My neighborhood pizza joint for over 40 years. Good specialty pies, especially buffalo chicken and margarita pies. My grandson loves the vodka pie. Great crunch on the crust! read more

Has the pleasure of ordering a pizza from this pizzeria last week. They did not disappoint. The telephone order was simple and we went in for a pick up. We tried the white pizza but for sure will be back to check the rest of the menu out. read more

Sunset Pizzeria - White Pie - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This is our go to pizzeria for spontaneous get-togethers with family and friends. Friendly staff that always gets you in and out promptly.

I was looking for a quick bite before work and stopped off at this pizzeria. I ordered a grilled chicken with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers. The sandwich was cold when given to me and had little flavor. It was covered with garlic and oil and was messy. Not a place I would visit again. A bit dirty inside as well. Tables had crumbs and condiments spilled over. read more

Sunset Pizzeria - Grilled chicken pita with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Always enjoy the food at Sunset. Buffalo slices are my favorite, with an Arizona to drink. Baked ziti slice if you want to overdose on carbs too lol. I also really enjoyed the chicken parm hero I got. The side of fries could feed an army! Only issue: when I went to order on the Slice app, the minimum order amount was $20! That's a lot of food for one person, I think you should lower it to $10-15. read more

I get prices are going up around here and other places but $19 for a large cheese pie that took k er 20 minutes to cook very little sauce and cheese. I mean you can go to a handful of other pizza places that are much better tasting. not cheap with sauce and cheese and charge between 13-16 at most. 19. id rather stand outside that pizza spot and give the next unsuspecting customer $19 to not go in there and save themselves a bad time. do better guys. also don't advertise $13.99 as a special on the front window. Especially if that is no where close to the real price. Yes long rant I know. Many will say "tHaTs ThE pRiCe FoR a PiE" ! Wrong. thats the price in Manhattan so yea You can get a mouth full of flesh as for the ambience of the place, nothing special but wasn't bad. read more

I lived in Brooklyn my entire life and became a Staten Island implant back in 2018. Personally, I wish we came here sooner. Staten Islanders are pretty amazing people, which brings me to my point. Their pizza is fantastic. One such pizzeria that always reminds me of home is Sunset Pizza at the Rossville Plaza of Prince's Bay, Staten Island. Not only is their pizza delicious they have numerous Italian, old world, delectable entrees to choose from. Having said that, the pizzeria is clean, the refrigerator is well stocked and the owners are very personable. Something I missed back home in Brooklyn. Try their food, you won't be disappointed. read more

Every order is made wrong, items are left out of order, price changes each night and management is horrible they workers have very poor customer service If you ask for dressing on the side of a salad you get lettuce soaking in dressing they do not understand what on the side means I was ordering here several times a week but no longer it is horrible worst on Staten Island read more

Great Friendly Service. Ordered a Round Pie, Buffalo Chicken Wrap and a Chicken Parm Hero and they were delicious. Great Neighborhood Pizzeria . read more

Great pizza Ordered lunch there many times It's always good Delivery is fast And place is friendly read more

Solid 3 stars means A-OK and they earned it. Stopped by this plaza pizzeria fro a quick slice and went ahead and ordered their round and Sicilian. The round was an average NY slice which cant really be messed up and their Sicilian was really good. The Sicilian dough was just right. Slightly crunchy from the oven and a nice chew on the inside. The sauce on the Sicilian though is what did it for me. Perfectly sweet yet savory. I'd go back and get their square for sure! read more

Very. Good food here very friendly service... Pizzeria and the pizzas are so fashion really good

Hungry at home, 15 minutes before close and my guy was able to call up and pick up a slice all before they closed. Large slice, the sauce is good (not sweet not spicy) and the cheese isn't over cooked. Maybe a smidge more sauce... I will request this again on movie night, for pizza cravings, and nights that I've had one too many whiskeys ;) read more

I picked up a pie today the man handed me the pie and then took it back and switched it with a different pie when I got home I called to tell them it's the wrong pie they said not possible I explained it was hard like rubber and burned obviously someone else ordered a well done pie and they mixed them up. another man got on phone and said not possible just made I wanted him to suggest bring it back to see it but he was like. cannt be. my 5 year old wouldn't even eat it accidents happen yes but give the customer the chance to show you and make it right. I was always happy but not today sorry moving on to another in Rossville read more

