Made a reservation for my partner and I. Got there almost 15 minutes late. When we arrived, they only had bar seating so it seems like our table was given to someone else? I asked about a grace period and it turns out they don't have one. I wasnt upset- it is my fault for being late but wanted to know for future reference. Later, the owner (same person who greeted us at arrival), came by and said they'd move us to a table when one opened up. Seating was super packed. I had to carefully squeeze my legs through the gap between the stool and the guy next to me or throw my legs over the barstool. I did fit but was constantly trying to avoid being in anyone's way. I was so cramped that i kept looking over my shoulder to see which tables might open up The bartender was friendly and very busy. There seems to be a lot of regulars here and multiple people were trying to chat with him as he worked. A table opened up and we were moved to a table by the door, along the window. It was great having much more space. Tables were still a little small but I liked how intimate it was. 5/5 chicken parm - SO GOOD. i saw a ton of reviews saying this was amazing so we ordered it and they were so right. all the flavors just work together. its savory and pairs so well with the sauce. they had given us a bread basket earlier and we dipped it into the sauce bc no way we were wasting it. 4/5 smoky potato pizza - good and very interesting. the potato was on there in slices, giving the pizza a nice bite. but bc so of the toppings were white, my partner had a hard time telling which parts were the potato lol. i didnt taste much smoke 4/5 carrot cake - so many layers!! quite moist. the drinks were good (can't remember what I got anymore though) but the real stand out was the food. *we originally wanted the coconut cake bc so many reviews were raving about it. the family at the table over were regulars and said all the cakes are good but 2/3 of them said the coconut cake was their fav and the other said chocolate cake was their's (she said she's a big fan of chocolate). -- I came back for the chocolate cake another day and had it with my partner who LOVES chocolate. i dont usually prefer chocolate flavored things but my god this is THE best chocolate cake i've ever had. its really so so good. its moist and rich without being overwhelmingly chocolate. its just right and not too sweet. i will go back for their coconut cake. I cannot wait to try it! read more

Cute charming place. The pizza and salad were awesome! The staff is warm and friendly. Their beer selection is great. We got Tiramisu for dessert and it was absolutely terrible, It's cake trying to be Tiramisu, failing at both, All the desserts are overpriced The tables to our left and right also got Tiramisu and all of us left it unfinished. Would go back for food but skip dessert. read more

Super Nice Pizza is the offshoot of the adjacent donut shop, applying the same dough techniques towards pizza. The pies are vaguely Neapolitan with a slight but not extremely pronounced chew. We tried a variety with potato and onions, as well as a classic margherita. Both were quite good, although I'm not sure why they keep such a limited set of options on the brunch menu. When we arrived at noon, we had expected a classic assortment of pizzas. read more

Super Nice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I LOVE Super Nice Donuts, and after months of text updates on deals and specials, I ventured to the westside to try the pizza. The corner spot has a great vibe, with indoor and outdoor seating. The waitstaff is patient and good-natured. All tables were reserved, so I sat by myself at the bar. Three stars is for the wait time, which I was told by a local sitting next to me at the bar, was abnormal. Two hours to get a burger and a piece of cake? I sat at the bar for 45 minutes before food arrived. Couples who arrived after I did left before I did, and I heard both of them say to the bartender to "forget" an item that never arrived. After announcing that this visit was my first, I was surprised to have the burger recommended over the pizza. The smash burger was ... a smash burger (although not advertised as such on the menu), well prepared with onions, cheese, and a super soft bun. Very tasty, yet not overly impressive. The fries were capital D-delicious! By 6:30 pm, the chocolate cake was gone, but the coconut was recommended and did not disappoint. I'm definitely going back to try the pizza, with fingers crossed that the meal progresses in a timely manner. read more

Super Nice Pizza - Burger and fries (Smash Burger) - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This is my neighborhood go-to - usually once a week and sometimes more. Excellent individual pizzas and mains, great selection of beers and wines, reasonably priced and generous weekly specials, and a friendly wait staff. All in a simple but clean and comfy setting. read more

