Sunrise Pizzeria

Their grandma pies are legendary. We order them for work all the time and they always deliverread more

Ordered takeout - meat lovers and a grandma pie, we thought the meat combo was a bit salty but is…read moreto be expected when you're getting pepperoni and sausage. The grandma was good for that order. Second time ordered just grandma and the cheese had an odd smell and did not taste like mozzarella, tasted very old. The 4 adults tried it and then ended up throwing it out. We had to physically remove it from the house and put it into the trash it was that off-putting. Would not reorder.

Penne Vodka and Eggplant Rollatini

Best Chicken Scarp around

See all

Chicken Scarpariello and Salmon al Dente

Colony Grill

4.0(238 reviews)

1.6 mi

We came to PC to see a movie and Bartaco had too long a wait so we came here instead. Fail. One…read morestar for service. One star for location and atmosphere. Our server was very nice and did a great job of explaining the menu as we came in totally blind. The space was nice. We sat outside and it was very enjoyable. But that's where it ends. The pizza was bad. Zero, and I mean zero, flavor. The dough was bland. The sauce was bland. The cheese was bland. The only flavor was the bacon in my mushroom and bacon pizza. My daughter had bell peppers and sausage and said that was also flavorless. My husband is watching his diet and he orders the salad pizza with chicken. It is the saddest pizza I've seen in my life. The salad part was fine but the chicken...good lord. It was dry, unseasoned shredded chicken thrown on top. Will not be back.

I have been wanting to try this place for a while. Had read some mixed reviews but figured we'd…read moregive it try given the reputation for the hot oil pie. We tried that, a regular cheese pie, and a sausage and onion which was the favorite. The pizza crust is super thin and nothing really special though it somehow managed to grow on us as we ate more. We had good service and enjoyed sitting out back on the deck.

Barr view from my table

See all

Valtori Pizza Kitchen

4.0(39 reviews)

0.4 mi

Great as ever! Have tried more menu items and all are top-notch. I keep bringing people here and…read morethey are delighted! They also do catering so party on! Latest rave is the eggplant pizza. Best of the genre! I always ask for my slices/pies to be "extra-crisp." Chicken wings are excellent as are their choices for sauces. They deliver so no excuse not to experience this delicious food regularly!

Solid Italian food, pizzas, and unique salads. Have been ordering quite a bit of takeout of late,…read moreand everything has been very tasty and fresh. Rye Beach salad is one of my favorites - also love the chicken entrees. Nice seating area as well for a no frills, quality dining experience.

Delicious Caesar salad with warm polenta croutons!

Peanut butter pie

See all

Dessert

Villa Rustica Pizzeria

4.2(97 reviews)

1.1 mi

I took my husband, son and grand daughter here on Father's Day. They loved it…read more Hubby got Lamb Ossobuco with sautéed spinach and potato croquettes; granddaughter for penne à la vodka; my son got cavatelli with chicken and early peas and the watermelon martini; and I ordered a Greek salad with penne à la vodka with shrimp and roasted peppers and a pomegranate martini.

Went for lunch with local friends. Neighborhood restaurant with friendly service and a varied menu…read more The chopped baked clams were tasty and a nice sized portion. The chicken parm was good size and I enjoyed the sauce and cheese. Side of pasta was good too. My friends' salads looked good and filling. Venue was comfortable. Reasonable prices in my opinion.

Cavatelli Rustica Dinner

See all

Watermelon Martini

Aurora Ristorante

3.6(104 reviews)

0.1 mi

Aurora is a place I've been frequenting since 2019. Their menu changes seasonally, and they often…read moreoffer great dinner specials that are worth trying. Service is consistently good, though the restaurant can get quite noisy depending on when you go, especially during peak dinner hours. The space is a bit tight, but there are a variety of seating options. Outdoor seating is a great alternative in late spring, summer, and early fall. The only downside is that on busy days, there can be a lot of foot traffic since it's right on the sidewalk, though this also depends on the time. Overall, I enjoy stopping by every now and then, especially to enjoy their complimentary hummus and fresh bread, it's definitely a highlight! A solid spot to check out and possibly make your own go-to place.

Our favorite restaurant! Always top notch and I LOVE their Mussels and Linguini with Clams! My…read morefamily always love the specials and of course, their famous hummus with bread! Friendly staff and upbeat ambience always make us smile when we go there.