I wasn't feeling well , and after running around all day , I didn't want to cook! I ordered a few things : lentil soup w escarole and sausage !!! Ohmygosh it was like homemade , almost as good as mine ! You have to ask for the escarole n sausage but it's worth it ! He sent me garlic knots w it , I ordered 4 quarts and it warmed our tummies on this winter night . Also their broccoli rabe n sausage w cavetelli n garlic n oil was great as always, the best ! The rice ball w meat parmigiana was perfect tonight ! We shared the above and it was sooo good . Vito the owner is extremely kind family man , he has served n helped us over 25 years! Sending food to us and I'd pay later when my mom or fiancé was in hospital . Kind , n old fashioned ...The above are our favorites and we love it ! read more

I love their pizza.. It's always done exactly the way I asked. Service and personnel are Also very pleasant .

best food and vodka sauce in Staten island the most Delicious is the sunset special chicken cutlet and eggplant parm combo ask to be made with vodka sauce it will be the best meal you ever had. Portions are large enough to share or next days dinner Stuart read more

The food is absolutely delicious and the staff are so kind and nice. Everything we had was outstanding and delicious! Delivery arrived sooner than expected. I look forward to ordering from them again when i am at my family's house who lives nearby!! read more

The food was really, really good. We got more than just pizza and everything was even better than expected. I can't wait to order again. Nice spot with a huge variety of options. read more

I have been ordering from sunset since I was able to walk to woodrow from my home with friends. I always enjoyed their food. And still do! However, I noticed that there is now a $2 delivery fee (i live a few blocks away) and then on top of that, I give the driver a tip. So for just a standard pizza, which is $13.95, I end up paying around $19 if I have it delivered and tip the driver. $19 is a lot for a local pizza delivery and there are nearby pizzerias and also further away places that deliver for free. This is something sunset should consider because a lot of their loyal customers aren't interested in paying delivery charges. read more

I would have never chosen this place based on the name but in the area it's really hard to find nyc style pizza. Most places are tiny chewy thick crust but this place does it right. It's not a classic 18inch but the flavor is right. The garlic knots are also perfect and the wings were great! read more

Wanted to try this place since I work close by. Stopped in for 2 regular slices but the margherita looked good so grabbed one n one. Guy didn't leave them in any longer than maybe 90 seconds (which If it's good pizza, they're still good warm) I choked them down since I was starving but I don't think I'll be going again. Sauce was bland and cheese tasted cheap. Wasn't the worst but I won't be recommending them. read more

Sunset Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Delicious chicken palm sandwich and cheesesteak order 2 of each was told 15 minutes when to pick them up order was ready to pick up Food was so good the bread was fresh and crispy chicken was fresh Will for sure be back when working in the neighborhood read more

This was a great food experience, excellent service from the most polite call taker to the delivery person. the food was delicious, hot and full of taste. We order a pie and a vodka sicilian slice one of the best i had and 3 of their version of L & B slice. I have to say that sunset L&B was better. Full of taste and judt the right crunch to the crust. I wish my area "Peekskill" had pizza like this. this is a must go to if your in the area. read more

Although the food tasted pretty good the 4 of us who ate the food all ended up in the bathroom within 10 minutes of finishing our meals. It was very painful. All had very different dishes too. Instead of throwing the rest of my meal I decided to save it and give it another shot. It was worse the second time around. Not sure if it's always like this because this was my first time getting from them. Probably won't order again. read more

Pizza crust is thin, sauce is delicious, cheese is decent, but the slice could use a smidgen more of it. Worth stopping in for a slice or two if in the area. Staff is very friendly. Seating is not great, but the Pizzaria is spotless. read more

Decent prices, great food. Such a great little pizzeria that never disappoints. I especially LOVE their eggplant roll with a side of sauce

