The Calzone was good with even ratio of Ricotta and Mozzerrela, the philly cheese steak didnt come as ordered, I wanted oil and vinegar, it came with none nor mayonnaise not even any grease so it was dry, Very small amount of steak meat Wouldnt order again.. The service was fast and friendly.. we ordered takeout so really cant comment on Ambience.. read more

See all

I stopped at Stella's for a slice and they topped it off with a thick helping of sliced sausage, and I have to say "it was great!" The crust was crispy and light, the perfect New York slice. This,,, definitely is the best pizza in Torrington. I've stopped in here a number of times before, but today was the most enjoyable. That's a review. read more

Did take out for the first time recently. Ordered the "New Yorker" pizza, Greek salad, and tiramisu. Really loved the pizza sauce. Everything was delicious. Will definitely return. read more

Came here the first time last week for pizza and it was good Second time it was no good and I was barely able to cut the pizza Something was wrong with the dough. If you own a restaurant yer supposed to be consistent with the texture and taste of the food. Not vary from employee to employee read more

we've been here a couple times & we love it! their pasta is really good also, we got a pizza this time & it was delicious! their really friendly & quick here while their polite! i def recommend(: read more

Stella's Restaurant & Pizzeria - new york style pizza - Italian Near Me - Torrington, Connecticut

I've come here several times for takeout since they opened mid-Spring of 2020. I really wanted to like this establishment, but unfortunately, the food has fallen short of my expectations. Pizza sauce is decent, but the pie itself was too greasy. I was careful driving home with my sausage pizza that night, but a good amount of the cheese still slide off the side despite my attentive driving (see my pic). Toppings were a bit on the skimpy side also. Antipasto Salad is over-priced at $12.95 for what you get -- I've bought more fulfilling salads at other restaurants for less. 100% iceberg lettuce, and not much of it. Chicken Parmigiana Grinder was OK, mozzarella sticks were alright. I also picked up a couple of slices of cheesecake one night, it had just come out of the oven. Problem with the cheesecake was, it was made with ricotta cheese, instead of cream cheese (or the ratio of ricotta to cream cheese was much higher, at the very least). Gave the cheese cake a grainy texture and it leaked water. Burnt on the top also. As I stated above, I really wanted to like Stella's, but they need to make improvements. Can't see a reason for a return visit until they do so. read more

See all

Bland, forgettable pizza. A bit on the oily side as well. Shrimp does not smell appetizing. Add some deserts and you might as well be shelling out for hibachi $$$. Delivery arrived on time. Hope they can improve. read more

Stella's Restaurant & Pizzeria - pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Torrington, Connecticut

See all

The pizza slides all over the place real cheesy like the establishment.. ITZ AHH STELLA"S their raw slogan. The fries are good their daughter ain't bad has a decent character if she gets her way, but a lot a lot of fighting goes on here. Also they use too much bleach and then go make the food like that sometimes. They need to be more professional. They came from Florida, but don't act like it too much. If the dad has to cook because he can't find a new decent one he flips out screaming swearing and going off his rocker where he should just sit and rock slow seeing all the lies he's spread. Not to mention the mice outbreak and rats crawling around his building. Waterbury is where he misses and where he should go back to. That man can cook though when he isn't throwing a temper tantrum. He's just run down like his business. read more

I ordered a burger and fries and a chicken Caesar salad. They forgot the dressing but brought it back!! The food is delicious!! I will definitely order again. They were so nice. read more

I had a few guys working in the yard today and randomly chose Stella's to order from. We ordered a large white clam, and a large meat lovers which unfortunately showed up as pepperoni! The restaurant, without hesitation, made the large meat lovers at no extra charge for the pepperoni that the guys ate, and were very apologetic! This has to have been the tastiest pizza we had from any pizza place in the area, everything about it was perfect! I can't get enough of the crust! We'll be back for certain! read more

Food was terrible Service was even worse Ambiance was not good ladies behind counter fought with each other. Couldn't wait to get out of there. Definitely won't be back. read more

I've never had a bad pie from Stella's. Always get eggplant and meatball or sausage and garlic. We pick it up, mostly because the store has no control over the quality of delivery services like DoorDash. I went in the rain and the fellow inside carried out my pizza and opened my car door. I was impressed and will give them my business as long as they're around. The pizza can be greasy, but if it bothers you just blot it with a paper towel before eating. Reviews are nice to go by, sometimes, but I encourage you to try them for yourself and make an informed choice. I love Stella's pizza! read more

Stella's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Large pizza with sausage and garlic. - Italian Near Me - Torrington, Connecticut

