Stefano&#x27;s Mexico

I called and ordered a medium pizza which was an insane price. The guy on the phone taking my order…read morewas a total dick bag. He was so rude and snotty and never said anything nice and welcoming. Don't work customer service if you are going to be an asshole. The pizza was also awful. I spent almost 30$ on a JUST a pizza and some shitty ass phone service. Delivery drive was a weirdo too.

Honestly it is bad practice to put the toppings under the cheese because it falls apart! Not only…read morethat it is extremely greasy as it has no where to go creating a layer between the dough and toppings, it is just a mess. Presentation wise, still bad, all the "toppings" are covered with cheese so you don't really know what you're getting and for 2 dollars a topping, it is kind of insulting. Many other good pizza places, go here if you want to deal with these issues.

Chicken wing pizza with onions

Hot had and cheese with fries

See all

Buffalo bites

The Bake Shop Eatery

3.3(10 reviews)

0.0 mi

Paid 19.50 for a medium 2 topping pizza that was the thinnest pizza I've ever had. Eatable but not…read moregreat. Can of soda 3.50 I initially wanted a couple other items from their listed menu - a Hamburger and fries or Wings which they had neither and haven't for over a year. Last trip here. Crust was literally so thin I could see through it. Worth the drive to Cicero or Liverpool for pizza for sure.

Excellent food! Many different options, subs, pizza, panini's, and pastries! Everything i've ever…read morehad here was flavorful and at a great price!

Menu page#1

See all

Holiday baked goods order form

Creekside Pizza Wings & Things

4.7(3 reviews)

14.7 mi

Wings are large and well seasoned. I like my wings on the crispy side and these are perfectly…read morecrispy!!! The pizzas are very good as well. I haven't tried any of the other goodies but they all sound amazing!!! We have ordered a few times and they have always been consistent. Highly recommend!!

We ordered 2 pizzas and wings to give Creekside a try recently. The pizzas were decent, but we were…read moredisappointed to not be able to order 1 with garlic as is our custom. The wings were a bit on the small side, but were well sauced and full of flavor. Everything was ready on time as advised for a hassle-free time at pick up. Overall they seem to have the basics right, and now just need to work at perfecting what they have on offer.

Stefano's Pulaski

3.5(63 reviews)

8.8 mi

Talk about a family business! With multiple locations around the area run by various family…read moremembers we appreciate being able to find our local favorites like Stromboli and I love to get a salad with Italian and crumbly bleu cheese. Have a large crowd or event they have a nice space to accommodate that too. Family run businesses where they know your regular order without saying a word.

We stopped in on our way home and was pleasantly surprised. The staff was pleasant, the place was…read moreclean, and we all really enjoyed our food. If you're gluten-free, I highly recommend their gluten-free pizza. It's one of the best I've had.

Cheese pizza

Ziti... I still have it...

See all

Stromboli

Passarella Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.3(29 reviews)

6.3 mi

Have tried several menu items & all have been excellent!! Best pizza in the whole county! Their…read moreplace is small but cozy & smells so good inside it's hard to decide what to order. Everything looks & smells so good my bunch wants it all, lol. The owners are the sweetest people ever, very accommodating & attentive. Once got a flat tire on my way to pick up my order. They stayed over & let me get my order well after closing time...who else would do that! I had called to cancel but they convinced me to get there when I could. My order was excellent, warm, & not all dried out from waiting. The Passarellas do business the old fashion way, their customers are their top priority & they treat them all like family. All ingredients are super fresh, top quality, & they're not stingy with toppings. The only place I will get pizza in this county!!

The Food is delicious; pizza, wings, pasta...all of it! The owner is friendly. *****/*****read more

Garlic knots

Apps and entrees!!!

See all

Mill House Market

4.4(88 reviews)

8.8 mi

Have had both breakfast and lunch at the Mill House and have had great meals! Love the bourbon…read moresyrup for lattes!! They have to go cold brews & lattes now which is awesome. We love checking out all the cute local items for sale in the front of the shop.

I really wanted to like this place because the sandwiches truly are delicious. Unfortunately, the…read moreowner's behavior completely overshadowed the food, and after giving her three chances, I won't spend my money there again. On our first visit, my 87-year-old father casually mentioned that he hadn't known the place existed. The owner responded by yelling at him about how long the business has been open and listing other places she owns, leaving him feeling embarrassed and ignorant. The final straw happened during my most recent visit. I flew in from Las Vegas and wanted to take my parents, both in their 80s, to get sandwiches. Standing for long periods is difficult for them, so they sat briefly in the dining area while I ordered. They were the only customers in the restaurant at the time. They were immediately yelled at and told they could not sit there unless they ordered from the dinner menu. My father politely explained that we were ordering sandwiches and that his daughter had just flown in. The owner said it didn't matter--if we weren't ordering off the dinner menu, we had to leave. As a result, we were forced to eat in our car in the middle of winter. Great food does not excuse disrespectful, unkind treatment--especially toward elderly customers. The lack of compassion was shocking, and I will not return.