Salmon Quinoa/Rice Bowl

Red Snapper with quinoa-beets

See all

Lamb-Mushroom Ravioli

Fortina - Rye Brook

3.5(402 reviews)

1.2 mi

Neil was our server and he was great. Fun night with the…read moregirls. Pizza always wonderful. Burrata- amazing. 5 stars all the way!!

Live near this place and never go. Went recently and I have to say their chicken cutlet sandwich is…read moreexcellent! Very pleasantly surprised. Not entirely sure on the ingredient quality, probably on the cheaper end, but the sandwich tasted very good.

Interior of restaurant

Cheese plate, soppressata

See all

Lunch time

Anna Maria's Wine Bar

4.2(21 reviews)

0.1 mi

cute wine bar in rye! busy saturday night, but wine bar was empty. bartender seemed annoyed and was…read morenot happy to be there. we had a quick drink and app. would have stayed, but was not feeling the vibe from the staff.

Delicious eats, vino, drinks, atmosphere, and impeccable bar service from the most genuine and kind…read morehost and owner Anna Maria. This wine bar is where you go to feel like you're at home with family and friends. Great live music too! Always a great time.

Aperol spritz, Pinot grigio

See all

Pizza margherita and prosciutto and sausage

Pizza 2000

2.9(163 reviews)

1.7 mi

Nice food. The service was very nice. Idk what ambiance is but I shall make Pizza 2000 proud.read more

This Bronx girl, who knows good pizza, has been transplanted to Boston and has been missing that…read moreslice of heaven that only NYC can deliver. I happened to be in Harrison for a celebration of life, and was happy to see this place located right across the street from the funeral home. My husband and I went in hoping to find a quick slice before heading back to Boston, and this spot did not disappoint! The slices were varied and heated to perfection (code for piping hot) and the crust crispy and oh so delish. The spot was clean, had plenty of seating, and the staff could not have been nicer. Even my husband was thrilled and kept going back to sample a new flavor. For $5 a slice, it couldn't be beat. If I find myself back in the area, I would definitely return.

Orecchiette Pasta with Crumbled Sausage and Broccoli Rabe

Chicken Parmagiana Slice & Sausage Roll

See all

$10 Greek Salad

T & J's Pizza & Pasta

4.0(230 reviews)

1.5 mi

"Don't Go Changing!" As the great Billy Joel sang…read more My friends told me T&J has been here for quite a while, which surprised me considering how often I used to be in Port Chester. I can't believe I never discovered it before. I just hope they never change. The food, the service, and the ambiance are all fantastic. It seems like every time I come back home, another place we used to love has either closed or gone so downhill that you almost wish it had. T&J will definitely be my new Italian stop whenever I'm back in New York. Like I said from the start: "Don't Go Changing!" BB

Ate here again today but this time I brought my husband who is the real connoisseur of Italian…read morecuisine. He ordered clams and chicken Marsala. I ordered Italian peppers and onions and meatballs for appetizer. It was all so delicious. I don't usually eat meatballs when I'm dining out because I don't like it when Veal is added to the mixture but I just couldn't resist this place because the meatballs were so big and delicious. I asked the waiter if they used Veal in their mixture and he said no so I knew this was my time to go for it. And they didn't disappoint. Each time gets better and better.

Thin crust pizza.

See all

Special Pasta

Michael's Famous Pan Pizza & Restaurant

3.5(53 reviews)

1.0 mi

(Let me start out by saying that I would have given this place a three but I am giving it a two…read morebecause of my experience with the waitress.) I have been waiting to try this place for a minute because I grew up in Chicago and love pan pizza. But I was so disappointed, not in the pizza, but in the wait staff. I went on 4/21/26 around 3pm and I was the only person in the restaurant besides the waitress. From the moment I entered the facility until the moment I left the as glued to her phone. So much so that she got my pizza order wrong and brought out a mushroom, green pepper and onion pizza when I hate mushrooms and don't even allow the word to come out of my mouth. When I brought it to her attention she took it back and put in my correct order. Right before the second pizza arrived I had to remind her that I had ordered a Mediterranean salad. She quickly went to the back to get it. When it came there were no tomatoes on the salad which, according to their menu, should have been on the salad. The pizza was decent; it had a light pan pizza style crust but I wouldn't make a special trip out of my way to go there. Also, as it pertains to ambiance and atmosphere, the volume on the television in the bar area where I sat was set to 40 or 50. It was so loud I couldn't hear myself talk on the phone. And everyone the business phone rang, the waitress would go into the dining room to answer the phone because it was too loud for her to hear herself talk too. Eventually, after about 30 minutes, the waitress had an epiphany and turned the volume down. Finally, I want to say that the waitress's demeanor was off putting and made me feel some type of way but that's for another day.

