Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sully's Wharf

    2.2 (16 reviews)
    ModerateNew American, Bars
    Closed 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Sully's Wharf Photos

    SULLY'S WHARF ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Live music
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sully's Wharf

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Chicken fingers
    Victoria U.

    What a scam of a place! Paid $14 for chicken fingers and fries straight from a freezer. Prices aren't even posted on the menu because they know they are scamming. My friend got stuffed shells and chicken Marsala, a "special" for the night which you would think woukd mean it would taste the best. No. Stuffed shell was crunchy and chicken Marsala was chicken Marsala and even had a green tint to it. My other friend got wings after waiting 20+ minutes while the rest of us already had our food- nothing special to them either for all that extra time. Dining was outdoors on picnic benches. No table side service. Def not coming back

    Mildred R.

    I'm going to give Tanner Park aka Sully's Wharf a solid 3 stars. Pier is in great shape and worth a visit. Beach water and area is decent and a good place to cool off. Food is a tad bit over priced but so is McDonald's. Bathrooms is what needs the most attention. Since the pandemic it hasn't been that bad because they're not getting as many visitors. There are a few picnic tables for use on a first come, first serve basis and high tables and chairs to eat your ordered food. All in all, I enjoy coming here to sit and relax and listen to the waves. I personally have never had any issues with staff. Although, a friendly hello or smile wouldn't hurt.

    Chicken quesadilla
    James V.

    Would give negative stars if it wasn't for our waitress who tried her best to catch up to the travesty of this place. Absolute sh*t show...should never have opened unprepared... took over 30 minutes to even be asked if we needed a drink...then we put our orders in...a quesadilla and a burger....an hour and a half later we saw the quesadilla but the burger was still cooking...a chicken quesadilla is what we ordered...ended up being about a pound of cheddar cheese and some bread..no chicken to be seen...I ended up canceling the burger...manager/owner was to busy going around socializing then seeing his business go to the ground...this place is a joke

    Katch lobster roll  Guacamole and chips  Lemonade  Whiskey and coke  Tuna salad wrap

    See all

    4 years ago

    Helpful 17
    Thanks 0
    Love this 17
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Great location, food is a bit over priced but you pay for the ambiance, life music durring the summer and some great people overall!

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Deb O.
    0
    19
    1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ryan P.
    218
    34
    14

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Kevin J.
    122
    187
    689

    7 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Karen H.
    12
    81
    19

    7 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Was much better run and cheaper when it was Katch and The Beach Hut. Disappointing. Gotta trek it over to The Venetian.

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Sully's Wharf

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 26,025 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Restoration Kitchen & Cocktails - Whipped cheese board

    Restoration Kitchen & Cocktails

    4.3(555 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    $$

    This was a great experience. The food was excellent. I had a stuffed blue cheese burger RARE. The…read morecheese was in the middle of the burger and it was rare. Char on the outside and red in the middle. Perfect and delicious. The pulled pork sliders were delicious and the coleslaw on the was great. The beef rib quesadillas were excellent. The sweet potato tots were good but I prefer the fries. The service was excellent. They were crowded but the hostess sat us quickly and the waitress was excellent always available when needed. She even anticipated our needs. I'm going back for sure. We had a table outside and it was perfect.

    I honestly don't understand the hype around Restorations Kitchen & Cocktails. I've given this place…read moreseveral chances, hoping each visit would be better than the last, but unfortunately I've been disappointed every time. The biggest issue is the wait. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, the food takes far longer than expected. Takeout orders are routinely 15 minutes or more past the quoted pickup time, which is frustrating when you're planning your day around their estimate. Service has also been inconsistent. The waitstaff often seems disorganized, and communication regarding delays is lacking. I understand restaurants get busy, but after multiple visits, the same problems keep occurring. The food is decent, but not enough to make up for the long waits and repeated service issues. After giving this restaurant several opportunities, I don't see myself return

    Photos
    Restoration Kitchen & Cocktails - Bar Area

    Bar Area

    Restoration Kitchen & Cocktails - Rainbow cookie espresso martini

    Rainbow cookie espresso martini

    Restoration Kitchen & Cocktails - Espresso flight

    See all

    Espresso flight

    American Beauty Restaurant - Pasta anyone?!?