Inside store area

Breakfast 1. Sandwich Choice of Meat and Cheese with Canadian Bacon and cheddar cheese.

See all

Cafe Latte - Large with a shot of Bourbon Caramel

Paulanjo's Pizza

3.0(21 reviews)

8.8 mi

Stopped in for lunch. You can't order slices here so I had to order a small pie. Wait wasn't bad,…read moremaybe 10 minutes. Mom and pop feel to this place. Pizza was solid. Didn't blow me away but wasn't bad. I would go here again.

Good pizza, fast and easy delivery. Overall friendly service…read moreby staff on the phone as well as their delivery drivers each time we've ordered

Chicken wing pizza with onions

Hot ham and cheese sub

See all

Buffalo bites

New York Pizzeria

3.9(165 reviews)

84.1 mi

We were in town for the baseball tournament at Dreams Park. It was like a second honeymoon. No kids…read morein tow and our son of course stayed in the barracks. It was wonderful. :-) We came here with friends also parents from the team. Easy parking. Fast service. We sat upstairs - it was like our own private dining room. We got a couple of different pizzas and some salads. Everything was very good. Absolutely recommend.

We thought we'd get a slice of pizza as we weren't that hungry. But they had full dinners,…read moresandwiches, etc., not just pizza on the boards. I ordered eggplant parm; my companion got lasagna. It came with salad & garlic knots. The salad was enormous & varied: olives, shredded cabbage, shredded carrots, tomatoes, not just lettuce. Really good. Then the dinners came out, on real plates with real utensils, not the usual pizzeria plastic/paper. Beautiful, large portions. Everything was really good (except the garlic knots were fairly ordinary). We ate on tables outside & got into a conversation with fellow diners, friendly spot. The parking lot was full, service took awhile but I assume it's because everything was cooked to order. It was just a lucky find. Wonderful place!

Sample of drinks we ordered but they have many to choose from.

Small pepperoni pizza

See all

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Village Pizzeria

3.7(11 reviews)

19.9 mi

Pizza is pretty good but with three people working you have to plan ahead on orders better. I…read morephoned in my order 90 minutes ahead but when I arrived they were behind and I got it late anyway. Plus there were no drinks at all.

I've always loved the food here but if there is an employee there that's doesn't like u don't order…read morefood from there cause ur food will be shit. I spent 45 dollars on food the wings weren't even covered in sauce and the pizza we couldn't even pick up a slice cause it just fell to mush on our plate. It's sad to come to this cause I have always loved the food but I will never go there again. U would think people who made food for a living would be embarrassed to serve food like that!!!

See all

Wings very crispy

Peter's New York Pizzeria

4.8(21 reviews)

33.7 mi

Was driving through town recently and wanted a quick late afternoon snack…read more This place was exactly what I hoped it would be. The guy working the counter was friendly and welcoming. He still had a few slices left from lunch, so I grabbed one of those. It was excellent New York style thin crust. Perfect for an afternoon snack. Bathroom was clean, parking was easy, food was good, and the pizza chef was a cool dude. There's a few booths for seating indoors and, at least in the summer, two tables outside. I'll gladly stop here next time I'm in town and need a bite.

Great pizza , their "weird" sauce is really good. Always positive and friendly, definitely…read morerecommend trying a slice

Two slices of cheese pizza and garlic knots.

See all

Stefano's Mexico - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Stefano's Mexico also viewed

Stefano's Pulaski

3.5

(63 reviews)

Talk about a family business! With multiple locations around the area run by various family…read moremembers we appreciate being able to find our local favorites like Stromboli and I love to get a salad with Italian and crumbly bleu cheese. Have a large crowd or event they have a nice space to accommodate that too. Family run businesses where they know your regular order without saying a word.

We stopped in on our way home and was pleasantly surprised. The staff was pleasant, the place was…read moreclean, and we all really enjoyed our food. If you're gluten-free, I highly recommend their gluten-free pizza. It's one of the best I've had.

Canale's Restaurant

3.6

(132 reviews)

A classic Italian restaurant. The rich wood interior and low lighting makes it the spot for an…read moreintimate dinner or family gathering. Extensive menu available. Sauce available for sale (the marinara is delicious). And service is excellent. Summertime on the patio is also fantastic

The problem isn't so much the food - it's the service. The server doesn't check on you. She's…read moretalking in the back. Asked for lemon- didn't get it. Asked for a straw - didn't get it.

Avicolli's Pizza

4.5

(39 reviews)

Even a small antipasto was large enough for extra to bring home. It was packed with ham, salami,…read moreolives, pepperoncini, pimentos, lettuce. It's a meal in itself. Delicious! Service was friendly; pizza shop atmosphere.

When you walk into a place and the entire counter is stacked with to-go orders and there's barely…read morean open table in the joint.....it gives the impression that they've got something going on. We grabbed one of the two available tables and the waitress quickly dropped off menus. The restaurant has a large open space in front of the counter and the pizza prep and pizza oven are right there to watch. By the looks of things the owner was running the oven - he didn't stop and when he wasn't checking pies he was talking with customers or shooting across the room to clear a table. We opted for the medium pizza and 10 wing special....added anchovies to the pizza (just because). Pizza was awesome, waitress served our first slices and the wings ordered medium we're well sauced and large. Nice place - can obviously tell now why they're so busy.