We had a really great lunch here. We sat in the back, outside under an umbrella table, and we…read morestarted off with the Gorgonzola salad. It was crispy, fresh and delicious. For entrées, we ordered a cheese pizza and the sunday pizza. The pizzas were delicious, with really crispy cheese edges, and a tasty crust. The sauce of sweet cheese was plentiful and I really enjoyed the meatballs and sweet sausage on the Sunday pizza. Service was excellent and everyone is friendly. We will definitely be back to try more of the famous pizzas!

Great burger

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

13 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Anthony M.

10 years ago

Order work lunch today from Sunrise. We order some specialty slices and some salads that were recommended. The slices were very small , oily n soggy, and the sauce was way to sweet. The salad was bland and the grilled chicken was cold as if it was pre cooked. Plus the price tag was crazy. Don't mind paying for good food. But this was not. We will keep looking for a good lunch spot. The search continues! read more

The Skone S.

126

1 year ago

AVOID. The pizza is miserable. Sits out all day. never fresh. and if you're lucky to find a fresh slice, the crust is bizarrely hard and inedible. legit the worst pizza in the area. Oh, and the people that manage the place are borderline fascists. total jerks. don't bother coming here. there are numerous solid pizza spots in town. AVOID SUNRISE like the plague read more

Saharra S.

6 years ago

Thin crust, fresh tomatoes sliced on mozzarella -- heaven! This place has the best pizza on the planet. When I am in Rye, I love to stop here. read more

Xxxten F.

5 years ago

I picked up a delivery (for a customer) And HAD to drive back and pick up a slice for myself. I really enjoyed their pizza. read more

Zain M.

17 years ago

The only person from Rye to actually review 'scam-rise'. Overrated, overpriced pizza and the owners are dirtbags

Cristina F.

7 years ago

Pizza pizza pizza!! My favorite spot in rye, also have great great salads. Arugula pizza is soooo good

Jessie I.

15 years ago

I just wish they delivered! Their pizza is worth the trip, even if you had to walk. :)

Rye S.

251

14 years ago

I love their pizza and Alex is such a professional and courteous guy!

Joe D.

12 years ago

Love every pizza I ever had..and we have been customers for 20 years.

Diana O.

11 years ago

best pizza in the area.. don't order from any where else

Nadia N.

100

10 years ago

Great inexpensive pizza in a wonderful area!

The B.

15 years ago

Honest westchester pizza. Cash only.

Katie B.

14 years ago

Best pizza in Rye!

Sunrise Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Sunrise Pizzeria also viewed

Al Dente Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.9

(110 reviews)

Their grandma pies are legendary. We order them for work all the time and they always deliverread more

Antonio's Pizza

3.6

(40 reviews)

Always a pleasant experience. Pizza sizes are very generous and delicious. You always have a choice…read moreof 6 or 7 different pizza varieties. It's always best to pay by cash since there is a substantial Surcharge when paying by Credit/Debit Card. Parking can at times be a bit challenging as Street Parking is Limited and the Private Parking can only hold 6 Cars Comfortably.

Ordered from here on Uber eats. I got a pepperoni slice and my boyfriend got a chicken parm…read moresandwich. Next day we both had the runs but thought nothing of it. Ordered again a couple weeks later and we both had food poisoning. Will never eat here again

Nonna's Pizza

3.8

(90 reviews)

Great food and service. Very pleasant and friendly place to eat, food is amazingly fresh and…read moredelicious. Salads are also fresh and tasty.

Classic NY pizza place. You arrive and there are locals hanging out eating and chatting. I told the…read moreman behind the counter what I was looking for and he suggested I order and entire pizza. It actually did not take very long. The cheese was amazing, sauce amazing, and slice size perfection. They were nice enough to let me kids use the bathroom as well. Do yourself a favor and go here when you are in town.