I came here with two former colleagues to catch up over a meal. One of them came here the week before and really enjoyed her burger. The restaurant is in a cute and cozy space with exposed brick walls. Even though it's cozy, they can accommodate groups and they have a bar area. One of us ordered the calamari which came with cherry peppers. We enjoyed it--it was lightly breaded and not too oily. The cherry peppers were a nice addition. For our entrees, I ordered the burger and requested cherry peppers to be added--I like a little kick. Another person ordered the same except without cheese or house sauce. The third colleague ordered the skirt steak which came with potatoes and sautéed greens. She loved the chimichurri sauce but thought the potatoes were bland. For drinks, two of us ordered amaretto sour (not on the menu) and the last one ordered the espresso martini. Everyone enjoyed their drinks. I hadn't had an amaretto sour in about a month of Sundays so it was nice to have. One of us initially ordered a cosmo but the restaurant didn't have cranberry juice just the bitters--it wasn't working for her. We didn't get dessert. The service was good overall. There was a bit of an issue when paying the bill. One of us was trying to redeem a credit and asked the server what does she need to do. She said it will ask for her email address and use the same card that she used last time. It didn't ask for her email address and she used the same card. By this point, the card was already used and the credit would expire on 1/31 (we went on 1/30). The server was kind of like "oh well." My friend was not having it. She asked to speak to the manager/owner. He was able to get it all sorted out. The manager was very hands on and listened to the suggestions of patrons. All in all, we had a good time and I would go back. read more

See all

I'm going to stick my neck out there are say THIS IS THE BEST PIZZA IN THE CITY!!! And every other dish is absolutely superb too. Def try the meatballs. Def try all the salads. Mos def order the sardines and homemade breads. The cocktails are sensational. The staff are lovely. The lighting and decor are super fantastic. Warm cozy. Great date night. Or friends night. This is a superb casual restaurant serving incredibly delicious dishes at reasonable prices. Seriously RUN !! Don't hesitate. read more

This place rocks. It's a perfect blend of sophisticated yet casual and has a homely hum to it. And the food is superb, which I had already suspected after having been a loyal customer of their best-in-NYC donuts for quite some time. (It's right next door.) Everything here is fresh no matter the order. You can count on that. This was our first time returning for dinner since Super Nice Pizza first opened a year or two back. We walked in late on a Friday night seeking two spots at the bar and were immediately greeted by the owner (great guy), who welcomed us and helped us choose our spread for the night. To start, we ordered the fried clams (MP), and they were outstanding. The clams were plentiful, perfectly fried yet light at the same time, and accompanied by a delightful tartar sauce. For the final appetizer, we ordered squash filled with ricotta and served tempura-style, which had a refreshing arugula salad on the side. And for the main meal, we shared an eggplant pizza, which greatly exceeded our expectations. We even found ourselves eating the crusts too, a rare occurrence, because Super Nice has a knack for serving exceptional dough. We will certainly be back. Tip well. read more

Really cute spot! Snagged a last min 8:30 reservation on a Friday evening, which was nice. Nice atmosphere with the ambient lighting and decor. Decent amount of bar seating as well as small tables which looked like they could configure to accommodate different group sizes. A moment for the (non alcoholic) Super Nice Tonic! This was really lovely. Believe it was house made lemonade, juniper berry, tonic water, and I watched them grate fresh nutmeg over the top. Feel like this drink represented the vibe - familiar and approachable, and yet elevated. Loved the pepperoni pizza with Calabrian chili oil added. Sausage pizza was good too. Also enjoyed the fried leeks - haven't seen this before! It was kind of giving onion rings, but better. read more

I absolutely love this place, and since they've just started offering brunch, we had to make a reservation. Everything was -- no surprise -- stellar. The breakfast pizza (we had the potato and egg one) and the pancakes were exceptional. I wish we had bigger stomachs because I want to try the breakfast burritos, the other pizza options, the shakshuka... I guess we'll just have to go back. (We will definitely go back) read more

Super Nice Pizza - Breakfast pizza with potato and egg - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

New pizza spot by Danny @ Super Nice bakery. lots of promise (still working out some kinks, I think) but the place is lively and the staff are SO nice. We got the arugula salad, original pizza, potato pizza, and chocolate cake. I loved the tomato sauce on the original pie and the chocolate cake - whose size recalls something out of Matilda - was amazing. Can't wait to return and sample more :) read more

See all

I made a reservation as soon as I saw a photo of their chocolate cake, lol. It wasn't hard to book via Tock. The space is modern yet casual and feels like a neighborhood spot. We shared the meatballs, eggplant pie, and clam pie between two of us. We loved both pies - the dough was soft and chewy. I really liked the acidity of the meatball sauce. The pies are on the smaller side (6 slices each) but we still ended up with leftovers. The chocolate cake was even bigger than I'd imagined but SO good and decadent. I think it had both chocolate mousse and frosting. Service was super friendly but kinda slow. I'm assuming they're still figuring things out. We'd love to come back and try other pies and the burger, which looked great, too! read more

See all

What an amazing place to drink and dine. Fantastic cocktails, amazing pizza and anchovy pasta to die for. What more could you ask for??