It's easy to drive right past this place due to the fact that Staten Island (especially Woodrow Plaza) never stops growing; however, don't be fooled- Sunset is one of the original Pizza staples of the area. It's a representative of the classic-styled NYC pizza spot. Filled with booths, two TVs, refreshment refrigerators, and a giant pizza counter, it's perfect for an after-work bite, lunch run, a date, and the list goes on. They didn't sell-out like many other pizza spots with blaring music and 2,000 TVs all over the place, which is MUCH appreciated. Keep it simple. I've been coming here since I was a kid and have many good memories through the years. 20 years later, I'm still booking some new ones. If you're in the area, go on in and try them out. You won't be disappointed. Thanks guys. read more

Sunset is my favorite pizzeria on Staten Island, and genuinely my favorite pizzeria that I've ever been to. Their pizzas are always hot, fresh, and delicious. Their garlic knots are perfectly doughy, cooked, and covered in garlic in the best way. I rave about their Italian Wedding soup to anyone who will listen to me. My family has been going here since before I was born and I have been eating their pizza since I could first chew. I am a NY pizza snob who thinks extremely highly of this place. I know there are a lot of supposedly amazing pizza places on the Island but I have tried them all and Sunset is my favorite every single time. Their crust is so fluffy and cooked perfectly and their sauce is delicious. Everyone who works there is exceedingly kind and makes it a pleasure to go in and order. Hot Tip: Their sausage pizza is out of this world. Definitely stop by if you live near here or honestly, make the trip to get some pizza - you won't regret it! read more

Quick delivery Good food nice owners Really good Sicilian pies we call at least once a week read more

I'm a frequent customer at Sunset and the food is always amazing. Service is friendly and the staff cares for their customers. Try the fresh mozzarella pizza it is delicious read more

I am impressed, Sunset Pizzeria was impressive. Definitely coming back here again. Everything I have ever purchased here has been fresh and tastes very good. All of the staff are incredibly friendly - you definitely feel welcome and looked after. The service was professional and I would definitely go back to Sunset Pizzeria. read more

Pizza is just OK. Heros are made with their own bread made with pizza dough. Had a Meatball hero and the meatballs were hard and dry. The bottom of the bread fell apart while trying to eat it. Was not enjoyable read more

This is the most shittttt pizzeria I have ever ordered from. The deliveries take literally forever. I ordered a pie at 1:00 pm and still not have received it, it's currently 11:07 pm. They also have no Wifi. read more

MUST READ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Ordered a pie, garlic knots and soda on a Tuesday night at 8:20 pm. Was told it would be a half hour (which we know everywhere always says that not a big deal) waited OVER an hour for our food. Called them and the boy was very nice and said our food is leaving now which is kind of funny for the fact I'm 5 minutes away and when we received our food it was ICE COLD. We noticed there was and extra box with 2 slices of pizza and some kind of wrap.. we didn't eat it just left it on the table. Right when we were done eating we get a call asking if we got an extra pie and we said no we got a box with 2 slices and a wrap and the kid says WE ARE GOING TO NEED THAT BACK... ummm ewww I feel bad for whoever is receiving that box because it's been opened by us and we touched the wrap to see what it was. Very disappointed with this place and we order here all the time never again. Maybe that's why my food was cold because it went to another house... p.s still waiting for this kid to pick the box up read more

I've ordered from them a few times. I thought it was good but I ordered one item this evening from Grubhub at 8:05 ... it's 9:30PM and my order still isn't here. After calling at 9:05 and asking for a status update and being told 5-10 minutes. They also charge $2 for delivery ? $2 for an extended wait on one item to a house that is literally a 2 min drive ? Not worth it, I suggest You order from Rossville Pizza or Pino's read more

Probably the worst pizza I've ever tasted in my life. I live in the area & had to wait for a banking transactions to go through so I figured I would grab two slices and a drink yet much to my dismay , the pizza was cold and tasted like cardboard. The guy behind the counter didn't care much and I never went back read more

So yummy. I usually order a Sicilian slice from them. The panini's are also delicious.

Besides stopping in for a quick slice or roll, we've gotten catering from Sunset twice. The food was exactly what we ordered, was delivered on time by a really nice kid and was hot and fresh. On top of the food always being on point, the owner is such a nice guy, really great customer service. read more

This is the best kept secret on Staten Island! Hands down, the best pizzeria/restaurant here. Everything is delicious!