing some sort of construction during my visit, so be prepared for some roadside limitations. There is a small, intimate dining area with room for only about four tables, but I loved seeing the white-tablecloth treatment. It added such a warm and welcoming touch to what is otherwise a very busy little establishment. The staff were busy but friendly. With the back-of-house operation appearing to be quite busy and working within tight quarters, it was impressive to see how well everyone seemed to coordinate and make the most of the available space. What We Tried Eataliano Crab Roll -- A specialty my daughter had told me about after seeing it on TikTok, and now I understand why! Generously filled with a tender, tasty blend of lump crab meat and fillers. Definitely shareable--but only with your favorite people! 10" Margherita Pie -- A NY-style thin crust topped with fresh ingredients, including tomato sauce, house-made mozzarella, and whole basil leaves. Simple, fresh, and delicious. French Fries -- Crispy and crunchy, just as ordered. Sometimes you just need a good order of fries! Greek Salad -- A generous portion loaded with fresh ingredients: feta cheese, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, Kalamata olives, carrots, green peppers, and pepperoncini. Fresh, colorful, and plenty to share. Overall, Eataliano is exactly the kind of neighborhood gem I love discovering. Between the market, deli, prepared foods, and cozy little dining area, there's plenty to come back and explore. Definitely worth a visit--and I'm already wondering what I should try next!

    Photos
    Eataliano Market & Deli - March 2023

    March 2023

    Eataliano Market & Deli - The Real Philly Cheesesteak

    The Real Philly Cheesesteak

    Eataliano Market & Deli

    See all

    Trattoria Amore

    Trattoria Amore

    3.8(154 reviews)
    5.2 mi
    $

    Classic red sauce Italian is the main staple at Trattoria Amore. We did a take-away of a couple…read morepasta dishes and meatball sliders... spoiler, the sliders are a meatball sub cut into four portions. It's not traditional, but great comfort food! The meatballs were well seasoned and complimented by the flavorful red sauce. The tortellini tricolor in tomato cream sauce was savory and paired well with the tangy sweetness of the sun-dried tomatoes. Cheers!

    2.16.23 This…read morerestaurant is located in Dorsey's Search Village Center. They offer daily manager's specials and also on Monday and Tuesday's. Catering is also available. They offer lunch and dinner size for their entrees. Lunch is served until 3pm. All dinner entrees are served with pasta, garlic, or regular bread. A side salad can be added to any dinner for $1.99. Orders are placed at the counter and you are given a number to place at your table. Orders are brought out to you. My hubby and I came in for dinner and ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It took about 15 minutes to make. A little longer than I would have expected since we were the only ones dining in. I did see a few people doing carryout. The pizza looked ginormous, but we managed to eat three slices each with two slices to take home. The pizza was crunchy, but I didn't think it was anything special. I actually prefer our usual pizza spots over Trattoria. On our way leaving, we were acknowledged and thanked, which was nice, but we're unlikely to return.

    Photos
    Trattoria Amore - 2.15.23

    2.15.23

    Trattoria Amore - Mozzarella sticks

    Mozzarella sticks

    Trattoria Amore - 2.15.23

    See all

    2.15.23

    Spicy Pie - burgers - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...