Great spot. Some of the best chicken parm I've had in my life. Really can't go wrong with anything in the menu. Good setting, friendly staff and overall a great place. read more

We came here with friends who live in the neighborhood, and had a lovely time! Great food, friendly service, and a casual, welcoming atmosphere. Our party of 4 adults and 2 kids shared the following: 1) Calamari - excellent 2) Squash blossoms stuffed with ricotta - delicious and unique 3) Little gem salad - good 4) Sausage Pizza - very good 5) Tomato pie with pepperoni added - great; my husband who doesn't eat cheese really appreciated the fact there was a cheeseless pizza on the menu 6) Chocolate cake - amazing; not too sweet Our 7 year old loved the gazpacho, and also enjoyed sharing the fish and chips with our friends' almost 1 year old. The service was attentive and friendly, and the space was quite pleasant and welcoming of children. We had a wonderful meal here! read more

Went for my birthday because it came highly recommended by good friends. The meatballs are perfect with a slightly sweet sauce. The pizza was the best I have had in a long time. Certainly the best i have had anywhere on or near the UWS. Crust is slightly charred and crispy. Light with the perfect crunch and flavor. Just the right amount of cheese and sauce. This is definitely going to be my new go to. read more

Super Nice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I'm a fan of Super Nice's coffee shop so I'd been looking forward to trying their pizza place. It surpassed my expectations! The mozzarella with roasted peppers was a great appetizer. We were a party of three so we split two pies and had a few slices to take home. We had the red sauce eggplant pie and white sauce zucchini pie. Both were delicious. We split the chocolate cake for dessert which was huge but also tasty. The prices are incredibly reasonable and the servers are friendly. My partner and I are adding this to our rotation of neighborhood restaurants. read more

Super Nice Pizza - Zucchini Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I was excited to try out Super Nice Pizza that had just opened up next to their UWS donut shop. Their menu is pretty extensive, offering salads, small plates, and various pies. We ordered: +the Little Gem Salad - prepared with rainbow radish, buttermilk dill dressing, and herbed breadcrumbs +the Potato Pie +the Mushroom Pie +the Pepperoni Pie Price point was more on the steep end, and we didn't feel it matched what we were receiving. Service was more of a miss, as it seems as if they were pretty overwhelmed. Patrons seem to enjoy their chocolate cake and their tiramisu, but you could always check out their dessert offerings next door. We're glad we were able to check this place out, but not sure if it's worth a return visit. +miss of a service +steep prices for pies read more

Rarely write reviews but couldn't resist giving this place some love, especially when it felt like a slice of the village in west harlem--amazing vibes, cozy interior, great staff/service, and DELICIOUS food! Full-belly fried clams--they'll be my only craving all summer. A must order. Squash blossoms--delicately fried with deliciously creamy ricotta. Pepperoni pizza--perfect crust and pepperoni-to-sauce ratio. Wish we lived closer to order it weekly when cravings hit! My fav!!! Mushroom pizza--loaded with a variety of grab delicious mushrooms.‍ The chocolate cake is incredible--it's the kind you try once as a kid and declare the best ever, then spend your entire adult life searching for something that matches up. Remember this review when this place blows up because you heard it here first folks Drinks were great, if you have the space for it get the limoncello Such a great addition to the neighborhood, perfect for date night or a meal with friends. Can't wait to be back soon!!!!!!!!! read more

See all

I would not recommend this restaurant. We eat in the neighborhood often, and this felt very different from our usual local experience. Our children were scolded by staff, and the overall tone was uncomfortable and unwelcoming. Even without kids, I'd think twice about coming here. read more

They took their quality dough that established their excellent doughnuts and channel it Into their pizza . I took the eggplant and it was perfect , zucchini & mushroom looks very promising as well for next time. Fresh quality ingredients, the right crispiness , very flavorable. Beautiful space and great service . Highly recommended!!!! Definitely a destination!!!! read more

Came for the pizza but found the burger to be my favorite item. It could use a bit of a aioli or more of the house sauce (I didn't really taste it) but still very good. Service was good even though we made a reservation but you're not guaranteed a table and may be seated at the bar. We ended up sitting a the bar for a few minutes before getting a table. The pizza was average pizza and cost $23 for a pretty small pie. The burger cost $23 and comes with fries. Fries were well seasoned. We ended up getting the chocolate cake which is a huge slice for $22 with a side of gelato for another $9. I found the total to be steep for what we got. read more