    American Beauty Restaurant

    4.3(104 reviews)
    3.4 mi
    $$$

    American Beauty had excellent service and decor. Came here on a Sunday and the kitchen closes for…read morean hour in the middle of the day. We weren't rushed when we sat down, but were told that the kitchen would be closing in 30 minutes. I got a chicken caesar wrap which came with a side of fries and enjoyed it. There was also an option to upgrade to truffle fries. The waitress was friendly and apologetic because there was a party wrapping up before we ordered. Overall, we had a good experience here and the booth seat was comfortable. Looking forward to coming back! Shared lot in the back of the restaurant.

    Another happy hour I just had to try. On Tuesday they also have $20 mussel pots and $10 martinis…read more Bartender Nicole was so friendly and chatted with us for a bit. She recommended the crispy burrata when we were stuck choosing between a couple of their delicious apps. It came with a savory tomato cream sauce and saffron risotto. The burrata truly was perfectly crisp. Of course we got the mussel pot. You can choose between white wine or fra diavlo. We got the white wine and I was really pleased with it. It's served with a couple pieces of crust bread to really sop up the delicious broth. And we couldn't pass up the oyster hh so we got a half dozen of those. I want to go back for their other specials. Unfortunately we dug in so quick we forgot to get pictures of the other items

    Photos
    American Beauty Restaurant - Cocktails for days

    Cocktails for days

    American Beauty Restaurant - Crab cake appetizer January 2025

    Crab cake appetizer January 2025

    American Beauty Restaurant - Cocktails for days

    See all

    Cocktails for days

    Tasting Room Kitchen & Cocktails - Sweet potato gnocchi with steak

    Tasting Room Kitchen & Cocktails

    4.3(62 reviews)
    5.9 mi

    Love this place! Everything we tried was absolutely delicious…read more We started with the street corn queso dip and stuffed zucchini blossoms - both were so good. The watermelon & feta salad was such a unique combo, I honestly haven't had anything like it on Long Island before. For mains, we got the lemon pesto pasta which was packed with flavor, and ended the night with the horchata truffle... my personal favorite Definitely a spot worth checking out!

    I came here on a Thursday night with four other girlfriends. We booked through Yelp with no issue…read more I ordered the strawberry basil aperol spritz which was very refreshing. We ordered the street corn queso dip and calamari as the appetizers. I enjoyed the calamari but the serving size is small for a shared appetizer. I ordered the miso glazed salmon. I did ask if I could have it cooked medium rare and waiter said absolutely. The salmon was still a little bit over, but flavor was decent. I thought the potatoes were pretty bland, but the brussel sprouts were good. The portion seems to be a bit inconsistent with what I had seen online. We had the horchata tartufo and peanut butter pie for dessert. The horchata ice cream had great cinnamon flavor and we enjoyed it. Additionally, there's a 2.95% service charge on our bill that was not explained and I am very curious about. My fault for not paying close enough attention to ask at the time.

    Photos
    Tasting Room Kitchen & Cocktails
    Tasting Room Kitchen & Cocktails - I had the Upper Cut Philly Cheese Sandwich, and it was exactly as described -- excellent

    I had the Upper Cut Philly Cheese Sandwich, and it was exactly as described -- excellent