The woman answering the phone got my order wrong. Then when i called to complain, she argued with me and tried telling me I didn't order the item I was missing! They charge too much to mess up orders and then be rude about their mistake! Customer service needs work. read more

Wish there was an option for negative stars!! Place is absolutely disgusting. Food all over the floor, cook was eating pizza while cooking my pizza with bare hands! Pizza and pasta dishes devastatingly gross. Zero taste, cheap ingredients, pizza raw, I could go on much more. Place needs to be shutdown or seriously step your game up. I offered some pizza to my dog (who adores cheese and pepperoni) and no lie, he completely snubbed his nose and wouldn't even smell it. What does that tell you?! Stay far far away! read more

I'm not impressed. Ordered a Margherita pizza for my boyfiend, it was covered in way too much, very low quality mozzarella, hardly any basil, tomatoes or garlic, no dollops of ricotta or drizzle of olive oil. The pizza crust was hardly edible, much too chewy. Texture was like it was frozen... I also ordered calamari I wasn't impressed with but to each their own. I ordered from here once before and got a really tasty bruchetta and salad. I hate leaving bad reviews, but this was honestly borderline inedible. The only good thing I can say is the kitchen looked clean. But , there was nobody cooking in it. So everything must have been reheated. Good luck read more

Ordered through Grubhub tonight. Food arrived on time but was a little bit cold. We ordered the chicken limone and chicken Milanese. Both were pretty good. Nothing different than you can get at any other place in town. Food was a bit expensive for the quantity. Overall not bad. read more

I am going to be honest, I am extremely highly ticked off. I never had Stella's before 1st time and I should have looked at the Yelp Reviews, Ordered Chicken Tenders and I got 3! 3 freaking small chicken tenders and the rest was onion rings. The onion rings were good, The Antipasto Salad was supposed to have no red peppers or green peppers. The pizza pepperoni and bacon, I paid about 2 bucks for the bacon to be put on and the bacon wasn't even all around the pizza it was just like someone took a handful of bacon bits and just threw it on the center. The tiramisu cake for 7 bucks wasn't even a good portion size. Mozzarella sticks were over priced and okay, I think Stella's should be ashamed of themselves. read more

See all

Our first Stella's order today - had a pizza split with two toppings and a Greek salad. Delivery was very fast, and the food was insanely good. We have a new pizza place! read more

I ADORE Pizza, and all-things Italian. So far I've had their Margherita and New Yorker pizzas, cheese rav, and house salad. All get a 5/5 review, except for the house salad, which earned a 6/5. I know 12/10 is not a normal review, but TRY IT. read more

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza. I instead received a leaf pizza in which; rather than simply putting pepperoni on my pizza, the cognitively challenged employees at Stella's thought it'd be fitting to put literal leafs (like the kind on a tree.... literal leafs) on and in my pizza. I have no words, i actually laughed out when i first took a bite of my pizza, only to be greeted by the sour crunch of Connecticut's finest leaf. 0/5 stars, they put leafs in my pizza like what?! Stay far away read more

I just had raviolis and manicotti from them and it was a big disappointment the ravioli was no better than chef boyardi with parsley on it 14.95 for 6 ravioli and ripped bread and then on top of it the manicotti was cold I called them and told them about it and they didn't care so I'm no longer going to go to them very disappointed read more

Stella's is so awesome! The food is fresh, the people are so friendly and the experience is great. They work hard and it's nice to see them come together and create amazing food! They definitely are my go to when ordering pizza! From customer service to quality food. FIVE STARS ALL AROUND! They make you feel like family . read more

A friend got this pizza and it smelled so good in the car that I decided to order it when I got home that night for dinner! Really good pizza and caprese salad! read more

My husband and I ordered 3 meals which totaled to about $80 . That wouldn't be a problem if the food was actually GOOD. Food is seasoned poorly, it's bland and tasted average. Nothing special for an $80 dinner. My husband and I are super laid back as well, not picky eaters whatsoever... but this was so disappointing i had to write this review which is my first review I've ever wrote. Do NOT order from here . read more

I was in the mix between 2 and 3 stars. Only reason for the 3 is that the pizza was still edible. First time here and last time. Only based on pizza and salads for 3 people. Salad was over salted and peppered. That went into the the trash. The cheese pizza was very greasy and the cheese was falling off in blobs. Another pizza with toppings looked as though if they were just thrown in handfuls on it. Both were the taste of grease and salt. If you ever had pizza down south at the fake Italian restaurants, this is exactly what it reminded me of. Bland crust and cheap ingredients. Sadly enough it fits right into Torrington. read more

Their fettuccine Alfredo was some of the best I've had. We have gotten take out several times and have never had a bad meal. Cheesecake is amazing! read more

Ordered Veal Parmigiana and was greatly disappointed. The veal was tough as nails, sauce watery, spaghetti was ok but a kids portion. Never again read more

ordered by mistake and it was a mistake. the sauce is bland and the pie seemed to be premade.