See all

Okay here's my brutally honest review. I was so excited for this opening because I love the donut spot and have been here for pizza twice in the past 2/3 weeks. And both times were honestly a miss. The first time we went we came on a reservation and spent the first 40 minutes at the bar because they were overwhelmed, which is understandable for a new restaurant. Clam pie was good but they ran out of clams for the top. Sausage pie was decent but again I think it was just decent. Sauce didn't stand out to me Meatballs weren't as flavorful as they could've been or juicy. The second time I visited, last night, we again went on a reservation and were told they might have to seat us at the bar. Hostess was also pretty abrupt with us for arriving 5 min past the reservation time which was weird to me given that every single reservation time slot was available for that night and I had made the reservation an hour earlier. Throughout dinner there were people crowded/standing by the door and it's clear they overbook reservations in some capacity. Probably kinks that need to be worked out. The wrong pie came to our table but they corrected it when informed. Clam pie was again very good but the bottom crust was soaked in clam juice this time and floppy. Eggplant pie was extremely under seasoned sadly. The whipped ricotta was delicious and the chocolate cake was again lovely. Service both times has been pretty unimpressive and quite slow. In the middle of our meal ln the hostess joined our table with a second empty one and then 20 minutes later pulled them apart? By the end of my second visit there was so much smoke built up in the room my eyes were burning. I do have sensitive eyes but I'm not sure the ventilation was enough. I hate to be this brutal but I'm holding this place to the same lense I would any other restaurant. Waited to visit twice to form an opinion. There's absolutely potential here but some serious kinks that need to be worked out. read more

See all

Great pizza! Very cute restaurant on the UWS. Get the chocolate cake!! It's enough for 4+ people.

Super Nice Pizza - A True Upper West Side Gem Tucked into the Upper West Side, Super Nice Pizza is a true neighborhood gem -- relaxed yet refined, with just the right touch of New York cool. Every dish feels intentional. The pizzas are thoughtfully balanced, from the classics to the clam pie, which is simply unforgettable. But the menu doesn't stop there -- the steak and hand-cut fries are perfection, and the hamburger is one of the best in the city: juicy, flavorful, and crafted with care. Each dessert is homemade, indulgent, and beautifully presented, adding the perfect sweet finish to any meal( chocolate layered and tiramisu a must try). The menu is diverse enough to make this your go-to spot any day of the week, and the bar program pairs timeless favorites with inventive cocktails that keep the energy just right. As night falls, Super Nice transforms -- lights dim, music deepens, and it becomes a cozy, speakeasy-style lounge that hums with effortless late-night charm until 2 a.m. Service is consistently rated a ten -- warm, attentive, and genuine. Kudos to the entire staff for creating such a welcoming experience. And congratulations to owner Dan Cohen for putting together such a unique and truly special restaurant. It's the kind of place that makes you feel like you've discovered something special -- because you have. read more

Good food. Pizza is obviously the go to dish, but I've had other things on the menu and those were very good as well. Particularly the desserts. My only complaint was the service. This isn't the west village or Williamsburg so the servers don't have to have an attitude. I decided to go there on an impulse when my favorite happy hour place was packed. Went into a nearly empty restaurant and wanted to sit at the completely empty bar. After the hostess made a questionably derisive comment about my T-shirt (vintage black rock and roll 70´'s band) the waitress told me that the only available seat was at the end of the bar by the kitchen. If that had been the only seat at the bar I would have been fine. But after me others came in and sat at other, more desirable bar seats without any problem. Got the feeling that they thought I was not their kind of customer. Bartender was nice though. read more

Super Disappointing (this time - stars relate only to this visit) Having enjoyed meals at Super Nice Pizza, was looking forward to a Saturday evening birthday dinner with a friend. On arrival for our 7PM reservation we were told that we could either eat at the bar or wait at the bar for some significant period of time for a table because all the tables were reserved for parties of four or more. A couple nearby indicated that they had been told the same thing and were waiting for a table. We were advised that we should have noticed that the website indicates that parties of two may be seated at the bar on Fridays and Saturdays due to space limitations. Would much prefer if the restaurant had not accepted the reservation and indicated that walk-ins would be seated if possible. If you go, beware that a reservation only means that you can buy a meal, not that you will be seated at a table (currently the website does not limit the size of the reserved party that may be seated at the bar or the days on which that may occur). Enjoyed dinner at Serafina a few blocks away. read more