    Tasting Room Kitchen & Cocktails - White wine blend was delicious

    See all

    White wine blend was delicious

    The Foundry

    The Foundry

    4.2(43 reviews)
    10.2 mi

    This was our first (and last) time at The Foundry. We were there for my son's birthday. It started…read moreoff well enough. The first issue was the length of time it took for our food to come. Then, we didn't see our waitress for a long time until we finally asked the water guy to ask her to stop by. Which took a while again. We ordered more drinks. My son's soda was flat and my old fashioned tasted like it had a bite like rye vs bourbon, but I ignored it and drank it. About halfway through it changed to sweet - but so sweet it was like drinking syrup. It was never stirred so the bottom half was undrinkable. We asked for our waitress to get the check, and asked her to remove the flat soda and my old fashioned. She brought the check, nothing was removed. I explained again and asked the drinks to be removed. Next the bar manager came to our table. She explained to me how old fashioneds are made, that they're never stirred. And some people sip them, some drink them with a straw. I've drank old fashioneds for many years. They are always stirred. And never drank with a straw. But she claimed she's made these for years. Someone else came and told us she could take off the soda but not the old fashioned. I said I only drank half as they took it away. Well they won't take it off. So I asked for half my drink back if I have to pay for it. They gave me a new small drink. It was terrible. We paid the check, tipped the waitress in cash (she did nothing wrong other than being too busy). I cannot get over the bar manager speaking to me that way. We will not be back.

    Ok food off the wall The wings gave me back in the day feel…read moreHouse made buffalo sauce with the Bleu cheese perfect mix The spinach artichoke dip I definitely definitely am worth. I'm not a big fan of pita chips so I substituted for chips and it definitely accommodated it really well. The drinks were well balanced as far as the place looks really amazing. Very quiet. I just me and my cousin in here for his birthday staff's pretty cool. I'm gonna be service recommended the wings. I'm actually taking some wings to go. Everybody get here to the foundry as soon as you can when you can peace and love.

    Photos
    The Foundry - Inside

    Inside

    The Foundry
    The Foundry

    See all

    The Piermont - Seafood stand

    The Piermont

    4.3(62 reviews)
    4.7 mi

    "I see her on the freeway Long Island Expressway…read moreHey, give me a break, baby Help me get out of this rain" (Rolling Stones) I just attended a wedding here, and I honestly can't imagine any aspect of the experience that could have been improved. It was that good. The wedding ceremony took place outside, where rows of chairs were set up and we all had gorgeous waterfront views. After the ceremony, we walked into the building's first floor for the cocktail hour. Simply put, the food was amazing. The cocktail hour alone could have served as a meal. There was a big central charcuterie station of cold appetizers - think meats, cheeses, fruits, and crudities. The four corners of the room each housed a food station - a carving station, sushi/sashimi, pasta, and Asian stir fry. Oh, and there were tons of butler service passed hors oeuvres too. Next, we walked upstairs to the large ballroom for the main meal. Dinner service started with a "Burrata Caprese" salad with a big hunk of creamy mozzarella served in a dressed salad with grilled bread. As for the dinner entrees, would you believe a choice of SEVEN entrees?? I kid you not -- seven entrees - Branzino, chicken, pork, beef, shrimp, Surf and Turf, and eggplant. My table had just about all of the choices, and everything disappeared. After the meal, there was an apple tart with ice cream and wedding cake. All of the people I interacted with, the hosts, the bartenders, the servers and the clearers were super polite and friendly. When I think about the decor, the scenery, the food, and the service, this was a top-notch experience, Well done, Piermont.

    I just recently attended a reception here over the weekend. It was AMAZING. From the views, to the…read moreservice, to the food. All of it exceeded my expectations of a New York wedding. When we arrived we enjoyed specialists drinks, appetizers, and a solo musician on the main floor. There were so many different and fun small plates constantly passed around from mini fish tacos, crab crakes, bruschetta, to fried ravioli. They had hot carving stations and a pasta bar. We were then moved upstairs for the main reception event and dinner. It was a huge wedding party and all of the guests fit comfortably. The decorations were perfection and all of the servers and bartenders were attentive and nice. It was a blast and the staff at Piermont helped make it a success. If you are thinking of this location for your future wedding or reception, I 10/10 recommend the Piermont.

    Photos
    The Piermont - Table setting

    Table setting

    The Piermont - Mini fish taco

    Mini fish taco

    The Piermont - Charcuterie bar

    See all

    Charcuterie bar

    Sully's Wharf - newamerican - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...