Two Brothers Pizza

3.3

(3 reviews)

We decided to take a chance on their Chicken Parmesan pizza and hot buffalo wings. Both items were…read moredelicious and any leftovers were fought over by family members. Luckily, such conflict did not escalate and result in injuries or fatalities, but it was a definite possibility! We'll be back to sample more dishes in the near future, and tempt fate with the leftovers again.

2 Brothers Pizza…read more 1:20 to get here. Almost understandable on a Friday evening. Wouldn't have been a problem if I didn't have to microwave it to eat it hot. Called, and got a very rude and impatient person who yelled that they would send another order and hung up on me. After once again feeling the lukewarm at best temp of my "meal" and deciding to microwave it, i called back to speak to a manager about the rudeness I had encountered and to stop the "2nd order". I asked for the manager and was put on with the first person who had already been rude and hung up on me. Questioned if she was the manager and she said she was the owner. Denied hanging up on me and became rude once more. Needless to say, 2 Brothers Pizza has lost my business permanently. It's ok. I don't mean much to them and Paulanjo's delivers here.

Marias Family Restaurant

3.8

(68 reviews)

2 eggs 2 toast…read more $6.75 They are over $2.00 over priced Wades at least included homefries and is still LESS expensive A dozen eggs can be had for $1.00 Loaf of bread $1.50 A 42 cent meal at almost a 2,000% markup Make that make sense Million dollar Restarants ocean front / hostess / 2 waiters and those places are less Sorry Maria's not sorry Places like you PUSH customers towards McDonalds or Byrne Dairy $2.50 meals

My son has been going to SUNY Oswego for 4 years and we FINALLY managed to get breakfast here…read more Sorry we waited so long because it was excellent. Our waitress was just the right amount of sassy and the food was plentiful and delicious. The late Wednesday morning crowd was either local elderly regulars or college students. Two groups who know the importance of a good deal.

The Red Sun Fire Roasting Co

4.2

(173 reviews)

Love this spot. Eclectic menu, great service. Today I enjoyed their wood fired pizza - Margarita!…read moreOlive oil base with cheese, tomatoes and basil. Guinness topped off the meal. Fun ambience- high ceilings and lots of art work hanging on the walls.

What to say about Red Sun that hasn't already been said- the restaurant is one of, if not, the best…read morethat Oswego has to offer. Fresh ingredients, delightful flavors, a curated menu and freshly made deserts! We have frequented this restaurant each time we are in town and truly. It never disappoints. From the appetizers to the main courses to the cocktails- Red Sun delivers. On our most recent outing I had the Pig and Swig pizza- fire roasted with pork sausage, broccoli, red onions, red pepper and mozzarella this was absolutely delicious! We shared the fire roasted wings too which were amazing! I had a cocktail- which sadly I cannot remember the name of but I do know that it has my favorite gin- Empress. Red Sun is one of the very few restaurants in Oswego to carry this delightful brand- and it makes me super happy! Laurie the owner, has been in business for quite a while in Oswego and also owns the delightful Port City Cafe right next door as well as the new and exciting Lorbird in Fulton- another amazing experience. We were so fortunate to meet and spend time chatting with her and let me say- this lady knows her stuff. Most inspiring is that she knows her customers and their tastes and she knows how to be successful! Red Sun is an absolute must when visiting Oswego- you won't be disappointed! It's an elevated experience that I truly hope will inspire other establishments to rise to!

Village Pizzeria

3.7

(11 reviews)

Pizza is pretty good but with three people working you have to plan ahead on orders better. I…read morephoned in my order 90 minutes ahead but when I arrived they were behind and I got it late anyway. Plus there were no drinks at all.

I've always loved the food here but if there is an employee there that's doesn't like u don't order…read morefood from there cause ur food will be shit. I spent 45 dollars on food the wings weren't even covered in sauce and the pizza we couldn't even pick up a slice cause it just fell to mush on our plate. It's sad to come to this cause I have always loved the food but I will never go there again. U would think people who made food for a living would be embarrassed to serve food like that!!!

The Rooftop Lounge Oswego

3.8

(42 reviews)

Best place in Oswego for cocktails and a proper meal with a view. Located in a building in middle…read moreof town close to River.

I am not a big fan of the restaurant as it is just too ritzy for the locals! The placement of the…read morerestaurant is a cool concept but you would have to dress up to fit in soooo I am out sorry!

Bistro 197

4.1

(100 reviews)

Staff. Chef. Fresh. Imagination. Oswego's best…read more Cocktails are magic. Food is creative and fabulous. Service is beyond great yet intrusive. Your loss if you don't join the party.

The Beef Short Rib was absolutely Amazing! It was so tender the meat was simply falling apart, and…read morethe flavor was delightful! (Warm, rich, full of flavor) just a beautiful dish!

The Press Box

3.4

(110 reviews)