This is a not-to-miss spot on the north end of the upper west side. Everything was fantastic, from the greeting when we walked in to the pizza, cocktails, and desert. Pizza was fresh, crust was on point and ingredient combos were original without being crazy. Hats off to Daniel and his crew for creating a warm neighborhood spot with creative and quality fare for all. It's small, so a res might be a good idea if they take them. We went on the spur of the moment after a Yankees game. Surrounding neighborhood is a gem on a Saturday night with a casual block party feel. We'll be back! read more

See all

I have been going to Super Nice for donuts as long as I've lived on the UWS (they're incredible!) and I was so excited to see their new pizza spot. Took the homies to dry it out, and it did not disappoint! The interior was beautiful and brooding, and the service was top notch. The pizzas were nice and artisanal, we really enjoyed the eggplant ricotta and the little piece of radish we got as a palate cleanser before our meal. We were too stuffed for dessert so I'll have to come back! read more

See all

Holy moly this was good We had the clam pizza, delicious crust! Also loved our cocktails. The server was very knowledgeable and friendly, and the place was super cute. Really hope this place does well, it was excellent! read more

Holy cow. Best pizza in the neighborhood, and the best Tiramisu I've had in my life. After my last experience at Aqua, big fan of their drink program, too. read more

Love this new addition to the neighborhood!! The vibe and ambiance are great but the pizza is exceptional! Totally rivals any of the best pizza in the city (I liked it better than Una Pizza Napoletana). Good service, too. I finally got to try one of the breakfast burritos this morning and, while I'm thrilled to finally have a good breakfast burrito in the area, it's way too expensive. Without any meat (and little to no salsa that I could see), this shouldn't cost more than $10-12 tops. Definitely not worth the $19 I paid... Donuts next door are also fantastic! But all around a great place that I will be visiting regularly! read more

Really cool place phenomenal pizza and great cocktails My wife and I had an awesome time loved it. Can't wait to go back. read more

Been multiple times. Space is sweet, warm, and cozy, but not "cute." Every pizza I've tried has been great, with mushroom and chorizo special as standouts. Staff is super attentive (but not too much). One of my Upper West Side "go-to's" for sure. Try the Plan Bee sour ale or the margarita arrabbiata -- both great choices against the cheesy crusty goodness of the pies. read more

Wonderful new place from the Super Nice team. You absolutely need the clam pizza, and the other pizzas are worth it as well. I did not get the giant chocolate cake this time, but will be back again to try it in the future. read more

Super Nice Pizza - Clam pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Another lovely quick dinner at Super Nice. Great Neighborhood joint. Try the cannoli's for dessert.

Super Nice Pizza... An Absolute GEM on the Upper West Side What an absolute gem, right in my own backyard! Super Nice Pizza is everything you hope to find in a neighborhood spot but rarely do: effortlessly cool, deliciously inventive, and bursting with character. The pizza is mesmerizing; each pie a perfect balance of flavor and artistry, with dough that's light, crisp, and full of soul. The menu hits every note, but what really takes it to the next level is the bar: classic cocktails reimagined with originality and flair, a thoughtful lineup of cooler drinks, and a small but highly curated wine list that beautifully complements the food. You can tell every choice was made with care and taste in mind. The space itself is intimate and inviting, glowingly lit during dinner, then dimmed and candlelit as the evening settles in, ushering in a laid-back speakeasy vibe with an even cooler soundtrack. We sat in the cozy window nook; comfortable, sexy, and alive with the joyful hum of guests having a truly great time and enjoying an eclectic menu. It's casual dining on the UWS at its absolute finest, warm, stylish, and full of personality. Great food, great staff, great energy. Kudos to the entire team and huge congratulations to Dan Cohen, a true restaurateur who's created something genuinely special. ------------ And just when you think it can't get better; there's an amazing bakery right next door. Don't miss the authentic tiramisu or the crazy delicious layered chocolate cake. It's hard to leave room, but do yourself a favor: take dessert home, pour a glass of wine, and enjoy an intimate, sweet ending with someone you love. read more

There is one size pizza and it is not large, about 12" in diameter, about the size of a small pizza anywhere else. At these prices, you may expect a decent size pizza but you will be disappointed. read more

Delicious food and really nice people and place. Apps and mains amazing as well as pizza!

Amazing pizza with character and great desserts. It's now one of our favorite restaurants in the neighborhood. We've gone a few times already and added it to our regular spots. Recently we got the seasonal melon salad with peaches and eggplant pizza. So good. Service was great, no nonsense and not pushy. The ambiance was also very nice and not loud or crazy on a Wednesday night and they played some great 90s oldschool hiphop. read more

Super Nice Pizza - Eggplant pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all