Italian Pavilion

3.3

(94 reviews)

The flavor is magnificent. My go to pizza!!!!! The sauce is…read morerobust without being acidic and the whole pie is mind blowing!

Came here on lunch and got a quick slice of Sicilian pizza. The store is very traditional and…read morereminds me of an OG New York pizzeria!! The staff were super helpful and nice. The slice was great. It was crispy and had a good amount of cheese and thickness to it. I will definitely come here for another slice next time!

Italian Village Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.1

(33 reviews)

The place is well located with plenty of parking, the pizza is excellent and cooked to perfection,…read morethe service at the counter is fast and friendly. The ambiance is great for a pizza place!

Italian Village has some wonderful specialty slices as well as a huge menu of high quality Italian…read moresides and entrees. Always a great stop for dinner when working nearby. Service is wonderful as well, the gentlemen are very friendly.

Johns Of Arthur Ave

3.2

(113 reviews)

During a recent visit to the area, I was on the hunt for a genuine New York-style slice, and "The…read moreJohns of Arthur" came highly recommended--a suggestion that turned out to be an absolute delight! This is not a fancy, upscale establishment, and that's precisely its charm. The Johns of Arthur is the quintessential quaint, little local pizza joint. It embraces its neighborhood roots, offering a wonderfully casual and welcoming atmosphere perfect for a quick stop. The star of the show, however, is the pizza. They currently sell by the slice in two classic varieties--Cheese and Pepperoni--and these slices are truly huge. They are perfectly cooked, flavorful, and deliver that satisfying, authentic taste I was looking for. It's simple, authentic, and utterly amazing. If you're passing through or are a local looking for a reliably delicious and quick bite, this is the spot. The Johns of Arthur is a great suggestion for any pizza lover who appreciates high-quality taste in a low-key setting. I highly recommend swinging by for one of their massive, delicious slices.

I don't feel comfortable going to this organization. There's a Hispanic waiter with a very bad…read moreattitude affecting his coworkers. I have been called on several occasions while attending this establishment trash, dirt bag, loner, and looser. I am continually disrespected and refuse to eat Italian food spit on by Hispanic animals.

Village Pizza & Pasta

3.6

(23 reviews)

Best cauliflower pizza!! If you can't eat wheat like myself and are gluten free, try their…read morecauliflower pizza. I love White pizza and they make an amazing cauliflower white. Slaps every time.

This is my go to pizza spot. Never had a bad meal in over 5 years. The staff has never been…read moreanything but courteous and attentive and delivery is always in a reasonable timeframe. I love their mozzarella sticks.

Michael's Pizza & Pasta

3.4

(92 reviews)

Friendly service, neat restaurant, and really delicious garlic bread! It might be the best garlic…read morebread I've ever had.

Improv stop after our flight and zero regrets. We rolled with the two specialty slice lunch special…read moreand eggplant parm sandwich. Holy deliciousness: The slices were delicious with that perfect crust crunch. This Jersey girl currently living in Florida was way elated! The guys behind the counter were friendly and all around awesome! Michael is legit! Thanks for some seriously good food!

Mario's Pizza & Restaurant

3.2

(133 reviews)

Stopped by Mario's recently during a wing walk and their wings are fresh, tender, and juicy. The…read moreBuffalo sauce has the perfect kick, and the BBQ ones are definitely a crowd pleaser (my sister's fav in the area). It's a classic, no frills pizza joint vibe with fast service and fair prices. If you're looking for a good wing and slice combo, this is the spot!

I only gave 1 star because 0 wasn't an option. Absolutely disgusting experience. A grown man making…read morea degrading, suggestive, and harassing comment to a woman at her own front door is beyond inappropriate. It was humiliating, disrespectful, and completely unprofessional. I called specifically asking for a manager--someone who should know how to properly handle a situation like this--and apparently there wasn't one available. Considering the level of unprofessionalism I experienced, that wasn't exactly surprising. Instead, I spoke with the owner's daughter. Although she apologized for his behavior, she then proceeded to defend him by saying he's a "good guy." Being a "good guy" doesn't excuse making degrading insinuations toward a female customer. An apology followed by an excuse isn't much of an apology. The comment was appalling, and the way my complaint was handled only made the experience worse. I will never order from this place again.

Mario's Pizza & Pasta

3.7

(87 reviews)