First time and will definitely be my last. Very expensive and the food was terrible. I ordered Buffalo chicken pizza... not sure if they gave me the wrong pizza or that's just the way theirs is? It was greasy, overloaded with tons of garlic (borderline inedible) and no Buffalo sauce at all. Packet of ranch thrown on top in the box was ruined from the heat. The garlic knots had a strange lemony flavor... no sauce, so you pay extra for dipping sauce that was eh. The desserts were ok. read more

I would like to give them no stars and as for numbers a big zero 000000. Our first order of pizza was very salty, greasy and barely any toppings. We should of trusted the reviews. But, we did give them a second chance because they are close to us. Pizza was just warm, very greasy, salty and the toppings small as rabbit pellets. We will never order again our money west right down the pipes. Save your money and buy a frozen pizza for $5.00 Another place in Torrington that can't make a pizza they should all close or take cooking class. 9/2020 read more

Very expensive for disappointing food. We ordered a few meals (takeout) for dinner awhile back and were charged $17+ per "meal" that was 3 tiny pieces of thin chicken with some sauce.. not even a side or pasta. Needless to say, meals were returned and we were refunded. Not pleased with this establishment, save your time and go to Vinny's or Bachi's instead. read more

First off it was former Vinny's restaurant second you don't open up a pizza place that was already a good pizza place and serve crappy food you say you know how to make pizzas yet the ones I ordered came out overcooked and dry and all your other reviews that are more up-to-date are horrible reviewsyou knock people for coming in to cook for you when you don't even know how to cook your business sucks and you will not stay in business because you suck read more

Ordered delivery - steak & cheese says it comes with sauteed onions & peppers - nope! just cheese. asked for extra crispy wings & they were so soggy. the calzone was 90% dough & 10% filling. will never order again. read more

Tried two pizzas and a caprese salad for the first time last night. Great crust on the pizzas, great taste, and friendly service. We'll definitely be back. read more

Ok. Did the grub hub thing because, well... personal distancing, etc and easy peasy. I ordered the lasagna which comes with a side salad (I did get bread too, but on the grub hub app it said it salad or bread). I also ordered cannolis too. Let's start with the lasagna. Full of cheese. Super cheesy and came hot. But the flavor of it was like Campbell's tomato soup. Lots of it. Had to search for noodles, ricotta and meat. Not impressed. Got a strange roll which I used to dip into the tomato soup sauce, which did help. I asked for Italian dressing for my salad.... and got a packet of Ken's steakhouse balsamic dressing. Not what I wanted, but can deal cuz I'm really hungry. I did get a BEAUTIFUL cannoli. But just one. For $7. This is a new restaurant trying to take off in Torrington when they are PLENTIFUL of already established Italian eateries, I was very disappointed in my meal and what I paid for it. Plus they don't pack up the food properly for the driver, because a lot of my tomato soup sauce on my lasagna was seeping thru the paper bag/foil container they packed it in. Not a fan. Maybe others like this food, but I don't think I will order again read more

No ketchup included in the order. No napkins included in the order. Ordered the chicken fingers, 2 pieces of chicken, the rest fries... with a bacon pizza, meh.. just decent. Not happy, never will order again, this was a door dash order. Garbage. read more

Stella's pizza is awesome. It's a guilty pleasure that we order often. They're making some great pizzas. Normally order a cheese or pepperoni. Can't attest to other items. read more

The worst, calzone was burnt, meatballs taste like they came out of chef boyardee can, the large is like a small, mediterranean salad same as a chef salad. Horrible food guess it will fit in this town. Never order from here dissatisfied. read more

The pizza I specifically ordered was NOT the pizza I received. I called the restaurant and they proceeded to argue with me. All of this after tipping the delivery person extra money on top of their delivery charge. I then tasted the "wrong" pie and it could not be worse. Also had a salad delivered and without tasting it, based on the looks of it, it went straight into the garbage pail. So, if you want bad take out and a surly staff, please patronize this place. read more

Ordered the Pizza/Wing Combo. The pizza was just average. The wings were flavorless, and without any texture. If you're going to be in a town with 10 other pizza joints I suggest you be better than them read more